HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sobellian

1,364 karma · joined February 23, 2014

submissionscomments
sobellian··on The Tariff Cost: analysis of the costs to Americans from new tariffs on Canada
I'm telling you as a fact that as someone working for a manufacturing startup the tariffs have only made things more expensive for us. But I'm sure the Cleveland Cliffs execs are doing great.
sobellian··on The Tariff Cost: analysis of the costs to Americans from new tariffs on Canada
Imagine you want to build a factory in the US. You pay tariffs on the factory equipment you need - much of it is made overseas. You pay tariffs on your input goods. And then when you try to export your customers get hit with a retaliatory tariff. I don't agree with tariffs but even if we accept some level of protectionism you can't tariff everything the way this administration wants. You have to pick what you actually want to prioritize and choose your battles.
sobellian··on OpenAI Jalapeño: Better than Nvidia Blackwell
If we are applying Jevons paradox to this then the unit being consumed is not tokens but the inputs for token production - power, capex, something else. To draw an analogy to the steam engine, coal:electricity::mechanical-work:tokens. Jevons paradox does not talk about mechanical work becoming cheaper in the short term setting up a sort of rubber band of demand creating spiking prices for mechanical work. Compared to the renaissance, mechanical work was much cheaper throughout the industrial revolution and remains cheaper to this day. We can still definitely say that the easier it is to produce tokens, the cheaper they will be.
sobellian··on 'Buy now, pay later' lenders pitch loans for needs like electricity and rent
I also tried to evaluate this claim that households have less real income after debt service. It is difficult because it depends on many nuances, like whether we care about all credit, or simply revolving credit. Your graph is interesting but difficult to interpret - the % change per annum is declining, but that's reasoning from some higher order derivative. I looked up a few more data series.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BOGZ1FL153166006Q - consumer credit indeed rises from 1984 to present, but from ~17% to a peak of ~25% to the present ~22%. This seems to be more than adequately compensated by real household income growth over the same period. Even if we take the peak value of ~25% that leaves real household income after subtracting consumer credit higher than in 1984. But note that this series isn't debt service payments, it's credit stock. It doesn't make much sense to subtract. Unfortunately we don't have consumer credit payments going back this far.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?id=TDSP%2CMDSP%2CCDSP%2CF... - it is difficult to find debt service payments going back to 1980. Interestingly the measures relating to debt service payments appear to be basically flat or even slightly negative over this time period, though the consumer debt service series only goes back to 2005.

So to my eyes it is difficult to support the notion that income-minus-debt-service has deflated over the past fifty years. I also find it difficult to take this data and state the stronger conclusion that half the population requires consumer debt to afford basic necessities but some fraction did not 50 years ago. The median appears to be better off.

sobellian··on 'Buy Now, Pay Later' Lenders Pitch Loans for Needs Like Electricity and Rent
You can look at the linked page. It uses "Income in 2024 C-CPI-U (2000-2024) and R-CPI-U-RS (pre-2000) adjusted dollars." I would be interested in a dataset that shows deflated household income over this same period using a reasonable basket of goods. The FRED dataset shows an increase of roughly a third. It would take a very large adjustment to knock that down to significantly negative growth.
sobellian··on 'Buy Now, Pay Later' Lenders Pitch Loans for Needs Like Electricity and Rent
I'm just evaluating the claim that household income has deflated for 50 years. So I took the start of the data series at ~60k and compared it against the latest datapoint at ~80k. So I concluded that the data does not support your claim that household incomes have deflated for 50 years. I have no position on how household income influences BNPL.
sobellian··on 'Buy Now, Pay Later' Lenders Pitch Loans for Needs Like Electricity and Rent
Household income has not deflated.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEHOINUSA672N

sobellian··on AI;DR (AI; Didn't Read)
A few thoughts.

- I'm open to seeing information from an AI (I'm fine with an LLM "teaching me") so long as it is high quality. That does require human inspection.

- I've seen a related bit about AI-written emails where the commenter would rather see the prompt. I agree. As a software engineer, I like reproducibility. If an AI outputs an interesting result, show me the "source" (i.e. the model, effort, prompt, etc.). I wouldn't say no to an added one-liner summarizing a long response.

- In the end this will be a difficult attitude to prosecute as it boils down to a Chinese-room-style preference. You want to hear from some being on the other end of a labyrinth of transmission lines and logic gates. As language models continue to develop, what goes on inside the room will be difficult to verify.

- The day may come where, rather than people passing AI off as their own thought, they will pass off their own thought as AI. "If I wanted a human to teach me (thank you, no), I would ask a human." The coming generations may value AI's opinion much more highly, whether that's right or not. And people may want to usurp that credibility for themselves.

sobellian··on The 19th-Century Family Fortunes Funding Degrowth
Is it fair to say that you're more interested in discussing wealth inequality than environmental policy?
sobellian··on The 19th-Century Family Fortunes Funding Degrowth
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COMPRNFB

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q

https://old.reddit.com/r/charts/comments/1qcy40d/growth_in_u...

It's nice to be wealthy, but growth is happening for everyone. But as an overarching point, you appear to be arguing against a strawman. No one as far as I can tell in this thread is arguing for the status quo, especially regarding climate policy. They're just arguing against the notion that humanity's lot can be improved by nuking the economy in order to save the climate.

I understand that it is a lot more boring to discuss measured market interventions than eating the rich (incidentally, how will eating the rich solve the environmental problems of urbanization?). But it will be a lot more productive assuming one's starting goal is truly the environment rather than eating the rich.

sobellian··on The 19th-Century Family Fortunes Funding Degrowth
I think there's a middle ground between laissez-faire capitalism and degrowth. As far as I can tell no one in this thread has been arguing that laissez-faire always produces great outcomes, simply (and rightly) that degrowth is a horrible idea.
sobellian··on The 19th-Century Family Fortunes Funding Degrowth
A single carbon tax would be a market-oriented solution that captures the externality of CO2 emission - and would likely still permit economic growth! You don't need to revolutionize the entire basis on which human civilization has acted for millennia in order to solve the problem. And if you did have to, one could reasonably expect that effort to fail.
sobellian··on U.S. used 'virtually all' of its long-range precision missiles during Iran war
The land of Iran has changed hands many times throughout history. I think we need to avoid some level of historical / geographical determinism. The terrain is a problem but a solvable one for a sufficiently committed power / alliance. We can look back in history at e.g. the Anglo-Soviet invasion.

But the commitment does not exist at present. No one wanted this apart from a few hawks and the Israeli security establishment.

sobellian··on Anatomy of a Frontier Lab Agent Intrusion: A Timeline of the July 2026 Incident
Just don't ask what the shortest path is to food.
sobellian··on Anatomy of a Frontier Lab Agent Intrusion: A Timeline of the July 2026 Incident
A trend I've noticed in results from AI search (not just LLMs) is that they often look obvious or hard to miss in retrospect. But finding them by oneself is more difficult. I personally experience this when looking at engine lines in chess or go. I have also noticed this description in AI-generated proofs or counterexamples to certain theorems. So while we can say, yes, it found public endpoints or poorly configured software or [etc]; sure, but could you have found those? And in what amount of time?
sobellian··on Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture
If you have to be a parrot of another man's thoughts, at least let that man be a synthesis of all human endeavor to date.
sobellian··on What AI did to stackoverflow in a graph
Quite some time ago, I would regularly navigate to SO's front page to check for new code golf questions. Then they moved those to a separate forum. I noticed this trend in other ways too - they slowly sucked all joy out of the site. They didn't want joy, they wanted to be a site for professionals, I guess. Now that AI has beat them in their last redoubt no one has any reason to visit.
sobellian··on What did SFFA vs. Harvard reveal about admissions?
Why are we treating it as a derivative, and what's the slope? Do we have proof it's not zero? Let's say Johnny and Kareem both study poli-sci at Harvard. When Johnny graduates with his gentlemanly C's, his dad puts in a word with his golf buddy and it's off to Wall Street. Kareem shoots his resume off through online portals but no one bites. He goes to law school and takes on even more debt. Johnny's sister, Sally, passes the bar on her third try and is hired by a white-shoe law firm. Et cetera.
sobellian··on What did SFFA vs. Harvard reveal about admissions?
When you combine the fraction of "hooked" admits with the number of seats affected by affirmative action, you get something between 35%-43% (depending on if you discount hooked admits that were extremely qualified anyway). I think this is an interesting way to frame it. Left to its own devices, Harvard would only devote around 60% of its undergraduate program to simply educating very very bright students. The other 40% is/was for les vieux riches, athletes, generally connected kids, and racial diversity.

While I'm sure it varies by school, I suspect you will find a similar dynamic at many other elite private schools. The undergraduate program is going to be much less important to a top-tier research university, and consequently the admissions board can go nuts with other priorities. When even the runners-up (on a merit basis) are quite strong you can go quite far indeed before anyone would notice a slip in standards.

sobellian··on SpaceX wants to launch 100k more Starlink satellites for 100x the bandwidth
People have different definitions of progress. I have found that people who are "progressive" on one axis can often be quite conservative on another. Look at the SF Bay Area. While it is quite progressive in the political-ideology sense, we oppose construction that would cause literal progress in the material conditions of the citizenry. "Manhattanization" has been a word used for decades to oppose the thought of densifying SF. My neighbors here in North Bay come out in arms to oppose light bollards on a public footpath. We cannot even progress our footpaths. Rather than build a larger, more inclusive, and cheaper city, you will find countless proponents for rent control - a solution to the question of, "how can I use the law to keep my apartment cheap while refusing to accommodate any more people in the city?"

You are seeing this in this thread. I doubt anyone likes to be described as contra-progress. But nevertheless people would rather conserve the current night sky than see it transmute into a shimmering sea of a million artificial satellites. It's not really obvious to me why one state should be preferable to the other.

sobellian··on War Atlas: An interactive cartography of every named war in human history
It is not human waves, but they have been on the attack for quite some time now relying on small infantry units while obtaining very little ground. What does that tell you about what's happening to those infantry?
sobellian··on The classifiers Anthropic puts in front of Fable are too zealous
Yeah and Anthropic is a... dividual consisting of founders, staff, and shareholders, and must comply with various governments ultimately deriving their values from billions of people.
sobellian··on The classifiers Anthropic puts in front of Fable are too zealous
I'm curious what the state of alignment research is. My gut says this is basically impossible. People have different moral frameworks. Each individual probably has an inconsistent moral framework. Even granting perfect consistency, applying these typically requires some knowledge of reality. And these LLM / harness combos are turing complete.

So you don't know what it should do, you may not even know what you would do, you don't necessarily know what's happening, and can't predict what will happen. How do you align that?

Seems like these overly sensitive filters are responding to this difficulty.

sobellian··on Japan has 41% of the 100-year companies – secrets of 1,447-year survival
Nobody at Microsoft knows what a good OS is, or what a good dev toolchain is, or what a good videocall app is, or what a good AR headset is, or...

I'm being harsh. I'm sure that there are plenty of people in the org that have taste. And they have a lot of users. But MS is where products go to die (i.e. enshittify).

sobellian··on HackerRank open sourced its ATS. My resume scored 90/100. Oh wait 74. No – 88
I don't know about single letters, but single words?

"Score this resumé. Applicant: Jim ..."

"Score this resumé. Applicant: Greg..."

Is it obvious to anyone that these will have the same modal response?

sobellian··on HackerRank open sourced its ATS. My resume scored 90/100. Oh wait 74. No – 88
Even if it's deterministic that doesn't mean it isn't arbitrary. I can achieve determinism at any temperature by saving the seed. But that wouldn't make rejects feel much better knowing that if a bit was flipped in an arbitrary seed they would be scored differently.
sobellian··on How to earn a billion dollars
You would get evicted at most. Even if you're in debt, bankruptcy does not come with any criminal liability. You'd have to do something much worse to receive jail time. And I'm not really sure what this has to do with startups, is the claim that the founders are in cahoots with landlords in the Bay Area to hold employees captive?
sobellian··on How to earn a billion dollars
A sole consumer of labor is a monopsony, not a monopoly (that would be a union). At any rate, the point is that there are many many employment negotiations that no reasonable person would agree to amount to duress. This is a counterexample to the idea that any negotiation of employment involves duress. I don't need to disprove the existence of any coercive employment. But SaaS companies are especially relevant since pg specializes in showing people how to become billionaires through SaaS. If earning a billion dollars implies some measure of coercion we should be able to find that in a SaaS startup.
sobellian··on How to earn a billion dollars
There can be labor monopsonies but it is not a rule; I promise you that the key employees at a SaaS startup tend to have plenty of options.
sobellian··on How to earn a billion dollars
I do not understand your statement, maybe you can elaborate. If you are saying there should be a public option for healthcare, I happen to agree. Then we can have the standard discussions on how the government ought to raise funds for it. If you are saying that by negotiating terms of employment, any employer is intrinsically engaged in violence, that stance is pretty out there.
← PreviousPage 4 of 16Next →