HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smallmancontrov

5,003 karma · joined September 17, 2019

submissionscomments
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
Gross profitability always happens before net profitability, lol. "We've reached the first but not the second" isn't a deceptive claim, especially with the caveat in the same sentence, and it's a step that every net profitable company went through at some point in its life.
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
That's just it: they have more compute. They have a "do more with more" lever in addition to a "do slightly less with much less" lever. DeepSeek can't win with the first lever, so they have committed everything to the second, while within the frontier labs the two levers fight for attention and frankly the first is clearly the favored child. I'm not accusing OpenAI and Anthropic of being slouches, but I am not sure that more resources + divided goals > singleminded pursuit of a singular goal.
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
...but in practice there are a few highly suboptimal Nash Equilibria sprinkled throughout the market that are systematically unaddressable by greedy optimization, and these turn into an infinite money glitch for the rich and an infinite resource drain for the poor.
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
"the trust-busters were the REAL monopolists"

Source: trust me bro. Lol.

smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
No, it's really not. Do you have a war chest to drag out a legal battle and the ability to bankrupt your landlord by withholding payment? The rules are different at this scale, and "you can't enforce a contract if the attempt will bankrupt you" is only one of the possible games.

Here's another one: pay a supplier to cripple their deployment. Suddenly it's the neocloud's fault for failing to deliver, not your fault for failing to pay.

Did we all forget how Sam Altman turned a non-profit into a for-profit? Do we think he'll bring less sociopathy to this battle?

smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
If you want to call Obama and Biden 7th party system, I don't really agree but I also don't think it matters for my argument: we can just re-label them and move on.
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
Nope, same guy. Seen it a dozen times. Unenlightened self interest is a helluva drug.
smallmancontrov··on America has lost 200k of jobs in media, film and the arts. How much is AI?
The American Dream is not to Owner's Equivalent Rent a house.
smallmancontrov··on America has lost 200k of jobs in media, film and the arts. How much is AI?
Not only is CPI calculated with Hedonic Adjustments (the term they use when doing the thing you said they didn't do), those are one of the most controversial parts of the CPI calculation, because they allow CPU GHz to offset wildly inflating health care, housing, and education costs, which is obvious bullshit.
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
Yes, but DeepSeek went absolute goblin-mode on optimization and I would not be shocked to discover that OpenAI and Anthropic were behind on that front.
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
Did the frontier labs take out debt or did they make flimsy unenforceable agreements to neoclouds who took out debt?
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
It's wild how businessmen will pitch you the 10 ways they will abuse the rules of the game to obtain a monopoly and extract rent, then they will turn around and say that the game rules are perfect and our only failing is not following them hard enough.
smallmancontrov··on OpenAI and Anthropic cut their LLM prices by up to 80% within a few months. Why?
In the hands of 4th party system Progressive Republicans and 5th party system New Deal Democrats, government was an extremely powerful force for trust-busting.

In the hands of 6th party system Republicans, namely Ronald Reagan and Robert Bork, the government worked hard to usher in a a new era of Robber Barons. We live in the culmination of this project.

History says the result depends on the hands, not the tool. 6th party system Democrats have largely failed to undo the Reagan/Bork policies, but that's an act of omission not comission and even then Lina Khan was a big step in the right direction. This issue was on the ballot in 2024 and will be again in 2028. Hopefully we make better choices in 2028.

smallmancontrov··on America has lost 200k of jobs in media, film and the arts. How much is AI?
...which is notorious for using a dogshit basket and basket-update methodology to make the number look good.
smallmancontrov··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
You ignore our history of doing this very thing. There was a time when the Robber Barons held US politics in an iron grip, funding the politics, the media, steering the discourse. We defeated them before and we can do it again.
smallmancontrov··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
This flak was all over the news at the time, but it never explained to me why a merger would have been better for consumers than a bankruptcy sale. In both cases, the competition goes down and the unprofitable business model gets adjusted until it is profitable. In no case would the assets go to waste, in no case would the effective freebies continue. So what was lost? Can you explain that to me? Or were you mindlessly repeating the flak?
smallmancontrov··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
Did you see how much flak Lina Khan got for pushing in that direction?

This issue was on the ballot and will be again.

smallmancontrov··on Ask HN: If the models are so good, why doesn't OpenAI just start 100 companies?
Not asking smart questions about the corporate excuses, that's what. Back to the bread line with you!
smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
I'm optimistic in the limit but I can be pretty cynical about the path. The self-serving narratives of the rich are embedded deep in our national psyche. We might need 30% unemployment, a precipitous demand collapse from the liquidated masses, a second Great Depression, and years of trying the wrong solutions before people begrudgingly move on to the right ones.

But we might not. The billionaires moved early; we have over two years until the next presidential election and a speeding AI train that seems on-track to deliver exactly the right amount of economic displacement by then: enough to convince people to act boldly, but not nearly so much as to achieve a worst case. That's no guarantee of success but the good path has substantial probability weight.

smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
> Who decides what is valuable?

Rich people who mostly want others to pay them for being rich? That's a weird and extreme answer and I'm tired of pretending it isn't. This is not an externality problem, it's a priority problem. These priorities are dogshit.

We don't need gini=0 to fix this. Gini=0.9 is nuts, famous billionaires having millions of times the weight as the median American is nuts, and we need to back off a bit. Maybe start by asking them to pay taxes. For once.

smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
No, the Great Depression had a huge role to play in unwinding inequality. I'm pretty sure Piketty talks about this in Capital but it's been a while since I've read it so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. In any case, it mechanically works the same way as war: a catastrophe incinerates capital, poor people suffer more in real terms but rich people suffer more in nominal terms and it's the nominal terms that drive the burden of furnishing runaway capital with runaway returns so the nominal wipeout has the very real effect of resetting the inequality spiral. The New Deal was downstream of this reset and represented real concessions to the middle class that persist to this very day.

> every other major economy on earth was decimated

That would be a more convincing argument if the decimated economies didn't experience the upswing in middle class living standards as well. Gary Stevenson has been covering this from the UK angle and his story (and the UK's story) is the same: middle class flourishing in the wake of WWII and a steady erosion back to the mean. This suggests that the capital reset, increase in worker bargaining power, and the concessions won through it were causal while being on the fortunate side of the Atlantic was not.

smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
If the economic value of a good or service is what someone will pay you for it, then unpaid charity has no economic value. We are applying the definition handed to us by (certain schools of) economics and finding that it leads us to some ridiculous places, which should cast doubt on the definition. A better definition of economic value could capture the value of charity, but then it would not support the laissez-faire policies that the usual one is often dragged out to support.

The "what someone will pay for it" definition is a trojan horse. It looks like a mathematical practicality, but it actually smuggles the self-interest of the wealthy into a value system that would not otherwise enshrine such as a guiding principle.

smallmancontrov··on Starcraft: Ashfall
THE MERGING IS NOT COMPLETE
smallmancontrov··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
Steering the conversation away from the pertinent and towards the irrelevant should meet with resistance and should be exhausting. I hope to exhaust the next person to try this evil trick even more.
smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
> it has (almost) never happened before

Ah, but it has! The New Deal era ~100 years ago is the one to look at. We've fixed this before, we can fix it again.

smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
Yes. The New Deal brought the 40 hour workweek + overtime structure to America, the business leaders all talked about how it would collapse the economy (they even tried to coup FDR!), and then it helped usher in the greatest era of prosperity the American Middle Class had even seen. So much so that people with the opposite politics keep pointing at this period while promising that economically opposite actions will lead to the same outcome. Just one more concession to Big Business, one more tax cut for billionaires, one more erosion of workers rights will usher in prosperity that will surely trickle down. This keeps not working over and over again (from the perspective of the gullible voter), so it's long past time to bring back the politics of the three-letter Democrats and demand a larger share of our own productivity.
smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
Exactly. Remember, economic value is wealth weighted, a fact that sets it starkly apart from nearly every other notion of value. Feeding the proverbial starving orphan? Zero economic value because the orphan can't pay you back. Merging all the banks to hike fees and offload risk onto the public? Enormous economic value, because a large number of wealthy shareholders can be made much wealthier.

As wealth inequality increases, the purpose of the economy as seen through its objective function increasingly revolves around the desire of rich people to get paid for being rich. The exponential growth of asset values in excess of economic growth (including yours, but dominated by those of the wealthy) ensures that not only does the growing economic surplus fail to trickle down, but that the median person sees a grinding deprivation as their ability to command a wage is slowly eroded while their costs rise.

smallmancontrov··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
Especially someone who claims interpersonal skills as a strength.
smallmancontrov··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
They listed food, medicine, and housing. The latter two have massively inflated and are creating the problem. The former is not. Why did you choose to steer the conversation away from the important ones and towards the unimportant ones?
smallmancontrov··on 90% of US working hours are spent on tasks not covered well by AI benchmarks
Health care, housing, and education are the drivers of the cost of living / wage crisis. Wheat is not. Furthermore, you know this. Why did you choose to steer the conversation away from the problem?
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →