HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smcq

72 karma · joined October 12, 2009

submissionscomments
smcq··on CRU's "very artificial correction for decline" is dead code
Fallacy of bringing absolutely nothing to the debate and asserting to the point of ad homonim that scientists would have skipped basic statistics on their data. Please see the post immediately above yours and go demonstrate that the method is flaw before continuing this debate.

The standard of evidence to show fault is yours. Assuming that papers published in freaking NATURE have sound statistics is a reasonable thing for a layman to do.

smcq··on CRU's "very artificial correction for decline" is dead code
You seem completely confused by the scientific method. They do not have an obligation to release all data, but rather to release the method by which data can be acquired. They released data for the paper actually published to justify their statistical analysis.

Any data that you receive from another scientist with the intention of reproducing their experiment is fundamentally tainted and violates the scientific method.

Please don't argue against straw men, it's annoying.

smcq··on CRU's "very artificial correction for decline" is dead code
I'm not an expert in climate change either, but I'm a journeyman in statistics and I support his claim that it can be correlated.
smcq··on Ban The Debugger
I strongly believe code that can't be understood by inspection is code that shouldn't be.
smcq··on Ban The Debugger
I think this metaphor is somewhat wrong.

Log files are like attaching medical imagers to the maze and keeping a trace of it's physical and mental state as it executes the maze. Debuggers are like attaching medical imagers to the rat and being able to only see the immediate state only.

Obviously, debuggers are much faster to bootstrap than good logging, and in that category I can see them being a clear win. However, I still see them as providing less information.

PS: That said, there are a few situations I bust out a debugger too. Mostly when I'm too lost to get started.

smcq··on Does Super-High IQ= Super-Low Common Sense?
Common sense is the beliefs held by common people, by definition common people are much lower IQ than someone in the 170+ IQ range.

It would shock me if someone in the 170+ IQ range believed much of what "common" people believe. If they did, it would imply we have an extraordinarily well educated population and an extraordinarily boring genius class.

smcq··on Ban The Debugger
I have never really understood the fascination with debuggers. A good log file will allow you to triage any error, even if it's not the one you were looking for. It seems to me that debuggers are mostly for spotting failed assumptions and won't find unreproducable or subtle systemic problems.

I consider the desire to use a debugger a bug in my logging and take corrective action.

Also, you can't grep an execution history in a debugger. I really have no idea how you would spot systemic errors without doing so.

Can anyone who lives by debuggers make a case to convince me to fire up the debugger more often?

smcq··on Perfect advanced programming language for the productive industrial developer
How often do people that need to write device drivers need to use a high level language? Is there really a lot of demand for this sort of thing?
smcq··on Why Can't I Pick the Technology I Use in the Office?
Technology can fix this! It was never the users problem to begin with...

    MAX_ATTACH = 50 * 1024 #50 kb

    def minimize_size(msg):
        if size(msg['attachment']) > MAX_ATTACH:
            upload attachment to s3 like storage
            insert link into email body
        return msg
It obviously needs fleshed out (I bet it ends up around 20 lines of python after everything is said and done). But seriously, the fact that your users would ever even need to think about this is just wrong.
smcq··on Why Can't I Pick the Technology I Use in the Office?
You forgot the third goal: the IT department wants to create a lot of work for itself that appears to be useful but doesn't directly increase productivity.
smcq··on Why Can't I Pick the Technology I Use in the Office?
Easy, switch to twitter and logless instant messaging for primary communication. I bet productivity would go up anyway.

Edit: I obviously meant a twitter-like internal service.

smcq··on A 2x Faster Web
You wait 2 seconds for a page load? You're amazingly generous.
smcq··on The Droid fails as a product when compared to Palm Pre and iPhone
Sounds like a droid fanboy to me.
smcq··on Why the mainstream media is dying
On the other hand, the problem with populating the air waves with experts is that it's hard to put on a good show and spin the story the right way if everyone on-air is authoritative.
smcq··on Billionaire (Sergey Brin) Aids Charity That Aided Him
My grandfather was literally starving to death before he immigrated. Are you seriously claiming the (theoretical) minor reductions in earning caps (for unskilled labor) we're discussing are comparable?
smcq··on Billionaire (Sergey Brin) Aids Charity That Aided Him
As the grandson of a 'slave' immigrant that was brought over to build the railroads I take great offense to your complete lack of empathy.

If they're willing to work for $8/hour here, that means things are worse for them where they are. Who are you to cast people into poverty, death, and dismay so that your economy can maintain a slightly higher salary.

smcq··on Git commits as code review?
We use git commit reviews as our primary review method, it's much lower overhead than sit down code review meetings. On the other hand, it's not quite as thorough, which works fine with a small team that's already high bandwidth.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2