HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smartician

1,067 karma · joined August 15, 2012

submissionscomments
smartician··on Transcript of controller telling plane to land in Minsk
Greenwald has been shilling for Russia for years now, so it's not a stretch that this would extend to Belarus as well?
smartician··on Greenwald: Yesterday Journalists Spread a Significant Lie All over Twitter
Sounds like you have a different idea of what "getting along" means?
smartician··on Greenwald: Yesterday Journalists Spread a Significant Lie All over Twitter
The conspiracy is now so wide-spread that almost everybody is part of it. I call it "reality".
smartician··on Greenwald: Yesterday Journalists Spread a Significant Lie All over Twitter
It's almost comical how you go from "it doesn't matter what the scale of the irregularities is, fraud is fraud" to "you have to qualify the scale of the insurrection, only a few were armed" in the same post.

If this is a sarcastic post, well done!

smartician··on Silicon Valley stays on top as tech salaries climb across U.S.
When I left Germany in 2007, I was making 52000 Euro per year. Crazy to hear that salaries remained practically flat. When I went to Silicon Valley, my pay practically doubled overnight, and now 13 years later I make 10x as much (and my job hasn't really changed much).

Curious though how your house cleaner is making more than a software engineer?

smartician··on Judge in Google case disturbed that 'incognito' users are tracked
I read through the original complaint[1] and had a few observations that made me scratch my head.

1. All other browsers' private/incognito modes behave the same. Then why do they expect Chrome to behave differently? Is the complaint about Google Analytics collecting data, or about Chrome making false promises?

2. It never explains how the information sent to Google Analytics can be tied to your person. A public IP address is generally not good enough. Forensically maybe, when combined with ISP logs, but not routinely at scale.

3. It asserts that Google is using this information "nefariously", without going into detail: "This does not mean that Google does not utilize and/or monetize this data in any way. Google does. It merely changes the form of storage after the data has served Google’s nefarious uses."

4. It points out that this kind of information is so valuable to Google that they run a program where they pay people to observe their behavior. But, the whole complaint is about how Google collects that information already. Why have a separate program where they pay users?

5. Classifying visiting a website in incognito mode as "confidential communication" is a bit of a stretch, but that's the centerpiece of their complaint.

[1] https://www.classaction.org/media/brown-et-al-v-google-llc-e...

Disclosure: I work for Google, but not in Chrome or GA. The opinions expressed in this post are mine.

smartician··on Judge in Google case disturbed that 'incognito' users are tracked
Can you define "tracking"?
smartician··on Ask HN: 3.4M video views, no reactions
My guess is that it was used as a paid ad in other YouTube videos. Channels will often do that quickly accumulate view count, which would help in organic rankings as well. In this case, it doesn't seem to have worked very well. Maybe it was unlisted at first and only recently made public?
smartician··on Google employees say AI researcher did not resign, despite what exec claims
For some reason there is a subculture within Google where employees act antagonistic towards their employer and go all Pikachu-faced when they're then terminated. Then they speak out and claim they were retaliated against, whereas people who worked for conventional companies would think, "well, what did you expect?"

It is part of Google's culture to not blindly agree with leadership on every issue and you're encouraged to voice differing opinions, but I guess some take this too far in the other direction and assume that every kind of negative feedback is appreciated and "protected".

smartician··on Google illegally spied on workers before firing them, US labor board alleges
The article doesn't mention anything about mobile devices though?
smartician··on Google illegally spied on workers before firing them, US labor board alleges
But in order for Google to catch people spying on other people by viewing their calendars, Google would have to surveil the activity of the people doing the spying. Maybe that's what the headline is referring to, but the article doesn't spell that out explicitly (which makes it a very poor piece of journalism in my opinion).
smartician··on Master of Magic
I thought this was about the 1985 RPG of the same name. The amazing Rob Hubbard soundtrack immediately played in my head when I clicked through, only to find screenshots of a completely unfamiliar game. It took me almost half an hour to figure out that my brain hadn't played tricks on me, and that there are two completely different games with the same name!
smartician··on Ask HN: Thinking of leaving California. Should I vest my options while here?
My understanding is that you will owe taxes on all 10,000 shares, since you were in CA when they were granted. Vesting dates don't matter.
smartician··on Ask HN: Why do so many German websites have dashes in the URL?
Multiple reasons come to mind.

1. Germany doesn't have TLDs like ".edu", and it became a de-facto standard to construct higher education domains by abbreviation of type of school and location: www.[uni|fh|...]-[location].de

2. Dashes in a URL emulate spaces, and in German, without spaces a phrase is often ambiguous. Example: "Gehweg" = sidewalk, "Geh weg" = get lost! Even in English, I often think a domain name would be easier to parse with dashes, e.g. "calstatela.edu" vs "cal-state-la.edu".

3. There's a strong compulsion ingrained in almost every German to be orthographically correct, and delimiting words correctly is a big part of that.

smartician··on Foxconn’s buildings in Wisconsin are still empty, one year later
Foxconn was promised tax credits, with the requirement that they meet certain job creation and investment targets. Tax credits lower your tax owed dollar for dollar. What happens when the credits exceed the taxes due? I looked it up:

The contract[1] states that these are tax credits pursuant to Wisconsin State statute 71.28(3wm)[2], which states "If the allowable amount of the claim under this subsection exceeds the taxes otherwise due on the claimant's income under s. 71.23, the amount of the claim that is not used to offset those taxes shall be certified by the department of revenue to the department of administration for payment by check, share draft, or other draft[...]"

So if Foxconn meets the investment and job creation requirements and doesn't have significant state tax burdens, the Wisconsin tax payers will have to write big fat checks to Foxconn, hoping that the indirect economic impact of Foxconn's activity is enough to offset these payments. In that case, these subsidies are a direct cost.

[1] https://wisconnvalley.wi.gov/Documents/WEDCcontract-state.pd... [2] https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/statutes/statutes/71/IV/28

smartician··on Study shows e-bike riders get more exercise than cyclists
Bingo.

"Travel-related activities of e-bikers who switched from cycling decreased by around 200 MET min/wk., while those switching from private motorized vehicle and public transport gained around 550 and 800 MET min/wk. respectively."

smartician··on Ask HN: Anyone know how to turn off damn Video Autoplay in Firefox 67?
Type `about:config` in the address bar. Search for `allow-muted`, set that to false.

If that still doesn't work, check other related autoplay settings, like `media.autoplay.ask-permission`.

smartician··on Ask HN: Why is Firefox Focus not able to block ads on Google AMP pages?
Usually ad blockers work by maintaining a blacklist of known ad server hosts and/or IP addresses, and simply block any requests to these.

With AMP though, any content (even ads) is funneled through a proxy CDN (the AMP cache), so ads are indistinguishable from regular content with this method.

smartician··on I'm being threatened by Magic Leap's lawyer. How should I handle this?
What's unclear about this? You are publicly distributing intellectual property you have no rights over, and the owner is asking you to cease and desist. It doesn't matter how many people actually access it, that's not a valid defense.
smartician··on Layoffs at Watson Health Reveal IBM’s Problem with AI
We have run into the same issue before. Many third party services like Optimizely for example just stuff all their tracking information into a cookie, serialized as JSON, which you as the site owner don't really have much control over.

The problem is not that they wouldn't be able to parse the cookie, it's that Akamai edge node web server (Nginx or Apache, don't remember) rejects any request with a header that's above a certain size. Your origin server doesn't even get to know that there ever was such a request.

See https://maxchadwick.xyz/blog/http-request-header-size-limits for example.

smartician··on Ask HN: How do you record your personal finances?
Ditto, Mint and Personal Finance is good enough.
smartician··on $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts
I agree. It also taught me a valuable (and fairly cheap) lesson on not relying on a single source of revenue.
smartician··on $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts
Good catch! From the agreement document: "“Class Representative(s)” means each and all of the named Plaintiffs in this Action: Free Range Content, Inc., Coconut Island Software, Inc., Taylor Chose, and Matthew Simpson"

So that clause means that the plaintiffs will get up to $5,000 on top of what they will receive as claimants, and there is no such limit on claims (but the total payments will not exceed 11 million, including attorney and class representative compensation).

smartician··on $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts
Yes: "... Payments to each of the Class Representatives, not to exceed $5,000 each, as compensation for their active participation in the case on behalf of the Settlement Class ..."

EDIT: see below for correction

smartician··on $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts
11 million is a joke really. I only lost about $250, but it pretty much killed off an otherwise promising potential startup.
smartician··on $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts
What's even worse is that they won't tell you what you allegedly did wrong. You can appeal, but you have to guess what you did wrong and provide evidence, but you can't even access your click data anymore since you're now locked out. It's like being in a relationship with a psychotic person.
smartician··on Ask HN: How do Google recruiters work?
It's about as exciting as having sent in your resume and hearing back from them. So not nothing, but don't picture yourself getting chair massages while sipping draft kombucha just yet.
smartician··on Why I've lost faith in p values
Let's see... Let's say you test 10,000 people, so about 100 actually have the disease. Since the test is only 99% accurate, only 99 of those will test positive. Of the remaining 9,900 actually negative people, 99 will test falsely positive. So if you test positive, you have a 50% chance of actually having the disease?
smartician··on Be likeable or get fired

  >  "This is just not true", "I don't believe you"
Those sentences stood out to me as well. Maybe I'm too conflict-averse, but in a professional setting I would rarely use sentences like this. Something like "Are you sure about that? I've read differently. Let's verify/look into that." gets the same message across and everyone saves face.

And I'm coming from a cultural background that's known to be very direct and blunt...

smartician··on Tesla crash victim had complained about auto-pilot in same location
Aren't many AI methods also inherently probabilistic? That would make it by definition impossible to definitively explain any particular behavior.
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →