HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

somesortofthing

620 karma · joined September 30, 2020

submissionscomments
somesortofthing··on War Is a Racket (1935)
A unipolar world order is a local optimum by its very nature. Regardless of who's in charge, conflict arises from parties thinking they have a chance to secure leverage against another power via violence. If there's a sole power with an overwhelming military advantage against their next-largest competitor, people aren't going to go off and die in hopeless wars. Russia and China's actions can't be separated from the fact that their existence in anything like their present form is a challenge to the US and its sphere of influence.

Even then, the US government and economy is organized in ways that make it disturb the trivial-to-maintain peace its position as hegemon affords it(see Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos, and various covert operations that succeeded before escalating to direct intervention) to secure itself minor advantages or even for entirely domestic reasons.

If you account at all for the inherent advantages of a unipolar world, the US's record is shockingly poor. I'm fine with rolling the dice on multipolarity in hopes of a less irrational hegemon emerging.

somesortofthing··on Sam Altman isn’t the answer to regulating artificial intelligence
Maybe he sincerely believes the line OpenAI's PR department is pushing, but that's an even better reason not to listen to him.
somesortofthing··on Fairbuds XL review: noise-cancelling headphones you can fix
I'm in the same boat. I got all the way to the checkout page before realizing that they won't ship to the US. Seriously considering buying these and asking a friend in the EU to ship them to me in hopes of them making spare parts available in the US before I break anything. Probably won't do it, but I've been waiting for years for a pair of bluetooth headphones that I don't have to constantly worry about breaking.
somesortofthing··on Palantir seeing 'unprecedented' demand for its military AI
To be honest, I trust the CCP to have my best interests at heart more than I do tech executives. One side is driven by straightforward, predictable self-interest while the other has spent the past decade looking for elixirs of immortality and trying to replace what little is left of our society and institutions with subscription services and payments platforms. I'd rather be ruled by Xi than Peter Thiel.
somesortofthing··on Don't believe the hype: why ChatGPT is not the “holy grail” of AI research
The difference here is that steam engines were "less powerful than a horse" in an easily quantifiable, easily diagnosable way. They produced fewer newtons of force. You could tell this was the case because your mechanism just wouldn't move when you wanted it to. Most new technologies followed this pattern, they quantifiably underperformed alternatives until the field matured. But AI doesn't act like a dumb human who's missing information or is inept at the task presented to them. It doesn't refuse to answer if you give it a question that's too hard for it or requires info that it doesn't have in the training dataset, it confidently makes stuff up and then covers up for the fact that it made stuff up by burying it in marketing copy and extraneous info such that you need to be an expert in the topic you're using AI for to even tell that it failed. Better AI models do help with this, but they simultaneously improve the AI's obfuscation abilities to the point where fatal flaws in its output are going to be even harder to catch than they are now with human review. It doesn't have the same risk calculus as a human, it doesn't care whether the marketing copy you're writing describes your product as wonderful and perfect or if it's providing you completely bogus legal advice that'll land you in jail for a decade if you follow it.

And this is all before we even bring up the topic of prompt injection, a problem so intrinsic to the technology that OpenAI doesn't even take bug reports on it because bug reports "are for problems that can be fixed".

somesortofthing··on Speech is violence? Not if we want a liberal, intellectual society
> Then you should defeat them in the marketplace of ideas and be able to counter their facillous words. To suggest otherwise is to stand in a position where you claim that some people are incapable of intelligently reasoning about something and that another superior individual should be able to police what they hear.

How do I defeat someone "in the marketplace of ideas" when the person inciting violence is backed by a multi-billion dollar media conglomerate, an undemocratic government, or a police union/sheriff gang?

> If someone says racist hateful things you're argument is that people should not be allowed to listen to it because it is a "bad thing" and other people who aren't as wise as you shoudlnt be allowed to hear it because they might act violently.

It's not about being "wise", it's about incentives. Plenty of people directly and benefit from violence against marginalized groups, and it's in their interest to accept and encourage the normalization of violence against those groups. Media provocateurs have an impeccable sense of what they need to say and what ideas they're communicating when they speak. Plausibly deniable provocation works so well precisely because the target audience understand the real message perfectly.

somesortofthing··on Speech is violence? Not if we want a liberal, intellectual society
I think this article makes a key mistake that I see almost all commentators make of visions of free speech less radical than, say, the first amendment: They consider only the direct effects of speech on those who hear it. If you accept this, it's very easy to(correctly) respond that it's not the state's job to police mere offense, no matter how grave it may be. Some people who try to make criticisms of a radical free speech regime(such as the NYT author this article mentions) also fall into this trap, but I think the much more compelling for limiting speech is less about harm done by speech to listeners and more about incitement of physical harm.

It's very, very easy to communicate in ways that encourage and incite violence(be it direct physical violence or denial of the means to live a dignified life), especially against groups against whom such violence is already normalized. Not all speech that does incite violence is intended to, but this fact also lends plausible deniability to people who do explicitly want violence but know that it's socially unacceptable to call for it directly. There is the danger of being overzealous with what speech to limit, but at the same time, it's undeniable that a lot of money and attention is flowing to ever-bolder provocateurs whose only possible goal is to escalate existing tensions and iniquities to violence in service of their political aims. Taking such people at their word on their intentions is dangerous, and those who do so have no right to act surprised and claim innocence when actions and rhetoric escalate past the point they're comfortable with.

somesortofthing··on USCO tells judge that art created without human involvement is not protectable
What is the actual ruling here? Is it that the work can't be protected by copyright at all "because no human was involved in its creation" or just that copyright can't be assigned to the model itself? The headline implies it's the former, then the article itself implies it's the latter, and then you get this segment that implies the former presented as making a case for the latter:

> The Copyright Office says that it “turns on a single question: Did the Office act reasonably and consistently with the law when it refused to extend copyright protection to a visual work the plaintiff represented was created without any human involvement? The answer is yes.”

This article is really poorly written. I guess they wanted the flashy headline?

somesortofthing··on Loyal to the Company
Loyalty in general can be thought of as a line of credit for employers and employees to informally "borrow" from each other to smooth things over. Explicitly enumerating all of a given job's duties in an employment agreement is functionally impossible, and a key part of what people mean by an employee's "loyalty" to a company is that willingness to go slightly outside of their expected duties. Meanwhile, a company's "loyalty" is willingness to tolerate downturns in returns on a given employee and protect employees' jobs even when doing so might cost them in the short term. A company's "loyalty" might take the form not punishing an employee for being unproductive for some time after a family tragedy or keeping employees on the payroll during an economic downturn even if that might cost them.

If you want to completely get rid of that, even the slightest imperfection in designing the bounds of a given employee's duties is going to result in whatever processes that person relies for grinding to a halt and everyone being trapped in a constant run-around of "That's not my job".

That said, given that companies have been increasingly unwilling to extend even the most basic loyalty to its employees, the right move for workers is to become more transactional. Normally, the accrued "credit" gained through loyalty might dissuade you from switching jobs even if you get a nominally better offer, but if that's no longer a factor, workers have no reason to hesitate about just looking at the bottom line on their employment agreement. This might be damaging to the broader economy since job hopping has considerable productivity costs, but on the individual level, it's the clear right choice.

somesortofthing··on Impossible Foods Plans to Lay Off About 20% of Workers
Maybe they're capturing a rising share of a shrinking market? A 50% increase under these conditions still does sound suspicious though.
somesortofthing··on Social media may prevent users from reaping creative rewards of profound boredom
These things are all possible in iMessage. Is iMessage social media?
somesortofthing··on FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried to be released on $250M bail
> A recognizance bond is a written commitment from the accused to appear in court when ordered. In return, Bankman-Fried’s camp would not be required to meet the full collateral requirements on the bail.

Doesn't look like that's what's happening. It's not clear how much money's changing hands, but it's definitely nowhere near the full $250m.

somesortofthing··on Handwritten complaint to the court by alleged CIA Vault 7 leaker
This is what decades of two parties trying to outdo each other on being "tough on crime" looks like. These punishments do act as a deterrent to whistleblowing but that's not really why they were instituted in the first place. Prisoners are a really easy demographic to throw under the bus for political gain(not like they can vote) so you get these sorts of barbaric conditions for an ever increasing subsection of the prison population.
somesortofthing··on Why is Booz Allen renting us back our own national parks?
> If Healthcare.gov bombed... whose head rolled?

Is your claim here that corporations are able to correctly assign responsibility for major failures? Why do you think this? There are so many ways to deflect blame for your failures onto others while taking full credit for successes you had nothing to do with in the private sector.

somesortofthing··on The Voyage of Life
> Suffering, even pain, are like the opposite side of the same coin. You can’t have one without the other, so when facing struggles, try to view it as such; the necessary component in a fulfilling life.

This is true to some limited extent, but it seems wrong to think of the distinction between happiness is suffering as entirely or even mostly about contrast.

For example, consider a person who has, through some combination of disability, misfortune, and the malice of others, never had any positive moments in their entire life. If you had the power to do so, would it be unnecessary to help them out of their situation? After all, they have no happy memories to contrast their situation against. If you can't guarantee that they won't return to their previous situation, a contrast-based view implies that you would actually be doing harm by putting their past and future suffering into perspective.

When you have no say over what happens to you, contrasting a painful present with a pleasant past is a valuable coping mechanism, but it's also important to not justify suffering(especially the suffering of others) on such grounds in general terms.

To be clear, I'm not accusing you of doing that, just talking about what I've heard from other people on the topic.

somesortofthing··on Why it’s hard to buy deodorant in Manhattan
And dozens of people have been spared serious injuries or mysterious "deaths in custody" as a result. Maybe you'd prefer some deodorant to that, but I don't.
somesortofthing··on Why it’s hard to buy deodorant in Manhattan
If you want law enforcement to deal with petty crimes, you're going to have to contend with the externalities of cops operating anywhere. How many bystanders and innocent people reported by paranoid suburbanites are you willing to see injured or killed to protect that deodorant shelf?
somesortofthing··on You can fire 80% of software engineers and the company will survive
I read the article, and my main takeaway was that the author massively downplays what "survival mode" practically means for the company/product. It doesn't just mean that engineers have to work harder or that you can't develop new products/improve existing ones. It means yearly "whoops hackers have all your emails phones and plaintext passwords now lol" data breaches. It means multi-day downtimes. It means being unable to take advantage of any market trend regardless of how big your comparative advantage is.

"Deep pockets" don't do anything on their own, especially not when no one believes in your company's ability to consistently fulfill its obligations to customers. You can hire engineers, sure, but how are you going to ramp them up when all of your engineering capacity is dedicated to keeping a small group of core services from falling over dead? How quickly can you bring people on board when you're notorious for a culture of overwork and abuse? You can borrow some money, sure, but who's going to lend to you when you're massively in debt from an LBO and you can't provide more than "long term" promises that in six months the company can actually function?

somesortofthing··on You can fire 80% of software engineers and the company will survive
This might be slightly true for a small subset of companies, but given that this is clearly about Twitter, you absolutely can't "survive" in any meaningful way. What is possible without 80% of the engineers is keeping the core services running at the current capacity, with no room for dealing with emergent issues. That's about it, and that's all Twitter has really demonstrated so far.

Forget about new products, forget about improvements to existing products, forget infrastructure work/cost optimization, forget not having major data breaches regularly, forget mitigating large-scale security vulnerabilities(i.e. log4j), forget being able to capitalize on market trends on a useful timescale, and forget about the ability to deal with situations that require more engineering capacity that your company uses on an average day.

Entering "survival mode" and keeping only enough engineering capacity on board to keep the service running on a normal day is implicitly a bet that no emergent events are going to demand more capacity from you than is needed on that normal day. The product might be standing now, but you can't do anything useful with a paralyzed company that's going to topple over the first time it faces a stiff breeze.

somesortofthing··on An Existential Threat to Doing Good Science
> We fail to acknowledge that sometimes the reaction can be just as bad, and lead to the same pathology, as the problem that initially provoked it.

I think it's interesting that you speak in such abstract terms about this. What has the American far left or center-left actually done that's as bad as, for example, the recent attempted insurrection or the stripping of rights from women and LGBT people perpetrated by the right?

> the fascists ideologues were probably certain of being "the good guys", themselves.

I've personally never heard of a political movement--left, right, or center--that considered itself the antagonist in its own narrative

somesortofthing··on For Best Results, Forget the Bonus
This sounds like it'd stop working really fast as the org grows. Low-performing/average employees will start to feel like their contribution to the pool is too small to justify additional effort while top performers will feel resentful that their work gets diluted among people who don't have as much impact.
somesortofthing··on AWS doesn't make sense for scientific computing
The author makes a convincing argument against doing this workload on on-demand instances, but what about spot instances? AWS explicitly calls out scientific computing as a major use case for scientific computing in its training/promotional materials. Given the advertised ~70-90% markdown on spot instance time, it seems like a great option compared to paying almost the same amount as the workstation but not having to pay to buy, maintain, or replace the hardware.
somesortofthing··on Ask HN: What am I supposed to do after I’m “disrupted”? Work in video and CG
> What's the difference between retelling someone's story orally, and using a printing press to make an exact replica?

But that's not what's happening. You can't "crack open" a model to find the bitmap of a piece of training data. It's not there any more than a painting you've seen is "in" your brain. A model sometimes creates things that look similar to existing pieces if it got a ton of copies of the same image, for the same reason that most people's artistic rendition of a tree is going to be more accurate than their rendition of an anteater.

The entire AI art debate is a symptom of the fact that society is structured such that labor-saving technological advancements can harm more people than they help, and it's baffling to see otherwise intelligent and ideologically similar people fixating on this single, relatively minor technology rather than the much more consequential, broader issue of the fact that automation always moves wealth into the hands of a smaller and smaller group of people.

somesortofthing··on More US Employers Are Trapping Workers in a New Form of Indentured Servitude
The issue with debt for training is the same issue as the one with all exploitative working conditions: The choice of whether or not to work somewhere is often illusory. Real people inhabit a specific area with a specific set of employers. If the only job openings that:

1. You're qualified for

2. Will hire you specifically

3. Will pay you enough to survive

4. Are within a reasonable distance from you

5. Don't have some other, even worse catch than training debt

are ones that saddle you with a life-changing amount of debt if you quit before x years, people are coerced by the fact that they need money for basic to enter this kind of working arrangement, even if they technically had a choice.

somesortofthing··on Ask HN: Why is everything a SaaS product?
Yeah this is less true than it used to be but it's a big part of how SaaS initially came to be the only game in town.
somesortofthing··on Ask HN: Why is everything a SaaS product?
One reason is that SaaS pricing is an easy way for people to "hack" corporate spending restrictions. You need accounting approval for that perpetual $10000 software license, but a $500 monthly subscription payment is totally at your discretion, even if you end up spending more of the company's money in the end.
somesortofthing··on Cloudflare's abuse policies and approach
> Think of them like a landlord (hosting) vs fire department (ddos) situation

This is kind of a ridiculous comparison. A real-world landlord is a private individual extracting rent from their tenants while a real-world fire department is a publicly funded institution with a duty to protect everyone.

Cloudflare offers both its hosting and DDOS services as a private company. They aren't morally obligated to provide anything, regardless of whether the DDOS protection is offered for free.

somesortofthing··on Robinhood lays off 23% of staff
It's hardly surprising that given breathing room, people who live in miserable poverty will spend on things they couldn't previously afford. "Man cannot live on bread alone" is a pretty old concept. As for the people who already could afford the necessities of life, why not have a bit more fun than normal?
somesortofthing··on TikTok videos leave teens thinking they have rare mental disorders (2021)
> Depression and anxiety are medical diagnoses. The other are normal emotions everyone can, should, and does experience.

Why? In what sense are they "normal"? They're unpleasant and they leave you worse off than you were before you experienced them. It's also becoming clearer that frequently experiencing them has harmful physical effects from stress responses. Over-diagnosis with depression and anxiety is bad because the treatments have such a wide array of potential side effects and limited evidence for efficacy, but it makes no sense to not categorize something as a disease just because we can't treat it.

somesortofthing··on Wild turtles age slowly, and some basically don’t age at all
> People (mostly) don't change - they (have to) die for change to happen.

How much of that is a consequence of the fact that our brains physiologically lose the ability to change over time though?

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →