HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sporkland

415 karma · joined July 27, 2011

submissionscomments
sporkland··on Copilot broke audit logs, but Microsoft won't tell customers
This is the correct answer. You do a pre-filter on a permissions correlated field like this and post-filter on the results for the deeper perms checks.
sporkland··on Copilot broke audit logs, but Microsoft won't tell customers
If you have a field like and acl_id or some other context information on the data that is linked closely to a user's files. You can pass in the user's set of those field values to the vector database to pre-filter the results and do a permissions post check with a fairly relevant set.

The vector db definitely has to do some heavy lifting intersecting the say acl_id normal index with the nearest neighbors search but they do support it.

sporkland··on Claude Sonnet 4 now supports 1M tokens of context
Does anyone have data on how much better these 1M token context models produce better results than the more limited windows alongside certain RAG implementations? Or how much better in the face of RAG the 200k vs 1M token models perform on a benchmark?
sporkland··on New executive order puts all grants under political control
The founding fathers didn't see the corrupting influence of political parties on the separation of powers. It's covered quite well in this SMBC related comic: https://www.lawsandsausagescomic.com/comic/101
sporkland··on MCP overlooks hard-won lessons from distributed systems
While I'm sure some of these predictions will come true and we'll have to layer some additional prompting and context engineering in here...

MCP seems to be the ultimate inheritor of ReSTful architectural practices as described by Roy fielding but instead of needing a human on the other end to interact with links (hateos) you can have an LLM bridging the gap between user intent and concrete subsequent calls.

So many issues around versioning and the fragility here will likely start to disappear. Like embeddings I'd put a bet on this being one of the major unexpected architectural improvements that lets us build our scaffolding a bit higher before it collapses to use a Steve Jobs analogy, LLM's at key glue points to create looser coupling.

sporkland··on Five companies now control over 90% of the restaurant food delivery market
The problem with this line of thought is that everyone just uses it to hate on people they already hated on. You go after rich tech monopolies, progressives generally go after big business, conservatives use it to go after the biggest business of all, the government.

We all just need to focus on monopoly in all its forms, instead of letting the politicians continue to separate us using division without difference.

sporkland··on Elon Musk's Grok praises Hitler, shares antisemitic tropes in new posts
And they managed to get it flagged. The longer HN mods pretend this is just natural flagging because folks are sick of the same old topics and not a coordinated effort to control the narrative, the more I'm going to start seeking alternative sources for interesting news.

At the very least someone showing data that in aggregate there are just more follow-on duped stories about things and they're letting one through un-flagged (ideally the top up voted one) to show that there is or isn't bias creeping in via the flagging system would be helpful in re-establishing trust.

I probably have a unique view as I view HN through an RSS feed of posts with over 100 up votes. Every single time I see a post critical of X or Musk and click through the story has been flagged. I'll try to do data analysis via that lense and see what it turns up.

sporkland··on Most RESTful APIs aren't really RESTful
As someone that criticized a number of their employers API's for not being sufficiently ReSTful especially with regards to HatEoS, I eventually realized the challenge is the clients. App developers and client developers mostly just want to deal with structured objects that they've built fixed function UX around (including the top level) and desire constructing URLs on the client. It takes a special kind of developer to desire building special mini-browsers everywhere that would require hateos and from the server side.

I think LLM's are going to be the biggest shift in terms of actually driving more truly ReSTful APIs, though LLM's are probably equally happy to take ReST-ish responses, they are able to effectively deal with arbitrary self describing payloads.

MCP at it's core seems to design around the fact that you've got an initial request to get the schema and then the payload, which works great for a lot of our not-quite-ReST API's but you could see over time just doing away with the extra ceremony and doing it all in one request and effectively moving back in the direction of true ReST.

sporkland··on LLMs should not replace therapists
I find having a therapist for an hour each week and then using chatgpt or gemini for specific scenarios that pop up providing some context from my understanding in therapy as well as telling it to be brutally honest with me and don't mirror or trying to make me feel better leads to some pretty useful insights into my psyche off cycle from therapy.

Please note this is after at least a decade of therapy and couples therapy so I've got a solid base of self insight that I'm working from.

sporkland··on I don't think AGI is right around the corner
yeah I've been thinking about them as stochastic content addressable memory. You can put as many next = userInput; while(true's) { next = mem[next]; } around them as you need in different forms. Single shot. Agents. etc and get wildly cool results out, but it's gated by some of the limitations there.
sporkland··on Serving 200M requests per day with a CGI-bin
Over a decade ago I was starting a java process up with local MySQL and getting 45k rps read, request per thread with load wasn't hard to achieve. Not sure why this is an accomplishment.
sporkland··on Ask HN: Startup getting spammed with PayPal disputes, what should we do?
I had a non-corporate personal PayPal account. I don't sell anything online, but someone sent me 50 bucks or something for some supposed product.

Then they demanded a return from PayPal. PayPal took the 50 then charged me a 20 dollar fee all without any interaction from me.

I tried to protest it through their appeals channel, but they decided I was in the wrong.

Needless to say I no longer have a PayPal account, life's too short for this Kafkaesque bullshit

sporkland··on GitHub MCP exploited: Accessing private repositories via MCP
Great succinct summary of a hard problem!

I might reword: "attacker-controlled data, sensitive information, and a data exfiltration capability"

to: "attacker-controlled data and privileged operations (e.g. sensitive information acces+data exfiltration or ability to do operations to production system)"

sporkland··on Graceful Shutdown in Go: Practical Patterns
Having operated a large site with 1000's of services I've never had the metrics thread crash on a service. I've often seen the telemetry pipeline crash. If you've been writing the metrics to logs in a thread you at least have a chance to recover and backfill that information when you fix the pipeline.
sporkland··on Migrating away from Rust
> These crates also get "refactored" every few months, with breaking API changes, which breaks the stack for months at a time until everyone gets back in sync.

This was a problem with early versions of Scala as well, exacerbated by the language and core libs shifting all the time. It got so difficult to keep things up to date with all the cross compatibility issues that the services written in it ended up stuck on archaic versions of old libraries. It was a hard lesson in if you're doing a non-hobby project, avoid languages and communities that behave like this until they've finally stabilized.

sporkland··on Congress passes Take It Down act despite major flaws
This is one place where I hope the emerging LLM world helps protect us. If the automated filters actually use image or text models to decide whether it is frivolous or not seems like a tool we didn't previously have in our tool belt.

Has a new YC business started that is looking to handle DMCA requests or is this largely the domain of Vanta and others?

sporkland··on PhD Timeline
Everything is getting flagged that seems anti-currently elected's actions. I tried to raise it here, seems like HN for various reasons is over talking about this topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43570025

I got some useful replies there but it is still hard to conclude something pernicious isn't happening.

I wonder if an upvote / flag ratio threshold would stop some of the abusive flagging that is happening.

sporkland··on AGI Is Still 30 Years Away – Ege Erdil and Tamay Besiroglu
Aren't humans and animals just prediction machines with in built goals around surviving and procreating?

Plus it's a massive prediction machine trained on a corpus of the bulk of human knowledge.

Feels weird to see it minimized in that way.

sporkland··on IBM orders US sales to locate near customers, RTO for cloud staff, DEI purge
Absolutely and unequivocally false. Unless you are casting Asian and Indian as white.
sporkland··on How Kerala got rich
I honestly can't tell if you're referring to the current administration or the previous one with this comment.

(Fun SNL video with similar confusion: https://youtu.be/8h_N80qKYOM)

sporkland··on 3dfx: So powerful, it's kind of ridiculous (2023)
Overclocking Celeron's those were the days. Intel binning down a bunch of processors capable of reaching higher clock rates but selling them as a lower end part was a boon for college students everywhere.
sporkland··on Natural occurring molecule rivals Ozempic in weight loss, sidesteps side effects
It is a somewhat though provoking question for me where you LLM's fall in automata theory? Are they non-deterministic finite automatons which would make regex's a cousin? Or does it require pushdown automata levels of capability?
sporkland··on Half-Life
I remember playing that leaked first level on the tram with roommates in college over and over again. We were so psyched by it. All salivating for the final release.

Next to playing Quake for the first time with 3d acceleration (3dfx voodoo) it was an awe inspiring flashbulb moments that changed what I thought was possible.

sporkland··on Musk-led group makes $97B bid for control of OpenAI
Gotta settle ownership in the octagon.
sporkland··on The FAA’s Hiring Scandal
I look at stories like this and a key moment of failure that is obvious to anyone that has ever deployed code is don't make a change and roll it out to 100% of all devices/servers immediately. Feels like there is just some basic things missing from folks brains that gradual release and validation of the impacted cohort isn't a built in instinct for us.
sporkland··on What's happening inside the NIH and NSF
I like how you analyzed that, one addition: I also think some form of the anthropic principle is at play.

The societies that exist have something that allows them to continue to exist. Free speech can allow a society to seek truth and being aligned with reality can be important in the survival of a society. But so can cohesion while being "wrong".

There's a lot of information floating around and there's a lot of play between truth seeking free speech and cohesion signaling going on. Esp. as noise has been added to all signals including the scientific channels both via corporations and via well meaning ideologues.

I'm sure this is naive but I assume most of us would just love to be able to filter the signal from the noise in places that are relevant to us and be able to ensure low malfeasance in the places that aren't.

sporkland··on Bacteria (and their metabolites) and depression
This interview about dopamine and homeostasis in the body would support the idea that resetting that system through suffering would likely be a valid approach:

https://youtu.be/R6xbXOp7wDA?si=iUUfMZe05DO0wR5K

sporkland··on I ditched the algorithm for RSS
I use https://theoldreader.com/ it's been reliable and trouble free since the death of google reader.

I even use it to catch popular hacker news stories: hnrss.org/newest?points=150

sporkland··on A marriage proposal spoken in office jargon
Adjacent News Radio Marriage Proposal: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-yGUSRdNG4
sporkland··on Dependency management fatigue, or why I ditched React for Go+HTMX+Templ
Reminds me of the Rich Hickey talk Speculation[1]. There is a special place in hell reserved for programmers that break back compat (for non-security impacting reasons) with widely used libraries, including google's guava developers. Linus Torvalds seems to be the only engineer with his head on straight on this topic and he has to constantly dive in and berate people that are trying to violate it in his project.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyLBGkS5ICk

← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →