HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smashah

1,114 karma · joined December 10, 2016

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/smashah; my proof: https://keybase.io/smashah/sigs/bREd6ydhJtwPxJlDyxa5M6TwQFAj_hVXZ9lqRA9kaR8 ]

Building http://openwa.dev/

https://twitter.com/smashah

submissionscomments
smashah··on Google is already pushing WEI into Chromium
Oh but that would be against the respective projects' code of conduct. /s
smashah··on Llama 2
We should also be mad about Meta (a now $800bn company) sending C&D legal threats and bullying OSS devs into no longer being able to maintain their projects
smashah··on Google has a secret browser hidden inside the settings
Side point: When you rent a Tesla, please do not sign into youtube. Subsequent renters can see your whole Google account (including family members, phone numbers etc).

Or at least sign out before you return the car!

smashah··on The Last Page Of The Internet
Ok so lets track

- Twitter kneecapping 3PAs with it's API changes

- Reddit doing the same

- Meta sending Cease & Desists to Whatsapp API alt OSS devs

- Youtube sending legal threats to Invidious OSS devs

Last two succeed because (shocker!) OSS devs don't have the resources to fight legal battles against $700bn megacorps.

Every age was defined by the rights we gained. Enlightenment, Suffrage, Post-World War, etc. all lead to new human rights. On the precipice of a digital age we need to start thinking about new human rights.

We all know the right to privacy (lol), I propose a few more:

- Right to Automate/Interoperability; A service must provide a programmatic interface with feature parity, or must allow users to create the tools to automate without any prior consent of the service.

- Right to 3PA; Users have the right to use and develop 3rd party apps without the consent of the service.

- Right of OSS dev defense; megacorps have to pay for the defense of the individual they are actively bullying.

These three will force services to either create a fully featured and open API or leave developers to create the tools to enable others to develop and use 3rd party applications or automation.

Without these three basic rights, we cannot realize the AI vision of a personal Jarvis for everyone.

Maybe we should also be thinking about a developer union that protects independant devs & advocates for coders rights. Also, maybe some sort of organization that acts as the digital-equivalent of the "public domain", which has ROFR for acquiring services which have become monopolies in their respective sectors (e.g Reddit, Whatsapp, Youtube, Twitter, etc.)

It's time to build..... the foundation for a digital utopia.

smashah··on Meta's plan to offer free commercial AI models puts pressure on Google, OpenAI
Cool now Meta please sending Cease & Desist threats to 15 year old OSS devs thanks
smashah··on Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking their communities private
Based on your last line, I am not surprised that you are surprised.

Users are the reason why Reddit has any value. They are the ones generating and reading the content.

Let's see how this strategy plays out.

day -1, total API requests X Bn per day, rev $0 day 0, third party apps shut down previously accounting for Y Bn requests per day, total API requests (X-Y) Bn per day, rev $0 day 1, everyone migrates to reddits garbage app. total API requests X Bn per day, rev $0

So you see, the goal is not to make money, and if you think that's the goal then I have a bridge to sell you. It's to eliminate a user's right to use a 3rd party client for the content generated by fellow users. Unless you seriously believe reddit is going to charge itself for API requests and somehow that will be a good business strategy.

Twitter did this move, and now they don't pay their rent nor their GCP bill.

So yes they can do whatever they want with their API, the same way I can do whatever I want with my body - including shooting myself in the foot.

For the contrarians that think this API change is a good idea, here's some alternative monetization strategies by chat gpt since you mentioned OpenAI:

Premium Subscriptions: Offer a "Reddit Gold Plus" or "Reddit Platinum" subscription for a monthly or yearly fee. This premium account could feature additional benefits like ad-free browsing, access to exclusive subreddits, enhanced customization options, early access to new features, etc.

Merchandise: Sell official Reddit merchandise online. This could include items like t-shirts, hats, mugs, stickers, and other items with popular subreddit logos or memes from the site.

Paid AMAs: Introduce a system where users can pay to get guaranteed questions in high-profile AMAs (Ask Me Anything sessions). This would need to be carefully moderated to avoid turning into a "pay-to-win" situation, but could provide extra value for users and extra income for Reddit.

Partnered Content: Partner with other brands for sponsored content, but ensure it's clearly marked and relevant to the Reddit community. For example, host sponsored contests or provide exclusive discounts to Reddit users from partnering brands.

Virtual Goods: Introduce a system of virtual goods that can be bought and gifted to others. This would be an extension of the existing awards system, with perhaps more tangible benefits tied to the goods.

Educational Content: Host paid educational courses or webinars on various topics. These could be in collaboration with experts from different fields who are also Reddit users.

Pro User Tools: Develop advanced analytics or other pro tools for power users, moderators, or businesses. For instance, improved post analytics, automated moderation tools, or subreddit-specific customizations.

Job Board: Create a job board where companies can pay to post job listings to the Reddit community. This can be especially targeted towards subreddits related to specific industries or fields.

Paid Polls or Surveys: Allow businesses to conduct paid surveys or polls, giving them access to the large and diverse user base of Reddit for market research.

Crowdfunding Platform: Launch an integrated crowdfunding platform where Reddit users can support other users' projects or ideas. Reddit could take a small percentage of the funding as a fee. This would also help foster a sense of community and support within the site.

And here are the risks with going for this pigheaded API monetization strategies (again by chatgpt):

Loss of User Base: Many users prefer third-party clients due to enhanced features, better user interface, or the ability to customize their browsing experience. Losing these could lead to a decline in user base and a drop in user activity.

Community Backlash: Reddit is built around its communities, many of which are very passionate about the platform. A significant change like this could lead to substantial backlash and negative sentiment from users, harming Reddit's reputation.

Innovation Stifling: Third-party clients often innovate and experiment with new features, some of which are later adopted by Reddit itself. Losing this could slow down the pace of innovation on the platform.

Monopolization of Reddit Experience: With third-party clients gone, Reddit would essentially have a monopoly on how users interact with its content. This could lead to less pressure to improve and innovate, potentially stagnating the platform's growth and user experience over time.

Potential Legal/Regulatory Consequences: Depending on the jurisdiction, such a move could potentially attract scrutiny from competition authorities or regulators, particularly if it is seen as anti-competitive behavior.

Decreased Developer Trust: Many developers, not just those directly working on third-party Reddit clients, might lose trust in Reddit. This could lead to decreased participation in any future developer-oriented initiatives by Reddit.

User Migration: Some users might migrate to alternative platforms that offer more freedom and customization, which could result in a significant loss for Reddit, both in terms of users and potential advertising revenue.

smashah··on Reddit App – Suspicious high number of recent 5 star, one word reviews
Probably wont happen unless people start threatening to cancel their wired/etc. subscriptions
smashah··on Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking their communities private
This is the result of shamelessness seeping into business. That contrarian business thinking that does away with any pretense of putting anything other than money first.

Also, this idea of charging for API access is lazy and unimaginative.

smashah··on YouTube Tells Open-Source Privacy Software ‘Invidious’ to Shut Down
The big distinction made by TheFrenchGhosty is that they did not personally agree to the Youtube API T&Cs.

If Youtube were as cunning as the goobers at the Whatsapp ToS fanfic department then they would add those terms to their Youtube ToS. So if you ever went on Youtube proper and accepted their ToS when you were 5 years old trying to watch baby shark then voila you have accepted to never code anything that would hurt Youtube's bottom line.

We talk a lot about Patent trolls and our right to privacy. It's now time to talk about ToS trolls and our right to third party clients.

A lot of people like to opine about the nigh-impossible task of being a full-time OSS dev and how AI will change the world; it's time we start talking about an OSS developer Union and how there's no AI-driven utopia without a human Right to Automate.

Solidarity with the Invidious team.

smashah··on Alphabet selling Google Domains assets to Squarespace
I literally dont understand why they did this. Their product was fine as is so didn't need more features, maintenance burden minimal. Isn't google domains just a UI for their GCP domains product? Will that get shut down? Will all my domains suddenly have a pointless premium on them?

Cloudflare, please gain tld parity asap!

smashah··on Reddit says it won’t overrule mods and force subreddits back open
Some digital services need to be the-internet-equivalent-of nationalized.
smashah··on Men who helped run Megaupload sentenced to prison in New Zealand
ok, he's wrong for that - still shouldn't be punished for piracy.
smashah··on Men who helped run Megaupload sentenced to prison in New Zealand
> Saying now that it's only the fault of its users

Who said that? Nobody should be punished for internet piracy.

smashah··on Men who helped run Megaupload sentenced to prison in New Zealand
My point is to say where does it end? What about the devs of BitTorrent/uTorrent? "Everybody knows that these two programs are mostly used for piracy". How about the whole p2p concept? "Everybody knows p2p means pirate 2 pirate".

People are dumping whole movies on Twitter right now. So Twitter staff should go to jail?

Nobody should go to jail for piracy period.

Hope I made my point clear.

smashah··on Men who helped run Megaupload sentenced to prison in New Zealand
If they can argue that because mega upload can be used for copyright infringement so people need to go to jail then so do the devs of ytdl, WeTransfer, YouTube, Google drive/chrome, etc. etc. etc.
smashah··on Men who helped run Megaupload sentenced to prison in New Zealand
People rally for individuals being targeted. If governments or shills don't want normal people to rally for individuals like KDC/Assange/Snowden/Winner/Manning then don't go after them.

Hope that clears up your confusion.

smashah··on New York State Senate passes prohibitions on non-competes
Ok great now let's do prohibition of anti-consumer, anti-innovation, anti-competitive clauses in Terms of Service/EULAs.
smashah··on NPM won't publish packages containing the word keygen
> ...NPM since those can differ from source code on Github.

True. How about people act their threat model? Instead of removing a feature for many users, just do whatever you need to do to be sure you're safe yourself?

In what other major situation is the solution to nuke a feature due to security concerns?

Afaik the main conversation about postinstall is around leeches complaining about political messages in their console and one or two other incidents

smashah··on Ask HN: Is everyone becoming a Product Manager these days?
Don't get me wrong, a great PM is a godsend but few and far between. Unfortunately, a bad PM has a big negative impact to a team.

> The problem just gets worse when you hire fresh grads or people with 1-2 years of consulting experience who don't have any background whatsoever.

Yeah these are the culprits of the trend and the source of most rubbish PMs. The undefined is where these waste-chameleons lurk.

I highly suggest reading the aforementioned book (or even listening to the audio book).

smashah··on NPM won't publish packages containing the word keygen
"any chance"???

I can't square this circle of someone being paranoid about postinstall script but at the same time thinks the first chance to review dependency code is after doing a `npm i`.

Check the git repo of the library you are installing beforehand if you're so paranoid about postinstall.

And above that, never install any library for which the source is not readily available. This is the most basic first line of defense.

username checks out.

smashah··on NPM won't publish packages containing the word keygen
Malicious unchecked code in postinstall can just be moved to runtime so blanket blocking postinstall is as effective a solution to supply chain attacks as the solution of blocking npm packages with the word "keygen" in them is to the problem of .... js based keygens???

There are many legitimate purposes for postinstall scripts yet the anti-postinstall crowd acts like they solved security issues with this one easy step.

smashah··on Ask HN: Is everyone becoming a Product Manager these days?
The Big Con[0] book touches on this subject.

Essentially, non technical people who want to insert themselves into technical projects account for many of the new PMs we see, at least in consulting, nowadays.

[0] https://marianamazzucato.com/books/the-big-con

smashah··on NPM won't publish packages containing the word keygen
This reminds me of the supply chain attack experts who's only solution seems to be blocking postinstall scripts.
smashah··on Pixelfed Introduces Import from Instagram
> Pixelfed has no contract with Meta

As a victim of Meta's Cease and Desists for open-wa, the contract terms is in the Terms of Service that anyone associated with Pixelfed, or anyone associated with the development of Pixelfed has ever accepted regardless if it's a personal or testing account.

In these ToS agreements, Meta believes they can prevent anyone making any tools that they deem break any of their ridiculous terms of service.

I literally had to stop working on my OSS project/tool due to this bullying. Unfortunately I, or other Devs, do not have enough resources to fight this immoral megacorp so therefore they win our compliance.

smashah··on Reddit banned Reddiw's (alternative API) subreddit and author's Reddit account
I reject any premise that free/reasonable programmatic access is dichotomous to profitability.

Just as Devs are forced to resolve bugs in their code, business people should sort out the bugs in their balance sheet.

These decisions are being made now not due to profitability concerns, they're being made due to the lack of backlash from the tech community and laziness.

"Oh? Elon start charging extortionate rates for the heavily restricted API & Zuck gets away with throwing his legal weight around at OSS Devs and nobody bats an eye? Cool, we'll do the same thing!"

smashah··on Reddit banned Reddiw's (alternative API) subreddit and author's Reddit account
True. This is only going to get worse unless technical people in these companies put a foot down.

Maintainers do not have the resources to pay for a legal defence (companies know this), the community has shiny-object-syndrome and so it's up to internal employees to show resistance to these immoral policies.

smashah··on Reddit banned Reddiw's (alternative API) subreddit and author's Reddit account
Not to derail this conversation but there is an extremely concerning pattern of big companies restricting programmatic access.

Elon with the Twitter changes and kneecapping third party clients.

Reddit with this situation.

WhatsApp with their systematic elimination of OSS API alternatives by sending legal threats/C&Ds to maintainers.

API access is a tenet of Web 2.0 and it's being robbed from us.

We need to start thinking about our human Right to Automate. If the companies don't want to give people reasonable access then it should be our right to make alternatives.

Solidarity with the maintainers of Reddiw.

smashah··on Rarbg Is No More
Thank you for your service
smashah··on Following UK antitrust order, Meta sells Giphy to Shutterstock for $53M
Whatsapp is more used than SMS and all other apps combined. Is SMS controlled by one company? Whatsapp made Meta almost a billion dollars last year. Yet they're out here sending legal threats to OSS devs and devs of 3rd party clients. Are there 3rd party clients for SMS? Yes. Then why shouldn't there be 3rd party clients for Whatsapp? Zucks failed experiments on metaverse is resulting in him trying to aggressively monetise the golden goose.
smashah··on Following UK antitrust order, Meta sells Giphy to Shutterstock for $53M
Great, now they should be forced to sell Whatsapp.
← PreviousPage 12 of 23Next →