HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

somethingsome

462 karma · joined June 13, 2020

Contact me at somethingsomehn@protonmail.com
submissionscomments
somethingsome··on Functional domain modeling in Rust – exploration
After watching this talk https://youtu.be/2JB1_e5wZmU?si=WXoYxGnSOoMYwCFU I was wondering how it could be implemented in Rust
somethingsome··on Blackmagic Debuts $30K 3D Camera for Capturing Video for Vision Pro
It is developed in the mpeg standard already, there is a whole group of people for that from some years ;)
somethingsome··on Blackmagic Debuts $30K 3D Camera for Capturing Video for Vision Pro
Having a user stuck in the center of the scene is what kills immersion in my opinion, but at the same time I develop free navigation systems for VR :)
somethingsome··on Developing Developers (2015)
See the paradigms poster built http://www.info.ucl.ac.be/people/PVR/paradigmsDIAGRAMeng201....
somethingsome··on Developing Developers (2015)
That remind me of Peter Van Roy, Concepts, Techniques, and Models of Computer Programming, 2004

Similar approach for first years in two of the main universities in Belgium.

One uses lisp with SICP, the other the language developed in this book (Oz).

The book constructs many of the current programming paradigms, starting from almost nothing, with an emphasis on software design.

somethingsome··on Blackmagic Debuts $30K 3D Camera for Capturing Video for Vision Pro
Hey! Nice writeup, Just something is missing, some MPEG formats can encode this kind of video in OMAF specification.

Edit: I'll certainly read the rest of the articles!

somethingsome··on Tree Calculus Visualized
Honestly I often publish just to keep a track :)

And it's more difficult to search infos in my fav comments than in my submission page.

somethingsome··on Tree Calculus Visualized
I found this gem on tree Calculus in another post (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42373437) and thought it is worth submitting it for itself
somethingsome··on Historically, 4NF explanations are needlessly confusing
You are right, now that I think about it, I was using php prior to their implementation of object oriented.

So I had no objects, the users were entities in my head, I had to keep track of their data, so a multi column entry in a database made totally sense to me at the time.

somethingsome··on Historically, 4NF explanations are needlessly confusing
>20 years ago, when I started with databases, I found natural to map a user object in my software with a unique 'user' table with many columns. (Excel style)

It's only when I discovered how things were implemented and the required space and combinatorial complexity that the 4NF started to make sense.

I think the natural 'naive' approach is to have many columns with redundant information inside.

At some point, with more experience, we see how this system is harder to maintain (burden on the code logic) and how much space is wasted. I discovered 4NF (without giving it a name) by myself to solve those issues.

The problem is that we teach 4NF to people that never implemented code with databases and had to solve the problems it generates if you only have multiple columns. So the examples seems artificial.

When for the first time I saw 4NF in my lectures, it was easy as I knew all the issues without.

somethingsome··on A statistical approach to model evaluations
Thank you for taking the time to read this already long thread.

> Honestly, I hate this take. I don’t think it’s good for science or academia I completely understand, I don't say that I like the system as it is, just that we are stuck in it because there is no real alternative.

I would also love to have experts reading papers, but the sad truth is that it is often a first year phd student doing the review outside of its field.

> The question then is how people enter a topic.

I really like the idea of encouraging PhDs to write blogs and supporting material for their paper, or at least reference to good quality blogs that lead them to insights. But it takes time, time that usually they don't have, teaching assistants in particular spend most of their time working with students, projects to follow, etc..

If you have a solution to how to do it properly I'm interested. I had myself some ideas on how to solve this, but it would require time and money that I don't have.

> We are hyper focused on this novelty thing but in reality that doesn’t exist and is highly subjective.

Thanksfully I don't work on fashionable research, of course I have some people working on fashionable dl, but we stay focused on the why and not just putting boxes one with the other and hope it works.

> The math often __is__ the insight.

When the math is the insight, it should be there and followed by the insight in text and analysis. I don't say don't put math, but put interesting math. Nobody cares about copy pasted math from any other paper, with possible mistakes inside.

But I keep my view, the math is a mean, but ultimately what we want to transmit is the insight behind, the math can be recreated at will when the insight is there.

I love math, and some fields are more mathematical than others, and they profit from it.

> We let the bureaucrats take too much control and dictate the universities.

Agree totally.

somethingsome··on A statistical approach to model evaluations
I totally understand your take, and you are right in some aspect. Reviews SHOULD NOT WORK IN THIS WAY. I'm totally agreeing on that, but consider this, the population is increasing, the number of topics are increasing, we are no more in a system where the review system work as it was designed to.

When it was designed, only a few people got the chance to read, and information was not easily available. So, people became experts, and knowing the sota was mandatory. Now, due to the high quantity of (good and bad) researches, you cannot expect the review system to work properly.

But you are still stuck in this system. So consider what is important:

- do you want to write and hope that by chance the right people will read it, and they will be educated enough in your topic and have enough time at their disposal. Or

- Do you think your idea is good and should be more known.

If it's the later, it's your work to make your idea as clear as possible so that any (good) researcher can understand it, and therefore use it. We must work in the reality of the current system if we want to spread interesting ideas to the community. The publication system is a social system, and it evolves with the people inside, you want to write to spread knowledge. How can you do that if the probability is that the reader will not fully understand?

The time is very limited and I always have many things to do, I only read what I filter as worthy enough. That filter is based on the quality of writing. If some paper is important but badly written, it will automatically fall in my 'if I have time to read it' and most of the time it will never reach the 'to read' category, because there are many many paper well written with good ideas inside.

We work in a biased system. It's extremely difficult to find reviewers, we do what we can with what we have.

I also was infuriated when I got a review saying 'you didn't explain structure from motion' in a conference with a topic on structure from motion. But the reality is this. If I want my papers to be read, I must adapt to my audience.

> Read best paper awards of good conferences

With that sentence, I did not mean 'read it for knowledge' but read it with the lenses of the writer, why did they present the topic in this way, what makes this paper clear and another on the same topic not clear at all. Reverse engineer the writing style. It's not about knowledge of the content of the paper, it's about communication. Best paper do not always have the best ideas inside, but they are presented in a way that even if the topic is difficult they provide insights on it. And often those insights are what readers want to read. The maths are not important, the important thing is the insight you give to the readers. That insight can be translated in their field of they internalized it enough.

somethingsome··on A statistical approach to model evaluations
1. When I said we revise the paper between two submissions, I wasn't implying it was becoming "better". The message was that there is no general consensus around what should be expanded and what might be concise. Someone believes you should discuss prior work more, someone thinks the main algorithm requires more elaboration, someone wants you to talk more about BayesOpt etc., but you just have <10 pages in the main paper, and putting this stuff in the Appendix, or citing source, doesn't seem to be good enough in many cases (another comment in a sibling thread gives an example wrt GANs, and my experiences have been no different).

That's exactly my point, the reviews do not converge because the message is too diffuse or not justified enough. I recently had a paper rejected because it was too difficult to understand, it was on 4 pages, now it's sent to a better journal and was expanded to 20 pages. The content was too big for a 4 pages content, we couldn't fit enough justifications. But in your paper you still have many places where the text could be shorter and clearer, gaining at least 1 page of content. Learning to write good research takes a lot of time, and a phd is the place where ideally this should happens. It's difficult, but you'll get there if you work on it enough! Read best paper awards of good conferences, notice how much material is there in the same number of pages, and reverse engineer what they did to make the paper clear, concise and easy to follow.

2. You say you randomly picked a few sentences to read; that's good for a casual discussion but that should not be how a review process functions. Some of the best reviewers I've encountered (and I hope I am continuing in that tradition) come back to say something like "I see what you're getting at, but your intro. doesn't sell it well enough; think about writing it like this ...". Rejecting based on random skimming is exactly one of the things I'm calling out. Let's face it - like a lot of things, high quality reviewing is hard. It isn't supposed to be quick or easy.

You cannot choose who will read. But even for the more throughout readers, if it's difficult to understand / missing justifications from the beginning, they will give a bad review, even if they read the whole thing. Reading should be like a conversation with the author, if I find the conversation with the author through the paper too sloppy or erratic, I will not understand the message, that's what happens when I ask more justifications on some part to the author. It's because I couldn't follow the logic enough or I was not agreeing with some part, so I require more justifications.

3. Predicting how much to elaborate: this is probably an extension of the first point, but I feel like this has become way harder in the recent years. The rule that mostly works seems to be that if its not a trending topic explain it as much as you can, because cited background material is overlooked. This is unfair for areas that are not trending - the goal of research should be to situate itself closer to "explore" on the "explore-exploit" spectrum, but the review system today heavily favors "exploit". And like I mentioned, a page limit means that the publication game stacked against people not working on mainstream ideas. This should not be the case.

I agree, there are no more general experts, everyone works in a very niche subfield, you don't get people that know the sota. Learning the good tradeoff is difficult. My threshold is: don't explain the math unless it's not self obvious why. For example for some equation I can give more insights on how it affects my method and if a parameter of the equation is very important to my method, a complete analysis of its effects and analogies and experiments to see its impact. I try to make the main story line as crystal clear as possible, if I deviate too much, it's better on a second paper. My experiments should reflect not trivial things. Finally I make sure the abstract corresponds to the text. I mainly don't work in deep learning, so by default my topics are extremely hard to find reviewers, I feel the pain. But it's my work to make them understand what I'm achieving and why it's important.

Hope that helps :)

somethingsome··on The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
I think that in 2014 it was already well known, there are several meta-analysis that precede this work. yes research is important, even just to state common knowledge, I just find the paper lacking depth and sources, making it not that interesting.

There is no follow-up of this research by the authors, and their research is not really focused on something in particular, I've the impression that it's just another paper on the subject.

somethingsome··on The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
I totally agree on that, I was not saying that it is not important, I just found the paper lacking depth
somethingsome··on A statistical approach to model evaluations
Just a note

> exposition is not clear (we have rewritten the paper a few times - we rewrite it based on comments from venue i to submit to venue i+1 - its a wild goose chase)

Does not mean that the paper is invalid, but maybe the storyline is difficult to follow, the results not easy to interpret, or overall badly written or missing justifications. Even if you take into account the reviews to rewrite it, it doesn't mean the paper is clear and easy to understand.

As you noted, researchers need to read material outside of their confort zone, and the publications have shifted in focus. Before you could expect a reader to be familiar to the topic, now you need to educate him as clearly as possible.

I picked a random text inside the paper > The workings of the technique itself are presented at a high-level in Figure 2.

Annoying to read.

> Instead of learning the training distribution directly, which might be expensive because of the dimensionality of the data, we first project the data down to one dimension.

Why is that good enough? Justification missing

> This is done just once, and is shown in the left panel in Figure 2. Since we are solving for classification, we pick this dimension to be a numeric indicator of how close an instance is to a class boundary.

Why is it a good indicator, justification

> As a convenient proxy, we train a separate highly accurate probabilistic

Ok, references on previous research that show it can work?

So in essence, I don't say you need to explain everything, but the text could be more clear on the choices and why they make sense.

My gut feeling is that you know and understand what you are doing, but you miss too many justifications that proves your work valuable.

I didn't read the whole thing, so maybe I'm missing the picture, but from random sampling on the text I expect the rest to follow the same.

While I read the introduction, I don't want to read 'we did that and that and that'. But 'there was this issue, we solve it in this way because this reason '

And following issues->solution->why should give me enough understanding of what you are trying to achieve.

Follow-up sections should refine the solutions

somethingsome··on The anxiolytic effects of resistance exercise
Oftentimes I find medical research not interesting, most of the people that do strength training know the anxiolytic effect, there is no need for an nth paper to say it, there is a need for research that explain why it is true.

Meta-analysis help in showing trends, it's kinda valuable per se, but there are meta-analysis that show important things that were previously difficult to find because they were scattered in the literature, and the litterature was not with the same sample of people. Here the insights are pretty small, there was not really a doubt about the effect of strength training. A better analysis would be 'which people do not benefit for anxiolytic effects doing sport'. That's unknown, do these people even exist?

somethingsome··on Being Productive
I normally do not take vacations, and I have a very busy and cerebral job. I love what I do.

To do that, I manage my internal battery by being aware of my internal state.. It translates to doing sport every week, doing stuff I like such as cooking, being mindful when I do stuff. Helping others in my job, that's very relaxing for me. I work on programming or learning stuff) (mostly maths) that I'm interested in but that it is not related directly to my main job.

All those activities are productive from an outside point of view, but for me, they are the places where I enjoy the most of the time I spend and refill my mood and energy level.

An important thing, is that if I'm sleepy, I rest, even if I have important and urgent work to do, the output will not be good if I'm too sleepy.

Finally,I manage my stress levels, work is stressful most of the time, good stress management is key.

The main drawbacks for me, and maybe the only things that would lead to taking time off, is administration, administratives tasks drain me.

somethingsome··on The EdTech Revolution Has Failed
To give more details on the story about my students.. At 14-15 years old, they were unable to perform subtraction correctly with single digit numbers.

All of which because they uniquely used tablets and qcm for all their work. This was a general issue with their capacity of concentration, memorization, and overall learning.

They were able to understand a simple concept, for example symmetries of objects, after a lot of work, but forget about it the following day. I helped them through some years. They are doing better now.. But they didn't catch up what they should be able to do as functioning adults.

If you don't teach to a child to study, he will never do it, studying is not fun per se, if it's not motivated, the random probability that one does it alone is extremely small, and even then. You fail him for not providing him a good education.

Now I hear you, you are talking about preschool and, clearly I think that prematurely forcing them to study has no purpose, they should start studying when they are ready to it, but we do not have a way to know when it is.

I'm on the camp of making study as fun as possible, not by creating random games around the work, but instead by providing lot of context and unexpected examples that motivate the creation of the theory. In this way, I think education can start pretty soon.

I like to have my student study because they are intrigued instead of having them study because they 'need to'. Which is counterproductive no matter the age.

somethingsome··on Good Software Development Habits
Combinatorial explosion of states is a nightmare, IME it means that the abstraction behind is not the right one.

You really don't want to have a function that branches a lot inside. It's very difficult to test.

When you think of adding a flag, run in your head 2^n, this will give you the least number of tests needed. Do you really want to write all of them?

somethingsome··on Good Software Development Habits
I write research code, doing that feels very different than web code for example.

In research it is absolutely OK to copy paste a number x of times, because you don't know a priori what will work the way you want.

Usually, I write an algorithm to solve my problem, then I copy paste the function and change it a bit with another idea, and set a switch to choose between them. Then I copy paste another time as the ideas are flowing, and add one more switch.. Etc..

At some point, when I feel that there is too much duplicated code, I abstract the parts of the functions that are similar and never change, so that I can focus only on the changes of ideas, and no more on the mechanic of the methods.

As the code converges toward something I like, I PRUNE the code and remove all not used functions.

But this process can take weeks, and I can go to another issue in the main time, this is because I don't know in advance what is the right thing to do, so I get a code with several parts duplicated, and when I come back to them, I can choose which version I want to use, if something start to feel smelly, I prune it, etc.. Iteratively.

What I wanted to say, is that duplication of code is really dependent on the kind of code I'm doing.

If I'm doing an app, it's way easier to determine which code to keep and wich code to remove and which code to duplicate. But not all fields are the same.

At some period of my life, I always made clean code for research, you loose too many ideas and hidden behind the abstractions, you are not able anymore to work with your code. When you get a new idea, it requires to go through all the abstractions, which is insane in a very rapidly evolving code.

somethingsome··on Thinking about recipe formats more than anyone should
It seems written by someone that does not cook, it is missing a lot of informations!

In particular, the cooking time is completely useless without the heat power and the kind of pan, and conversions between pans

somethingsome··on The EdTech Revolution Has Failed
Personally I have bad experience with edTech because when a student is young, he is not disciplined enough to do hard things alone or even just annoying things, and studying can be both.

So when they have an app with for example a qcm in front of them, the first times they try to do well, then they learn that if they randomely click buttons, at some point the app validate the answer, even if they didn't read the questions/answers.

So you get a group of young people that after school, just spend 10min randomely clicking on a app without any purpose, and after that they can go play.

I've got students that were from a private school, everyone was doing that, and their level was extremely bad.

somethingsome··on The EdTech Revolution Has Failed
I'm just very curious as I'm passionate about teaching, how do you evaluate 'their level'?

I my experience, I can give material that is way out of their comfort zone, but it's my job to make it interesting enough and make enough bridges so that everyone can learn the material well, no matter the starting point.

(note: university level, but I also teached numerous times for schools)

somethingsome··on The Silurian Hypothesis
>Back then the conference organizers gave away funny, tongue-in-cheek awards (this would be inconceivable by now – humor!), and one of these awards was for the “most interesting hypothesis most likely to be false”. I thought this was a great award, honoring science which was daring, and which had just missed the mark by a bit.

I find this so sad, there is less and less place for humor in society to not offend anyone

somethingsome··on Learning to Learn
Actually, what you experienced is a well known technique to increase the number of pullups, the idea is that your previous training only allowed to get 8 reps, which is a low volume for a muscle, so you are not working optimally, by doing one by one, you can focus on giving maximum power at each rep, so if you want to increase even more, do series of 2-3 with explosiveness, pause 30-60 sec, start again, and try to reach a volume of 20 or something. It should feel easy enough to be able to do the 2-3 reps at maximum strength. If you are already at >15 you can increase the number of base reps, but the key is that each one should be kinda easy.

There is a related concept called grease the goove if you want to Google.

Now, regarding learning, while some parallels between muscle building and studying exists, I find it a stretch. Yes consistency is often key, but now suppose that instead of focusing for 1h every day on difficult problems I only do 5min, certainly it will work, I'll learn stuff, but not as much as someone doing consistently 1h study.

Recovery time is important in study and muscle though

somethingsome··on Ask HN: Resources for Learning Graphics Programming
I'm writing lecture notes about graphics programming, mostly focused on the math behind, if you like this kind of material, they should be ready by December ;)
somethingsome··on Goodbye, Atomic Habits. The overlooked problems with building healthy habits
Yes I am also very mindful with my pans, the rest goes to the dishwasher ;)
somethingsome··on JabRef – Literature Management
Zoo for zotero is pretty good ;)

I think the dev do not work on it anymore, but it's in a very usable state and open source.

somethingsome··on Goodbye, Atomic Habits. The overlooked problems with building healthy habits
I find there is a difference between

1. washing dishes by hand (supposing you don't like that but it's necessary)

2.Meditating

The first one is an habit you create because you need it done and you want it to be less pain.

The second one, if done for the wrong purposes of just 'wanting to improve oneself' it becomes a pain, because you know you don't really need it, but you force yourself to do it anyway.

Of course, if meditation is one of your strong believes, this doesn't apply, but 'meditating' because 'some people say it will improve myself and it will create an healthy habit' is noy a good goal.

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →