HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

slownews45

2,904 karma · joined May 14, 2021

submissionscomments
slownews45··on Ex-Google workers sue company, saying it betrayed 'Don't Be Evil' motto
I thought they were fired for somehow getting chrome to pop-up notices when visiting the website of a google contractor that was anti-union.

I mean, I like the effort, but... it's unlikely that an employer is going to want to pay employees to do things they don't want to have done?

"Her suspension began just three hours after she published a piece of code that created a pop-up notification when Google employees visited the website of IRI Consultants"

I'm curious how one even gets chrome to monitor and pop up a notice when google folks visit a website. If it was some kind of ad that seems OK. If she used google's infrastructure to push a popup to all google employees... do other businesses permit this? Can a chase employee push something to all chase.com users alerting them to something they care about?

slownews45··on Costly Airbus paint flaw goes wider than the Gulf
Yes, in the US we (now) think of 250 as too low.

1,500 is pretty dang high. Persoanlly, 500 - 1000 wouldn't be unreasonable in my view.

Major airlines might still be at 3,000+ hours.

Remember, it used to be in the US you could also fly as a FO with a commercial pilots license at 250 hours!

FAA Commercial Pilot is 250 (50 of which need to be in powered airplane). https://www.aopa.org/training-and-safety/active-pilots/safet...

50 hours behind the actual yoke? 200 lives 30,000 feet in the air?

Overseas, some of the cadet / local pilot programs - you get pretty low time and/or connected pilots into the seat.

"The committee noted that these deficiencies had been identified previously in training and reemerged during the accident flight. When the MCAS activated, it took the first officer four minutes to locate the proper checklist because he wasn’t familiar with required memory items. During training, the same pilot had shown unfamiliarity with Boeing and airline standard operating procedures and had weak aircraft handling skills, the report revealed. His training record reflected numerous deficiencies, including “major problems” controlling the aircraft."

There is a reason Boeing initially said there might have been some pilot factors. They look at that memory item checklist, and think, trim problem, stab cutout memory item.

In the US they have Capt Sully (glider / fighter pilots, lots of experience, with a strong FO) gliding a plane with two engines out to a safe landing. So human in the loop kind of works in the US. Could you program a computer for that? Probably, but not there yet.

That said, I still blame Boeing to a large degree. If you are going to sell new planes to countries that have this type of system, you must design the plane for purpose. Ie, low time pilots who struggle / are connected / can't be fired etc - you don't then design the plane assuming the human in the loop will have hand flying ability to step in. That was pure greed, roll out this type of plane in the US / EU / UK etc. Good maintenance, good safety reporting systems (ASAP etc) work out the kinks, then go overseas.

First Max 8 to Malindo air!!? Really??

They really need to get to airbus and beyond envelope protection etc in these markets.

I'm also curious about checkrides overseas. Stuff like engine out on takeoff etc is just hammered into folks in the US.

slownews45··on Ph.D student demonstrates a single, working laser on silicon
Does it need to be ordinary silicon, or ordinary silicon processes (including temperature?). One seems much easier than the other, the later seems much more likely to be cheap (I can build a big laser on ordinary silicon today). Much harder to do with ordinary silicon in a somewhat standard process flow.
slownews45··on Costly Airbus paint flaw goes wider than the Gulf
The standard is a fair bit higher now in airplane safety than it was. The 787 issues make you realize this (shims / flatness stuff etc). Go back 50 years this wouldn't have gotten a second look in most cases (and yes, there were more fatalities).
slownews45··on Costly Airbus paint flaw goes wider than the Gulf
Excellent point.

A lot of focus is on pilots, but the safety chain was also weak. Maint, communication with flight dept, communication to subsequent pilots etc, training dept and required experience / education to fly. Not a good combo. Someone with 200 hrs of time, plane badly maintained, no good handoff around prior issues etc.

I still think Boeings safety model with humans as the backup for computers probably doesn't work in a world where a large majority of pilots lean on fully fly by wire (computerized) planes. Someone with 240 hours, a bunch of that just sim time - can they hand fly a plane in its entire envelope?

This is where Boeing sounded really tone deaf. They built a model around humans as backup, a very US centric model (ie, folks with tons of general aviation experience just as a hobby from young ages, military flight experience etc) which was not really appropriate here.

slownews45··on Costly Airbus paint flaw goes wider than the Gulf
The old procedure was

Control Column - Hold Firmly

Autopilot - Disengage. Do NOT re-engage. Control pitch attitude manually with column and electric trim.

If runaway continues, stab trim cutout (both) to cutout.

http://www.b737.org.uk/images/runawaystab2000.jpg

The new procedure is not that much different.

With PK-LQP - previous flight it took 6 minutes for them to get to this procedure - and it was suggestion of a dead-heading pilot. This resolved things. Despite going through this exact issue on previous flight, the next flight takes off, same issue develops because of underlying maintenance issue, they were dealing with this for 8 minutes, 28 activations of incorrect trim but with a fatal outcome.

Yes, MCAS was a bad design, yes it increased risk. I'm not sure it was a "nothing could be done" type situation. Better maintenance? Better communication between flights? Stab trim cutout earlier if you don't like how the automatic trim is working?

Airbus has historically pushed more automation / flight protection. My own suspicion is Boeing will go that way as well, ie, human in loop model they had (where human fixes the computer going crazy) just doesn't work well especially for folks flying these big jets without much earlier GA / manual flying time.

For example, in the US, a pilot would have done lots of manual flying on small planes first, and so might be a bit less automation dependent and better able to take over when computers go crazy. Also more hours before you fly the big jets (think 1,500 hours flight time). Usually a 4 year degree.

Overseas, you can come off the street and be flying a jet with 200 - 240 hours of time including sim time? That is a TON less flying time, probably very very little manual stick and rudder flying. A fair number of saves in the US have come from folks with great stick and rudder flying experience, even things like glider experience you just don't have overseas.

There usually is something called differences training for variants like this. Wouldn't cover MCAS, and is usually brief, but not normally zero. I'm surprised they did zero differences training if that was the case - that is very unusual. You've got to do normally at least an hour or two. A new variant is not unheard off, 737 probably has something like 12 variants under one type certificate. I would check your source there that no differences training came up.

slownews45··on A $5B hoard of aluminum
Seems very possible that there was a similar approach here in Vietnam where a goal might have been to get the stuff to the US.

I'm a bit confused by the seizure. Ie, if US doesn't want the cheap aluminum -> let another country have it cheap?

That said, Biden does seem to be going big on tariffs.

"The decision is one of Mr. Biden’s first significant moves on trade and suggests that his administration may be inclined to maintain the type of hefty tariffs Mr. Trump imposed on foreign metals to protect domestic industry. That position found favor with unions, but disappointed industries and businesses that have argued the tariffs raise costs." - NY Times - Biden Reinstates Aluminum Tariffs in One of His First Trade Moves

So this story does seem to be continuing with efforts by Biden to keep imported prices higher and there may be an element of politics in some of this all.

slownews45··on A $5B hoard of aluminum
If people are upset by so called "dumping" - can't they just let China charge more than they would have for this aluminum?

Aluminum has well known fixed costs in smelters, it's one of those products they use as an example where it may make economic sense to keep a smelter going (even if incurring losses / ) because the cost of shutdown.

Ie, a potline may take up to a week just to "turn off" and a huge amount of effort - think a month of full time work + weeks of troubleshooting as annode effect issues, alumina concentration and other bits settle down. Don't you basically have to recondition (fully, replace all anodes, dig out the crust) the pots, and even then you may be taking a bit hit on pot life with the cool down / reheat cycle?

I know the US has "anti dumping" rules regarding sugar as well - which I've been told contributes to a fair bit of corn syrup use.

I'm not that hung-up on the US blocking imports of cheap materials (if that's what the US wants to do), but how does the US get some third party country to grab this quantity of metal? Ie, China could sell to other countries that are not as concerned about dumping. For example, why would a poor country without a local smelter even care about "dumping" - it would seem the cheap prices would be a subsidy in effect.

slownews45··on Costly Airbus paint flaw goes wider than the Gulf
I thought Boeing blamed it on a combination of poor maintenance practices by the relevant airlines, poor handling and response to inflight error messages and maintenance requests on previous flights that left the issue unaddressed, and then weaknesses on the pilot side during the accident flights?

I personally think they went a bit overboard with the revised procedure memory items.

slownews45··on AWS price reduction for data transfers out to the internet
1) $50/TB is not insane pricing relatively. I used to pay something like $3/GB (way back) which would be $3,000/TB. There are still plenty of folks charging high rates.

2) $50/TB may not be a big part of some customers bills. If it is on cloudfront you drop to 0.02/GB or $20/TB for larger volumes.

3) AWS doesn't charge separately for some services that wrap around networking. Their nitro instances have a pretty good networking story.

4) Especially with this new free tier on cloudfront, a fair number of users will never hit 1TB per month (free) data.

slownews45··on AWS price reduction for data transfers out to the internet
"The CloudFront free tier is a full-service free tier, meaning customers can use all CloudFront features, such as support of website images, media workloads, and APIs, without service restrictions or data type limitations."

That's a pretty direct dig at cloudflare with their service and data type limitations :) So this does seem pretty cloudflare targeted.

slownews45··on AWS price reduction for data transfers out to the internet
Probably half R&D (no issues there), half sales and marketing.

One thing - is their free service offering a sales and marketing expense or is that in cost of revenue.

Last quarter they did 80M in sales costs (vs 40 in R&D and 28 in G&A). Sales costs were 50% of operating costs and close to 50% of revenue.

Amazon has everything blended, but sales runs 7% of revenue.

slownews45··on AWS price reduction for data transfers out to the internet
Over 150TB I think you are easily down to 50% off their base rate already aren't you? $50/TB or so?
slownews45··on AWS price reduction for data transfers out to the internet
Cloudflare has $20M in revenue growth in last quarter.

AWS had growth of $1.2B in last quarter? I think AWS is still hitting something like 30%+ revenue growth YoY even though they are already huge?

With this size / scale, AWS should be able predate someone like cloudflare on base pricing.

I do think cloudflare may be able to evolve their products faster given they aren't carrying around x billion of recurring revenue.

slownews45··on AWS price reduction for data transfers out to the internet
If you believe cloudflare egress is "free" I have a long list of "free" and "unlimited" services to sell you.

Cloudflare simply doesn't share egress pricing.

slownews45··on AWS free tier data transfer expansion
"It is crystal clear that this comment validates the misunderstanding of how bandwidth is priced in the real world and how"

If you don't think AWS bandwidth pricing is something in the real world I don't know what to say :) AWS is now broken out in Amazon financials - worth a look to see what they are raking in and the margins they are getting in the real world :)

"Clear pricing you say? I'll use Corey Quinn (The Duckbill Group [0]) as an example again"

His entire business depends on the fact that AWS pricing is clear and public. For a service like cloudflare (ie, call for pricing / dealing with a salesperson trying to figure out how much they can squeeze you for on upfront or on renewal) this type of service is much harder.

In short, if your bill is too high, you can talk to someone like Corey and they can probably help you bring it down.

slownews45··on AWS price reduction for data transfers out to the internet
Issues with cloudflare

1) They do not have public egress pricing. That should be a red flag at this time.

2) They are currently LOSING a lot of money on their offerings - AWS makes a ton. That should be red flag #2.

slownews45··on I faked tons of Covid passes – “Weak Key Cryptography in real world”
Short version if they get taken down:

The validation apps used a 512 bit RSA public key.

They used a factoring app and spend $200 on amazon to factor the private key from the public key.

They were then able to generate the COVID passes.

This is for the Honai Police Dept.

slownews45··on AWS free tier data transfer expansion
Let's be crystal crystal clear here. If I host a high data use video site on AWS, I can calculate what my costs will be. That provides me some certainty with respect to a business plan. Even better, AWS does have a history that is much better than others in terms of pricing stability. This doesn't mean best price.

Can you say the same about cloudflare? No. Can you say the same about oracle? No - they have a miserable history of screwing customers.

AWS is offering clear pricing, cloudflare is not. It's really that simple.

This makes me realize that folks just don't understand the value AWS is providing, and is perhaps why they can charge such insane prices.

People with actual money to spend don't want "free" because they don't believe it's actually free.

In terms of cloudflare, they have something like a negative 60% operating margin. The idea of building a business on a company with a negative 60%+ operating margin is insane, either they will go bust or have to raise prices.

AWS by contrast makes money. Because of this, they can shave a point or two off margin to give (another) price reduction.

1TB per month cloudfront, 2M cloudfront functions etc etc. They are under almost NO financial pressure to raise rates.

Cloudflare is under pressure or will be. With VC money perhaps they will get a longer runway.

The "free" offerings are an old story by now.

slownews45··on The 3-2-1 Backup Rule – Why Your Data Will Always Survive (2019)
Same here.

Since I "restore" this backup pretty frequently just for day to day living (ie, doing taxes) I'm also pretty sure it's accessible.

I do pay for versioning for the online sync of this, and I do a period S3 object lock copy (30 days). For me, that's good enough.

slownews45··on The 3-2-1 Backup Rule – Why Your Data Will Always Survive (2019)
For automated ransomewhere this works.

For targeted - it often doesn't because often your AWS keys are on the system doing the back up and have permissions to delete items etc.

Of course, this is why S3 allows you to set and object lock rule (ie, 30 days is plenty) that means even you (or your computer) can't go and delete those online backups.

slownews45··on AWS free tier data transfer expansion
You claim that a bunch of GPU crypto minors won't exploit a chance to incur billing overruns if amazon waives charges?

The amazon deal is simple. Very clear pricing for pay what you use.

Cloudflare - can you link to the page where they show the cost of bandwidth? Still waiting.

slownews45··on AWS free tier data transfer expansion
Um. They'd much rather deal with a waiver request from someone for $100 then to deal with a bad credit card in accounting spinning down a major account.

BTW - I've never heard of the later happening at AWS ever, and I have at other hosting providers.

slownews45··on AWS free tier data transfer expansion
I really would love if folks talking about volatile AWS prices would actually give examples.

I have been screwed, personally, by enough "free" and "unlimited" offerings to never believe them.

On AWS, all the price changes I've had have been to reduce my costs. This is over a pretty long period.

So inform us of the uncertainty with AWS.

Google, sure, they could cancel or 3x your bill (hi Maps API customers etc). AWS does not have that history.

Cloudflare has secret pricing - that's the really annoying thing. Seriously, put a porn site up online with cloudflare and see how far "free" gets you.

slownews45··on Science upside for Starship
The good news is we have some direct comparisons.

NASA has invested more than SpaceX in the Space Launch System (think $20B plus in spending). This will be a rocket that is disposable, every launch it lands in the ocean, all work lost. Estimated per launch costs and sustaining costs for all the facilities involved run about $2B-$3B - NASA isn't saying actually.

Anways, once things are head to head we will get to see if Musks promise of cheaper access to space vs the rocket with tons more money invested pans out.

Facility List for SLS by the way to give you just a sense of the cost base Musk is competing against.

Booster Fabrication Facility (BFF) - 45-acre site at KSC used to refurbish, manufacture, and assemble the aft skirt assembly and forward assembly for the SLS boosters. Includes the Multi-Purpose Logistic Facility used to receive, inspect and store shipped flight hardware.

Vertical Assembly Building (VAB) - Large (456 ft H max) vertical rocket integration facility. Floor load capacity of 12 million lbs, cranes located throughout building. Handling and storage of hazardous/ nonhazardous commodities.

Payload Hazardous Servicing Facility (PHSF) - The Payload Hazardous Servicing Facility (PHSF) was built in 1986. It is a Level 4, class 100,000 clean room that can be used as a Payload Processing Facility (PPF) and/or a Hazardous Processing Facility (HPF).

Michoud Assembly Facility (MAF) – 832 acre production complex located in New Orleans. MAF is one of the largest manufacturing plants in the world with 43 environmentally controlled acres (174,000 m2) under one roof. Includes two Vertical Assembly Buildings. Current site of the majority of core stage manufacturing and assembly and planned location for EUS manufacture and assembly.

Systems Integration Lab (SIL) - The Systems Integration Lab (SIL) supports end-to-end integrated avionics and software integration, check-out, verification, and validation. It demonstrates real-time flight control of a launch vehicle, such as SLS, during ascent. This lab at NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center in Huntsville, Alabama, not only includes the flight computers and avionics identical to the core stage avionics but also includes emulators for the rocket’s boosters and engines, the Launch Control Center and Orion.

Systems Integrated Test Facility (SITF) - The Software Integration and Test Facility (SITF) at MSFC on Redstone Arsenal integrates and tests software specifically for the SLS Core/Upper Stage avionics system.

Software Development Facility (SDF) - This Capability Maturity Model (CMM) Level 3 certified facility at MSFC performs a complete range of flight software activities from requirements development and analysis, software processes and planning, design and development, to systems integration and development testing. Products developed at the SDF are installed and tested at MSFC’s SITF.

Huntsville Operations Support Center (HOSC) – At MSFC on Redstone Arsenal, the HOSC is capable of distributing secure mission voice, video and data anywhere in the world. Includes Engineering Support

SLS Engineering Support Center (SESC) - Engineering Support Center (SESC). Certification runs for contingencies are performed by engineers responsible for the major elements of the SLS. Located in the HOSC, the SESC leverages remote architecture built for the ISS Payload Operations Center to allow engineers to focus on the engines, boosters, and stages of the SLS during testing and launch.

Advanced Manufacturing and Weld Facility – Located in MSFC’s Building 4755 on Redstone Arsenal, this friction stir welding facility uses advanced robotic tooling to weld barrel or dome segments up to 33 feet in diameter.

MSFC Flowrate and Structural Test Stands –Located at MSFC on Redstone Arsenal, designed to push, pull and apply pressure loads to SLS cryogenic tanks. Cutting-edge technology is also adaptable for future large-scale rockets and systems. Testing and data can be safely monitored from a control room via fiber optic cables.

Stennis Space Center – Multiple propulsion testing facilities for components, engines and stages located near Bay St. Louis, Mississippi. Facilities include the B-2 test stand used for the SLS core stage green run. Formerly used for Saturn V and Space Shuttle testing, this stand is equipped with a 195-ton (US), main derrick, lifting crane, with a 20-ton jib crane and is capable of static-firing test articles up to 33 ft in diameter.

slownews45··on GoDaddy Security Breach
Agreed. Headlines have just gotten terrible.
slownews45··on Singapore’s tech-utopia and surveillance state
But for example Young Dolph, went back to get some cookies in a tougher area, blown away and killed. Not so good. It's not clear that being socially competent / successful helped him.
slownews45··on Chrome breaks my website by hiding www in address bar
"There is no justification for hiding the subdomain from the url."

I'm just curious how developers are so blind to the issues of showing a subdomain that they assert that there is NO justification?

Can we perhaps assume a bit more good faith, or just consider that perhaps google has SOME (maybe bad) justification for this change?

I can easily think of MANY reasons to hide the subdomain, starting with the classic secure.bank.chase.com-url.io type phishing sites.

And this is actually illustrated here, if you don't have control over root domain, should google be able to trust your subdomains?

I would suggest that in 2021, if you can't get content to your root domain (or a redirect), you should update how you approach your hosting. I've been able to get content on a root domain for over 15 years.

Ie, look to yourself before ranting at google.

slownews45··on Tell HN: Amazon fraudulently canceling orders as returned items
You are a customer. There was a big issue in BC, your package from amazon was delayed and they refunded your money in full.

You are complaining because

1) the refund took two days to process, which you claim is unreasonable.

2) You are also complaining based on your emails that they didn't offer you a "rain cheque", depsite the fact that amazon does not offer rain cheque's, and in fact changes prices of item you have put in your cart.

You have now contacted a consumer protection advocate with this claim of fraud.

Good luck! This is the MOST ridiculous consumer complaint I have seen.

Are sellers treated like crap? For sure, that is a given. Sellers are not amazon's customers, there is no seller obsession, their is a customer obsession, and for the metrics amazon is watching what they did here probably makes sense, they can restock and reship these items to places they can deliver to.

slownews45··on Singapore’s tech-utopia and surveillance state
Sorry to see you getting downvoted, its an interesting perspective.

That said, even rappers seem to retire to "safer" places then these "lively" options you describe. So something about being safe appeals to many people, not just the socially incompetents'.

← PreviousPage 2 of 25Next →