1,975 karma · joined December 17, 2011
Granting monopoly power to state governments to use aggression against the people would have resulted in the continued application of that aggression against slaves.
In that specific context it's good to have a story saying, actually this is turning out not to be such a big deal.
When the two comments in this thread say "well yeah, Siri's probably over-hyped and its usefulness is actually quite limited" they aren't disagreeing with the article nearly so strongly as they are disagreeing with the majority of what the tech press was saying when Siri first arrived.
Because when you say this EO is a watered-down version of a bill, and CISPA was a watered-down version of that, and say that what Obama likes is 'worse' than CISPA - what many people are going to hear is that this EO is the super-mega-SOPA that will take away all their freedoms, and this time sneakily enacted by Obama alone - not that you just think these measures are ill-conceived because they do little to improve security.
It doesn't seem completely accurate to count all the time spent at university as equivalent to the same time spent working in the trenches.
And it seems extremely harsh to say that there is no reason to hire people who didn't do CS in university, because they were "asleep at the wheel." Figuring out what you are going to do in the future is not the same skill as shipping software.
Then there are other packages which will never be less tested than a default because they have already been tested for a few years.
Candidates differ on concrete policy issues which have concrete consequences after elections. If you don't care about those differences, that is your affair - it does not mean that voting is 'demonstrably meaningless.'
If you had ever looked into what tends to happen in a violent revolution, you would have found that due process is not a significant part of it, and the end result is often a dictatorship, theocracy, etc.
There is no reason to suppose that the lawless violence you advocate will ultimately result in any improvement, for anyone except 'the party' which wins the revolution.
It makes getting good, scalable performance basically trivial. Static content distributed across CDNs means someone else solves that problem for you at low cost. Forget SQL injections and usually forget XSS. If you need a comments section, you realistically need outside help to filter out spam anyway, might as well use something like Disqus. Also, very few moving parts to break after deploy.
Leave the people who develop knowledge and disseminate it for the rest of society alone with your political agenda.
There is no shortage of people who will do poorly at IQ tests because of cognitive difficulties and (sure) lack of motivation to practice. Does loading on factors like these make IQ tests less predictive of academic or career outcomes? No, both of those things also require a combination of cognitive ability and motivation.