HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

socillion

798 karma · joined July 27, 2009

I'm afraid you won't find me around under this name anymore. Feel free to drop me an email at gmail.

"The advantage of a bad memory is that one can enjoy the same good things for the first time several times."

submissionscomments
socillion··on Sweden becomes the first country to reject low-fat diet dogma
> it is better to use such a diet rather than simply doing something harder that yields the same end result

You assert that exercising and changing your diet have the same end result when they clearly do not, unless you are using "healthy" as a euphemism for "lose weight" or something similar. Do you have a factual basis for asserting that changing your diet and exercising result in the same end results?

Thank you for clarifying that you do not find exercise enjoyable, I was curious if that was the case. I find exercise to be rewarding in it's own right - it's unfortunate that you don't experience it the same way.

"No pain, no gain" can be interpreted as saying that sometimes it is worth enduring discomfort or pain in the short term for a longer term reward. It's more a comment on dealing with delayed gratification than a description of whether an activity is enjoyable or worth doing.

socillion··on Sweden becomes the first country to reject low-fat diet dogma
My argument is that challenging yourself is healthy, and that applies to both physical and mental activities. I suspect the difference may lie in what we consider "good health".

Being challenging also doesn't imply an activity is unenjoyable or unrewarding.

> But personally I would not choose to do things that were clearly suboptimal for my body solely because it would be more challenging.

What things?

socillion··on Sweden becomes the first country to reject low-fat diet dogma
What if people took the same tack when it comes to mental processes? "Math is challenging, so I refuse to do any". "Reading books is too hard because I have to look up some of the words". Surely we can agree that challenging your mind is a good thing.

Is it impossible to find any enjoyment in challenging your body as well as mind?

socillion··on Google shares hit $1,000 after strong earnings
If you just want a map, "!map <address>" will send you to google maps with that address.
socillion··on You’re infected—if you want to see your data again, pay us $300 in Bitcoins
You can try disabling (not deleting) the startup task. Start > Run > msconfig > Startup > Disable GoogleUpdater.exe

Or try Firefox!

socillion··on Barbarians at the Gateways: High-frequency Trading and Exchange Technology
> Without such a cap it's an arms race that adds no value.

I have seen nobody ever challenge the value of liquidity in these discussions of HFT. Assuming this, the argument is that at some amount of latency the additional liquidity turns into a negative.

It seems more like the additional value is simply extremely small, but meaningful over an entire market.

What's the exact cutoff point for the value of additional liquidity turning negative, and will anyone agree on that arbitrary number?

Assuming HFT does turn into a negative at some point, wouldn't the same apply to optimizations in other markets like online advertising?

If it does apply elsewhere, we should also legislate away the practice of making online advertising more efficient to prevent tech giants like Google and Facebook from wasting billions of dollars and untold man-hours on these activities that are clearly worthless to society.

socillion··on The Octopus That Almost Ate Seattle
It may have more to do with anthropomorphizing than anything - it's much easier for an urban dweller to project human qualities onto animals like dogs, which they interact with frequently, than the slabs of pig meat they see in stores. A distaste for eating animals perceived to have more human-like qualities follows naturally from avoiding eating humans.
socillion··on How exercise boosts brain health
I find that even at 20 it's very easy for me to cause joint issues after several years of inactivity. If you do too much too fast it'll cause problems no matter your age - although I'm sure age is something that you should take into consideration.

If you're concerned, there are alternatives like swimming and biking that are lower impact.

socillion··on How exercise boosts brain health
A bit pedantic, but I'd like to defend endurance running - comparing 2 mile runs to really pushing yourself with HIIT is unfair. At 5mph (a slow pace) that's only 24 minutes, which is usually not enough time to even experience a runner's high and about when you get settled into a rhythm as a distance runner.

If you only have 30 minutes you're indisputably better off sprinting.

socillion··on How Bolivian Farmers Made the World Crave Quinoa
A negative externality is the cost borne by parties unrelated to the transaction. In this debate, that party is the environment. I'm confused by your usage of the term.

According to your argument, buying organic food is worse for the environment than buying non-organic food because it costs more. Likewise, buying hydroelectric power would be worse for the environment (have more negative externalities) than buying coal power if it cost more. Do you dispute the logic of this extension of your argument?

socillion··on How Bolivian Farmers Made the World Crave Quinoa
Your "bratwurst vs quinoa" argument makes the assumption that negative externalities per dollar is constant, therefore negative externalities can be measured by dollars spent.

You later disprove this assumption yourself when describing how local goods can have fewer negative externalities than those imported from across the globe.

socillion··on Valve demonstrates Steam Controller [video]
> obviously it's not for competitive players.

Yep, I just wanted to explain why it isn't :) Having to click rather than press a key is a big downside, but if I remember correctly SC2 already has a keybind mode that limits you to a subset of the full qwerty keyboard. World of Warcraft is a good example of a PC game that uses a huge swathe of keyboard, players often have 30-60 unique keybinds.

My point about the 180 was that you need a wide range of different motions. Sometimes it'll be 170, sometimes 145, etc, sometimes only 2.4 degrees, and if a mouse user uses 1 swipe when you need 2 or 3 you're toast. A common tactic for Scouts in TF2 is to stay in the air above your head, which from experience is basically impossible to beat on a trackpad.

I'm looking forward to the Steambox/Steam controller, if only because I have quite a few Steam games accumulated and the biggest reason for me to avoid consoles is that I'd be forced to buy multiple copies of games.

socillion··on Valve demonstrates Steam Controller [video]
There would be two disadvantages compared to traditional mouse-and-keyboard: 1) a low number of total possible bindings, and 2) a lower range of possible movements compared to a mouse.

1) is straightforward, if you don't have enough input buttons you're out of luck. A problem for games like SC2 and WoW.

2) this problem forces you to use acceleration for input, which is commonly accepted to ruin precision (reproducibility) because you lose the easy mapping between inches and pixels.

I'll use Team Fortress 2 (an FPS) as an example for this. First, if 180 degrees takes more than 1 swipe, the controls are effectively unusable. The demonstration indicates this may be the case.

You need to be able to flip 180 degrees to check your back, as well as make other large and fast movements like those required by rocket jumping. At the same time, you also need the ability to make very small aim adjustments. It's guaranteed that the trackpad will be weak somewhere along this variety of movements.

It's unsurprising that it will be a poor replacement for mouse and keyboard, but existing controllers have demonstrated that people are fine with sacrificing resolution of controls for other advantages like relative simplicity and easily playing with friends.

socillion··on Our Logo Looks Like Underpants: A Case Study in Internationalization
https://i.imgur.com/cLG7L5u.png

1366x768 screen resolution, same position on Chrome and Firefox.

Resizing the window and reverting to full screen again results in this:

https://i.imgur.com/zkK85tN.png

Which is below the original fold.

socillion··on How Lavabit Melted Down
Being legally bound to give up the information is equivalent to being forced. If it wasn't forcible, why did Lavabit have to choose between compliance and shutting down?

Could you clarify what you mean by "How was it a handwave if it actually worked?" Lavabit, like Hushmail, has had no problem giving up information to law enforcement in the past.

socillion··on There's a .00006% Chance of Building a Billion Dollar Company
Your conclusion does not follow from the premise. Couldn't the experience gained from starting the first 5 result in a greater chance of "success"? If failure is defined as anything less than 1 billion, it is particularly meaningless as an indicator of future success.
socillion··on iOS 7 “activation required” error on iPhone and iPad
I wonder if the large amount of regular users who jump at the chance to join a beta has anything to do with the severe dilution of the term. These days a product labeled as beta is very likely to be using that to imply a degree of exclusivity or simply to emphasize that it is the absolute latest, rather than it being unfinished. Beta access for video games is extremely desirable, Google has made the term completely meaningless with products like Gmail, etc.

When beta is so frequently a good thing, who wouldn't want to get the latest iOS and tell all their friends about how awesome it is?

Just some thoughts, but I'm feeling deja vu while writing this post - I suspect the topic has been beaten to death in the past.

edit: indeed it has, here is a discussion from when iOS5 was released: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2649222

socillion··on Mugged by a Mug Shot Online
> Several legal experts interviewed for this article said seeking money to remove mug shots from the Internet does not qualify as a crime such as extortion, since extortion requires a threat ahead of time to post the image unless the mug shot subject pays.

> "Wow - it does seem to come pretty close to the line," Robert Weisberg, co-director of the Stanford Criminal Justice Center, said upon learning about such sites. "I'd say it skirts the line but may stop just short. (It) depends on how a reasonable person would perceive this in terms of fear."

Source: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/20/net-us-usa-interne...

socillion··on The Best Part of Grand Theft Auto V is the Stock-Trading Platform
I think there are far better games for market PvP such as EVE Online, Guild Wars, or Kingdom of Loathing. Making profit on the WoW AH was very formulaic (refining raw materials into the largest variety of items possible to maximize turnover - see JC shuffle), the best route was to find botters who would sell raw materials to you below market rates, and the huge number of shards made markets much less interesting.

Every action also required far too much clicking, which meant many people just used tools like autohotkey (cheats, although nobody ever got banned for them), and having to relist products constantly to beat minor undercuts was a terrible experience.

WoW AH is to virtual markets what hitting a pinata is to hitting something that fights back - it's simplicity makes it unrewarding.

socillion··on Google Has Spent $21 Billion on Data Centers
Google had a 5 minute outage this August, where global internet traffic dropped by 40%.

http://www.fastcompany.com/3015942/most-innovative-companies...

socillion··on Why I Play Video Games
As far as benefits from playing action video games go, improved vision is only a small part. Many other spatial skills benefit.

1. http://www.polygon.com/2013/1/30/3932876/research-playing-fi...

2. https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=site:rochester.edu+act...

3. http://www.researchgate.net/publication/228091955_Video_Game...

socillion··on New NSA Leak Shows MITM Attacks Against Major Internet Services
Great tip! It's not exactly what you laid out, but here's the interview you're probably thinking of (ctrl+f verisign): http://wikileaks.org/Transcript-Meeting-Assange-Schmidt

Quoting Julian Assange: I have been told actually that VeriSign... has actually given keys to the US government. Not all, but a particular key.

Very interesting.

socillion··on FBI Admits It Controlled Tor Servers Behind Mass Malware Attack
Sabu had his identity compromised for a few reasons:

1) Old whois info with his real name on a domain (prvt.org) that he linked on IRC. He had long since changed it but someone looked it up.

2) Mistakenly logging into IRC without a VPN/Tor.

More: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/03/doxed-how-sabu-wa...

socillion··on Ask HN: What will happen when everybody uses an ad blocker?
Twitch.tv, a live streaming site, has Adblock rates of around 60% (unclear if that just means 40% fill rate) due to the obtrusiveness and frequent over-use of ads by streamers.

The Starcraft website Team Liquid also has around a 60% block rate despite actively encouraging people to disable Adblock on their site and having very minimal advertising.

Sources:

A League of Legends team manager on Twitch.tv Adblock rates: http://www.reddit.com/r/starcraft/comments/1ewq95/totalbiscu...

And a Team Liquid admin: http://www.reddit.com/r/starcraft/comments/1ewq95/totalbiscu...

socillion··on AT&T gives DEA 26 years of phone call records to wage war on drugs
The DEA uses "administrative subpoenas", which they are allowed to unilaterally issue for anything relevant to an investigation.

Here's an older article on them: http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/08/administrative-subp...

socillion··on Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests
Replying to your first point, here's the relevant law (FAA 702): http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1881a
socillion··on Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests
It is a fact that they don't need individual court orders to obtain communications.

As to "obtaining targeted communications without having to request them from the service providers", here's a quote by Gellman:

> In another classified report obtained by The Post, the arrangement is described as allowing “collection managers [to send] content tasking instructions directly to equipment installed at company-controlled locations,” rather than directly to company servers.

Regardless of whether it is actually accurate, that is what the NSA documents stated.

I think the whole "direct access" argument over semantics is a red herring and completely irrelevant by now.

socillion··on Microsoft and Google to sue over US surveillance requests
"Direct access" was taken directly from the slides but misunderstood as editorializing by Greenwald.

http://littlegreenfootballs.com/article/42134_Greenwald-_We_...

socillion··on CIA is largest US spy agency, according to black budget leaked by Edward Snowden
None of what he has released qualifies him as a whistleblower, because it is classified information (which has strictly regulated ways to handle impropriety) and the activities are not illegal (ignoring tenuous Constitution arguments).
socillion··on On Lisp
PCL is also available for free at http://www.gigamonkeys.com/book/
← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →