HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

spats1990

517 karma · joined August 27, 2019

submissionscomments
spats1990··on Reddit seeks to hire advisers for U.S. IPO – sources
You'll find that those types of foreign concerns about freedom of the press in Korea go back a really long way, and are not limited to the current administration.

>I have no interest in debating someone that thinks SK shouldn't be blocking NK contents, a sorry piece of dystopian communist-authoritarian country SK is still in war with?

Okay, so you do believe in censorship, correct? But only for your political opponents.

spats1990··on Reddit seeks to hire advisers for U.S. IPO – sources
I spent 2017-2019 posting/arguing with people on /r/korea almost every day, and I was really... inflammatory sometimes. Never got banned. As someone else points out, you probably deserved at least a temp ban for the "moonies" thing. It's a bit different than your average political sneer word.

The shadowban sucks, though. Usually, the trick is to come back on a new account, and keep your head down for a while (and, if appropriate, try not to do the things you were banned for). That goes for all the subreddits I've been on. People will notice if you're a single-purpose commenter, back on a new account.

Also... (oh god, this is like smoking a cigarette after years off them)... it has always been so funny to me that this flag of "censorship" has suddenly been taken up by certain elements/people in the Korean political discourse, in light of the fact that there has never been a time when there was no censorship of Korean media. Lee Myung-bak? The removal of all those Daum comments? Every Korean administration has used the KCSC and attendant powers like a cudgel.

Your comments in that thread show either an unintentional or deliberate ignorance of the history of this stuff in the ROK.

"Free speech" type arguments currently being levelled at the Moon administration are a joke in the Korean political context. There is no free speech in the ROK and there never has been. Remember PGH's blacklists of artists etc for being pro-North? Remember that guy who had his house raided for using NK propaganda posters in memes? There has never been any free speech, freedom from censorship, etc, in the ROK. And most people there actually don't seem to mind. Or else they do mind, but it depends on who's in power. That's their business. They're the polity. But these claims of sudden "censorship" are lies by omission, because there is literally no time in the history of the ROK state at which the press has been anything like "free" in the western sense. It's all political ebb and flow.

Unless Moon Jae-in's critics would be willing to join me in calling for the KCSC to remove the internet blocks on North Korean content (or the ones on porn for that matter), any claims of censorship/free access to information/free speech will just look like political opportunism. It's "do as I say, not as I do" stuff. The election of every new president brings legal trials for the previous one, or at least for members of the previous president's administration. And so it goes...

spats1990··on William Gibson is a literary genius
Yeah I wasn't being precise sorry. The agency stub's similarities to our world felt too "on the nose" or similar, in a way that detracted from it being an accurate/enthralling depiction of our world (in the way that all sf is no matter when/where it's set). It's hard to phrase what I mean here but I think the countryside/suburbia might have something to do with it. "2060s USA: The Department of Homeland Security is an oppressive militia and also one of very few sources of stable employment" felt much more real and powerful than "Kinda 201X USA: Trump didn't win, but now there's a nuclear standoff" but I can't say why exactly. There is still a lot of classic Gibson prose in Agency though--the good stuff. High hopes for the new book.
spats1990··on William Gibson is a literary genius
You're a legend. I've already lost an hour and a half reading these posts. There are 7 years of them!

"In Pattern Recognition, the only physical environments I can think of that evoke Cornell boxes are the basement arcade off Portobello Road, where Cayce sees the book’s first Michelin Man, and Boone’s ex-girlfriend’s rather too perfect apartment in Hongo, and, possibly, Baranov’s fetid caravan. None of these are felt as sympatico environments for Cayce.

But there may be another sort of Cornell box there, in the form of F:F:F, the website where Cayce and her friends have been discussing the footage, in the months before the book begins. I think that’s an improvement, though, as a website can become a Cornell box full of friends. Having seen that happen elsewhere, and been a part of it myself, my best hope for this site would be that, for some of you at least, that will happen for you here. (If it does, it won’t have much to do with me, and everything to do with you.)"

https://williamgibsonblog.blogspot.com/2003/01/#90148619

spats1990··on William Gibson is a literary genius
Thank you, I thought this blog was gone from the internet. His site at one point had a fairly active message board attached to it and I was sad when that went along with what I remember was some sort of author-bloggy appendage.
spats1990··on William Gibson is a literary genius
I think you're right there and I think it suffers from the political context in which it was written. The near future America of Peripheral was far stronger and more convincing, even politically, than the near future America of Agency.
spats1990··on William Gibson is a literary genius
I'm a superfan as well and I think the Blue Ant ones hold up the best. With a few years of context we can see now that he was really well ahead of the curve on a ton of stuff that is now our reality. When Cayce explains why she quit coolhunting she says that the world has begun to suffer a contagion wherein almost everybody is a coolhunter of some kind, and of course that did happen, but the publication of the book where she says this predates instagram by two or three years. Gibson was one of the first to point out how ubiquitous internet essentially killed the geographical subculture with its signature language of fashion and so on. They still exist, but on a smorgasboard of options presented by the twining together of internet and culture. The Bigends of our world will send global anything that looks promising, shorn of its physical context.

e: Molly Millions is the most iconic and famous Gibson character but I think Bigend, with his charm, machinations, drive to commodify art, etc, is the one really representing an archetype for our times.

spats1990··on William Gibson is a literary genius
>"literary naturalism" (great phrase!)

Just a great phrase describing a key development stage of the western novel, nothing special or anything :) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_(literature)

spats1990··on More wind energy was installed in 2020 than any other energy source
Liquid-air batteries. Big ones.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/jun/18/worlds-b...

https://highviewpower.com/

spats1990··on Why the Covid Vaccines Aren’t Dangerous
Perhaps, as is a common argument from the vaccine-hesitant, we should wait for more scientific data before concluding that previous infection provides more protection than the vaccine? :)

After all, this whole thing has happened quite quickly.

spats1990··on Why the Covid Vaccines Aren’t Dangerous
It can be considered irrational thinking given the scientifically documented rarity of adverse reactions to the vaccines thus far.

It is lottery-ticket thinking but with a negative outcome imagined in place of a positive one.

Just like with lottery tickets, you have to be in to win. But it is overwhelmingly unlikely that you will win, and it is overwhelmingly unlikely you will have an adverse reaction to the vaccine.

It's weird to see someone argue that this is "not irrational thinking" on numerically literate HN.

spats1990··on Arm China Has Gone Rogue
Thank you. I'm surprised by the tone of some of the comments here. The linked article's framing of the story is outright flamebait.
spats1990··on Arm China Has Gone Rogue
>But I don’t think I’m the only one with a queasy feeling that Eastern elites seem to be admitting more people to the middle class while Western elites seem to be pushing people out of it.

I agree with this and everything in your comment but that specifically doesn't really make me queasy. I'm glad that the elites of some countries still seem focused on creating positive outcomes for their citizens, even if some in the West may want to quibble about the nature of those outcomes.

What gives me the queasy feeling is reading threads like this on HN where the top comments discuss the "security risk" of Chinese nationals/ABCs in American STEM fields (the parent makes the distinction of those fields related to national defence, but replies do not) (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28334051, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28332562) and the general preponderance of what I consider extremely shortsighted, low-info, and jingoistic comments. It's frightening. It's possibly hyperbolic but these comments about "security risk" in particular seem to carry the shadow of internment camps.

My basic queasy feeling is that certain western elites may be sleepwalking into something very bad here. I really hope that this feeling I have is just that mid-pandemic feeling of living through history in the making, but metastasized into areas where it doesn't belong.

edit: the comments I refer to are I guess a microcosm of the fact that China hawkishness in all its forms is one of the very few bipartisan issues in US politics right now. I'm not American, and again, this makes me very uneasy.

spats1990··on The Peril of Politicizing Science [pdf]
>had a change of heart later on.

He certainly did. Toward the end of his life he produced a list of notable people in the UK and US whom he believed to be Stalinist sympathizers, foreign agents, communists, etc, and passed it to a British Foreign Office employee. Charlie Chaplain was on it, among others. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orwell%27s_list

spats1990··on How to Remember What You Read
Are you talking fiction or non-fiction? Strategy 2 will work pretty well for most non-fiction books, especially trendy ones. It'd be a bit odd for fiction IMO.
spats1990··on The metaverse is a dystopian nightmare – let’s build a better reality
Thank you for this. It's basically a better-articulated version of the gut response I had to that recent Zuckerberg interview about his thoughts on the metaverse.
spats1990··on End of the line for Uber?
the report cory refers to covers lyft as well. https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2021/08/hubert-horan-can-ube... i submitted it before i realised this "end of the line" post was on the front page.
spats1990··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
The parent also ranks the countries by % of world emissions rather than by emissions per capita, which tells a very different story.
spats1990··on A 3°C world has no safe place
try this (PDF d/l): https://watson.brown.edu/costsofwar/files/cow/imce/papers/Pe...

"...the DOD is the world’s largest institutional user of petroleum and correspondingly, the single largest institutional producer of greenhouse gases (GHG) in the world. From FY1975 to FY2018, total DOD greenhouse gas emissions were more than 3,685 Million Metric Tons of CO2 equivalent."

"World's largest institutional user of petroleum" is both more precise and pretty damning.

spats1990··on Drought-stricken communities push back against data centers
See: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-04-01/how-much-...

"In Red Oak, Texas, a town about 20 miles south of Dallas, Google wants as much as 1.46 billion gallons of water a year for a new data center by 2021, according to a legal filing."

The legal filing: https://interchange.puc.texas.gov/Documents/49863_21_1037351... The 1.46 billion gallons of water _a year_ figure comes straight from this filing. Divide by 365, that's four million gallons a day, way more than 1.25 million.

Could you expand on how something might be wrong with the reporting when by Google's own account it is planning to build datacenters that use this much water a day/year?

More:

"Google’s data center water use became a subject of controversy last year in Berkeley County, South Carolina. An environmental group opposed the company’s request for 1.5 million gallons of groundwater a day from what it said was a “historically threatened” source.

The company has also worked with Berkeley County Water & Sanitation to get 5 million gallons a day from the Charleston Water system. Google said its share of this supply is far less than 5 million gallons a day, with the rest available for the broader community."

spats1990··on Why the United States has the best research universities
"Spoils of war" on Wikipedia redirects to "war looting" or: "A prize of war is a piece of enemy property or land seized by a belligerent party during or after a war or battle, typically at sea." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prize_of_war

>but the United States has relied almost entirely on resources within its own borders to gain its power.

How did it attain control of those resources? You haven't addressed the parent's point.

spats1990··on Bitcoin is a ‘boon for surveillance’, says former CIA director
Thiel recently said something to the effect that it's possible bitcoin could be a tool for China to threaten the stability of the US dollar. Interestingly, he is an investor in a crypto startup[1] that (if its intents are read uncharitably) aims, with a stablecoin, to do something similar to the economy of Venezuela and other South American countries that have extremely inflation-prone currencies/have experienced hyperinflation. Mass adoption in Venezuela is the current goal of this project. At least as far as I can see, success for this project would mean some significant chunk of the Venezuelan population transacting in a currency controlled by a company based in California.

[1] https://reserve.org/

spats1990··on MasterCard to open up network to cryptocurrencies
>In reality, once Bitcoin becomes a mechanism for the early adopters to wield wealth over the later adopters, everyone who didn't get rich early on will switch to playing a different game. No reason to go all-in on Bitcoin if the system is stacked in so far in favor of early adopters that you'll never be one of the wealthy ones.

Where I live, this is how some people my age are starting to feel about real estate. Maybe that's why cryptos are so popular, for better or worse, among younger people.

spats1990··on Email a Dumpster Fire
Samsung's Lee Kun-hee did this as well, in the 90s I think, but he made the factory workers watch while he and the other board members smashed stuff and set it on fire.
spats1990··on Manuka, the World’s Most Coveted Honey (2018)
The uses I know of are temperature in order to indicate when the bees have started raising brood in late winter/early spring--warmer hive temp=broodraising--and hive scales, which could theoretically tell you when the bees are about to swarm and would allow you to track how much honey the bees are bringing in in real time. Neither of these are a decent value proposition for commercial beekeepers.
spats1990··on Manuka, the World’s Most Coveted Honey (2018)
Older beekeepers in NZ will tell you that until the late 1990s/early 00s, it wasn't even considered commercially viable and was only suitable as winter feed for bees, because all anybody wanted to buy was clover. There was not much space in the market for darker honeys from the NZ bush and scragglier hill country. This fit perfectly with the mindset of thousands of NZ farmers, who were diligently clearing the mānuka off their land because it was "scrub" that could be replaced with grass. Fast-forward to the year 2020 C.E. and Comvita is doing mānuka plantations...
spats1990··on Manuka, the World’s Most Coveted Honey (2018)
>And all honey has the same antimicrobial properties -- it has nothing to do with hydrogen peroxide and definitely nothing to do with UMF. The reason honey kills microbes is it has exceptionally low water content.

Nah. It's about dihydroxyacetone and methylglyoxal, which are found in what is referred to as "active" mānuka honey, and which are not found (or at least not found in such high concentrations) in honey from other flowers. Dihydroxyacetone in mānuka honey converts to methylglyoxal over time. Not all honey from mānuka is "active", and there is an ongoing fight between NZ beekeepers and the NZ Ministry of Primary Industries about the latter's guidelines for what constitutes mānuka honey.

Some or all of these details are glossed over in the article, which is pretty low-quality for HN, but this has probably gone unnoticed because it's a long way from most readers' usual fields of expertise.

I think it is silly for people to buy expensive honey with labels claiming high antibacterial properties, high activity, etc, when there are no proven medical benefits to just eating it. On the other hand, its efficiency as a topical (iirc) antibacterial relative to other honeys is scientifically proven, but you generally can't use the off-the-shelf stuff for that no matter how strong the label says it is. However... people buy all kinds of silly things, and if there's a premium market for such things overseas, and no full-on marketing lies are being told, then I'm all for it. NZ needs a few high-value, high-scarcity exports to make up for all the thousands of tons of milk formula, etc.

I just wanted to push back on the idea that the whole thing isn't science-based at its core. It is. However, it's true that the marketing hype and shady practices (mixing mānuka honey with lower-value kānuka because the two can be very hard to distinguish in testing...) were out of control for a while there, and this has been reigned in somewhat by the MPI guidelines, even if those guidelines have created additional stress and strife for beekeepers in some cases.

edit: A very short primer on DHA and MG in mānuka honey: https://www.analytica.co.nz/Portals/0/Docs/Articles/DHA_MG_a...

edit 2: If any of you readers in the UK or US find yourselves standing in front of a whole shelf full of expensive imported New Zealand honey, try the Arataki rewarewa honey, which is from a honeysuckle-esque NZ native tree. That stuff is incredible.

spats1990··on The New York Times' first article about Hitler's rise is stunning
edit: disregard, article pdf available upthread

- vox's link to the archived NYT article is broken because most archived NYT stuff is behind the paywall now. if anyone else wants to read the full article, someone has reproduced the entire thing here with helpful wikilinks added: https://medium.com/@marcslove/new-popular-idol-rises-in-bava...

spats1990··on “The Far Side” Returns to a Weird World
I'm extremely glad he's back. I'm sure some part of why my brain is the way it is in 2020 is due to reading old collections of Far Side cartoons as a kid. Some of them I didn't understand properly until years later, but others (like the all-time classic where the cows are in the field standing on their hind legs, until one cow yells "Car!", and they all stand on all fours until the car is past, or "when potato salad goes bad", or the "Llamas at home" one) are the kind of thing that goes straight into your little-kid psyche and stays there.
spats1990··on I Am Deleting the Blog
That isn't TLP, it's one of TLP's millennial disciples. They mentioned working as a trainee doc in the ER but TLP was a psychiatrist at a large university hospital.

Also I don't think TLP quit because he was doxxed necessarily. If that were the case, he wouldn't have kept paying the site hosting fees all this time. I think he decided the blog had become too much about his identity as a sort of minor messiah figure in the eyes of his readers, which is sort of against the founding principles of the blog itself. The character or voice he created for the blog was gaining too much power. Having his real name revealed was only a secondary concern.

He probably still writes somewhere though... probably, he's a well-respected/beloved voice on some obscure phpBB board or similar (real TLP heads will know he used to read/post on Metafilter back in the day.)

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →