HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

smooke

452 karma · joined February 18, 2013

what a remarkable world!

hackernoon.com

submissionscomments
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Hey PascLeRasc, we're doing some work to improve quality, but it is a tough nut to crack. It starts with more editors. We onboarded 4 so far this year https://hackernoon.com/meet-the-new-hacker-noon-editors-b375... We're working on an activity feed of some form in 2.0, showing you when an editor has opened, edited, then published your story, and we’ll continue to build on that with feedback from the community. We've also been curating our favorites here https://hackernoon.com/editors-top-tech-stories/home
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
What do you know about the way we publish? David from Hacker Noon here --- Most stories on Hacker Noon are not published by me, they are published by one of these four other editors https://hackernoon.com/meet-the-new-hacker-noon-editors-b375...

Every Hacker Noon story is reviewed by editor. On sites where anyone can publish, I'd guess less than 10% of stories are reviewed by an editor... but who knows?

I heard 7 of the 50 most clapped stories in 2018 are on hackernoon.com https://twitter.com/search?q=most%20clapped%20hackernoon&src... but I don't trust claps these days b/c of the evidence I've seen showing how clap counts display differently for different site visitors. If I go to hackernoon.com right now, "Blockchain Empowering Women Around the World" displays as zero claps on the hackernoon.com homepage, but I am following the author and when I click on the story many people have clapped it... https://hackernoon.com/blockchain-empowering-women-around-th... But if claps are to be trusted as a measure of quality, Hacker Noon outperforms the vast majority Medium posts: https://schleiss.io/2018/07/28/average-hackernoon-claps/

BTW, greatly appreciate the kind words about doing more initiative with my life! I thought a top 5k site in the world was cool, but it is small potatoes when you're neighbors are making twice baked. As the kids say, "CHEEEEEEESE"

smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Hey Tony for the equity crowdfunding campaign we were vetted by 3rd party accountants and 3rd party lawyers. We published hundreds of pages of information will full financials and risks. You can find it here: https://www.startengine.com/hackernoon

Interesting that you think I raise money dishonestly, while Equity Crowdfunding is the only form of funding that publicly discloses all kinds of information for EVERYONE, not just the wealthy. For private raise, these kinds of info would typically be, well, private.

A short overview of the misinformation here:

$ I've been very upfront with my investors about what Medium is saying to me. Just a month ago Medium wrote that they wanted to cooperate on archiving past hacker noon on a hacker noon subdomain. Would you like me to forward you the email? But I've come to learn that when working with Medium, its best to hedge your bets. Well over half of our library have already explicitly opt-ed into Medium free terms with us. And I think its the better half. We also have been recruiting great content that we haven't published yet. Either way, our long term success will not be determined by content from the past; it'll be about how good or bad of a site we have going forward. And as Ev says "publishers and writers are free to move from Medium at any time" so there shouldn't be any problem here, but there is: https://twitter.com/DavidSmooke/status/1105522935349952512

$ Pageviews is not our metric. We don't need 8M pageviews to make far more $$$ than we are making now b/c Medium blocked our ability to run sponsors on our site (while running their own pop up ads). And we can open up new revenue streams. already this year we have podcast and events revenue.

Anyways, you think you're right and are willing to spend your time shouting about it. In a different time, I think we would have really liked building media together. You've made some cool things and have worked with some remarkable ppl - but I am just going to see you as another guy writing for his own vested interest. All the best. - David

smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
David from Hackernoon. We won't be doing a pop up ad to force login or a paywall on Hacker Noon 2.0. Hope you can consider us as an exemption from your blacklist!
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
FYI - Tony is medium advisor. Unsure why he is making it his job to make uninformed comments like this. This is David from Hackernoon, letting you know that without the use of Medium at my last job, I recruited, edited and published 400+ contributing writers with the use of Wordpress. When I started there, the company started with no brand, 5 employees and barely any seed money. When I left, it had 120 employees, $60M+ in Venture capital, a brand everyone in the recruiting space knew, and I couldn't publish contributors fast enough. Medium helped grow Hacker Noon, but if what Tony is saying were true, there would be thousands of publications just as big as Hacker Noon building with Medium's content management system. Also, most stories published with us are not already on Medium, we have to painstakingly onboard them to be a Medium writer while Medium does little to distribute any of our stories anymore. We've spent thousands of work hours educating people on ppl on how to use this content management system.
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
I AM ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE FROM THE FUTURE https://giphy.com/gifs/friend-stay-cSBOKwfGbKmg8
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Hey David from Hackernoon here. I liked Medium too. I just wish they hadn't given up on empowering others to build great sites. The good content from 2 years ago is still there https://hackernoon.com/archive , and I think top stories still has some good reads today https://hackernoon.com/editors-top-tech-stories/home
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
David from Hackernoon here - to admit that I have been bested! Brilliant stuff!!!
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
The key here is that hacker noon publishes exclusively on hackernoon.com, and the majority of our contributors have agreed to continuing doing so.
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
David from Hackernoon here. I am thankful Medium (as it used to be) existed. I wish they didn't give up on empowering people to build their own sites. But their new business model is interesting and I wish them the best, it just has nothing to do with empowering people to build their own sites.

In our own small way, this is how I see the relationship: https://twitter.com/JulienVallini/status/1060

smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
We're about to see if that's true in Hacker Noon 2.0 :-)
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
It's great to hear that Medium deemed some publications worth dumping money into - more funded media outlets is awesome! This isn't a zero sum game. But any publication with one paying customer is taking on TREMENDOUS risk. The reality is the community and not the wealthy should determine what media exists. Medium killed the ability for publications to have their readers pay to subscribe to them https://www.cjr.org/business_of_news/medium-publication.php and killed the ability for publications to run sponsorship (while continuing to run pop up ads on content they didn't own). It was an interesting tradeoff but I am done with it.
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Hey David from Hackernoon here. The technology industry is very consolidated. It's easier to get a small business started, but when it grows, it's easier for another technology you depend on to change its terms. In my case, I was content running a bootstapped business that barely made enough to fund two jobs (hacker noon in 2017 & 2018), but my revenue stream was cut off by pivots from my content management system. With an enormous cost of switching, we turned to our readers to fund the movement into our own infrastructure: https://www.startengine.com/hackernoon Now, I have a small team, and win/lose/or-draw, I'm thrilled to have the future of my business not tied to the fate of medium.
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Hey Tony from Medium, David from Hacker Noon here. We are proudly funded by 1.2k readers, what's wrong with that? Instead of raising money from VCs, we want to be accountable to the people who actually value Hacker Noon. Obviously you don't and won't.
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Please let us know which paywalled articles you have seen? We want all our content to be free for all. Medium did a design switch recently where authors have to uncheck a box as so a story is not paywalled. Hacker Noon 2.0 won't put a paywall in front of any writer's story.
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
As a site gets larger, quality control is tough, and the irony is, having SEO content makes it easier for the best content on your site to have better distribution. With more control of collections, tag pages and topic pages in hacker noon 2.0, I think we find strong SEO in other areas.

I will say if you pick the 3 best of today, the experience is a bit better:

"Why are we (still) sending so much web traffic unencrypted over the Internet?" https://hackernoon.com/why-are-we-still-sending-so-much-web-...

"Going Global (or Globally Local)? How Netflix Produces Amazing Global Content"https://hackernoon.com/going-global-or-globally-local-how-ne...

"The Future of Robotics Development with Eva Li of Vincross" https://hackernoon.com/the-future-of-robotics-development-wi...

And as a site who's rooting for every day tech story (as opposed to professional writing), there will be some bar to raise. Thank you for your 2 cents. Creating a better version of LinkedIn Publisher for the technology community would be a better site than we are today.

smooke··on Medium going after hackernoon contributors as they move off Medium
Hey David from Hackernoon here. There are not good guys and bad guys. Its just changing business interests. Medium blocked our revenue stream (weekly sponsor) while continuing to run pop up ads on site to create medium accounts. To be a sustainable business, independent publications can not depend on medium's content management system. Also, request a story is a function that hasnt existed for years. Overall, the vast majority of links to hacker noon stories go to hackernoon.com, and we are asking the community to opt-in to keeping their stories where they are at hackernoon.com/story-title.
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Hey Btown, David from Hacker Noon here. Thank you for feedback on our terms of service. We are trying to make a simple non-exclusive license, and don't have as large of a legal budget as maybe we should. There are mistakes in these terms. We will be updating our terms to make it more clear that contributors can remove their content at any time and contributors will always be accredited (and fix the typos). We are not trying to sneak anything through, just want a medium-free nonexclusive license to keep content where it is on hackernoon.com
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Hey Danols, David from Hacker Noon here. Publishing is a hard business. While I don't agree with everything you said, I do like you believe that the best stuff to read is from the expert themselves. Sometimes the articles we publish are too shallow (we will work to improve quality), and other times we're able to achieve a better place to read (by publishing top tech professionals https://hackernoon.com/archive/).
smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
Wanted to clarify why Hacker Noon had to move off Medium. Here’s why:

1. Medium decided it no longer wanted to support independent publications of curators and writers like us, The Awl (RIP), The Ringer, and others. 2. Medium at one point allowed publications to monetize using promotions, but arbitrarily decided to cut those off earlier last year, which cut off many independent curators and publications from their sole revenue stream. 3. At the same time, Medium put ads on every page of our site, including pop up ads.

Hacker Noon 2.0 sent an email to contributors asking if they wanted to join our new community, and in exchange Hacker Noon asks for a non-exclusive license to the content, just like Medium. Contributors can remove the content at any time.

In the move to our new infrastructure, we will work hard to make sure links don’t break (which is what will happen now for Hacker Noon content still on Medium), never put any story behind a paywall, and be the best and most up-front amplify button for all people writing great tech content.

We’ve taken your feedback on the existing ToS for Hacker Noon and will be updating that soon. We are independent writers and curators ourselves, so we have no interest in owning your content.

We’re here to build a great community, and we hope you’ll join us. Thanks for your help and support.

Back to the Internet!

-David Smooke

smooke··on “HackerNoon is leaving Medium, but also trying to take rights for people's work”
lol i was on twitter
← PreviousPage 2 of 2