Biology is one of very few areas of science where you do just find free lunches sometimes. Human bodies are adapted to environments with harsh constraints about injuries, pathogens, temperature, energy usage, etc. The only catch to counteracting those adaptations is that it makes you worse at being a hunter-gatherer.
Generating reports that are rarely read and almost always ignored seems like a great use case for AI. Performance reviewing is de facto zero-sum - once you've ranked the people in your bailiwick, there's no reason not to let the incentives you're subject to do the rest of the work.
Draw up the product roadmap such that you can claim maximum AI-ness while including as little of it as possible in the actual product. Sounds like the CEO doesn't have any technical objections to not using AI, he just wants the ability to raise on AI branding.
Include as much non-AI work as you can in the AI teams' projects, pitch an "AI efficiency initiative" that minimizes new spend on AI with the justification of other teams picking up the slack, talk up whatever ML you're already doing, etc.
Layoffs in particular are like this because they're planned very quickly by very small groups of people. Rumors of impending layoffs obliterate morale, so the people in charge do everything they can to maintain secrecy and minimize the time between people hearing about layoffs and the layoffs taking effect. This basically always translates to random-seeming decisions - priority 1 is to cut costs by X amount, choosing the right people to cut is secondary. This means that, for example, engineers that have received performance-based raises are punished since, on paper, they do the same job as lower-performing but lower-paid engineers.
Not defending the process(the right way to break this equilibrium is statutory requirements for layoffs a la the WARN act) but that's why you see the outcomes you do.
Depends on the time horizon you choose. If you look at US stats, we're only 1.5 suicides per 100000 people above a previous post-WWII peak in the early 80s. Suicide rates in the first half of the 20th century were downright apocalyptic by modern standards, sometimes reaching 22 per 100000 before sharply declining post-WWII. If you want to look outside the US, Japan used to(~2000-~2010) hover at ~20 suicides per 100000, compared to our current all-time high of 14.
The increase is significant, but I wouldn't call it definitive proof of an urgent crisis.
Journalist salaries, especially at prestigious piblications, are quite famously set such that only people who can rely on external support to the tune of 5-6 figures a year can become journalists. It makes sense that the journalists union would prioritize things other than salary in bargaining - their W2 job isn't where their money comes from.
But are they using it for anything else? Even GPT-2 was "good enough" for high school writing assignments. The fact that this power user class of young people hasn't found any other use cases for LLMs despite vast improvements in LLM capability doesn't reflect well on the merits of LLMs as consumer software.
Sure, AI represents a substantial improvement over other heuristic methods in some areas. But that's a long way down from the "AI is going to be a permanent fixture in most people's day to day lives" claim that the tech industry is betting the farm on right now.
> I can't think of a single recent technology that was so widely adopted by tech and non-tech people alike, immediately integrated into day-to-day experience.
I've heard this asserted sometimes, and I just don't think it's true. ChatGPT's use cases as consumer software were discovered basically immediately after GPT 3 came out, and nothing new has really emerged since then. It's great for automating high school/undergrad B-quality writing and the occasional administrative email. Beyond that, it sometimes does better than 2024 Google(though probably still worse than 2019 Google) on knowledge questions.
ChatGPT is software. The barrier to entry is almost zero, and the tech industry has had decades of practice in enticing people into walled gardens and making sure they can never leave. If it's not completely taken over the world in the time it's had, I wouldn't bet on it doing so without a massive jump in capability or accuracy.
Seems like this article is putting the cart before the horse - what recent breakthroughs have there been to justify saying that we're entering some new era of neuroscience, or that AI has anything to do with that new era?
Hypothetically, if the yeast could work fast enough(I'm 99% sure it can't unless he's leaving the mixture in a sealed container for a few months before drinking it) wouldn't this result in straight vinegar
I have really awful genetics for drinking(I'm 23 and already experience the thing you're describing with taking multiple days to feel good again, and instead of physical symptoms I get crushing depression) so I'd love to just take some of this stuff before a night out to drink the same volume as other people without having to deal with the aftereffects.
This is dependent on a world where immortality is expensive because it's difficult to actually make someone immortal rather than because it's difficult to figure out how to make someone immortal. For all we know, immortality is as simple as a one-time injection into an egg cell, and the challenge is almost entirely in figuring out what to inject.
Also, how much is the death of bad individuals actually contributing to making the world a better place? It seems to me like the various abuses of robber-barons and tyrants past and present are perpetuated by institutions built around them rather than their own personal capacity to affect the world. A king in exile on a remote island or a Rockefeller driven to bankruptcy can remain unchanged as a person while losing virtually all of their capacity to impose their will on the world, while a kingdom or corporation can keep going centuries after the death of its leader if conditions stay favorable.
I'm not sure I've ever seen a self checkout removed, even in downtown Seattle locations where everything's been locked up and security is patrolling every floor. I've seen increased surveillance and scare tactics at self checkouts but I think costco is just about the only major store left that hasn't pushed people into using almost exclusively self checkout.
If this was the universal(or even most common) outcome of people organizing against sources of suffering in their lives, we'd still be living in stone age city states. The process you describe has time and again led to net-positive outcomes. "It has to work 100% of the time or it's not worth doing" isn't a standard we apply anywhere else.
An increasing number of people being unproductive doesn't rule out an increase in total production. It does suggest that for those whose jobs are now obsolete, there is increasingly no alternative to subsidizing their entire existence. We've kept pace so far, but a majority of people being in a situation where their labor is worthless is a huge potential societal fault line.
Past technological breakthroughs have required large, costly retools of society though. Increasingly, those retools have resulted in more and more people working in jobs whose societal value is dubious at best. Whether the next breakthrough(or the next five) finally requires a retool whose cost we can't afford is an open question.
I think the reason they don't is because the overlap between users with the general internet savvy to use an ad blocker and users who have the general internet savvy to literally never pay attention to or click on ads is pretty high. It's sort of the same problem reddit had -- There's just no way to monetize users like this other than locking the entire service behind a paywall for everyone, shutting out the much more lucrative remainder of your customer base.
Though it was far less clear when this article was written than it is now, if you're starting from scratch on a webapp today it's hard to go wrong with React.
You only need to generate a single patentable refinement once every twenty years. In a lot of places, this is a horrible pace relative to the organic rate of progress. Compare the progress made since the main patents for FDM 3D printing expired compared to the progress made while it was still under patent.
I think a more appropriate conclusion to draw is that big leaps in automation required huge, costly reorganizations of society to ensure enough people have jobs to avoid civil unrest, increasingly in ways that were dubiously productive compared to, say, directly providing for the people whose labor had suddenly become worthless. Whether the next big leap(or, for that matter, the next two or five big leaps) will finally require a retool whose cost we can't afford is very much an open question.
A lot of it seems to be the machinery behind the Chesa Boudin recall taking on a life of its own by tapping into a previously-unknown donor base for right-wing causes in California.
> Word traveled, and he discovered that new jobs would only hire him with longer vesting schedules and sign-on bonuses that had to be paid back if he left before 2-3 years.
I've occasionally heard anecdotes like this but I have a hard time imagining how this kind of thing ever happens outside of very small population centers with less than ten tech employers. Unless he's some kind of executive where huge amounts of resources are devoted specifically to vetting and networking is the interview process, what incentive is there for people in charge of hiring to share such granular info with one another? Is everyone in charge of hiring at major tech companies just in a big whatsapp group exchanging dirt on employees they didn't like?
They're exaggerating the efficacy of their technology, and are demanding a regulatory moat that currently doesn't exist under the pretext of the danger of that technology being misused. Notice the singular focus on "extinction risk" rather than flaws that the technology actually has right now, like hallucination, training bias, and prompt injection or the looming harm of AI adoption in both putting people out of work while substantially reducing the quality of anything automated with it. Part of it is marketing and part of it is ego on the part of people who grew up on fictional narratives about AI destroying the world and want to feel like they wield the power to make it do that, but whether any individual's belief is sincere or not, the overall push is a product of the massive incentives everyone involved in AI has to promote their product and entrench their market position.
Researchers aren't immune to the incentives the rest of the field has. They're every bit as financially incentivized to push the AI risk narrative as the rest of the industry.
This is ignoring the fact that the material basis for the 15 minute city people's complaints and the complaints of, for example, privacy advocates are not only completely different but irreconcilable. The right-wing complaints come from a wealthy, usually retired, small business/property-owning class threatened by the march of global capital consolidating away their footholds into economic growth and placing them or their children in the same bucket as the disgusting poors they've spent their entire lives campaigning to immiserate. They aren't mad about the fact that the systems of repression they're protesting against exist, they're mad that the systems want used against undesirables might be turned against them.
The surface-level rhetoric sounds vaguely similar, but look under the surface and you'll find that the people behind opposition to global capital from the right have less in common with the people who oppose it from the left than with their supposed shared enemy.