HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sokka_h2otribe

178 karma · joined February 25, 2023

submissionscomments
sokka_h2otribe··on Stop trying to engineer your way out of listening to people
It's not based on writing they didn't read...

The feedback is to the author of the post complaining (understandably) about their manager using AI and destroying the carefully written document.

That post alone is plenty to give feedback on absolutism and the nuances of existing in the world with mostly neurotypical people. [My interpretation of the feedback]

We dont care about the manager, they don't matter. This is not "defending" or "justifying" the manager, in case you see it that way.

sokka_h2otribe··on Electric motor scaling laws and inertia in robot actuators
Another way to look at it, is that bldc motors are sort of like solenoids with the motion between between poles of the motor. There's a limit in both cases to what you can do and how much flux you can push
sokka_h2otribe··on DHS Contracts Explorer – Hacked data from the Office of Industry Partnership
You too were inspired by the children's light up shoes? I know I was
sokka_h2otribe··on Can a wealthy family change the course of a deadly brain disease?
Uhh, you know you could skip the vaccine and just call it a tax..
sokka_h2otribe··on Show HN: I reverse-engineered car lease math against three real dealer documents
I got halfway through. I'm tired of AI writing sometimes here. <<That's what most calculators get wrong>>. Not, that's $11, it's NOT very significant.

AI slop ATM seems to indicate heavy importance on all your sentences, but not all of your sentences are that important. It makes it harder for me to skim personally, and ultimately, it's harder to edit because it "sounds" ok as it is (even when it's not.)

But, in my experience, the AI writing slop [negative experience] is everywhere here.

sokka_h2otribe··on Show HN: I spent 3 years reverse-engineering a 40 yo stock market sim from 1986
I honestly think you're wildly missing the point.

Writing is not about writing. Admittedly, that is a trick sentence [what does it mean??] and it exists because I'm trying to get you to re-evaluate my next words. And, I am doing this because I think you are missing the point.

Writing is about organizing your thoughts. You cannot have someone else organize your thoughts. Once you approach writing as a thought excercise, and not an output excercise, then there is a world of nuance and writing is more than just organizing your thoughts.

Further, you have allegedly spent 3 years on this. I know you're busy. That said, you can certainly spend 3 days on writing if you spent 3 years working on this.

Please don't double down on acting like everyone is just a hater. There is more depth to the criticism than I think is being acknowledged.

P.s, if you feel "blocked" writing and think of it as just about output, try this: (0) Ask yourself what you want to convey, why; to whom. (1) Write without inhibition (2) Edit, cut, delete. Refer to (0); look at what seems higher word count in proportion to its value.

There are other tips to editing and writing. This is one rough off the cuff formula that I think tracks & may benefit you, especially since you seem to see yourself as a worse writer than you may actually be.

sokka_h2otribe··on Show HN: I spent 3 years reverse-engineering a 40 yo stock market sim from 1986
It has nothing to do with missing "coauthored by Claude"

The problem is you're wasting other people's time, with long and low quality writing.

One of the points of writing your own words is to gather your own thoughts. The value of writing skills is to organize the delivery. But the first point is that they are your thoughts.

I think your replies are seriously missing the criticism.

sokka_h2otribe··on A party balloon shut down El Paso International Airport; estimated cost –$573k
The problem with that attitude is it normalizes it, which is extra scary for military
sokka_h2otribe··on Skip the Tips: A game to select "No Tip" but dark patterns try to stop you
I think the procedure is being misinterpreted. This isn't a scam, it's just a common social convention. It's not a scam by the waiter because they have a limited amount they can do this for and they have just chosen to do it for you.
sokka_h2otribe··on Pretty soon, heat pumps will be able to store and distribute heat as needed
To whatever degree you are serious, this can be a phase change thing.

Cheese melting takes energy Cheese freezing, releases energy.

So you do actually get the temperature to remain at the melting point of the cheese for a longer period of time if you have enough % cheese to be significant.

sokka_h2otribe··on Surely the crash of the US economy has to be soon
Refinancing and loans work differently outside of the U.S. what I don't remember is exactly how. If I recall, you can't refinance without paying
sokka_h2otribe··on Wisconsin communities signed secrecy deals for billion-dollar data centers
Arguably, an 800 person town is likely quite far from most.
sokka_h2otribe··on ManusAI Joins Meta
Op is saying it sounds like it was written like an LLM
sokka_h2otribe··on Well being in times of algorithms
How are you disagreeing? I think your point is separate?

Poster above is making a claim about what brings us into our body-experiences, or what takes us out. Technically mostly noting that technology takes us out of the somatic experience.

Accessibility? Meditation apps? There are things with technology that allow us to be more connected with each other and ourselves in some ways. But not really to the somatic experience of their body, the world around them.

Generally if I understand OP correctly, I strongly agree. As a techie it took me a long time to understand the somatic experience as the missing part to my world view and thinking.

sokka_h2otribe··on A train-sized tunnel is now carrying electricity under South London
Some good reasons:

-gotta hang them somehow, and in a very controlled way.

-thermal expansion, very important not to cause axial strain on a cable, which happens on tight bends.

You might think it would be enough to just have slack "somewhere" but I think you get to have many many micro adjustments when you have it across the entire length.

Why don't HV telephone lines do this?

I have no idea. Maybe because they can hang and droop more easily. I hope someone more knowledgeable gives a real answer.

sokka_h2otribe··on The most banned books in U.S. schools
I think it might be the literalism sometimes common with autistic spectrum. Uhm, not to cause offense, I relate to it?
sokka_h2otribe··on Using secondary school maths to demystify AI
Gambling exists more because of people dopamine systems than math...though I get the overall drift. People are fooled by politicians because ?? Also not really math related I think.
sokka_h2otribe··on After my dad died, we found the love letters
Consider finding a therapist and quality couples counselor to help you navigate the necessary rupture as you take steps towards honesty and clarity in your relationships
sokka_h2otribe··on Why don't people return their shopping carts?
So, I see 2-5 carts in the lot, and a few hundred people in the store.

You maybe are making yourself part of the 1% who don't return their cart (or my locale is better than average at returning it)

sokka_h2otribe··on A new chapter begins for EV batteries with the expiry of key LFP patents
If it's suitable for sedans it's actually more suitable for SUVs. SUVs require less power per cubic feet of space. So there is more space available for them, even if they take more energy overall
sokka_h2otribe··on A Fond Farewell
Change in the anti monopoly enforcement norms near the end of the 70s
sokka_h2otribe··on Hi, it's me, Wikipedia, and I am ready for your apology
I believe the academics concern early on was a lack of confidence in the quality. First through the sciences then outside I think wikipedia showed sufficient quality to eventually be in the good books for academia.
sokka_h2otribe··on Microwave technique allows energy-efficient chemical reactions
Large vats benefit a lot from having a better surface area to volume.

The microwave is not necessarily better at large scale, and the microwave transformer itself will have inefficiencies.

But at small scales. .yeah

sokka_h2otribe··on The link between trauma, drug use, and our search to feel better
No, it's not actually understandable to me.

I don't believe the person with PTSD of your definition benefits from gatekeeping an understanding of ptsd.

It also just flatly does not correspond to the research. Modern PTSD and cptsd concepts exist because the existing concepts didn't work, and the patients fit classic outcomes.

Put another way,

If someone was assaulted in church, maybe they had a more "real" PTSD If someone was different in their head and felt constrained at church everyday and their heart rate goes up every time they enter a church to the same degree as the assaulted persons does too....that's the outcome being similar (with some simplifications).

Trauma is the bad thing and being unable to do anything about it, and what that can do to your psyche.

People develop trauma not just because of how bad the experience was, but the circumstances before and after.

sokka_h2otribe··on Three-Minute Take-Home Test May Identify Symptoms Linked to Alzheimer's Disease
You're describing why your default aesthetic is not dark.

Dark mode however is just an accessibility concept, not really about aesthetics. For some people they work hard to make it aesthetically consistent. But honestly I think dark mode compatibility should not have to be a perfect replication

sokka_h2otribe··on Freeway guardrails are now a favorite target of thieves
Aluminum also has some long term corrosion benefits over galvanized steel especially in the context sometimes where they are attached to treated wooden posts. They use isolation these days but still not enough usually.
sokka_h2otribe··on Freeway guardrails are now a favorite target of thieves
No, it's aluminum wire actually. They are not copper
sokka_h2otribe··on John Carmack's arguments against building a custom XR OS at Meta
I admit you encouraged me to think a little more about how the person (like myself, in many ways), might feel to be called abrasive, difficult, or any other negative thing.

It makes me want to reframe this a little with your statement 'understand the person and adapt accordingly.' As someone who has learned their social skills later, I think it's usually more of a responsibility of the abrasive person to adapt their communication style and know when it is best used.

Specifically, I think abrasive and direct works great in high trust environments. It has served me well as well. It does sometimes relate to autism for me, ymmv.

Anyway the reason why it doesn't work outside of high trust environments is that people have feelings, and their feelings matter. Ultimately you do have a responsibility to try and be considerate. So like, for me I try to separate the high trust and low trust environments in my life, and keep the part of me that's direct and abrasive (often among peers in technical context) less vocal in the low trust environment.

When I intentionally want to push back in a low trust environment, I try to check in more with the person, look to where they seem uncomfortable, and double check I understand what their insecurities might be in a certain context as that often increases defensiveness.

Sometimes in low trust environments I might not notice, or I might identify it as low trust and just not care. In those contexts yeah I'll be the disgruntled aspie ;) but in other contexts I want to connect to people and really think through the impact of my words not the righteousness.

sokka_h2otribe··on Standard Thermal: Energy Storage 500x Cheaper Than Batteries
Uhh, I think a big reason why solar thermal is more meh these days is that solar panels are so cheap and heat pumps are reasonable
sokka_h2otribe··on 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC
I think they're saying that 4chan is not responding bc there is limited people at the helm, not that the UK gov is upset at their security.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →