HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

snowwrestler

33,347 karma · joined November 1, 2011

All thoughts posted here are entirely my own personal opinions.
submissionscomments
snowwrestler··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
You've provided evidence that prominent journals experience retractions, fraudulent results, etc. All true. But it is not the job of peer reviewers to decide what gets published.

You've provided evidence that peer-reviewed science often turns out to be incomplete, inaccurate, wrong, fraudulent etc. All true. But it is not the job of peer reviewers to assure completeness, accuracy, or freedom from fraud.

A peer reviewer reads a paper and make comments on it. That's it! They don't check primary data, they don't investigate methods, they don't interrogate scientists, they don't re-run experiments just to double check. They assist a journal's editors in editing--that's it.

The check on published scientific results is the scientific process itself, not the publishing process. Prominent results attract further investigation, which confirms or disproves the reality of the underlying phenomena. Again: that's not the job of peer review.

Do some people ascribe too much authority to peer review? Yes, for sure. IMO your comments in this thread are exacerbating that problem, not addressing it.

snowwrestler··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
The naive public does not believe anything in particular about peer review. They think new scientific results are significant when they read about them in the popular media, that’s it.

People who do need to work professionally with peer review, do understand what it actually does and its limitations.

You seem stuck somewhere in the middle, caring deeply about a system you don’t seem to fully understand.

snowwrestler··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
I don’t understand why people care so much about the cost of journal subscriptions. If we add up all the revenue from all major scientific journal publishers, is that a big number in the context of the national economy? Or even compared to one major tech company?

I feel like this is one of those classic local minima where a community starving for resources fights vociferously amongst itself because they have internalized that they can’t win externally. From where I sit outside academia the problem with science seems obvious: there is not nearly enough money going into it.

I doubt bringing the heads of for-profit journals would change that under current national conditions in the U.S.

snowwrestler··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
Imagine being a scientist and reading “if you take this grant, you cannot publish your results in any of the most prominent journals in your field.” Sounds good?
snowwrestler··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
> Part of the problem is we got tricked into thinking "peer reviewed" meant "true," or at least something like it.

No actual working scientist thinks this.

“Glitchc” has it right elsewhere in this thread: the motivating force behind journals is prominence and reputation, not truth.

snowwrestler··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
U.S. scientists already did, at least at work. They still drive home at imperial speeds though.
snowwrestler··on MacBook Neo
People habitually misunderstand this moment in Apple’s history. Jobs took a shredder to a complex product line of poorly selling products, produced by a company that was nearly bankrupt. That was the right thing to do at that time.

Later when Apple was on sound financial footing, Jobs expanded the product line. That was the right thing to do at that time.

With the Neo, Apple now offers 3 lines of laptops: Pro, Air, Neo. This is not substantially different from 2010 when Apple under Jobs offered 3 lines of laptops: MacBook, MacBook Pro, and MacBook Air.

snowwrestler··on MacBook Neo
My local school district is 100% Chromebooks, first issued in 4th grade and through high school.
snowwrestler··on MacBook Neo
So I guess they must have fully depreciated the gigantic fleet of CNC routers they use to cut the aluminum cases. Making a cheap laptop seems better than throwing them away.
snowwrestler··on MacBook Air with M5
The final version of the “wedge” Air case was an amazing piece of physical design. The lid had a large-radius complex curve that perfectly controlled reflections. The bottom case had a curve that made it look like the machine was hovering above the desktop from almost any angle. Calling that a “hack” is sort of like calling it a “hack” that a Ferrari looks fast even when it’s parked.

The new designs are overtly boringly utilitarian. I would say they intentionally look ugly. I guess this must have been intended as a marketing signal.

And it seems like it’s working since you think the new design delivers better battery life. It doesn’t! The 13-inch M1, M2, M3, M4, and M5 MacBook Airs are all specced for 18 hours of battery life.

snowwrestler··on Court finds Fourth Amendment doesn’t support broad search of protesters’ devices
He was powerful enough to hang someone on a flimsy excuse, but not so powerful that he did not need a flimsy excuse. Right in that sweet spot.
snowwrestler··on Court finds Fourth Amendment doesn’t support broad search of protesters’ devices
This apocryphal quote was a statement about his overwhelming power (strong enough to hang people who have done no wrong), not on the mutability of the law. It is frequently mis-applied.
snowwrestler··on The Pentagon is making a mistake by threatening Anthropic
You don’t need Anthropic for this use case, so obviously this use case is not what the current fight is about.
snowwrestler··on The Pentagon is making a mistake by threatening Anthropic
Use of the DPA can be litigated, and surely would be. Designation as a supply chain risk surely would be as well.

These court cases would produce bad outcomes either way. If the court finds for Anthropic, future DoD leadership will find itself constrained or at least chilled. Or if the court finds for the government, an expansive permissive view of the DPA might encourage future administrations to compel tech companies to make AIs break the law in other ways, for example by suppressing certain political points of view in output.

National defense is strongest if the military is extremely powerful but carefully judicious in the application of that power. That gives us the highest “top end” capability of performance. If military leadership insists on acting recklessly, then eventually guardrails are installed, with the result of a diminished ability to respond effectively to low-probability, high risk moments. One of many nuances and paradoxes the current political leadership does not seem to understand.

snowwrestler··on Statement from Dario Amodei on our discussions with the Department of War
Congress needs public pressure to act, and the public needs a spur to apply pressure. That’s really what Amodei is doing with this statement.
snowwrestler··on 27-year-old Apple iBooks can connect to Wi-Fi and download official updates
More specifically: because they cannot be revoked, they need to expire. Same with root certs.
snowwrestler··on IRS Tactics Against Meta Open a New Front in the Corporate Tax Fight
> what on earth could they be continuously doing for four years?

It’s not continuous. Court time in particular is a scarce resource. Many people are involved in complex litigation, and for almost all of those people it is not their only project / job.

> My guess is that it's like a poorly run software project: mostly empty, where Person X is blocked waiting on the output of Person Y for weeks, and so on.

Correct but the off times aren’t empty; the lawyers and staff simply pick up one of the other hundreds of tasks in front of them while they wait.

snowwrestler··on 27-year-old Apple iBooks can connect to Wi-Fi and download official updates
> Of course they do, they have to.

Why do they have to?

(This will also tell you why certs in your OS need to expire.)

snowwrestler··on 27-year-old Apple iBooks can connect to Wi-Fi and download official updates
Right, because DNS entries never expire.
snowwrestler··on 15 years later, Microsoft morged my diagram
Maybe not a winning strategy because a lot of public companies have a comms team that manages the CEO’s LinkedIn. Thereby saving the valuable time of the CEO themselves.
snowwrestler··on Stephen Colbert says CBS forbid interview of Democrat because of FCC threat
It is unlikely Carr will be FCC chair past January 20, 2029. (If he makes it that long.)

However, all those conservative billionaires will still own their media companies. Expanding the coverage of the equal time rule would hand the next Democratic administration a big club to swing at them.

Hey maybe for his next act, Carr will revive the Fairness Doctrine that was repealed under Reagan.

snowwrestler··on Stephen Colbert says CBS forbid interview of Democrat because of FCC threat
> It should come as no surprise that the moment they were handed the power, they began to push the boundaries of what is acceptable when it comes to censoring media they see as a threat.

To be clear, they were “handed power” by decisively winning a national election, which sort of undercuts your opening statement about how unpopular they are.

snowwrestler··on Stephen Colbert says CBS forbid interview of Democrat because of FCC threat
I think it’s funny that while GOP supporters are investing tens of $billions to take over popular broadcast and social media brands to privilege their point of view, Brendan Carr threatens to invoke the equal time rule, which would completely negate their structural advantage.

This is kind of like when conservatives spent years wrapping their advocacy in the banner of free speech, and then Brendan Carr announced that free speech is over, actually, because Jimmy Kimmel was mean. Oops! Nevermind.

snowwrestler··on Poor Deming never stood a chance
Deming’s idea is that each line worker is responsible 1) for understanding and minimizing variation in their specific area of work, and 2) for speaking up when they have ideas on how to do that better.

It is management’s job to protect their ability to do that, and integrate the information from workers to make decisions about what to change next.

snowwrestler··on I'm not worried about AI job loss
Isn’t it a bit silly to say AI is going to eat the entire economy, but you have a contingency plan?

It seems kind of like saying “I’m smarter than all the AIs in this one particular way.” If someone posted that, you would probably jump in to say they’re fooling themselves.

snowwrestler··on I'm not worried about AI job loss
Checking the scoreboard a bit later on: the French economy is currently about the same size as the UK.
snowwrestler··on I'm not worried about AI job loss
Real wage growth has been positive for the last 3 years:

https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/CES0500000013?output_view=pc...

snowwrestler··on An AI agent published a hit piece on me – more things have happened
Sounds like the sale price for vintage HN accounts is about to skyrocket.

Just kidding! I hope

snowwrestler··on An AI agent published a hit piece on me – more things have happened
I don’t know how to create a robot-free Internet without accidentally furthering surveillance of humans. Any technique I can think of that would reliably prove I’m not a bot also seems like a technique that would make it easier for commercial or government tracking of me.
snowwrestler··on Something Big Is Coming (Annotated by Ed Zitron) [pdf]
Also in reply (satirically):

Something Small is Happening

https://x.com/johnpalmer/status/2021966462198460849?s=12

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →