HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sobriquet9

256 karma · joined January 1, 2021

submissionscomments
sobriquet9··on The infamous coin toss
If you have nothing in your checking account, it does not mean your wealth is zero. In real life you can earn more money, in the given example you can't.
sobriquet9··on The infamous coin toss
> The only solution: eat the rich.

The only? Maybe not bet 100% of your wealth every time? That's what Kelly criterion is about.

sobriquet9··on Stem Formulas
Some of those are just definitions. Not sure what's the usefulness of det(A) = |A| or c=λf, it's not like one would need to look that up.
sobriquet9··on An invitation to a secret society
> the overwhelming majority of papers in most disciplines will hold up very well under scrutiny

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_Most_Published_Research_Fi...

sobriquet9··on What the media won't tell you about US heat waves (2022)
> The extreme temperatures of 1930s present a challenge for the detection and attribution of trends in heat waves in the United States.

The theory predicts extreme values well, although only if we ignore historically observed extreme values.

sobriquet9··on Lets-Plot: An open-source plotting library for statistical data
No empirical CDF plots? This is the first thing I do when looking at the new data.
sobriquet9··on The Password Game
Qxg7+. Chess subreddit has a counter of days without a puzzle that starts with a queen sacrifice.
sobriquet9··on The Password Game
XXXV * I = 35. Po (from Poland), V, and I add up to 160, so you need to add Zr.
sobriquet9··on Intelligent people take longer to solve hard problems: study
People with higher intelligence scores, not intelligent people.
sobriquet9··on Automatic emergency braking should become mandatory, feds say
It's not only rear ending. The main road near my house has a sharp left turn with a sign on the side of the road. I occasionally get a BRAKE! warning there, probably because AEB mistakes that sign for a car in front of me. On a wet road, stepping on the brakes when the car is turning can easily result in understeer, which is particularly dangerous in that spot because of the large boulders nearby.
sobriquet9··on Pixel Tablet
Will GrapheneOS run on it?
sobriquet9··on Get Running with Couch to 5K
Having done Couch to 5K, I can say 9 weeks is too short. I understand that a longer, more realistic time frame would mean fewer people will attempt it, but such quick growth makes injuries more likely. Lungs and heart adopt faster than ligaments. I ended up hurting my knee, which set me back by a couple of months.
sobriquet9··on Non-ECC memory corrupted my hard drive image [video]
The probability of a bit flip depends on the size of the transistor used. RAM tends to pack many small transistors.
sobriquet9··on 0.999․․․
> Absurd.

Show me the proof of Newton's laws of motion.

sobriquet9··on 0.999․․․
My point is that if all I need is to convince my audience, I may be able to make them believe the flawed proof.

In this example the flaw is intentionally obvious, but there are other examples where the flaw is more subtle.

sobriquet9··on 0.999․․․
The problem with this formulation is that one can convince the audience that something is right when it isn't. Example:

31 is prime,

331 is prime,

3331 is prime,

33331 is prime,

...

33333331 is prime, therefore

333333331 must be prime (while in fact it's divisible by 17).

I'm not arguing one should never look at proofs and take everything for granted. I'm saying that rigorous proofs going down all the way to Peano axioms are unnecessary. In fact, most math people actually use, including linear algebra, calculus, Fourier transform predates Peano axioms.

sobriquet9··on 0.999․․․
Everything you know is easy for you. For others, there's opportunity cost. The time one spent on learning Peano axioms is the time one could have spent on learning something more useful, say, linear algebra.
sobriquet9··on 0.999․․․
I look at math the same way as at physics, where rigorous proofs are not possible. The difference only matters to the few people who do it professionally.

I know I can dig deeper all the way down to axioms if I choose so, but realistically there is not enough time for me to learn all of the underlying math. At most, I can occasionally check if the results are consistent and match reality.

sobriquet9··on 0.999․․․
> these algebraic demonstrations are not rigorous proofs because we have not shown that elementary rules for addition and multiplication extend to repeating decimal numbers too. They do but we have not demonstrated that here.

That's why I don't like proofs. There are many things that are not demonstrated here. The same can also be said about the other proof that is presumably complete. Unless you build everything from axioms up, any proof will be incomplete. And building from axioms is too verbose.

From the practical perspective it's like proving that 1 is equal to 1.0000...

sobriquet9··on Calculating the maximum diagonal distance in a given set of points
cos(54 deg)/cos(49 deg) ~ 0.588/0.656 ~ 0.9, so a longitude degree in the north of the country is about 10% shorter than in the south.
sobriquet9··on Calculating the maximum diagonal distance in a given set of points
> without accounting for the curvature of the Earth) is 768 and a quarter

After accounting for the curvature of the Earth, the distance between (53.92085665, 14.2861684) and (49.0080789, 22.88022362) is 806 km, and the line is very different from what's shown in the article.

sobriquet9··on What’s driving the rich world’s falling fertility?
Not only rich world's. Fertility is dropping wherever per-capita income is growing.
sobriquet9··on The Mystery of 355/113 (2010)
113\355 is easier to remember.
sobriquet9··on How to build software like an SRE
I was thinking about including the necessary instrumentation to check code coverage during regression tests. Something like coverage.py. The intent is not to get a specific number, but to understand which parts of the code might not be exercised enough by existing test cases.
sobriquet9··on How to build software like an SRE
> Don’t waste time on code coverage

Is it really that useless? I was about to start doing code coverage and now wonder if I should reconsider.

sobriquet9··on The reality of celebratory gunfire
It takes considerably more to kill someone than to break the skin. Maybe if you are laying on your back and the falling bullet hits the carotid artery, but this is a really contrived example.
sobriquet9··on The reality of celebratory gunfire
Let's take a common 9 mm round with muzzle velocity of 1,100 fps. When fired at 87 degrees, horizontal velocity component is 1,100 fps * cos 87 deg = 57 fps.

It will be much less than that on the way down due to air resistance throughout the flight, and negligible compared to terminal velocity (around 200 fps).

sobriquet9··on The reality of celebratory gunfire
Let's do science then.

Terminal velocity of a falling 9 mm bullet is 219 fps, .223 bullet falls at 244 fps. [1]

To perforate the skin and enter the underlying subcutaneous tissue and muscle, a minimum velocity in the order of 230 fps is necessary. [2]

So the bullet falling at terminal velocity has barely enough velocity to break the skin, and is therefore very unlikely to be fatal.

[1] https://forensicmcq.com/terminal-velocity-of-falling-bullets... [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7304523/

sobriquet9··on The reality of celebratory gunfire
Source? In the case Mythbusters mentioned, the person killed by falling bullet was about a mile away, hence those bullets were fired at a lower angle.
sobriquet9··on The reality of celebratory gunfire
See my other comment. Mythbusters found the same thing, that bullets fired at low elevation remain dangerous, while bullets fired at high elevation (close to vertical) come down at a much lower velocity, not sufficient to kill a person.
← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →