HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

spenrose

2,992 karma · joined November 21, 2008

submissionscomments
spenrose··on BART slows rollout of new trains as it contends with more repairs than expected
Most of BART’s challenges stem from 180 software packages and 30 microprocessors that make up each Bombardier vehicle. Each is a complex symphony of systems that communicate over an Ethernet backbone. A bug in one line of code could shut the whole thing down, requiring a rigorous safety review process that may take months before engineers can reinstall the software."
spenrose··on Browser tabs are probably the wrong metaphor
There's an old joke about four-wheel drive on cars: instead of getting stuck right when you go off road, it ensures that you'll get pretty far into the woods before getting stuck. IHMO that metaphor applies here. Like the Web, Google, and even the WIMP interface before them, tabs were invented to manage information overload but "succeeded" only in pushing the problem out a layer:

"The most sophisticated and efficient users of Google today find that “trying to navigate the growing deluge of data [just within their scientific field] has become a second job.” The United States’ library of scientific papers for health and medicine adds new ones at a rate of two a minute, year round. Like Memex and the Web, Google has solved the problem of published work burying itself unread by pushing it out to a vastly wider layer, one we will perhaps never manage to tame. We have not escaped [Vannevar] Bush’s quandary:

Those who conscientiously attempt to keep abreast of current thought [find that] truly significant attainments become lost in the mass of the inconsequential. … publication has been extended far beyond our present ability to make real use of the record."

http://whatarecomputersfor.net/the-worlds-knowledge/

spenrose··on Incentivizing healthy group dynamics in classes (2012)
The Software/Data Carpentries focus intensely on these matters, and their founder Greg Wilson continues to work on them:

https://carpentries.org

http://third-bit.com

spenrose··on Effects of a diet based on inulin-rich vegetables on gut health and nutrition
That is what I'm saying.

"this audience understands ...": 1. I think a quick scan of their responses will refute that, but in any case 2. my point is that there is no value to this study for non-researchers. General sophistication doesn't matter.

spenrose··on Effects of a diet based on inulin-rich vegetables on gut health and nutrition
Not implying, just informing, for those who may not make the connection.
spenrose··on Effects of a diet based on inulin-rich vegetables on gut health and nutrition
N=26. No control group eating, say, lots of low-inulin vegetables. Highlighting studies such as this one is not the right way to popularize science. This study should be of interest to other researchers. Once N is several orders of magnitude higher and lots of comparison groups have been included, then tell a general audience what's going on.

PS related to "inulin-rich" is "high FODMAP".

spenrose··on Oh shit, git (2016)
Same idea, but much more comprehensive: https://github.com/k88hudson/git-flight-rules
spenrose··on Green New Deal: How much does fixing climate change cost the US?
Saul Griffith: "what, then, is a reasonable and defensible cost estimate for a GND that focuses specifically on solving climate change and decarbonizing the economy? ... the price tag for complete decarbonization is reasonable, and doesn’t rely on a miracle cure. It is doable starting now, and most likely will not cost us money but in fact, save us money. We’ll see it is a capital cost challenge in the short term with a long-term payback as we won’t have to supply expensive fossil fuels to the system in the future."
spenrose··on They think they are above the law: the firms who own America's voting system
"VotingWorks is a non-profit building a secure, affordable, open-source voting machine."

https://voting.works/2018/11/votingworks-better-voting-machi...

spenrose··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
He titles it "college" and mostly uses Harvard as the example. About 0.1% of students attend Harvard, and their admissions experience is atypical.
spenrose··on Post-surgical deaths in Scotland drop by a third, attributed to a checklist
The study:

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bjs.11151

spenrose··on Battery Reality: There’s Nothing Better Than Lithium-Ion Coming Soon
Our 2015 model year Leaf has not had any observable loss of range, FWIW.
spenrose··on Battery Reality: There’s Nothing Better Than Lithium-Ion Coming Soon
The article states:

1. The price of Lithium will drop by half in the next five years: "prices, which averaged $1,160 per kilowatt hour in 2010, reached $176 per kWh last year and could drop below $100 in 2024".

2. Tweaks to the formulation "could boost the energy storage of a lithium-ion battery by 20 percent or more".

3. Supply is going to increase: "Capacity now stands at 302.2 gigawatt-hours, and plants with another 603.8 GWh are planned to open within the next five years."

So there is something better coming: in a few years we will have vastly more batteries, which worker better, and cost much less. It's just that they'll be an evolution of lithium-ion rather than a brand new technology.

spenrose··on The culture war at the heart of open source
Kudos to Klabnik for quoting from original documents. As he notes, Free Software is a complex phenomenon, and I respectfully submit that he doesn't do justice to the seeds-of-its-own-demise nature of its founding. My account, based largely on Sam Williams' outstanding Free as in Freedom:

http://www.sampenrose.net/tools/

spenrose··on Interviews with developers who became managers
Highest recommendation for The Manager's Path: https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/the-managers-path/97814...

Also excellent but require some translation to a tech setting: Becoming a Manager (Hill) and Managing (Mintzberg)

spenrose··on PyPy v7.1 released; now uses UTF-8 internally for Unicode strings
Great work, thank you so much! I was looking for PyPy vs C-Python 3.x speed comparisons on the site and not finding any. Do you publish them?
spenrose··on Iodide lets you do data science entirely in the browser
Summary: "Directly import and utilize the best-in-class visualization and UI tools in Javascript. Combine Python, Javascript, Markdown, and CSS. ... Your notebook should be as easy to share as a web page.
spenrose··on My New Plan to Climate-Proof Lower Manhattan
Excerpt: "South Street Seaport and the Financial District, along the eastern edge of Lower Manhattan, sit so close to sea level — just eight feet above the waterline — and are so crowded with utilities, sewers, and subway lines that we can’t build flood protection on the land. So we’ll have to build more land itself. Over the coming years, we will push out the Lower Manhattan coastline as much as 500 feet, or up to two city blocks, into the East River, from the Brooklyn Bridge to the Battery. The new land will be higher than the current coast, protecting the neighborhoods from future storms and the higher tides that will threaten its survival in the decades to come. When we complete the coastal extension, which could cost $10 billion, Lower Manhattan will be secure from rising seas through 2100. We’re going to build it, because we have no choice."
spenrose··on ‘A toxic culture of overwork’: The graduate student mental health crisis
Excerpt: "In 2015, Sophie — a recent graduate of the School of Earth’s Ph.D. program who wished to remain anonymous in order to preserve her relationship with her advisor — and five others in her Ph.D. cohort took a prospective Ph.D. candidate out to dinner.

Sitting at a restaurant on University Avenue, the prospective candidate mentioned that she was in therapy. One by one, the current students at the table said that they were, too, but none of them had ever discussed it with each other.

“Unless it’s your really good friends, you don’t talk about it,” Sophie said. “It’s still stigmatized, and it’s still seen as a sign of weakness. It took someone to be honest … [and then] everyone else opened up.”

According to statistics provided by CAPS director Bina Patel, CAPS counselors saw 22 percent of the graduate student community over the 2017-2018 academic year, for an average of 4.5 visits per student. Graduate students make up 59 percent of the students CAPS serves, which Patel said is consistent with peer institutions. "

spenrose··on Zuckerberg’s So-Called Shift Toward Privacy
Excerpt: "Here are four pressing questions about privacy that Mr. Zuckerberg conspicuously did not address: Will Facebook stop collecting data about people’s browsing behavior, which it does extensively? Will it stop purchasing information from data brokers who collect or “scrape” vast amounts of data about billions of people, often including information related to our health and finances? Will it stop creating “shadow profiles” — collections of data about people who aren’t even on Facebook? And most important: Will it change its fundamental business model, which is based on charging advertisers to take advantage of this widespread surveillance to “micro-target” consumers?

Until Mr. Zuckerberg gives us satisfying answers to those questions, any effort to make Facebook truly “privacy-focused” is sure to disappoint."

spenrose··on A $10 Accessory Proves Smartphones Are Too Big
https://twitter.com/sampenrose/status/944986515930624002

"Resolved: Apple should make iPhone for the human hands that hold it, not just the eyes and fingertips that invoke its software. ... Now we can update Jobs' "[design is] not just what it looks like ... [but] how it works" for iPhone. What is design for Apple in 2017? ... Design is how it gleams, how it works, and how it shatters."

spenrose··on Closed-door meetings on unions preceded Amazon's withdrawal
https://twitter.com/ritholtz/status/1096449884180434945

The whole thread is worth reading (note he links to a counter-argument at the end).

spenrose··on Handling 1M websocket connections in Go
An issue with Go channels and high-performance networking from 2016:

"There was one fundamental mistake made, however, which is that we shouldn't have used channels. ... First, they don't perform well enough. ... Second, they make it very hard to prevent message loss. ... Third, the buffered channels mean that Heka consumes much more RAM than would be otherwise needed"

https://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/heka/2016-May/001059.html

spenrose··on A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change
"it costs the firm between $500 and $600 to remove a metric ton of CO₂ from the air"

Ricke et alia center their cost-of-carbon estimates at $417: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-018-0282-y . Climeworks is already very close.

spenrose··on Solar and Wind Power Investors Get More Bang for Their Bucks
"Much of this spending-installation correlation comes from investment in more expensive offshore wind, which generates more power per megawatt than onshore turbines. Also, onshore turbines are more efficient and produce much more power now, on average, than they did 15 years ago. In terms of investment and capacity, it’s “spend the same, get the same,” but in terms of the cost of power generated, it’s “spend the same, get more generated power at a lower cost.”

Solar’s paradigm is different: “Spend more, get more,” then “spend the same, get much, much more.”

Solar investment has increased by a factor of 11 since 2004. Solar installations have increased by a factor of 110. Today’s solar asset builders invest an order of magnitude more money than they did 15 years ago, and they build far more generation capacity. And, like wind projects, today’s solar projects generate significantly more energy than those built 15 years ago."

spenrose··on The Mail Order American Dream: An Introductory Guide to Identifying Kit Houses
"The invention of the horse-drawn streetcar in 1853, followed by the electric streetcar in 1888, meant that middle-class families could now expand outwards into the first generation of suburbs, the streetcar suburbs.

Enter the kit house: a home you could order from a catalog, and have shipped via rail to your building site. Before kit houses, many homes were built from pattern books: collections of house plans with blueprints for skilled contractors and carpenters to follow.

The kit house, a product of mass-production took the pattern-book concept even further. For each kit house, every piece of lumber, siding, doors, windows, columns, etc. were produced to exact precision in a factory, numbered for easy assembly, and sent to the site by rail and delivered to the lot via cart or truck."

spenrose··on Before the Electric Car Takes Over, Someone Needs to Reinvent the Battery
The article begins by contradicting itself: "To deliver an electric vehicle that’s cheaper, safer and capable of traveling 500 miles on a single charge ..."

That's not a "car". A "car", as driven by a billion people every day, takes trips whose distances have a power-law distribution falling off from ~2 miles down to 150 miles, by which point you are looking at < 0.1% of trips. A large fraction of cars have never been driven on a 500 mile trip.

spenrose··on Cost breakdown for Solar PV with lithium-ion storage
LCoE for utility-scale solar-plus-storage is very roughly $30/MWh:

" Xcel Energy in Colorado saw bids for solar-plus storage at $36 per megawatt-hour, compared to $25 per megawatt-hour for standalone solar, and NV Energy has seen even lower bids in its solar and solar-plus-storage RFPs.

That equates to about a $6 to $7 per megawatt-hour premium for solar projects that are partially dispatchable — if not completely dispatchable in the manner of a power plant. By 2023, when the ITC window closes, the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) of combined solar-storage projects will put them in direct competition with traditional generators, Manghani said."

https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/five-prediction...

spenrose··on No new nuclear units will be built in US due to high cost: Exelon official
If the existing nuclear units in the US can be kept operational despite the economic challenges they face, and technology can be developed to store energy generated by renewable technologies, which are currently intermittently available, "then we won't need these [new nuclear units] at that point," Von Hoene said. "And we won't build them because they'll be too expensive." ... Von Hoene's stance includes so-called small modular reactors, or SMRs, and advanced designs, he said.

"Right now, the costs on the SMRs, in part because of the size and in part because of the security that's associated with any nuclear plant, are prohibitive," Von Hoene said.

"It's possible that that would evolve over time, and we're involved in looking at that technology," Von Hoene said. "Right now they're prohibitively expensive."

spenrose··on Cyclomatic Complexity and Why we don't use it (2014)
Summary: "cyclomatic complexity is a heuristic with degenerate cases, and some tools don't implement it correctly."
← PreviousPage 7 of 18Next →