HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

snowwrestler

33,347 karma · joined November 1, 2011

All thoughts posted here are entirely my own personal opinions.
submissionscomments
snowwrestler··on Oh good, screwworms are back (2025)
Tariffs would not stop the screw worm, which lives half of its life as a winged fly.
snowwrestler··on Anti-social: It's fads, not friends, which now dominate social media feeds
Nah, this is the same self-congratulatory dismissive mindset humans have been having about each other for years. “Wake up, sheeple,” “NPC,” etc.

We’re not lacking for opportunities to believe the worst of each other. It’s not something TikTok invented.

snowwrestler··on Anti-social: It's fads, not friends, which now dominate social media feeds
The legal and political theory was that the Congressional vote count was a moment of power that could be interrupted and seized with relatively few people. No need for tanks in that case.

Most people attacking the Capitol were unorganized protestors, who were gathered as cover for the real effort, which was quite well organized. It was well described in Congressional hearings; people were convicted of conspiracy; lawyers have been disbarred, etc.

snowwrestler··on India's surprise baby bust
In the U.S., birth rates fell pretty much continuously for at least 150 years until WWII and the Baby Boom. Now they are slightly declining again. Many industrialized nations have a similar graph.

So that pretty much kills any explanation that depends on our recent experience, like pressure to get a degree, good job, etc. Seems like there is probably something far more fundamental at work to create a 200+ year trend with a one brief interruption for a couple decades.

snowwrestler··on Three of our worst VC stories
Cloudflare is fantastic at marketing, and pretty good at technology. I evaluated them twice for enterprise contracts and both times picked a competitor. The first time, it was DosArrest for DDOS protection, which was a much better value per dollar (but they sucked at marketing.) The second time, we needed a CDN with particular features and Fastly was a better fit.

My point is that it’s very very hard to know in advance that a startup is going to be awesome at marketing. Their tech was not, on its own, a giant moat or a “must have” standout. So I can see why some VCs shrugged.

snowwrestler··on Entanglement Builds Space-Time. Now "Magic" Gives It Gravity
That’s very interesting, but the analogy is not wrong, because the mattress is analogous to space-time, not just space. Essentially it is a 2D analogy for a 3+1D reality.
snowwrestler··on When AI Builds Itself: Our progress toward recursive self-improvement
I don’t understand how lines of code matter at all for scary LLM core capabilities. Does the transformer architecture get better with more lines of code?

My impression was that LLM training codebases were 99% resource management and only a few lines actually implement the core training algorithm, which is where 100% of the intelligence comes from. Data, not lines of code, are the constraint.

After training you can adapt the intelligence in various ways, and that takes a bunch of lines of coded too. But you cant raise the intelligence ceiling again without another training run. So where is the scary recursive part?

snowwrestler··on When AI Builds Itself: Our progress toward recursive self-improvement
If they actually have concerns they can communicate them directly and privately. There are less than 10 companies, in only 2 countries, with advanced enough AI programs to qualify for this type of concern. And Anthropic has the phone numbers for all of them.

Companies do tons of communication and work directly, without press releases or blog posts. If a statement is released publicly, it is done for a PR purpose.

snowwrestler··on How Fear and Social Pressure Are 'Overarming' the U.S.
Sure but some people own like 30 guns. There’s more going on with gun ownership than just basic self defense.
snowwrestler··on Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
It’s a great episode of TV because Data is a main cast character who is obviously conscious. We know before the episode starts who is right and who is wrong in this particular argument. This episode is not about consciousness, it is about civil rights: resisting bigotry and power.

Note that the episode is NOT about the ship’s computer. They all know it’s not conscious, despite also being a machine that can converse and do things.

Our LLMs are like the ship’s computer.

snowwrestler··on MacBook Neo is so popular that Apple doubled production
Apple has never been a luxury brand. It’s a label lobbed at them by critics and fans of competing products. But it’s never been supported by their price points, volumes, marketing, or operations. The few times they have tried to play in the luxury market, like their gold $10k Apple Watch, it went pretty much nowhere and they quickly stopped.

They make not-crappy productivity tools at not-cheap price points, and aim for top-5 market share. That’s not a luxury product strategy. They are a lot more like Honda or Volkswagon than Lamborghini.

snowwrestler··on US's big bet on quantum computing may not be legal
Access billions in federal funding, obviously. Which is something!
snowwrestler··on US's big bet on quantum computing may not be legal
It may also be salient post-2028, is the thing.
snowwrestler··on Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations
Sure but that goes both ways in a conversation.
snowwrestler··on Google changes its search box
Over the past year to 1.5 years, in the sites I run, I have seen a drop in traffic from Google, which leveled off, and is now slightly rising.

I think if you look through this thread you’ll see a lot of skepticism of the AI results, and I think that is a fairly broadly held opinion. The obvious way to check the AI answer is to click through to some sources.

I think for Google to stop sending me traffic, it would have to be essentially perfect at AI answers. It will never get there, especially as so many searches are opinion-based like “what is the best mobile phone right now.”

snowwrestler··on It is time to give up the dualism introduced by the debate on consciousness
I think what is needed, and what will happen, is to pull apart concepts like intelligence, consciousness, and language use, and create narrower and more rigorous definitions of what those are.

My go-to analogy is the concept of heat and warmth, which was the subject of philosophical speculation and inquiry for centuries. But ultimately it was not useful or predictive until it was redefined very narrowly by scientists as a specific measurable attribute of a collection of molecules. Arguably this redefinition itself was an important component of the establishment of “science” as a discipline distinct from philosophy.

This let scientists work with heat rigorously, even though non-scientists still have a largely colloquial vocabulary about it, e.g. “this coat is warmer than my last one.” On matters like consciousness, we’re all still smashed together into colloquial land, arguing about definitions when we think we are arguing about concepts.

I do think the current advancements in AI may help us develop the new vocabulary we need to quantitatively reason about intelligence and language, and in doing so, help better define / constrain what the we mean by consciousness. We think of LLMs now as a tool we can use to do work, but another view is that they are a sensor that directly correlates physical inputs to intelligent outputs. Sort of like how burning can be used to measure the energy contained in various materials, in addition to keeping us warm.

snowwrestler··on Multiple commencement speakers booed for AI comments during graduation speeches
No, expertise is more important when working with AI, because it can make mistakes. Expertise is the ability to predict, understand, and mitigate such mistakes.

In science for example, anyone can do an experiment about gravity. In fact millions of high school kids do every year. What makes an expert scientist is the ability to understand all the many ways such experiments can fail to accurately measure the underlying reality.

Or consider an AI writing a press release. A PR expert will catch nuances of wording that will confuse readers, or leave fodder for others to attack or mischaracterize the announcement.

College students know this because they are working with AI. And what makes them mad is the human-driven false notion that AI devalues expertise. AI looks like magic to non-experts. But it’s not, it’s more like a “junior engineer” or “PR intern” to people with actual expertise to evaluate its output.

snowwrestler··on DMARC Fail: 7 Causes and How to Fix Each
There seems to be an additional factor lately, especially for email going to Microsoft, which is how long these DNS lookups take.

We configured a new email sending service and kept the DNS TTLs low on the TXT records for SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, in case we needed to change them. We saw a lot of mystery failures for emails going to Microsoft inboxes (M365 and Outlook.com). Changing the TTLs to be very long (86400 or more) caused a large improvement within a day to two.

The only way I can think to explain this is that some of their DNS lookups would time out if they had to follow recursion back to our DNS provider. Lengthening the TTL increased the chance the records would be cached locally to Microsoft’s systems and therefore served faster.

The only other explanation I can think of is that MS prefers longer TTLs as a matter of policy and downgrades based on that. But usually they publish policy preferences like that and I could not find one.

snowwrestler··on Alberta voter list leak is a potential public safety disaster
The public policy purpose is to allow independent verification of who voted, in furtherance of trust in elections. It is arguably one of the reasons voter fraud is extremely rare in U.S. elections. “Many eyes make bugs shallow,” to steal a phrase.

Unfortunately, a lot of people still believe in widespread voter fraud despite the obvious and well-documented rarity.

I would say something similar about the availability of voter files, though. A lot of people are horrified they are available despite the obvious and well-documented lack of evidence it causes any significant harm.

snowwrestler··on New statue in London, attributed to Banksy, of a suited man, blinded by a flag
The 2nd level of Banksy’s pranks is how angry they make self-appointed arbiters of what is counter-culture or cringe.
snowwrestler··on When Dawkins met Claude – Could this AI be conscious?
Natural selection is universal and undirected, so it is meaningless to wonder “why” it was “content to evolve” anything.

This sort of determinism has been a problem for Dawkins going back to the late chapters of The Selfish Gene.

snowwrestler··on The X-Files has made me nostalgic for a time I never experienced
I've heard this idea before but I think it's primarily hindsight. At the time The X Files was on, there were even more popular shows about strong institutions, like Law & Order or The West Wing. So if popular TV was influential, why didn't society evolve toward those portrayals? I think we can look back today and say "that looked like this," but it doesn't mean that caused this.

It took something far more powerful than a TV show that was mildly popular for a few years to create what we live today. It took the great flatness of the Internet. As Terry Pratchett predicted to Bill Gates back then.

snowwrestler··on GitHub Copilot is moving to usage-based billing
But if the org already has an agreement with Anthropic (and many do) then why pay GitHub…
snowwrestler··on Google DeepMind Paper Argues LLMs Will Never Be Conscious
There’s been plenty of philosophy, but what will probably happen is a re-definition of the terms to a more rigorous and repeatable mathematical formulation. This will fail to satisfy philosophical or fundamental questions, but will enable better quantitative predictions.

This essentially is where the schism is between science and philosophy, and has played out repeatedly across history. Heat for example was redefined to a specific physical property, and subjective experiences of warmth were then explored in reference to that. Or look back to the moment when Newton essentially said “I don’t know what gravity is, but I can accurately calculate any ballistic trajectory you can think of.”

snowwrestler··on Microsoft and OpenAI end their exclusive and revenue-sharing deal
I think you’re right about this deal. But it’s kind of funny to think back and realize that Microsoft actually has just written off multi-billion-dollar deals, several times in fact.
snowwrestler··on Sawe becomes first athlete to run a sub-two-hour marathon in a competitive race
These athletes are eating nutritionally complete diets overall. The simple carb intake is a strategy just for the run itself.

That said, pretty much everything about highest-end athletics is net negative for long-term health. It’s incredibly hard on the body to run a marathon in general, let alone at record breaking pace.

snowwrestler··on Flickr: The first and last great photo platform
Is that not what Wikimedia is for?
snowwrestler··on US special forces soldier arrested after allegedly winning $400k on Maduro raid
The idea is that people will lie lie lie since words are free, but make real decisions when it’s their money at stake.

It’s not that different from the general concept of pricing. People will swear they want to buy American, support small business etc. but when it’s time for new jeans they go to Walmart and buy the pair on sale.

snowwrestler··on We found a stable Firefox identifier linking all your private Tor identities
And yet this sort of endless (fingerprintable) browser feature list is what people cite when they claim that mobile Safari is somehow way behind Chrome, and how it’s a travesty that Chrome can’t natively implement all these (again, highly fingerprintable) features on the iPhone.
snowwrestler··on FBI looks into dead or missing scientists tied to NASA, Blue Origin, SpaceX
“Planetary defense” is a fig leaf covering the development of technologies to intercept and destroy ballistic missiles above the atmosphere.

The belief is that the first country to have this reliably at scale breaks the “mutually assured destruction” paradigm that has governed nuclear weapons policy for decades. If the U.S. can send nuclear ballistic missiles, but can’t be hit by nuclear missiles, what stops them from just nuking anyone who disagrees with them?

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →