API access (interop) is a digital human right. If companies can't be profitable without restricting that then that's a deficiency upon them and their gormless VCs
1,114 karma · joined December 10, 2016
Building http://openwa.dev/
https://twitter.com/smashah
API access (interop) is a digital human right. If companies can't be profitable without restricting that then that's a deficiency upon them and their gormless VCs
This is a good one:
Should Sony decide what you do with your TV? No.
Should Haier decide how you control your AC? NO.
Should Whatsapp decide how you interact with your own account. NO!
Interop devs are the Louis Rossman's/mom & pop repair shops of the software world.
They take whatever redundant software/service you have and enable you to use it as you see fit.
It is a fundamental digital right despite what nonsense-ese is present in any service's egregious terms and conditions.
There needs to be an anti-adversarial interop specific complaint department at the EFF.
Otherwise one day, one of these developers will take the lack of support at its face and choose to defend themselves in court without any (legal) resources.
When the precedents are set that billion dollar megacorps can ruin an interop developers life due to overreaching ToS or some bs about copyright then it'll be too late to cry about it.
Invidious (YouTube), beeper (iMessage), Meta Vs many OSS Devs, etc. etc. etc. largely show that tech's freedom loving stance is not much more than lip service.
Interop projects aren't sexy. The Devs behind them get a pittance if anything. It's not VC-able. Yet instead of praise for the dog work they do we have well-actually-niks berating then in situations like this.
We are now becoming digital beings. We should have digital human rights. Interop is a base level digital human right.
I want to thank you for your work Andre0512 and Long Live hon!
P.s if there any EU digital lawyers out here please reach out to Andre0512 and actually help him please!
You can't even call out a genocide with references and empathy without being fired from the board of a company you founded? Tech's relationship with the genociding apartheid state is a stain on this, usually, forward thinking freedom loving industry.
Crazy how that works. Maybe someone should look into that.
Many beeper mini users already have apple devices + Eric in his post said he's willing to pay some reasonable fee.
Nobody pays for iMessage directly.
There are handsomely VC funded successful startups that do exactly this in banking, for example Teller:
https://jobs.lever.co/teller/ebf503af-bb82-49fb-97bd-6d9bcbb...
Everything that has transpired over the last few weeks strengthens the narrative for an anti trust case and hopefully makes an illustrative case in favour for adversarial interop (w.r.t megacorps).
That itself protects an untold amount of OSS projects that have been victims to billion dollar megacorp legal threats and bullying.
Idk how these things work but I hope Eric and the beeper team take Apple to the cleaners and get enough to retire a thousand times over.
API key so premium users can use invidious makes total sense - it makes creator revenue attribution more accurate also.
As a paying user to any service I should have the right to interop with whatever client or third party service I want.
Secondly, imo technical measures is fair game - much better than their previously scummy tactic of sending legal threats to the stellar team at invidious.
Thirdly, adversarial interoperability is a human digital right.
Fourthly, godspeed to the invidious team, their hard work and story is important for the wider internet.
https://twitter.com/smashah/status/1721992084167725078
(i forgot to add) + complete ban on MIC + Economic system completely realigned for joint and global humanitarianism (tikkun olam)
You might be asking why I can claim many on tech feel this way. It's because I've seen similar repression from Saudi Arabia (powered by Israeli cyber weapons).
In Saudi, a lot of really loud people barking are able to do so because that is the establishment line.
Everybody else who is silenced have, usually the diametrically exact opposite opinion (or even unacceptable tame variations of the establishment line).
In Saudi they use Israeli cyber weapons to hack, monitor then jail (even mild) dissent.
In tech there are many establishment lemmings who don't think for themselves who essentially act the same as establishment propagandists and their pernicious weapon against dissent is being iced out from opportunities.
Tech is meant to be decentralized, meritocratic, (somewhat) contrarian.
Yet we've seen in these last two months all that goes thrown out the window when it comes to narratively protecting a genocidal project because unfortunately there is a well oiled Israeli Extermination Force to Tech pipeline that people don't like to talk about (aka Affirmative action for extreme Zionists).
Most of the few founders I know will be raising with BDS in mind - that hopefully includes LPs where possible.
Don't support right of return? You don't deserve right to my returns.
They did this to Paddy Cosgrave & Paul Graham.
We need to stand against this type of astroturfing and bullying.
Revoking or paywalling API access falls under this definition of enshittification.
The enlightenment* brought about human rights.
We are well within the digital age without any meaningful Digital Rights.
Adversarial interop should be one such digital right.
There's no story in the world that will get people to stop using services like Whatsapp or Instagram.
The only thing stopping these big companies is potentially setting a legal precedent that interop projects are legal.
They can potentially win such a case as it stands because the targets for their threats are few and far between.
If we as digital humans want to solidify this digital right then we need to have a unified front against threats like this. That means we need to have an OSS union behind which companies and individuals can unify if a precedent setting case ever does come up