HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

snowwrestler

33,347 karma · joined November 1, 2011

All thoughts posted here are entirely my own personal opinions.
submissionscomments
snowwrestler··on Rank the 50 best Apple products
I want to speak up for OS X. When it came out, and for years afterward, it hit an amazing sweet spot of looks cool, runs browsers well, runs MS well, runs Adobe well, full Unix shell, added great new features every year. There is a reason it became extremely popular with web devs, as the web was taking over the economy.

A closed local firewall blocking all inbound by default. Spotlight indexing. Time Machine backups. Flexible screenshot tools. Print anything to PDF. Lots of useful trackpad gestures. And after Intel, we got Rosetta, Boot Camp, easy Windows virtualization like Parallels, etc. That’s all off the top of my head, but for sure OS X had Microsoft on their back foot for years. Gates used to yell at his team about it.

snowwrestler··on Supreme Court Sides with Cox in Copyright Fight over Pirated Music
If copyright was only a decade then Sony could have waited 5 more years and made the movie of Project Hail Mary without paying one dime to Andy Weir.

I think the law is too long now, but a decade is too short to protect artists. Even a patent is 20 years.

snowwrestler··on France's aircraft carrier located in real time by Le Monde through fitness app
You can buy satellite imaging.

Operationally, navies with carriers assume that opponents know where they are.

snowwrestler··on How the Turner twins are mythbusting modern technical apparel
One of them used an iPad and one used parchment to take notes.
snowwrestler··on How the Turner twins are mythbusting modern technical apparel
Harvard’s signal is how hard it is to get in. There are less prestigious universities with a higher sticker price. Bad example, but I agree with your point in general.
snowwrestler··on “Your frustration is the product”
> This is a pretty inconsequential blog post where Gruber is just echoing another article.

He does this to amplify things, and look: it worked! The original post made the HN homepage a couple days ago, and now Gruber’s post about it has made the HN homepage again.

snowwrestler··on “Your frustration is the product”
You have to pay for the web version of the NY Times as well.
snowwrestler··on Measuring progress toward AGI: A cognitive framework
Capacity is not binary. A washing machine can accomplish one task, so it has low capacity. An LLM can accomplish many tasks, so it has higher capacity.
snowwrestler··on I haven't used a mouse for 14 years
The three finger drag pattern comes from Fingerworks, the multitouch trackpad company that Apple bought to get their multitouch tech.

A Fingerworks trackpad is when I switched away from a mouse, and in some ways it was even better than a modern Apple trackpad. First it was huge, maybe like twice the area of a MacBook Pro trackpad. It had no click switch at all. Taps only, which were very reliable.

It also lay flat on the desk and was only a few mm thick. So it felt like just resting your hand on the desk. And it was possible to just passively rest your hand on it with no reaction. So using it, my hand and wrist were totally relaxed when not moving the cursor (most of the time). Whereas with modern Apple trackpads, I sometimes get spurious inputs when resting my hand on it.

It also had tons of gestures that were mapped to keyboard shortcuts. So an “opening the jar” arcing motion with 4 fingers opened whatever file was currently highlighted. And “closing the jar” closed the current window. Etc.

snowwrestler··on Have a fucking website
To be fair, Google Search does this to sites too. Small sites can see all their traffic disappear within a few days if an algorithm update goes against them. And there is zero recourse.
snowwrestler··on Tech hobbyist makes shoulder-mounted guided missile prototype with $96 in parts
The engine and the warhead are two of the biggest challenges in making a missile, in large part because anything high performance is also going to be spectacularly dangerous to manufacture.
snowwrestler··on Measuring progress toward AGI: A cognitive framework
If a human cares about the work, they can often outperform an LLM because they will keep at it until the work meets their standard of quality. Whereas the LLM will guess and then wait to be corrected. As a recent tweet I saw said: it’s amazing how fast the software bottleneck went from writing code, to reviewing code.

I think we’ll need to split the concept of intelligence into the capacity to accomplish a task and the capacity to conceive and prompt a task. If the former is called “intelligence” then LLMs are intelligent.

But what then do we call the latter? I think the idea of an AI that can independently accomplish great things is where people talk about “general” intelligence. But I think we need a label more specific, that covers this idea that successful humans are not just good at doing things, they originate what should be done and are not easy to dissuade.

snowwrestler··on US SEC preparing to scrap quarterly reporting requirement
To be fair, this is a side effect of financial deadlines in general. A business reporting annually will still try to beat that deadline right up to the last second.

In this particular example a single truckload would be less significant annually than quarterly though.

snowwrestler··on Meta Platforms: Lobbying, dark money, and the App Store Accountability Act
The environmental movement and labor movement are two examples where citizens organize to go up against corporate interests and win pretty regularly and durably.

Most of those folks would not call it lobbying because of the negative associations of the word. “We have activists, our opponents have lobbyists.” But it works the same way.

It is specifically protected in the First Amendment: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

Emphasis mine.

snowwrestler··on Polymarket gamblers threaten to kill me over Iran missile story
Alan Kay had a great quote: “The best way to predict the future is to invent it.” A quote that many technologists and inventors have used as inspiration over the years as they create things.

It looks a little less inspiring when applied to prediction markets. Because yeah, one way to win a bet is to bet on something you already know you can make happen. AKA insider trading.

But even worse, another way to win a bet is to cajole / threaten / bribe someone into lying about what really happened. That’s the stakes in this story. And at that point, the social value of prediction markets has gone negative. You’ve no longer got a tool that helps predict reality, you’ve got a new way to reward people for lying about what is real and not real.

snowwrestler··on Harold and George Destroy the World
That’s not how genetics works. It’s not a simple averaging scheme.
snowwrestler··on Harold and George Destroy the World
Genetic heritability, which is a subset of heritability, does not generally mean what people think it means, though. To the extent IQ can be attributed genetically to parents, it does not imply a "compounding" effect where smart people continuously have smarter kids and dumb people have dumber kids. This can understood by analogy to other personal traits like eyesight, height, weight, hair color, etc. which vary within a range across generations with occasional unpredictable outliers. This is why folks who do test for intelligence, have to test each person individually and not just rely on bloodline tracking.
snowwrestler··on Reddit's Lawsuit Is a Dangerous Attempt to Expand Platform Power
Copyright protects copying. Scraping content does not violate copyright if the content is not republished. Otherwise Google and all search engines would be illegal.
snowwrestler··on Reddit's Lawsuit Is a Dangerous Attempt to Expand Platform Power
It doesn’t hurt SerpApi’s defense against Reddit’s lawsuit, because SerpApi does not need to prove they have your permission. They only need to prove that Reddit does not have the legal authority to prevent SerpApi from scraping your content. Which they almost certainly don’t.
snowwrestler··on The Wyden Siren Goes Off Again: We'll Be "Stunned" by NSA Under Section 702
To answer your question, Congressional leaders are elected by their colleagues. Their power comes from that and from the rules that Congress writes for itself.
snowwrestler··on The Wyden Siren Goes Off Again: We’ll Be “Stunned” By What the NSA Is Doing
This is all true and it kind of defines the scope of the harm he is talking about: bad enough for vague warnings, but apparently not bad enough to risk consequences to seniority etc. by outright revealing it.

Worth noting his full quote is that people will be “stunned that it took so long” for the info to come out. Which is not quite the same thing as being stunned in general.

snowwrestler··on The Wyden Siren Goes Off Again: We’ll Be “Stunned” By What the NSA Is Doing
The warnings are nice but he could just say what it is. Members of Congress have immunity for what they say on the floor of their chamber in session, classification or no.
snowwrestler··on Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conversation between humans.
Citations can be helpful. But AI summaries and Google searches are poor citations because they are not primary sources.
snowwrestler··on The MacBook Neo
To what extent is there still a “consumer PC industry?” You mention Dell; for like a decade I think I’ve only ever seen Dells that were company-issued.

My sense is that consumers spend most of their tech money on phones, tablets, headphones, watches, services. People who really want a laptop get a Mac or Chromebook. Gamers buy / build PCs, for gaming. Linux geeks buy Linux machines for Linuxing.

I’m not saying no one buys PC laptops at consumer retail. I guess I’m just wondering how big that market is anymore after consumer discretionary spending on tech has been hollowed out by the above list.

(I’m sure most people reading this have purchased a laptop. I think the HN audience is a tech outlier compared to most consumers.)

snowwrestler··on How the Sriracha guys screwed over their supplier
You think GPU manufacturers are paying people to post fake positive comments all day in /r/buildapcsales in the hopes of materially increasing their revenue?
snowwrestler··on How the Sriracha guys screwed over their supplier
Oh, there’s risk? Somehow you forgot to mention that in your post about how incredibly easy it is.

I’m sure it’s possible to make small amounts of money with Reddit bots, just like it’s possible to make small amounts of money with email spam, and posting AI slop to Facebook and X, and SMS scams.

The idea that major brands do this habitually, is what I’m objecting to.

snowwrestler··on How the Sriracha guys screwed over their supplier
A note of caution on this line of thinking. Pretty much every story you'll ever hear about a commercial subject is going to a) be incomplete and inaccurate, and b) seem beneficial to one party in the story. That's just how stories work.

You can spend your entire online life seeing ghosts of astroturfing in everything you read. Like, how do we know that Huy Fong didn't pay you to come here on HN to neg the Reddit story that makes them look bad? You're stuck trying to prove a negative: impossible.

There is a reason accusations of astroturfing are against the HN guidelines, and it's this: in the absence of evidence, anything opinionated could be astroturfing... or it could not. Which makes it completely useless as a heuristic. It feels like smart skepticism, but it does not actually add any substance to the conversation.

snowwrestler··on How the Sriracha guys screwed over their supplier
If this is true, it implies that such marketing on Reddit is not worth much. Because if a marketing tactic is easy and effective, intense competition will drive up the price of doing so.

Conversely if Reddit astroturfing was actually valuable, "upvotes cost nothing" could not be true. Like, we know that Meta and Google ads are effective, and those cost something. Not because they're hard to do, but because everyone is trying to do them at once.

snowwrestler··on Judge orders government to begin refunding more than $130B in tariffs
Could you go into detail about what you think happened? The tariffs were public knowledge, and the suits to invalidate them were public knowledge. Are you saying you think the Supreme Court justices secretly communicated to the Commerce Secretary how they intended to rule on the case, far in advance of publishing their ruling?
snowwrestler··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
Would be interesting if you would be willing to share a paper you reviewed and detail your review process of it. I don't see how one could check primary data or interrogate scientists in a blind review process, for example.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →