HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

slurgfest

1,975 karma · joined December 17, 2011

submissionscomments
slurgfest··on No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app
They don't necessarily know what they need. Perhaps all they need is a bookmark for your site, exposed as a big button choice. You'd have to follow up with some testing to find out what this really meant.
slurgfest··on S-expressions
Thank you for this post, because it made me curious enough to look up Dijkstra's views on LISP. (It seems he credited it for some innovations but had a lot of complaints about its early design and docs, and favored ALGOL family design decisions)
slurgfest··on "Most of you steal your software"
Right, if a failed company (even one which failed because of piracy) had a letter like this, you wouldn't be reading it.
slurgfest··on "Most of you steal your software"
Piracy is not the same as "open technologies" in any way. In fact, the latter prevents the former (if I settle on GIMP instead of pirating Photoshop...)
slurgfest··on "Most of you steal your software"
It's amazing, and frankly stupid, how quickly you slid from piracy to OSS.

OSS has nothing to do with piracy. If I licensed my project MIT, sharing it is not piracy. OSS platforms do not have thriving piracy ecosystems because there is plenty of OSS software for them. In my experience, people who believe in OSS are the most likely to champion using a legal OSS alternative to pirating some widely-used proprietary software.

slurgfest··on Why Did The Media Keep The Recent Peaceful Icelandic Revolution Quiet?
When one of the sides is British, the BBC presents one side, or presents the other side in a completely jaundiced way that omits relevant but inconvenient facts.
slurgfest··on The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius
Even if I could create sentient beings, this wouldn't imply the power to declare what is good or true by fiat. 2 + 2 = 4, massive objects attract each other gravitationally, and it's morally problematic to put children in ovens for being Jewish even if a maximally powerful alien or wizard said otherwise. These things cannot be changed by any fiat, and being very powerful doesn't make it any more possible.
slurgfest··on Iran unveils new indigenous stealth fighter “Qaher 313″
This isn't just about today's politics, it is also about a long-standing sense of national inferiority and a strong desire to prove that Iran is as good as other big countries
slurgfest··on Ruby gems are still not safe to use
Consider physical security against terrorist attacks. You can spend unlimited resources trying to prevent these. But this is subject to diminishing returns, and has other costs.In software projects, too, there IS a point at which it is more rational to trade off security against something else.

I would argue that the situation with Rails is analogous to the (historical) situation with Windows. There have been some design mistakes which have opened up more surface area for attacks. But the number of exploits has a lot more to do with market share.

slurgfest··on Ruby gems are still not safe to use
Much as I prefer Python, I don't think that switching to it just for more security is going to be very satisfying or have a huge return.

I submit that security is typically more a function of your project than JUST the language it is written in. For example, I doubt that Haskell's focus on type safety alone will make your programs secure (particularly when you are not enjoying it and are spending more time than you want on issues other than security). You may get more bang for the buck by focusing on security as an issue within whatever language you are using?

slurgfest··on Ruby gems are still not safe to use
Without disagreeing with you substantively, Python eggs have not been the main way Python packages are distributed for years now. This is not to say that PyPI couldn't use some attention to issues like signing!
slurgfest··on Flight: A lightweight, component-based JavaScript framework from Twitter
Do you find that this is a big deal in practice, or does it just feel messy to you?
slurgfest··on What If Cars Were Rented Like We Hire Programmers?
The process only has to look objective and quantifiable. Everyone doesn't get the same treatment, but it's not actionable if the differences are all deniable and have rationalizations like 'culture fit'. People can and do still hire who they want for whatever reason, they just claim some objective reason for it.
slurgfest··on What If Cars Were Rented Like We Hire Programmers?
If you hire someone who is boring and has no obvious problem but isn't very productive, you have your ass covered. His lack of productivity is his fault. If you hire someone exceptionally useful with some notable problem, or even just some notable flavor someone doesn't like, it is something you should have noticed and you are liable. A lot of companies want an unblemished calf more than they want a Zed Shaw.
slurgfest··on What If Cars Were Rented Like We Hire Programmers?
Hiring practices of Google and Amazon are very unrepresentative of smaller companies and more heavily emphasize general intelligence, prestigious background and background in computer science. As you say, it's about the process of working a problem more than experience with specific tools.

However, most companies are smaller than Google and Amazon and have different practices. Sometimes, stupid practices, because the interviewers don't really know how to do it, just want to get it over with, or really care about things which aren't important.

But since they are in the hiring position and assume they and their company are awesome, they are not so likely to question their own technical or interviewing abilities and certainly don't want to hear what interviewees have to say about it.

You need additional insights beyond just doing the job to understand what makes someone else useful in that job. And if you don't even have that much, you are guaranteed to ask stupid questions and end up with people selected for how good they are at selling and how much you think they're cool.

slurgfest··on Chuck Close on Creativity, Work Ethic, and Problem-Solving vs. Problem-Creating
I don't see the purpose and don't have the time to have a long, detailed argument about this, particularly when you have begun by putting the words "during his time" in my mouth. The supremacy of Leonardo is contentious and shouldn't be taken as dogma.

If you want to become an excellent engineer or artist then you will probably be better served by getting educated, and logging many hours in progressively more difficult jobs, than procrastinating and dithering.

Anyway, most people don't have the luxury, and will only get anything interesting done if they put in serious focused effort.

slurgfest··on A business meeting
If you are in charge of widget production, you should absolutely understand the basics of widget production. Don't blame the widget-specialists you have hired to produce widgets if you are not putting forth any significant effort into understanding your own business.
slurgfest··on ScriptCraft: Building cool things using Javascript in Minecraft
From the server's standpoint, running n players has optimistically the same cost whether those players are client-side bots or not (although, bots can be more abusive). In the MUD days (20+ years ago) this was called "multiplaying" and was usually forbidden, partly on grounds of this resource use, but some games did allow it. MMOs 10+ years ago saw an influx of people using GUI scripting tools to implement bots. It's fairly obvious when it's happening and people really don't like it for the same reasons that they often don't like server-side bots in multiplayer games.

So realistically I believe this is a niche idea which might be hard to make commercially viable. But it could be an interesting thing for private minecraft servers.

slurgfest··on Chuck Close on Creativity, Work Ethic, and Problem-Solving vs. Problem-Creating
There were better artists, and better engineers, but he certainly had a fertile imagination, and who knows, maybe freedom of schedule was part of that.
slurgfest··on How to Tackle Three of the Toughest Interview Questions
That's a thing, it's technically true in itself, and it's bad enough to sound plausible. I think you are a smart person and it's a good self-preserving tactic. We all have to eat.

But this answer is unlikely to be the worst thing about you. You probably do have character flaws which affect your work. It's just that digging into them won't do anything except give the advantage to someone else who kept his mouth shut.

I submit that what this question really does is test fit to a certain corporate culture. There's a tacit understanding that you are supposed to come up with some token flaw to use. People oblivious of this will either overshare or obviously deflect the question, and people who are stubbornly honest will also not give the expected answer.

This kind of obliviousness or stubborn honesty can be a political liability. E.g.: if you are asked about your boss's or team's or company's worst weakness, you should also offer some bullshit token flaw which isn't really meaningful, because this determines their futures too.

If a culture isn't specifically built to put honesty ahead of politics, politics will quickly take the lead and honesty will be a casualty.

slurgfest··on How to Tackle Three of the Toughest Interview Questions
If you want to gauge ability to communicate then you should probably find some way to get relevant work samples, like explaining the kind of thing which will have to explained in the job (e.g.: docs or brief presentation on something), rather than relying on the totally unreliable assumption that asking someone bad things about themselves in a high-pressure situation is a close analogue to what they will be doing on a daily basis.

This is like the ancient Chinese exams which assessed applicants' suitability by their knowledge of classical poetry. Of course people who are very well prepared or smart will do better in aggregate and with certain biases, but this doesn't mean you are measuring what you claim to measure.

slurgfest··on How to Tackle Three of the Toughest Interview Questions
You say something that's not an issue, therefore it is not really the worst thing about you. (Unless there is nothing bad about you. Lucky you.)
slurgfest··on How to Tackle Three of the Toughest Interview Questions
It's a pressure question, a kind of interrogation. If you are honest, you will realize that you have a ton of things wrong with you and it isn't all that meaningful to pick the "worst" one.

People have been asking this for so long that it really only gauges whether the applicant canned an answer to it which sounds bad enough that you won't think it's bullshit, but good enough that they aren't hurting their application. As with other interrogation techniques you often aren't selecting against lying, but just for plausible lying that you are unequipped to detect. It is certainly an illusion that you are selecting for honesty this way.

If you do want to hire honest people, and it isn't for an area like sales where it is important for them to project unrealistic levels of self-confidence, you will cause less needless anxiety and get more actionable information if you can get specific on what sort of disclosure you need, rather than just asking the applicant to incriminate themselves in the worst way they can imagine.

If you want to punish people with ability and integrity but lower self-esteem then this question is your ideal instrument.

slurgfest··on How to Tackle Three of the Toughest Interview Questions
Being asked to rule yourself out of a job that you are interviewing for (or else deflect the question with some bullshit humblebrag) is far from an ideal gauge of self-awareness.
slurgfest··on For Wealthy Chinese, Bicycles Become Status Symbols
When you can hardly get a new bike for $600 any more, and it's not considered abnormal to spend well over $1000, I would say it is a bit of a status symbol
slurgfest··on Let's make a FirefoxOS app
Apple computers used to run Apple DOS
slurgfest··on OS X emulation layer for Linux
Why doesn't Apple make it possible to use its development environment (required for developing products to run on its hardware) in a VM? This seems like a user-unfriendly decision.
slurgfest··on Watch Out: India’s Aadhar And The Consumer Credit Tsunami
Individual credit card debt is NOT what precipitated the global debt crisis.
slurgfest··on My New Development Laptop: Samsung Chromebook
Rather than just making baseless assertions about people who favor vim or emacs, please mention an IDE with the same maturity, community, cross-platform support, cross-language support, and customizability as either vim or emacs.

To pick just one random alternative, let's take gedit. It looks simple and standard, which is nice. It's newer, that could be OK. It can be installed on more than one platform (though not necessarily simply). It has the major features, it's basically feature-complete. For fancier stuff and language-specific tools, you can write plugins with Python, which makes all kinds of things possible. On the other hand, it can get crashy when you use a few plugins - maturity issue. There are few plugins and fewer actively maintained because there's not a big community to support and build on it. A lot of its behavior is reasonable but not really customizable. Random example - if I personally want to have a simpler interface in the vein of scribes or WriteRoom, I'm SOL. Of course, gedit simply cannot be used from a terminal, so you will use another editor for that, with its own keybindings etc.

Most of the good editors have a story like this. Even if it seems to work great and be flexible enough, the community and plugins aren't there.

If your goal is only (say) to write C# for Windows, Visual Studio is probably best. If you only want to write Java, (say) IDEA is probably best. These are powerful environments. But only for certain things, and in a certain way. If you want to code on another platform, different language, really change the behavior, get around a bug, or get a fancy new capability without paying a vendor lots of money, you are just going to hit limits and have to pick up yet another tool.

If you've learned vim or emacs then you at least have a default which licks all these issues at once. In this sense they are "ultimate editors". And this is an opinion informed by broad usage of many editors.

slurgfest··on My New Development Laptop: Samsung Chromebook
You can use vim and gvim locally.

Sharpening your tools is an investment where you trade time now for power later. Vim is very much an instance of that trade-off. It's a ridiculously flexible power tool. If you are a machine at driving nails with a rusty hammer and you are happy, then there's no reason to stop doing it that way.But if the reason you don't use vim is that you're scared of it, it's not as bad as you think. You don't have to be superior to learn it, you just need a week and an open mind.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →