2,992 karma · joined November 21, 2008
https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/say-hello-to-th...
"After a stormy, dependent youth, the wind-and-solar-energy industries have matured into boring, profitable middle age. This year’s plunging interest rates make that a more appealing proposition than ever for investors. Wind turbines and solar panels, which once proliferated thanks to government handouts, now produce energy more cheaply than coal and natural gas."
https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2020/6/17/renewables-p...
Lots of comments on this thread that reveal folks are up to date with the state of hydrogen infrastructure c. 2017. It's changing really fast as billions of dollars are poured into R&D and pilot projects. For example, storage and transport:
https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-japan-hydrogen-chiyoda-cor...
Siemens has pledged to make turbines that run on 100% hydrogen by 2030: https://new.siemens.com/global/en/company/stories/energy/hyd...
Hydrogen trains: https://www.snam.it/en/Media/Press-releases/Agreement_Alstom...
Hydrogen in steelmaking: https://www.spglobal.com/platts/en/market-insights/latest-ne...
I could post 15 more. Our collective priors were well-grounded just a couple years ago, but it is time for a big update.
Simulation plays a central role in population genomics studies. Recent years have seen rapid improvements in software efficiency that make it possible to simulate large genomic regions for many individuals sampled from large numbers of populations. As the complexity of the demographic models we study grows, however, there is an ever-increasing opportunity to introduce bugs in their implementation. Here we describe two errors made in defining population genetic models using the msprime coalescent simulator that have found their way into the published record. We discuss how these errors have affected downstream analyses and give recommendations for software developers and users to reduce the risk of such errors."
1. That source is a mess; three of us spent a couple years trying to update it only to be foiled by classic alpha Wikipedians who are happy to see an article rely on 10 year old price estimates, but not to see standard industry terms used. Note the age of the LACE sources.
2. The LACE frame is an important complement to LCOE, but also imperfect. Take California's recent decision to require solar PV on new homes. Really high LACE, right?: California is already being forced to pair marginal PV additions with gigawatts of rapid response gas to handle the "neck of the duck curve" when the sun goes down but LA is still using gigawatts of electricity to power AC. Well, the LACE of that low-marginal-value PV is dependent on how many batteries we add, how much offshore wind appears, etc.
3. The people who promote LACE won't let you include the social cost of carbon as part of the discussion. They'd rather see the page wither.
Wind and solar scaled better in 2019 than the Chinese were hoping nuclear would scale when they made big plans c. 2015. Those plans weren't realized: https://twitter.com/sampenrose/status/1162772916125126656
Again, I am rooting for nuclear to take off. The best realistic plans are that low gigawatts will start to arrive towards the end of this decade. Meanwhile, wind and solar will be added at that scale every year in between, and more and more of it will be used to create liquid fuel:
https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/mega-projects-h...
Advocating for clean power is good. Failing to update the priors that Stewart Brand et alia formed 15 years ago when wind and solar were an order of magnitude more expensive and three orders of magnitude less deployed is not good.
"But what if there were sources of zero-carbon electricity that didn’t require heavy-handed regulation to make them viable in the marketplace? ..."
Wind and solar are cheaper now than nuclear advocates hope nuclear will be by 2030.
1.https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/aeo/pdf/electricity_generation....
2. https://cleantechnica.com/2019/10/30/latest-bnef-report-find...
"... What if we could produce more power—and do it affordably, with minimal environmental impact? That’s the almost utopian vision that some backers see for the next generation of nuclear power. ..."
Utopian?! We are adding gigawatts of wind and solar this year, and modulo coronavirus we'll add more next year. New geothermal plants are measured in dozens of megawatts:
* https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2020-01-22/califor...
"According to Ted Nordhaus, founder of the “eco-modernist” Breakthrough Institute, SMRs could offer a more decentralized, entrepreneurial approach to reducing CO2 emissions without hobbling the economy."
Wind and solar are extremely de-centralized and competitive. The economies that install them at scale—China, California—are doing as well as any.
“Will any of them ultimately be a success in the marketplace? You can’t say for sure,” he said. “But I think a bunch of them will get licenses to build test plants.”"
While we are waiting, offshore wind farms will continue to be installed at hundred-megawatt scale:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_offshore_wind_farms#La...
Please continue promoting new nuclear; we could really use it. But please stop with the anti-variable-renewable BS, and FFS stop giving Nordhaus airtime when he insist on talking like this.
1. 60% is too high for current turbines; 45% is about what recently installed turbines do. 2. Only old (and outmoded) turbines are anything like 25%. 3. The newest 12MW turbines should achieve 55-60%, as Hywind did for the (windy) winter months. Since future deployments are the topic here, that's the relevant number. Call it 55%, and say I was exaggerating by 10%.
I'm glad that ~10GW of nuclear is coming online, albeit at high LCOE. We don't know how to accelerate deployment. We do know how to accelerate the wind deployment that is already at higher volume. The small-modern nuclear camp is hoping to reach 10GW a year a decade from now at higher-than-wind LCOE. And I hope they succeed! But that is not a reason to talk down the wind and solar-plus storage wave happening right now.
Nuclear electricity is good. I wish we had a lot more of it. Nuclear advocates spend way too much time bashing variable renewables, including with trivially-Googleable misinformation such as your "25%", and not enough tackling the horrible political economy of nuclear. Safe micro-nuclear plants are an excellent start on the "economy" side of "political economy." Now y'all need to build a political coalition—and pro-variable-renewable peeps such as myself must be part of your core coalition if you are going to get anywhere. So start treating us as allies.
"There is enough wind in the world to supply the entire world’s energy needs. Solar supply exceeds even that by many times and is by far the largest renewable resource. In reality, wind is a second-order effect of solar energy anyway — the sun differentially heats the oceans, atmosphere, and land, and these thermal differences create the wind. This wind, in turn, makes waves; while there is, in fact, a lot of energy in the waves of the deep ocean, there is very little nearer to shore. Even if we captured all of the waves hitting every coastline on the planet, that’s not enough to meet humanity’s demand for energy. The ocean is a fragile ecosystem and capturing large portions of wave energy would negatively affect the oxygenation of the oceans, among other effects."
WRT intermittency, the point of this conversation is that hydrogen generation is a solution: over-provision and generate combustible hydrogen (or ammonia, etc) that can be used later and / or where electricity performs poorly: long haul transport and high-temperature industrial processes. Many links on @ChrisGoodall2's excellent "Carbon Commentary": https://us9.campaign-archive.com/home/?u=a336c39e55a6260d59a...
[4] https://www.barrons.com/articles/warren-buffett-berkshire-ha...
Nuclear is good! We should deploy it as fast as we can! That happens to be quite slow relative compared to our deployment of utility scale solar and wind. Let's go faster if we can. But for heavens' sake, nuclear advocates should, well, advocate for nuclear, not badmouth the clean energy coming online today at grid scale.
[1] https://microgridknowledge.com/solar-plus-storage-prices-hec... [2] https://cleantechnica.com/2019/09/11/la-8minute-solar-ink-lo... [3] https://www.environmentalleader.com/2019/12/gemini-nevada-so...
[1] https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/report-levelize...
[$65/MWh, end of thread] https://twitter.com/sampenrose/status/1224019148562321408 [start, focusing on China's nuclear buildout] https://twitter.com/sampenrose/status/1162772916125126656
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/20/opinion/facial-recognitio...
PS, thanks for saving the Web when you did. It seems genuinely heroic to me.
I will leave as an exercise for the two of you to Google:
1. How many new EVs arrived in 2019, in the US and worldwide? 2. How many are committed for 2021, in the US and worldwide?
You might start with VW committing to 27 models in 2022: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1118857_vw-plans-27-ele...
And is investing in making solid-state batteries affordable at scale: https://www.sae.org/news/2019/09/battery-show-solid-state-ba...
It's called Grand Gulf, and it boasts a 1,443-megawatt capacity.
But it hasn't been acting like a dependable backbone of the power grid.
An E&E News review of federal daily reactor status reports from 2013 through last month found Grand Gulf listed at full power roughly 52.5 percent of the time. It was at zero percent power almost 21 percent of the days studied. On other days, it was at various reduced levels.
Does that sound like a baseload plant?
"No," said Ted Thomas, chairman of the Arkansas Public Service Commission.