HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sporkland

415 karma · joined July 27, 2011

submissionscomments
sporkland··on Netflix buffering issues: Boxing fans complain about Jake Paul vs. Mike Tyson
Was this the plot of a silicon valley episode?
sporkland··on OpenID Connect specifications published as ISO standards
Agree. I'd say openid connect looks closer to SAML in terms of authenticating users and bootstrapping a "sessions" if you will. OAuth2 in my mind is one potential approach to maintaining a session, post initial authentication, used for ongoing authentication on a per-request basis. It also has information about which client the session is associated with to allow for per-client authorization decisions to be done via the authorization mechanisms you mentioned above.

Basically both are concerned with different parts of Authentication, initial vs on-going (though 2 legged Oauth2 is also an initial authentication step).

The line between authentication and authorization can get quite fine, especially if the authorization policy is as simple as "this set of services can talk to me" if you use mTLS and a fixed set of trusted services in a trust-store.

sporkland··on Learning not to trust the All-In podcast
I remember them talking about self driving and the tesla's being so far ahead and then not being able to tell the difference between Cruise and Waymo. Waymo is so far ahead of everyone else as someone that uses them in SF it's not even funny. It definitely was my Gell-Mann amnesia moment with them.
sporkland··on Quincy Jones has died
Starla is crushed right now
sporkland··on Wait Until 8th
Anyone have any takes on the Fitbit Ace LTE vs the devices listed on their approved devices list (https://www.waituntil8th.org/devices)?
sporkland··on Detecting when LLMs are uncertain
I've asked chatgpt to state its confidence after an answer and it's mostly said it's very confident, except onetime when the question was pretty ambiguous.
sporkland··on In SSRI withdrawal, brain zaps go from overlooked symptom to center stage (2023)
Do these occur without the use of SSRI's? e.g. in ADHD patients? What if _someone I know_ has had these brain zaps extremely infrequently but definitely noticed them in the past?
sporkland··on Bike Manufacturers Are Making Bikes Less Repairable
I hate how fetishists on certain narrow cross cutting topics (e.g. right to repair, open source, environmentalists, security) drag the conversation in such a negative direction. The biggest revolution in biking accessibility happened in the last 10 years with electrification of bicycles. Most people care about total cost of ownership. The old bicycle were 100% repairable by most people and while it's a loss to not to be able to do that anymore it won't impact many people other than the ones looking to either drop their costs to near zero or the fetishists who will scream their heads off the whole time.

It reminds me of not being able to pick a milk without getting scorn from somewhere (real milk ~ cows, oat milk ~ sugar, macadamia milk ~ env impact, soy milk ~ hormones, etc). All the while we're watering alfalfa to feed cows for beef.

Oh boy the bikes are less repairable, even though half the city dwellers could be replacing cars with electric bikes. A car has way higher repair bills and up front purchase costs not to mention the ongoing costs.

sporkland··on TSMC execs allegedly dismissed OpenAI CEO Sam Altman as 'podcasting bro'
I'm definitely of two minds on this topic: 1. I'm getting value out of the current batch of models in the form of accurate Q&A/summaries as well as tweaking or generating clear prose or even useful imagery well beyond what I'd ever considered possible from computers before the last two years. 2. It definitely has limits and can be a struggle to get exactly what I want and the more I try to refine something the worse it gets if the initial answer wasn't perfect.

It really feels like a substantive step forward in terms of computer utility kind of like spreadsheets, databases, apps. We'll see how far it takes us down the line of human replacement though.

sporkland··on Inside the "3 billion people" national public data breach
I'm sure you've seen teams that have bad leadership / a culture of dysfunction. They're always asking for more headcount and no much how much you add they don't get any better. I assume parent was pointing out that no matter how many resources you give to the IRS they won't get functionally better. You need to change the leadership/incentives/culture, which is hard with govt agencies but resources also won't make the problem go away.
sporkland··on Why, after 8 years, I still like GraphQL sometimes in the right context
Good response to: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40521518

Covered a lot of things I was thinking reading the original article.

sporkland··on Instead of “auth”, we should say “permissions” and “login”
I came on to say much the same thing: a lot of authorization policies are very basic "is this a request by an authenticated user or service."

But I also think the fact that they both get abbreviated to "auth" also causes a lot of bad mental modeling and poor communication.

sporkland··on Figma’s Journey to TypeScript
They run k8s on borg. From what I can tell as someone that worked a lot on early k8s and a large GCP customer they still use borg mostly internally. k8s is their path to creating cloud portability and neutralizing AWS "network" effects.
sporkland··on Run llama3 locally with 1M token context
Yeah looks like they misused the word "train". And instead meant context stuffing.
sporkland··on If Inheritance is so bad, why does everyone use it?
In my mind, the more generic rule underneath these rules is you want to be able to comprehend what a unit is doing without jumping between a massive number or files or contexts. Inheritance hierarchies with shared state and overrides means you need to understand multiple files and their interactions vs interfaces and composition tend to allow for fairly understandable units with clear interactions.

The big problem these deep inheritance hierarchies cause is mediocre programmers often think they're writing good code (often high focus on maximal reuse) but the interfaces and clarity are terrible.

sporkland··on Why choose async/await over threads?
I don't know how the challenges with cooperative (no-preemptive) multitasking keep needing to get rediscovered. Even golang, which I consider a very responsibly designed language, went with cooperative at first until they were forced to switch to preemptive. Not saying cooperative multitasking doesn't have its place, just that it's gotta have a warning sticker or even better disallow certain types of code from executing statically.

Also great time to plug a related post, What color is your function:

https://journal.stuffwithstuff.com/2015/02/01/what-color-is-...

sporkland··on Great ideas in theoretical computer science
Inspired by the title my two top ideas from theoretical compsci:

1. Move to front lists are at most 2x the optimal list order search time (and are often much better than any static list order). [1]. A similar conjecture exists for Splay trees but is unproven called the dynamic optimality conjecture.

2. Randomized algorithms (e.g quicksort) often have the same worst case time as a non-randomized one but often are much faster in practice than their non-randomized variants.

1: https://www.dgp.toronto.edu/public_user/JamesStewart/378note...

sporkland··on Jim Keller criticizes Nvidia's CUDA, x86
I found his interviews on Lex Fridman to be interesting:

https://youtu.be/G4hL5Om4IJ4

https://youtu.be/Nb2tebYAaOA

sporkland··on K8s Service Meshes: The Bill Comes Due
As someone that got a lot of value out of client side load balancers as a language neutral network library (e.g. we ran envoy under synapse for a while) From the start the Istio design choices tended to address problems we didn't have / felt like architectural dream states while making problems we did have harder to address. The messaging and overall focus seems to have improved and focused more on meat and potatoes features but there's still a number of things that are hard to tweak via the standard istio apis that we have to backdoor in there.
sporkland··on Docusign just admitted that they use customer data to train AI
I started at "oh boy this is gonna be bad for docusign" but after thinking about it I assume Docusign is removing any filled form fields / actual values and just training on the contract structure sans actual values. So all the complaints about "anonymization is impossible" are probably pretty specious.

I guess we'll all find out if/when people use the model to get it to disclose other users information but I won't be holding my breath.

sporkland··on Financial systems take a holiday
Sounds like a simplified form of the generic idea of a rules engine.
sporkland··on If you're just going to sit there doing nothing, at least do nothing correctly
I wish the concept of dev mode and prod mode were baked deeper into all language runtimes/libraries.

e.g. before going to production with real users these cases should error as hard as possible, including potentially logging crashing the program to make the program errors super visible. Then in production it should largely log these things in error logs and keep chugging along.

And not like an environment variable with conditions. Something as first class as changing the standard exception and fatal calls behaviors.

sporkland··on Cyclist hit by driverless Waymo car in San Francisco, police say
Let me help you:

"While I'm excited about the potential improvements to traffic safety, congestion and waste of life that self driving cars can bring. I still yearn for improvements to public transit and micromobility that can eliminate cars from the road altogether and yield major improvements in density, efficiency, safety and pollution (noise, tires)"

sporkland··on Cyclist hit by driverless Waymo car in San Francisco, police say
Your comment is a misguided attempt to point out that even if we have safe cars we still have cars with all of their challenges around noise and other inherent dangers and problems. Hope you do better next time.
sporkland··on Vision Pro teardown part 2: What’s the display resolution?
OP was saying the native apps look good but screen sharing is bad. How does this explain that?
sporkland··on Markov Chains are the Original Language Models
I'm pretty sure that is a property of the word2vec embeddings. I'm not 100% sure if the embeddings/hidden states in LLM's have the same property but my guess would be they do.
sporkland··on Apple built iCloud to store billions of databases
Windows during the longhorn timeframe tried to create a database/FS hybrid. I think the interface differences matter in terms of optimization offered by the storage layer.

I'm sure you know all this and you were trying to make a high level point, but this old school diagram from the java content repository days shows a nice breakdown of functional differences between the two that lead to very different outcomes: https://docs.jboss.org/author/display/MODE28/images/author/d...

sporkland··on Ask HN: Will there be more layoffs in 2024?
I assume any small companies that were on the fence will no start doing more as it's easier to pull off in an environment where other companies are doing layoffs. Also a lot of smaller company outlooks are trending downward which until they hit bottom will likely involve more layoffs.
sporkland··on Higher vehicle hoods significantly increase pedestrian deaths, study finds
Illegal but not enforced in California. I say we let these people run a few more years and then basically revoke the license of anyone that has done this for a year. The front dark tinted window is nearly 100% correlated with reckless, aggressive driving for me.
sporkland··on Apple built iCloud to store billions of databases
Previously:

"FoundationDB: A Distributed Key-Value Store" [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36572658]

"FoundationDB Record Layer" [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18906341]

"Apple Acquires FoundationDB [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9259986]

"How FoundationDB works and why it works" [https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37552085]

← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →