HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smogcutter

2,923 karma · joined October 6, 2016

submissionscomments
smogcutter··on Car companies are in a billion-dollar software war
It’s very obviously a rhetorical exaggeration.
smogcutter··on Fandom sells gaming media brand Giant Bomb to long-term staff
> These gamers presumably want reviews of what is / isn't worth their time.

Judging by online reactions, what gamers want is their own opinion reflected back at them. Anything else brings frothing rage and vitriol.

For some extremely-online types who have made “gamer” their identity, the purpose of gaming media is primarily to have that identity confirmed, not to gather information.

smogcutter··on The cult of doing business
Have you read “The Accursed Share”? Batailles argues that society is shaped by the ways we squander surplus (eg in war, sacrifice, carnival, art, sex, etc)
smogcutter··on Healthy soil is the hidden ingredient
Just to clear up what sounds like a simple misunderstanding, because you mentioned being in Europe: in the US (can’t speak for other English speaking countries) to “break down” box is to flatten it, not break it like to destroy or tear apart. As in “help me break down these boxes for recycling”.

Forgive me if you got that, it just sounded like you were talking past each other.

smogcutter··on Trump's Tariffs Wipe Out over $6T on Wall Street in Epic Two-Day Rout
On NPR they ran a response quote from Ryan Zinke that was nominally against it, but if you read between the lines you can see them laying the foundation. It was something like “I draw a hard line at violating the constitution, that’s something I’ll never support. But also right now there are leftists and activist judges who think they can violate the constitution by taking power away from the executive”

He never directly spoke against a third term, just “violating the constitution”, and then named some enemies. It’s a long way off still, but you can see the groundwork being laid for something like “emergency measures to protect the constitution” if they decide that’s the way they want to go.

smogcutter··on Therapy chatbot trial yields mental health benefits
Seems like a good place to recommend “The Death of Doctor Island” by Gene Wolfe for some terrific & grim writing about AI therapy. Don’t read a synopsis.
smogcutter··on France rejects backdoor mandate
I would reject a backdoor man date too, but to each their own.
smogcutter··on The School Car Pickup Line Is a National Embarrassment
Consider that the fact that there’s a tv show about it means it’s a novelty in Japan as well.

It’s great that Japan has a civil society that makes a show like that possible, but don’t mistake it for more than it is. It’s the same mistake as generalizing from what you read in the news: it’s news because it’s unusual.

smogcutter··on The NIH is being slashed and burned, not "reformed"
Historically, authoritarian regimes have handled setbacks like these by scapegoating target minorities and other undesirables.
smogcutter··on The man who spent forty-two years at the Beverly Hills Hotel pool (1993)
Most people with happy loving homes don’t get divorced.
smogcutter··on DOGE's only public ledger is riddled with mistakes
> I'd much rather my money being spent on education, foreign assistance, scientific research, etc., even if there is some inefficiencies and waste

In fact, I’d argue that the government’s role is specifically to spend on things that are economically inefficient but nonetheless important.

smogcutter··on Why can't we remember our lives as babies or toddlers?
In other words, you’ve forgotten the class for the same reasons you’ve forgotten being an infant.
smogcutter··on Why We're Falling Out of Love with Tesla
This is a tough crowd for sarcasm
smogcutter··on Learning fast and accurate absolute pitch judgment in adulthood
> This was used to identify Soviet spies by showing them colors written in Russian; native Russian readers were slowed by the incorrect coloring, people who didn't know Russian could read it quickly.

Hold up, I’m confused. How could people who didn’t know Russian read them at all? There’s probably something obvious I’m missing, but I just can’t parse this at all.

smogcutter··on Nevada Ivanpah Solar Plant Accidentally Incinerates Up to 6k Birds a Year (2016)
> Plop down a housing development on those same 3,500 acres and it’s likely to kill far more birds.

Do you actually believe that? It seems obvious that single family homes don’t kill birds en masse.

Plop down 3500 acres of glass office towers and we’ll talk.

smogcutter··on Antiqua et Nova: Note on the relationship between AI and human intelligence
> claims no authority

It should be obvious what authority is implicit in a document from the vatican.

smogcutter··on Young men now spend more of their free time alone than any other group
I mean, it sounds like what really fits the bill for what you’re looking for are coworkers or collaborators more so than friends.

Which is fine, and recognizing that might help you find it. End of the day, having meaningful social connections takes actually being interested in other people, not just a shared external interest, or hobby.

smogcutter··on Is social media more like cigarettes or junk food?
Junk food addiction (your word, not TFA’s) is also not in the DSM V, so appealing to authority like that or hanging on the word addiction gets you nowhere as far as whether the comparison to social media is interesting.

For what it’s worth gambling addiction is in the DSM-V. What’s it’s direct route to biochemically alter the brain, like nicotine and food intake?

smogcutter··on Games Workshop and the big ambition of a miniatures business
Switching costs are high for this type of game. If you want to play something new you need to invest time and money into buying & painting new figures, learn a new set of rules, and convince your friends to do the same.

OTOH historical wargaming is even more niche, but because nothing’s tied to IP games are much more diverse, and the hobby’s backed by a healthy community of small businesses and individual creators.

smogcutter··on Why is homeschooling becoming fashionable?
Which is where an expulsion often leads, similar to how adults unable to function in society are channeled into SSDI, homelessness, or prison in some combination.

There are unlikely to be many caring and constructive adults there though, for reasons that should be obvious.

smogcutter··on Why is homeschooling becoming fashionable?
Thank you for demonstrating the point that there are constraints and complications that are difficult to appreciate from the outside. The law generally disagrees with you.
smogcutter··on Why is homeschooling becoming fashionable?
There are some rotten incentives at work here, as well as constraints that aren’t obvious from a parent or student’s point of view.

For example, CA schools have to publish statistics on suspensions and expulsions. So there’s an incentive for administrators to minimize them. In practice, this means that expelling a student (short of some extreme situations) is a lengthy process of ass-covering. Even when administrators are doing the right thing, from the outside it can look like nothing is being done. Think HR putting you on a PIP.

Meanwhile, the “right thing” isn’t always so obvious. The “violent and disruptive” student is also a child with a right to an education. And for what it’s worth, usually a child in crisis. For school staff, your role as an adult is to teach the child to participate in society with whatever limited influence you have. As a parent or classmate, of course, you have no reason to give a shit about some asshole kid, but the teacher has to.

And then, what does “violent and disruptive” actually mean? How much violence? No tolerance? What about a bullying victim who sticks up for themselves? Playground scuffle? At what point does the dial turn from teaching a child not to hit, to teaching a child that they are bad and do not belong? What about non (physically) violent bullying? What about children who are disruptive, but not violent (surely including a lot of those posting here about how their ADHD was misunderstood)?

Sometimes expulsion is the answer, even keeping in mind that every student expelled before 16 is just going to school someplace else. But the problems are more complex than people often realize.

smogcutter··on Decline in teen drug use continues, surprising experts
Agreed that Covid was disillusioning for young people, but uniquely so? The 2008 financial crisis, 9/11, and the GWoT would all like a word.

The only generation I can think of without a similar formative crisis (in the US at least) is Gen X. Does the death of Kurt Cobain count?

smogcutter··on TikTok divestment law upheld by federal appeals court
You’re flatly wrong, and so is vkou. From the text of the 1st amendment: “Congress shall make no law […] abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press…” (cut the establishment clause for clarity).

It doesn’t say “congress shall make no law for citizens” or “within the US”.

smogcutter··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
I find it completely unsurprising that parents who would sue to change a C+ into a B raised a kid who would cheat.
smogcutter··on Oxford accused of relying on young academics employed on gig-economy terms
I’d presume that as a postdoc they have a pretty good handle on the academic job market and don’t need a one sentence FYI about how it’s important to publish.
smogcutter··on Behaviors reveal sophisticated tool use and possible “pranking” among pachyderms
Sure, maybe, but if you tried you could come up with a similar explanation for literally any behavior or emotion. It might be true, but it isn’t falsifiable.
smogcutter··on Nikolai Fyodorov wanted to resurrect the dead to live among the stars
For those in LA, there’s a related exhibit at the Museum of Jurassic Technology. Definitely worth checking out if you haven’t been, the whole collection is a delight.
smogcutter··on Wikipedia article blocked worldwide by Delhi high court
> India obviously has the right to ban the Wikimedia Foundation

I don’t think that’s obvious at all. In the US, constitutional rights to freedom of speech, assembly, etc apply regardless of nationality or citizenship status.

smogcutter··on How to grip Bronze Age swords
The king of kings’ chariot was a status symbol. Persian cavalry fought from horseback.
← PreviousPage 2 of 26Next →