HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

slowpoke

1,598 karma · joined June 28, 2011

submissionscomments
slowpoke··on Captchas Are Becoming Ridiculous
I, for one, refuse to be used as the source of free labor by Google just because I want to sign up for a website.
slowpoke··on YouTube Pushing Users Switch To Real Names
>Plus it helps get rid of the "internet fuckwads"

Hahaha. No.

Take a single look at Facebook, and you'll be proven wrong. The amount of utter retardation people post under their real names is both astonishing and depressing.

I've seen the reaction of another community where the "overlords" had the brilliant idea to force real names for exactly this reason. It was, by at least two orders of magnitude, the biggest shitstorm in the history of World of Warcraft, and that's saying something.

(In all fairness, Blizzard realized what a gigantically fucking stupid idea that was and retracted the announcement pretty quickly.)

I hope that this will deal a decisive blow to Youtube as a platform. The monopoly it enjoys in its segment is unhealthy and needs to go away.

slowpoke··on On Patents
>If the argument that computer algorithms are invalid because they are mathematical concepts is going to be made, it needs to be applied consistently which would exclude all currently patentable subject matter.

I wouldn't argue it that way, but you are correct: nothing should be patentable. The whole patent system is wrong and fucked up, we need to get rid of it before it causes even more irreparable harm to mankind.

slowpoke··on Linux 3.5 Kernel Released
>And as a proud owner of (what is widely considered the most supported linux laptop) lenovo laptop, I can say that many things just dont work. E.g. Suspend.

Suspend worked out of the box for me on my X220t. I am running Arch Linux.

slowpoke··on On Patents
I do not think that the whole patent issue is one of scale. It's one of principle. Nothing and no one should be allowed to own ideas, formulas, algorithms, genes or molecular arrangements.

Besides - and I've argued this countless times in the past - most medical research is already funded by the government. So it's not like innovations in medicine would suddenly grind to a halt. Maybe we'd see less useless shit like the newest "Anti-Aging" creme or other complete wastes of money.

Here's another fun fact: only about 15% of the income of the big pharma concerns actually goes into research. Most of it goes to advertisement. How in all hell is that a good use of money?

Furthermore, this system incentivices the utterly wrong things, and this remains my strongest argument against patents especially in pharma. You aren't encouraged to find cures, things that stop the cause of a sickness. The most profitable way is to find treatments for symptoms, which bind the patient to your meds, often for a long time, possibly until death. The best example would quite likely be AIDS. This is nothing less than completely, totally, absolutely, irredeemably and unexcusably fucked up.

slowpoke··on On Patents
>When people say "software patents" they are usually talking about "business process" patents, not computer algorithm patents, and business process patents should be disallowed generally.

You are contradicting yourself. "Business processes" are nothing more than algorithms, themselves. Algorithms are math. Math isn't patentable.

slowpoke··on MIT Economist: Here's How Copyright Laws Impoverish Wikipedia
Actually, the original intention was governmental censorship.
slowpoke··on Firefox Beta 15 supports the new Opus audio format
>That's typical - otherwise, you could implement some almost arbitrary protocol but say it was this one (and use a small amount of it) and claim that you were shielded from Skype's patents.

No, that's what standard bodies are for. No need for stupid patent licenses.

Besides, this is exactly why this isn't free.

Could I make a format based on Opus, but not conforming to the spec? Maybe because I had an idea for better algorithms in some parts? No. I cannot take the parts of Opus which fall under Skype/Microsofts patents and use them in derivatives. This means that both the implementation as well as the standard are free and open on paper only. In reality, I am denied freedom number 3 - the right to distribute modified implementations.

Take note that you could just solve this with a trademark on Opus (which probably already exists). Many large FLOSS projects do that. Firefox, for example - derivatives are not allowed to call themselves "Firefox" (which I think is one of the very few valid uses of trademarks).

If Skype/Microsoft would be actually interested in a free and open standard, they would have pledged to let go of these patents. I don't know if you can just say "this patent is now invalid", but if not, they could hand them over to the standard body, which could then assure that everybody is allowed to use these patents until they expire.

>Personally I think that's fine. If you want to engage in a full-on patent war, you should not benefit from a patent license like this.

I find it quite funny that people already implictly assume that if someone starts a patent infringement lawsuit, they are in for patent war. Please tell me again why we haven't got rid of patents yet?

slowpoke··on Firefox Beta 15 supports the new Opus audio format
I vehemently disagree. This is supposed to become an open standard. Open standards must, in my opinion, be completely free. No compromises. No exceptions. No footnotes. No patent bullshit.
slowpoke··on Firefox Beta 15 supports the new Opus audio format
Unfortunately, according to Wikipedia, Skype holds software patents on parts of the algorithm. Even though they said they'd make them avaiable royalty-free, this still means it isn't completely free.
slowpoke··on EFF, Reddit, Mozilla, others launch Internet Defense League and Cat Signal
>You could just, you know, choose not be logged in with facebook. Im not.

This utterly misses the point. This is not about being logged into Facebook or not. I don't have a Facebook account I could be logged into, and they still try to track me (if they could, and wouldn't be shitlisted by at least 4 different filters, that is).

Facebook has no business with me. They can - and should have to - stay the fuck out of my life. The same goes for the other billions of people who don't have a Facebook account and hopefully won't get one.

And even if you are logged into Facebook, that still gives them no right to track you. Privacy is an inalienable right that you cannot give away by signing up for a Facebook account.

>And as for tracking cookies: every website has them to some extend.

That's not an argument, that's a lame excuse. Everyone needs to stop this shit. There's no justification for it. And no, targeted ads are not a justification. If your business model depends on infringing on the privacy of people, then your business modell is highly unethical and should be illegal.

slowpoke··on Ubuntu is coming back to Dell Laptops
>Plus, if you're a linux guy, and the windows version is cheaper, just buy that and get the ubuntu image or drivers from dell support.

This is not an option if you are opposed to the Windows Tax on principle. I am extremely uncomfortable with artificially boosting Windows sales and indirectly supporting a monopoly.

And no, this by no means not a monopoly. Windows comes preinstalled on the overwhelming majority of computers today, and most of the time, there is no way around that. Most manufacturers even deny refunds, even when they are required to do so by law ("whatcha gonna do, sue us?").

For the record, I've been having "fun" with Lenovo trying to get my rightly deserved refund. I'm actually not adverse to taking this to court, but I'm a student and not exactly rich, so I don't know if I could afford that.

It's my firm opinion that forced bundling should be outright illegal, and it somewhat already is. There's a consumer protection directive from the EU that forbids "agressive or unfair practices", which this most certainly falls under.

slowpoke··on Dan Bull: Censored By Copyright For Protesting Being Censored By Copyright
Copyright is not part of the constitution. That's flat out wrong.

What's part of the constitution is congress' ability to create copyright or patent laws. There's absolutely no imperative to have these laws, and as others have pointed out, there was opposition against this power from several founding fathers, including Thomas Jefferson.

It strikes me as either uninformed or dishonest to assert/imply that copyright is a constitutionally granted right.

slowpoke··on Bringing Bash's powerful command line editing to Microsoft Windows' cmd.exe
Because lock-in is the only reason Windows is still so heavily entrenched on the market. This isn't even about the merit of Powershell as a program. This is about a tool which is designed to work on Windows (and Windows only[1]), and thus to increase the strength of the chains that bind you to the operating system.

Ever wondered why Microsoft didn't just make a bash-compatible shell? It's not like they couldn't - it's that they don't want. It would make it easier for people to jump ship, after all. And that's something they hope to prevent.

[1]: Yeah, yeah, there's a PS port to Unix land, but no sane human being will seriously use that. It's pretty much just another waste of time to save people from their mistake of investing into a proprietary tool tied to a proprietary environment.

slowpoke··on Bringing Bash's powerful command line editing to Microsoft Windows' cmd.exe
The difference is that in the world of GNU/Linux, a different desktop environment or window manager is usually just a single package manager command away. You're being free to choose. Microsoft will force their UIs on you, and there's nothing you can do about it (except not updating, which is a workaround, not a solution).
slowpoke··on Bringing Bash's powerful command line editing to Microsoft Windows' cmd.exe
Do yourself a favor and don't lock yourself even more into the Windows environment if you, for whatever reason, have to work with it.
slowpoke··on How patent protection for antibiotics creates incentives to render them useless
>The flip side of patent protection is this is what encourages drug companies to spend the multiple years of drug research and drug approval to develop new antibiotics.

That's patently wrong (pun intended).

At least in Europe, a major part of the income of the pharma concerns come from the government[1] - and as such indirectly the public. Furthermore, most of that money doesn't even go to research. but into marketing and other things which have nada to do with research. Pharma concerns generally spent only about 15% of their budget on actual research[2].

Furthermore, this system encourages the development of treatments instead of cures. It's a lot more profitable to bind a patient to a daily mix of pills than it is to give them a shot that cures their disease. Or develop other completely unnecessary shit, like all these "Anti-Aging" products.

This system is all sorts of fucked up, and it's ignorant to claim that it's the only alternative. I'll make the bold claim that without medical patents, we'd have already gotten rid of AIDS and severely reduced the mortality of cancer.

[1]: http://www2.piratpartiet.se/an_alternative_to_pharmaceutical... [2]: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/01/080105140107.ht...

slowpoke··on Sublime Text 2.0 Released
Vim has the ftplugin (filetype plugin), which makes this easy as pie, and extremely configurable, too.

You simply

    set filetype plugin on
then put configuration files for a filetype into ~/.vim/ftplugin/$filetype.vim (for example, python.vim, text.vim or even gitcommit.vim).

Within those, you can do things like setting expandtab or the tab/shift width - they are full local subconfigurations which override your global configuration. They are usually not very large (5 lines on average for me), but it sure helps keep things organized and easy to find and change.

slowpoke··on Malthusianisms
It is true, though, that there is a limit to how much people this planet can reasonably sustain, and I'd say we're billions over that mark - the only reason the system still works (barely) is because a large part of the world's population lives in poverty and hunger.

Optimization will only get you so far. We simply can't optimize away the fact that there is limited space on this planet and that we're pretty much out of it already. We can't sustain 7 billion people, tendency growing. Not at a humane average living standard.

slowpoke··on Alan Turing's Suicide in Doubt
Please don't give me the "rational adult" when you are obviously unable to differentiate between having a sexual preference and acting on a sexual preference. I've explicitly stated that child abuse and/or rape is a crime, and I've never questioned this - though there are some quiet interesting discussions to be had about age of consent, but this is not the time and place for them.

For future reference, before you jump on the "but think of the children" bandwagon, try to actually understand what the person you are accusing of defending child rape is saying.

slowpoke··on Alan Turing's Suicide in Doubt
>we've seen thought the history of time that it's ok to punish otherwise-acceptable behavior as long as it acts as an insurance in order to prevent more harmful acts.

I doubt there's actually any evidence for it. It's not that I don't understand the rationale behind it, it's that I reject it. Outlawing something merely because of the potential for abuse/escalation is almost always a slippery slope argument of the fallacious kind.

slowpoke··on Alan Turing's Suicide in Doubt
>Now, I'm a child of my time, so I think homosexuality is OK, and I think paedophilia is a crime.

Except paedophilia isn't a crime, child abuse (and rape) is. Assering a sexual preference (which paedophilia boils down to) is criminal is steering into thoughtcrime teritory. You can think it's wrong all you want, but that doesn't make it a crime.

It is, therefore, equally as abhorrent and repulsive to use these methods against paedophiles as it was using them against homosexuals in the 50s. It is, indeed, abhorrent and repulsive to ever use them on a human being, regardless of the reason.

But how will people fifty years hence look onto our debates about whether to allow people to marry? How will they look onto our treatment of socially not accepted sexual deviants. Social ousting, sex offenders list, incarceration, the eroding of free speech in the name of reducing just the chances of sexually "deviant" activity?

They will be equally as disgusted at this nonsense as we are right now at the heinous things perpetrated in the 50s. In fact, I am disgusted at it right now.

slowpoke··on EFF taking on software patent reform
>There's too much money in them.

This is not an argument. I'm pretty sure there was a lot of money in the slave markets as well. Didn't stop the US from abolishing it, though.

slowpoke··on EFF taking on software patent reform
The more people take the "radical" stance, the less radical it becomes (relative to the status quo). That's my whole point. So stop bickering about how we'll never get anything done with demands for abolition - demand it be done, and tell others to do the same. It's that simple.
slowpoke··on EFF taking on software patent reform
We don't want a different system. We want no system at all. How's that so hard to grasp? Every single proposal to "fix" patents so far either involves fighting bureaucracy with even more bureaucracy (that's suuuure gonna work out) or are based on the naive assertion that a shorter evil is somehow a lesser evil.

People need to acknowledge already that the patent system is not just a little broken, it's fundamentally broken to its very core. You can band-aid it all you want, it won't fix the inherent problem, and that is and always was the paradoxical claim that slowing down progress will somehow lead to more progress, as well as the utterly illogical assertion that you can, in any way, own abstract concepts.

I completely agree with iwwr: don't be afraid to take the "radical" stance for the sake of a twisted form of political correctness. If something is bullshit, then say so, and demand it be stopped. Not weasel around trying to appease the people who profit from the status quo. Patents are bullshit - the only good patent is a nonexistent patent. Period. So demand that we get rid of this impediment to mankind.

slowpoke··on Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
>I simply do not believe that there is a moral imperative that software vendors allow anyone and everyone to redistribute that package.

The moral imperative here is not that they need to allow it - it's that they can and should not be able to forbid it. You can't force someone to share something, but neither can you stop others from doing so.

slowpoke··on Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
>its still debatable whether such a thing would be viable given the R&D costs in producing a modern desktop OS, mobile OS, programming languages and runtimes, Metro, etc.

Bullshit. The estimated cost to redevelop the Linux kernel in a proprietary environment exceeds 600 million USD, and has probably even reached the billion USD mark by now.[1]. It's perfectly possible.

The only reason Windows is still so entrenched on the market are shady monopolist tactics, intentional lock-in practices and closed, shitty formats such as the Office pseudo-standard. In other words, the very things RMS warned about and which the free software community is fighting against.

>Linux, on the desktop, has barely caught up to the last decade's state of the art, and in many places (such as graphics drivers), it relies on closed-source software.

Your ramblings are so dishonest it's cringe-worthy. GNU/Linux is perfectly viable on the desktop. The greatest hurdle it faces is exactly the kind of FUD that you are spreading.

As for the drivers: yes, and this is a problem. The evil of proprietary hardware and closed specs is something that needs to go the way of the dodo, too, and it needs to do so fast. We could have drivers vastly exceeding anything proprietary if the specs for nVidia or ATI/AMD cards would be accessible. For the record, the best graphic drivers available for GNU/Linux are for the Intel Graphic chips, and they are perfectly free.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_kernel#Estimated_cost_to...

slowpoke··on Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
>If my users don't want me to trample on their "Freedoms", they don't have to buy my software.

They could most likely not make an informed choice, because you do not educate them about denying them their freedom. And still there is no argument to do it.

slowpoke··on Secure Boot: Who will control your next computer?
>Provides the ability to turn a profit on the sale of software licenses, which is a tried and true method for producing better quality consumer software than we've ever seen from OSS products.

a) "Tried and true" does not mean it will work forever. It's also bullshit to sell copies of non-scarce resources. Besides, you can sell Free software. Your argument is invalid.

b) "better quality [...] than ever seen from OSS products" is bullcrap, and you know it. There's a few select niche markets where proprietary software is still entrenched (eg, Graphic Design), but this too will change. Also, if you don't like something or you feel like a feature is missing, stop complaining and start contributing.

>I write closed-source software, and sell it to people that want to buy it.

And again you are missing the fact that this neither requires your software to be proprietary nor does it mean you need to trample on your users' Freedoms. If they want what you are writing, they will still want it if it's Free (as in Speech).

>If making a decent wage while giving people what they want is evil, well, call me Satan.

Making a decent wage with unethical practices is still evil. The circumstances do not matter. You're essentially saying that the ability to turn a profit somehow excuses wrongdoing. It doesn't.

>Yeah, this right here? This is why I can't stand the GPLers.

Hate us all you want, in the end we are right and we'll eventually win. :)

slowpoke··on Microsoft introduces Windows Phone 8
>They have taken a far too totalitarian approach to their offerings and it is not getting any better.

You might have missed the part about Microsoft being equally as eager to lock down everything they can get away with. This isn't going to make things better, it's going to be worse.

← PreviousPage 3 of 20Next →