HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smashah

1,114 karma · joined December 10, 2016

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/smashah; my proof: https://keybase.io/smashah/sigs/bREd6ydhJtwPxJlDyxa5M6TwQFAj_hVXZ9lqRA9kaR8 ]

Building http://openwa.dev/

https://twitter.com/smashah

submissionscomments
smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Yes they demanded us to delete and stop working on all projects.

At the time it seemed like a serious threat.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Here's a write up of the legal threats timeline to our projects and how it coincides with their in house development of an npm package:

https://gist.github.com/smashah/667d4d5cf31670ee87547450861a...

They sent us C&Ds based on ToS.

Meta has done this before to insta and android devs.

Some never came back to their projects. It causes insane amount of stress and depression amongst the devs I've spoken with who went through the same thing.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Terminating accounts is fair game. Billion dollar companies making legal threats to OSS devs is another.

I can kick said person off my network. It shouldn't be grounds for me to go and start legal proceedings against the developers of uTorrent.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
I agree. After receiving a C&D from Meta for my OSS project (along with some other maintainers from some other projects) I strongly believe adversarial interop is a basic digital right that is required to fulfil the broken or revoked promises of web 2.0

If you know anybody that can help please let me know because I want to get back to maintaining the project.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
I've been told by a C-level exec at a similar company (but relating to banking) that citing Van Buren against CFAA claims gets the claimant's lawyers to back all the way off.
smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
DMA.

These companies have many years to comply and drop Fred functionality to 3PAs.

It's not enough imo.

DMA should've explicitly greenlight adversarial interop, superceding any existing agreement between gatekeeper and interop developers.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Please read this:

https://gist.github.com/smashah/667d4d5cf31670ee87547450861a...

The game being played here is poker. If they call beeper's bluff then they risk setting a whole industry wide precedent that interop supercedes ToS (that's the only angle).

As it stands, ToS based C&D for interop is untested afaik.

We as a community need to discuss ToS-trolling and fight against it.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Emulator based WhatsApp accounts are highest risk of bans just f.y.i

If you're worried about using beeper due to bans then just get a second hand burner phone (needs to have had WhatsApp before so it is safe from being identified as "poisoned") then make an account on there to use with beeper.

Beeper is very helpful NGL.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Van Buren protects it from CFAA.

The only avenue that is untested is based on Terms of Service.

I did a OSS WhatsApp reverse engineering project and got a C&D from 800 billion dollar Meta's lawyers all based on violation of their Terms of Service.

As far as I'm aware, there's no precedent for interop against ToS.

smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Apple may not buy WhatsApp will. If there's ever a commercial or OSS third party WhatsApp voice client I would expect they will try to send their Perkins Coie dogs after the project. They've already done it to many oss projects, terrifying Devs from continuing their work
smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Congrats on the Eric & Team. Can't wait to try it
smashah··on Show HN: Beeper Mini – iMessage client for Android
Have you ever received C&D for your work? There's a big problem of OSS projects being TOS-trolled by billion dollar companies and having to shut down out of fear.
smashah··on Nothing Phone says it will hack into iMessage, bring blue bubbles to Android
Make sure you get your dog or a random stranger to accept Metas terms and conditions on the accounts you may or may not be using otherwise they will try to send you legal threats based on their overbroad terms and conditions
smashah··on Nothing Phone says it will hack into iMessage, bring blue bubbles to Android
They should also add WhatsApp support
smashah··on Open source app to watch videos from any platform
If there is a consortium which is ready to protect this project from legal threats (C&Ds) from platforms based on their overreaching TOS then please share it as many OSS maintainers out there are stuck in legal purgatory who need help and dont have the same backing that futo does.

Us C&D'ed maintainers have the context to help this kind of app potentially win legal battles but in exchange we want to get back to work without fear!

If you care about OSS maintainers being protected from billion dollar bullying anticompetitive megacorps then please reach out.

smashah··on Invidious – An open source alternative front-end to YouTube
It isn't about copyright laws. These megacorps send the MAINTAINERS THEMSELVES C&Ds based on their TOS - why? Because OSS devs do not have the means to pay for a potentially unlimited defense.
smashah··on Invidious – An open source alternative front-end to YouTube
The tech industry failed the invidious team and other projects like this. This should be 100% legal and allowed based on a right-to-mod precedent but not lawyer is willing to take it that far because this is open source.

This project gives control back to the user. It shouldn't be a grey zone and it shouldn't put maintainers at risk to work on it.

Till this issue is resolved, OSS projects like this are unsustainable.

Some evil megacorp is already carpet bombing maintainers with C&Ds and there is ZERO help for this.

smashah··on California Right to Repair Signed into Law
Right to repair should include right to mod (software) which also then necessitates right to reverse engineer
smashah··on H+DNH License 1.1
This license was created to take the best parts from the Hippocratic and Do No Harm Licenses.

In version 1.1 some prohibitions were added. Mainly settler colonialism and apartheid.

Feel free to add it to your projects.

https://firstdonoharm.dev/

smashah··on Be an Open Source Absolutist
Absolutism includes the right to repair (our software) which extends to the right to reverse engineer. Unfortunately those are both untenable at the moment as there is no legal mechanism to support or fight for those rights

To create such a mechanism there needs to be an open source union that doesn't just help people with x y or z license.

Just like how the unions fought for workers rights, this OSS union would fight for digital and coder's rights.

smashah··on Facebook/Meta blocks accounts for posting link to EFF privacy tips
Here is the context

https://gist.github.com/smashah/667d4d5cf31670ee87547450861a...

smashah··on Disclosure of Pirates’ Identities “Compatible with EU Privacy Laws”
The big argument against piracy is that it doesn't allow people to get paid for their work, however, with these recent Hollywood strikes and how people are getting paid $0.08 residuals I don't see how piracy makes anyone any worse off.

Arguably donating $50 to a writer and pirating everything is better than paying $100s to these streaming services.

Maybe WGA SAG AFTRA should make their own subscription called the "pirate pass" where pirates can pay the people directly for their work without all the overhead. If I was a pirate I'd $50 a month to get a pass.

smashah··on Facebook/Meta blocks accounts for posting link to EFF privacy tips
....and they send legal threats and harassment to 15 year old OSS project maintainers.
smashah··on Matrix 2.0: The Future of Matrix
I strongly believe users should be able to automate and interact with their accounts through whatever clients they wish however I think blocks/bans/technical countermeasures is fair game.

Count yourself lucky for not having an undeterminable, unfightable legal threat over your head from a $800bn mega corp.

smashah··on Matrix 2.0: The Future of Matrix
I'm aware of DMAs regs but it forces Whatsapp within 6 months to start enabling interoperability. However it doesn't provide protection for these existing bridge projects.

open-wa, Baileys, invidious devs are all in the dark as to whether or not they're Scott free from their respective C&Ds due to this legislation.

smashah··on Matrix 2.0: The Future of Matrix
Matrix is great but when is the tech industry going to deal with the fact that many, if not all, bridges are against the respective services' ToS and subsequently put the developers of those bridges under legal risk? Whatsapp has already sent legal threats to multiple bridge-component level project maintainers without any recourse.
smashah··on Mullvad on Tailscale: Privately browse the web
Wouldn't it be more "efficient" networking if I could sometimes just use the mullvad app instead of tailscale > mullvad?

Either way it would be good to at least have the option to use an existing account. Maybe tailscale is taking a cut since mullvad dropped recurring sub support natively.

smashah··on RyujinX – Open Source Nintendo Switch Emulator
The developers shouldn't have to be anon for this type of amazing project. They should be publicly celebrated instead of having to hide for fear of being buried in legal trouble. Sad state of the world.
smashah··on FFmpeg Explorer
great demo video
smashah··on British Gas starts to turn off Hive smart home devices forever
This is why regulation is required to force companies to release feature-parity APIs and protect reverse engineering projects from legal threats.
← PreviousPage 11 of 23Next →