HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

somethingsome

462 karma · joined June 13, 2020

Contact me at somethingsomehn@protonmail.com
submissionscomments
somethingsome··on The American vs. European Mindset on Life
> The European mindset, on the other hand, prioritizes collective well-being and ensuring a high quality of life for everyone.

Sounds completely false to me, people are not happy in general (maybe only previous generations), and even less happy are people that love their work where there is no reward, only more administrative tasks and regulations.

The skills are not there anymore, the competency neither, it is not sustainable at all..

But people like their current comfort and do not think too much what will happen next.

Taxes most of the time are used to finance some private company, disguised in fundings. Or taxes are used sustain people that don't work and never will. Someone that doesn't work in my country make 3/4 to 5/4 of someone working 100h a week. It's completely nonsense, they have absolutely no incentives to work, and people are incentived to stop working.

There are almost no working services, and functioning facilities. I really don't identify myself with that so great European mindset.

I'm maybe only one data point that should move to America, but I cannot agree about 'European mindset prioritizes collective well-being and ensuring a high quality of life for everyone'

somethingsome··on European Investment Bank to inject €70B in European tech
Honestly, in academia you have good hands too, just not every lab. As in business, you also have not so good businesses.

Giving it to academia can 10x the result, but yes research is risky, that's why it's important it is founded externally.

Companies that profited from research in academia are very happy.

Overall I agree, the current European strategy is not optimal, for both Industry and academia.

somethingsome··on Show HN: TheorIA – An Open Curated Physics Dataset (Equations,Explanations,JSON)
I like the idea of having a dataset for physics, but those entries are very basics, most of the physics happens with very complicated maths and it will be difficult to make an entry for a lot of physics.

For example, imagine the entry for the standard equation, should all the derivation and symbolic implementation done as a unique entry? It will be difficult to separate it in logical entries that reference each others, and many physical ideas are fundamentally different, leading to divergences.

I have the impression that it should be easier to just parse reference books and format each paragraph/section as an entry, and maybe build a graph. (considering the reference book as authoritative on the subject)

somethingsome··on Show HN: TheorIA – An Open Curated Physics Dataset (Equations,Explanations,JSON)
There are only 3 entries, am I correct?
somethingsome··on On thinkers and doers (2022)
I'm not sold, there are thinkers and doers in both camps..

At some levels there is no line anymore.

somethingsome··on Show HN: I’m 16 years old and working on my first startup, a study app
That's cute 30 pages a month for 5 bucks, you may be interested in ab testing depending on the study level of the students, university usually requires way more pages per month, but 15 bucks to get unlimited seems too high imo.

(and unlimited may generate for you too high costs ;))

Otherwise seems nice, will test, good luck!

somethingsome··on Show HN: Hyvector – A fast and modern SVG editor
I think you can use the XML editor in the edit menu to directly edit the SVG in inkscape
somethingsome··on Show HN: Hyvector – A fast and modern SVG editor
What's the problem with inkscape? It has some bugs, but otherwise it works quite well
somethingsome··on Propositions as Types (2014) [pdf]
Hey, do you have interesting slides/homeworks to share? I would be interested in taking a look
somethingsome··on Show HN: Visualizing web server activity using gource
It allows you to visualize your git repository in time, so that you can see the changed and created files and their interactions. A very nice project.

https://gource.io/

somethingsome··on For AI Startups, a 7-Day Work Week Isn't Enough
I'm not defending their arguments, but I think that some employees can also improve themselves on the job, it's not just the company improvement, I guess it depends on which projects, what kind of management, and the mindset of the employee.
somethingsome··on Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development
I don't see how you could justify using not challenging work with ZPD?

To be just out of the comfort zone, it should be just more challenging than the current student abilities.

Can you explain their view?

somethingsome··on Why can't HTML alone do includes?
I understand your point, but I still think it is bad from the point of view of language paradigms[1]. Iframes should have not been created in the first place.. You are changing the purpose of the language while it was not made for it.

(yes in my view I interpret includes as a basic procedure)

[1] http://www.info.ucl.ac.be/people/PVR/paradigmsDIAGRAMeng201....

somethingsome··on Why can't HTML alone do includes?
I'm not an expert on this but IMO, from a language point of view, HTML is a markup language, it 'must' have no logic or processing. It is there to structure the information not to dynamically change it. Nor even to display it nicely.

The logic is performed elsewhere. If you were to have includes directly in HTML, it means that browsers must implement logic for HTML. So it is not 'just' a parser anymore.

Imagine for example that I create an infinite loop of includes, who is responsible to limit me? How to ensure that all other browsers implement it in the same way?

What happens if I perform an injection from another website? Then we start to have cors policy management to write. (iframes were bad for this)

Now imagine using Javascript I inject an include somewhere, should the website reload in some way? So we have a dynamic DOM in HTML?

somethingsome··on You Wouldn't Download a Hacker News
Hey I never actually tried lobsters, do you mind if I ask an invite?
somethingsome··on Gaussian Splatting Meets ROS2
Il very curious of that.. My mean training with ~25-30 high quality cameras takes around 20 minutes and some Gb of memory on a single GPU, what is the size of your large scale scenes? I see many possible optimizations to lower that number of Gb and time
somethingsome··on Performance optimization is hard because it's fundamentally a brute-force task
I teach my students to make a tree of the promising optimizations and suboptimization (it can be rough), keep track of each interesting optimizations, then implement the branch that seems the more promising and at each step use the profiler massively, memory bound, compute bound, latency bound, number of flops, cache accesses, etc..

After narrowing the smallest leaf, think about another branch and if some optimizations studied could lead to nice results there too.

With time they learn which branch is more promising and which optimizations are good beforehand with their problem.

I guess this could be called branch and bound with memoization instead of brute force aha.

Note: we write code in cuda

somethingsome··on Why Momentum Works (2017)
In a more philosophical matter, why there need to be a why? Does the full universe need to be causal? Are we biased to think that there always must be a why?

In Feynman lectures there is a very nice way of describing what is energy, if you like this kind of things it's also a big question ;)

Note:I think the why is important to explore, but I'm unsure there is always something more complex than 'otherwise the universe would collapse or be completely different' it may be that some more fundamental axiom, that I'm unaware of, leads to inertia in such a way that the universe is coherent

somethingsome··on Why Momentum Works (2017)
A rough idea and simplification:

Suppose you have a bunch of 2D points, without coordinates, they exist because you say so, they can represent anything you want.

But you can't do a lot with those points, you may be interested in knowing their distances. To do that, you create some reference system, i.e. 2 non parallel axis and you set a unit on each, for example one could have one centimeter and the other one meter.

Now by placing the reference system on one particular point for example, you can 'identify' each other point on that scale.

With this correspondance, you can uniquely map each point to a coordinate and each coordinate to a point in space, this allows you to measure distances for example.

Notice that the choosen coordinates didn't really matter nor the direction of the axis. But as the rest of the 2D world can be mapped to them, everything is coherent.

Now if you create a novel axis system with another initial point and both axis with 1cm on each, you can find a transformation that transform your first system into the second, this transformation allows you to transform any other point in the new coordinates system.

So what is a position exactly? I would say it's the identification of some objects by an arbitrarly chosen referential system. What are the numbers? They corresponds to an arbitrary chosen unit of measure.

I hope this will give you more tought matter :)

somethingsome··on Show HN: Flowcode – Turing-complete visual programming platform
I went to the Enso website, but it looked like spam, so I left
somethingsome··on Show HN: Flowcode – Turing-complete visual programming platform
That reminds me of a very beautiful flow based language years ago, Luna-Lang[1] but it seems that the website died and it is no longer maintained.

[1] https://github.com/binary132/luna

somethingsome··on Paper2Code: Automating Code Generation from Scientific Papers
I would love that, I mostly work with ideas and the codes are implementation details for me, so yes, in some way, having automated code generation would allow me to be way more productive. I'm not against it, I'm just scared about the efficiency of the approach by an LLM (at the moment at least)

The example codes they give is 'implementing deep learning papers', I find those papers the easiest to implement compared to some obscure algorithm for example that can't rely on frameworks such as pytorch and where speed is critical.

I can't find the essay, but I think it was wolfram that wrote that we should let students use Mathematica and educate them in using it from a young age, the rationale behind is: before you had to use logarithmic tables, and it took much time during the education. Then, with the event of the calculator, students could instantaneously compute logarithms, so they could focus on more advanced ideas that use them. With Mathematica they could automatically execute matrix operations, so they would spend most of the time thinking about matrix operations instead of just learning how to manipulate a matrix by hand.

So with more powerful tools, you can expand the capabilities faster.

But the main difference I see here, is that maths are precise and well defined. Here you get a software which is a sample in the space of possible softwares that solve the problem (if you are lucky).

To get to the metaphorical point punchcards->GHC you need a LLM tool that give always the same answer, and hopefully, the optimal one, and with small changes in the paper, it moves the software in the space of viable softwares only a bit. Maybe we will get there, but this is not yet what this paper proposes

somethingsome··on Paper2Code: Automating Code Generation from Scientific Papers
Very interesting, do you have a specific approach to educate them in how to use LLMs? Or they do it free wheel? Do you give advices? If so which kind?

I would love to have a structured approach to help students learn to use better LLMs. What I have observed (for uni students) is that they produce better code overall, but have no idea how it works, and would not be able to reproduce it without LLMs. (this is from first to last year)

somethingsome··on Paper2Code: Automating Code Generation from Scientific Papers
Can you give more details? I'm curious
somethingsome··on Paper2Code: Automating Code Generation from Scientific Papers
I like the idea of having automatic code creation from papers, but I’m scared of it.

Suppose you get a paper, you automatically implement the code, and then modify it a bit with a novel idea, and publish your paper. Then somebody else does that with your paper, and does the same.. at some point, we will have a huge quantity of vibe coded code on github, and two similar papers will have very different underlying implementations, so hard to reason about and hard to change.

From a learning perspective, you try to understand the code, and it's all spaghetti, and you loose more time understanding the code than it would take to just reimplement it. You also learn a lot by not only reading the paper but reading the authors code where most of the small details reside.

And I'm not even talking about the reliability of the code, test to know that it's the correct implementation. Authors try to make papers as close as possible to the implementation but sometimes subtle steps are removed, sometimes from inadvertance, sometimes because the number of pages is lionmited.

A paper and an implementation are not one-to-one mappings

somethingsome··on Restoring Old Software for Child Learning Safety
I really love this! I had a similar idea, but on the software design space.

Now the trend is to design softwares where the interface is not editable anymore, long time ago it was fun to tweak programs so that they look like what we want, change the colors, move things, change rounding, basic stuff sometimes and usually we just needed to change a plain txt file to do it. I miss that, now the softwares are non-personal, distants to the users.

somethingsome··on Reproducibility project fails to validate dozens of biomedical studies
The thing is, that would encourage two teams to cheat together, it would displace the problem, I'm not sure it will limit the effect that much (?)
somethingsome··on Reproducibility project fails to validate dozens of biomedical studies
I'm curious, I don't get why the down votes? Having to race for publishing pushes people to cheat, It didn't occur to me that it was a bad point, but if you have a different opinion I would gladly hear!
somethingsome··on Huge reproducibility project fails to validate biomedical studies
IMO, stopping the race toward better h index.

There is an huge amount of pressure to publish publish publish.

So, many researchers prefeer to write very simple things that are probably true or applicative work, which is kind of useful, or publish false/fake results.

somethingsome··on 'Fighting crime blindfolded': Europe is coming after encryption
So.. Criminals will move discussions to tor with encrypted messages, and only businesses and normal people will suffer from more hacks? Did I miss something?
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →