2,799 karma · joined March 9, 2012
Solar is not low-tech but I think you need to view it from the point of being able to have a computer and internet at all, in which case you'll need some form of electricity generation.
For hunting you don't need a firearm, bow and arrow does the job just fine for most game.
> So I think the point is to question the never-ending technological advance a bit, and especially its application to day-to-day life, which I think is good food for thought in general.
Yup. Lots of elementary stuff like do you really need to heat your whole house in the winter or could you just use a blanket (or some other form of localized heating) where you spend 95% of your time. Stuff like most people won't give much consideration to because the tech is there, it's easy to use and it's cheap.
Basically we're talking about traveling back in time but forgetting all your memories after that point. And without those memories you'd just end up at exactly the same spot where you now are, wouldn't you? Assuming the universe is deterministic. Which paradoxically means you actually cherish those lived experiences so much that you wanna relive them. ;)
Articles touches upon that:
> I don't think any of us would trade our lived experience for a faster-working brain.
Personal history: I started playing guitar around 18 and at ~25 I was way ahead most of my 18-20 year old peers who had started way younger. And I was a jazz snob since like 20.
I did learn the basics of piano and reading music when I was around 7 but never played actively, but it might've helped that I didn't start from scratch at 18. But I was immersed once I started - music was literally all I did in my spare time aside from doing drugs. :D
I'm now in my 40s and have been learning piano for the past 2 or so years. I think I've been progressing quite fast, but it's easy since I already know what to do, it's just another instrument (the challenge is mainly the hand coordination).
Edit: I.e. how does "it" know if people just bought a ton of used cars, or if people were simply selling them back and forth to each other constantly?
(and if sales between private persons wouldn't register, imagine dealers being in between every transaction)
Recipient's phone could also be compromised. There are various threat scenarios. But having plaintext backups would make it very likely that your communications are mostly insecure.
I.e. if everyone just bought stuff back and forth from each other constantly (assuming no taxes on the transactions) the GDP would shoot up.
For me:
- HN scrolling to find ideas/inspiration, staying longer if I find something interesting
- Twitter scrolling to get a glimpse of what's going on in the world and then staying if I get baited by something :D
- Facebook scrolling, usually for a particular purpose these days (maybe once every other week on average, to check up on someone in particular I happen to think of), then staying scrolling for a bit, past irrelevant posts for a while, where I might get warm/happy/nostalgic by some updates
- Instagram scrolling takes literally 30 seconds before I get annoyed by the ads and close the app (happens 100% of the time although I might last 1-2 minutes some times)
Those are all quite different experiences and I could do them all in quite different ways. I used to mindlessly scroll FB for example while not using Twitter at all. The psychological effects were quite different, but perhaps more socially attuned?
Nowadays I scroll less overall and more for intellectual reasons.
But... getting caught in the "must... scroll.... more...." mode is the same for all of them psychologically (Youtube as well), the same addictive behavior.
So yeah. I think there needs to be a distinction between scrolling for a (moderately healthy) while and doomscrolling. The algorithms can be quite very helpful in presenting relevant data, but they're also a potential black hole.
Oh and I'm not sure why I was replying to you specifically. I guess you got to be my therapist today.
I'd argue that it's waaaay easier to make stable bodycam software than a stable mobile phone OS.
How is it nonsense? I am not that knowledgeable on the topic but to me the biggest issue (outside of moral ones) is the decrease in genetic diversity. Is there anything else in particular you have "scientific" qualms with?
So to me it's not "nonsense" but rather "problematic, and moreso the further you take it".
>
> This means they are not running out like most people think.
You seem to be missing the point - I never said anything was running out. You seem to be arguing about our current civilization. If you imagine a future upcoming civilization (post-apocalypse, whatever), having progressed to an iron age stage, how on earth would they even discover those deposits hidden deep beneath the sea? They would have no reason to drill there in the first place.
The easy-to-extract close-to-land-surface deposits are long gone. Humanity would have to somehow progress to industrial stages without the help of fossil fuels that we've enjoyed, which seriously restricts growth. And thus we're talking about much wider timescales than what we've so far experienced.
The other reply had a very interesting idea regarding wood gas and that could be an option for a cool future cyberpunk civilization that would allow for somewhat constrained population growth (assuming balance is found and it doesn't lead to another Easter Island).
> But they will never run out, just become more expensive to extract.
You are very much correct here. It's more expensive (= complex & energy-intensive) both to extract and to discover in the first place. A future civilization wouldn't make these discoveries by chance, like we happened to discover oil. Unless we'd store a Rosetta Stone type thing for future civilizations instructing them how to do so. And even then they'd require tools that would likely not be viable without first having fossil fuels.
So we'd better get it right this time because it's our only chance.