HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sridharvembu

1,049 karma · joined January 6, 2008

submissionscomments
sridharvembu··on Mr. Benioff, Tear Down That Wall
Alas, everything I wrote is true, it exactly happened the way I describe in my post. To be honest, I haven't seen a platform with as myopic a strategy as Salesforce, not from Microsoft, not from Google, not from Facebook, not by a long shot, so their situation is a bit unique.

In fact, several months after those events happened, there were people on their team who were uncomfortable with Benioff's stance. They tried to get him to change his mind, to no avail - a second set of interactions happened where one of their execs tried to get us in to Force.com, but he was vetoed by Benioff himself much to his disappointment and frustration (he ended up leaving Salesforce, so he won't be impacted when I say this). It was only after all that happened that I decided to go public with this.

We still stand ready to integrate our suite, just as we do with Facebook, with Google single sign-on and so on. The key question stands: would they let Zoho play in their ecosystem? If not what is the meaning of being "open"?

After all, Benioff compares Salesforce's "openness" with Microsoft, but consider the contrast. AdventNet, the parent company of Zoho, sells most of its software on the Windows platform (like most software companies do, no surprise there). We didn't have to seek permission from Microsoft to create applications on Windows. I don't know the terms, but I bet Microsoft would let us play on the Azure cloud platform, because they know a thing or two about empowering third party developers. Google lets us offer their users the option to sign-in to Zoho using their Google ID. Google lets us integrate Gears for the offline version - they even gave us publicity when we finished the integration. Google APIs are open to any and all vendors, including Zoho, on equal terms.

sridharvembu··on A Critique of Krugman's Economic (not political) Commentary
Recently, Bernanke seems to have come around to accepting that asset prices are important to monetary policy, breaking a long-held Fed orthodoxy, dating back to Greenspan. Contrast his speech in 2002, where he outlines the"don't burst a bubble but clean up the aftermath" philosophy:

http://www.federalreserve.gov/BoardDocs/Speeches/2002/200210...

with this recent speech in October 2008:

http://business.smh.com.au/business/bernanke-signals-new-app...

sridharvembu··on A Critique of Krugman's Economic (not political) Commentary
The Austrians are right to condemn the fractional reserve policies that caused MZM to get so big. But the only thing the Fed can do now is to printing money to make the two match, and then make sure it never happens again.

To even have that discussion, there has to be acknowledgment from academia & the Fed that their policies led to this. Right now, the intellectual climate is far, far from any such acknowledgment. In fact, the Nobel for Krugman signals exactly the opposite. It has conferred on him a degree of economic credibility (and perceived infallibility) that, frankly, he does not deserve - that was the point of my post.

Without that Nobel prize, he was easy to ignore as just-another-commentator. Not now. Yet another Keynes quote seems appropriate, why this debate is important:

The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else. Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influence, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist. Madmen in authority, who hear voices in the air, are distilling their frenzy from some academic scribbler of a few years back.

sridharvembu··on A Critique of Krugman's Economic (not political) Commentary
While [printing too much money] might make the current recession relatively short and mild ...

That is by no means assured. Right now, we are in truly uncharted territory economically. My prediction is that theories are going to be rewritten.

sridharvembu··on Zoho: The Little Engine That Could (Take on Both Microsoft and Google)
Point taken. Design is hard, great design is harder. To contrast with 37Signals, we don't believe, and haven't believed in less is more. As Joel Spolsky has said, nothing sells software better than new features. We are working on new interfaces that will expose the feature set better.

Safari isn't supported yet. We will eventually support it, but haven't gotten around to it yet.

sridharvembu··on Zoho: The Little Engine That Could (Take on Both Microsoft and Google)
Jason, thanks for the complement and the criticism. To clarify a couple of points: Zoho CRM has nothing do with SugarCRM code. It is entirely written in Java - just as all the rest of the Zoho suite, in fact, it shares the same underlying Java distributed framework with the rest of Zoho.

vtiger has a clean open source license, same as Firefox (MPL) - the entire product is available on that license - and vtiger offered it on exactly equal terms to everyone, including SugarCRM. What is "ripping off" about that? SugarCRM basically has been trying to have it both ways, using the word open source liberally, but not quite living up to it. About half the product they offer is not open source at all. They basically have abused open source as a marketing term. vtiger called them on it. vtiger is doing well - it is now a separate stand-alone company, which was spun out a while ago.

As for our "soulless" UI, I suppose the marketplace will judge. We do have a lot of very happy customers - otherwise we won't be in business. On innovation, have you looked at Zoho Creator?

On the corporate side, there is only a single entity: AdventNet, which itself is a bootstrapped, organically grown company. We just have been around long enough (12 years) to afford to do things like Zoho.

sridharvembu··on Nintendo makes more profit per employee than Goldman (or Google)
My point is that they aren't likely to do a stand-alone DVD player ...
sridharvembu··on Nintendo makes more profit per employee than Goldman (or Google)
Outsourcing is a perfect illustration of the revenue/profit per employee analysis. If a particular function your company is doing is low-value-added (i.e it can be done by companies with lower revenue per employee than yours), you should consider outsourcing that function.

Employees are the most valuable resource of most companies, and efficiently utilizing this valuable resource is the most important function of management. Managerial complexity is a super-linear function of headcount, and complexity kills productivity.

sridharvembu··on Nintendo makes more profit per employee than Goldman (or Google)
Actually, it would explain very well why Nintendo would never get into, say, DVD players, HDTVs and such.

And Nintendo's per-capita profitability also explains why Microsoft is so desperate to break into video games, except that they just haven't been able to replicate the magic so far.

sridharvembu··on The Economist: Deflating IT
Google & Microsoft will both do very well, indeed. Even then we will have a decent business if we execute well.

First, we are much smaller, so it takes a lot less to be successful. Second, even in the face of the most successful business on the planet, Intuit and Adobe succeeded well. Third, monopolies are exceptionally rare, and fairly transient - so Microsoft's Windows/Office monopoly is likely to prove to be the exception than the rule, even for Microsoft itself. Linux on the server side, Mac on the client, Firefox/Chrome in browsers ... all point to that.

Dell is an outstanding success, and still only holds somewhere under 20% of the global PC market. That's what I expect to be true in cloud computing.

Bottomline: there are going to be many players with many successful strategies.

sridharvembu··on Why We Compete with Google
I will respond to Matt Maroon's argument directly: revenue per employee is one of the most important metrics in a software company, which is about as pure human labor as you can get. The eventual business goal of every such effort, including Y Combinator (if you define "revenue" to include the proceeds of an exit, which is accurate when you consider that Y Combinator itself is an ongoing business entity) is to maximize revenue per person.

So Google's management, having tons of cash to invest in growth, faces this question "What do our next 5000 employees do?"

My argument is that even with a monopoly in two areas, Microsoft is underachieving Google in that metric today. A new competitor to Office, Exchange, Sharepoint etc. will, by definition, not be a monopoly (at least at first, perhaps for a long long time), so their revenue/profit numbers will have to be lower than the monopoly's numbers.

Then there are markets like CRM etc. where very successful incumbents make a lot less than what Google makes today.

Put all these together, and the conclusion is obvious.

(I will ignore the irrelevant tangent on English - I have nothing to prove).

sridharvembu··on How We Recruit - On Formal Credentials vs Experience-based Education
Thanks for all the feedback. As a regular Hacker News reader, I am thrilled to see my post here!

Hexstream made a great comment about the wasted potential of teen years. It echoes what PG has said - boredom being the biggest problem in high school (or even college for that matter). Kids are getting smarter every generation (really true - IQ is going up world-wide), yet they don't feel challenged. Tapping that wasted potential is a huge opportunity, leave aside the "doing good" aspect of it.

sridharvembu··on Peter Schiff: "In many ways, it's going to be worse than the Depression."
I upvoted for this. I take Peter Schiff very seriously. He has been right on housing, right on gold/commodities, and he is coming from a very fundamental point of view. I have been a fan of the "Austrian School" of Economics (Mises/Hayek/Rothbard) also known as the libertarian school, which is where people like Schiff come from.

Do yourself a favor, and read up about it before you dismiss all of that as pointless doom and gloom. Ultimately it all comes down to the mindset change that has happened in America (and many other countries) over the past 15-20 years. Debt has become very fashionable, and large segments of the population have unwittingly become debt slaves. The ultimate root cause is Federal Reserve monetary policy (find out why).

Credit bubbles do not end well.

sridharvembu··on IBM, Microsoft & Google Eras of Computing
I use number of employees - I do agree productivity has increased, in fact, that is part of my point on why the dominant company could achieve its dominance with fewer people. In the limit, may be there will be a 1 person start-up that will be the dominant company of an era in future, and it will achieve its 15 minutes of fame ;-)

Thanks for pointing to Skrenta's post. I read Skrenta regularly, but I missed that one.

sridharvembu··on Fire the workaholics
Couldn't resist this one (sorry!): http://www.toondoo.com/View.toon?param=182598
sridharvembu··on Ask YC: Ruby and Lisp devs, please answer this (Not a flame war)
Granted. To be fair to Paul, I got about 60% of it based on a (rusty) idea of lisp. The _ got me (should've thought of Perl)... but now it is clear.

My broader point still holds though - there is a maximal density ...

And the reason I commented on it was that in posting that code fragment, the message was that it would be "kind of obvious" to any reasonably competent programmers how macros really help. I agree macros really do help, so no quarrel there.

In this case, we understand the "application" perfectly, and then we get to see the code. It still got (some of us) stumped, and (some of us again) actually know about macros and are moderately familiar with Lisp idioms. That is why I asked if density can go too far.

Compare that to something like LINQ, which I am coincidentally studying. It is a DSL for querying object collections (a similar use case to the code here). With no special background, you can go in, read code, and get a reasonable idea of what is going on.

LINQ actually lets you get rid of a lot of code (something I agree with in general), so it lives much higher on the density scale than a typical blub.

sridharvembu··on Ask YC: Ruby and Lisp devs, please answer this (Not a flame war)
Agreed on the obsession with brevity.

Reminds me of mathematical proofs, where you work out everything offline, and then make the proof elegantly brief. There is a similar process going on here - writing macros really does boil down to that kind of offline work.

Just as with such elegant proofs, though, you do need a pencil and paper to trace through the steps. And if the programmer were anything but of the highest caliber, it is fairly easy to get tripped up.

The way blub languages handle (the absence of) macros for td, tr etc. is to invent templating languages (JSP etc) where you embed Java inside HTML. You basically have a DSL living in a separate syntactic space. That gets the job done, for the specific problem space at hand (web apps).

I have come to like that syntactic space separation: HTML lives as HTML, SQL lives as SQL and so on. With macros, you are getting everything to live in the same syntactic space, so you get the proliferation of tokens, without that structural separation that aids in comprehension.

sridharvembu··on Ask YC: Ruby and Lisp devs, please answer this (Not a flame war)
Actually, the equivalent Ruby/Python would use a simple SQL query. I have long noticed how SQL is the poor-man's functional "DSL" for such uses ...
sridharvembu··on Ask YC: Ruby and Lisp devs, please answer this (Not a flame war)
(before I begin: I am familiar with macros & DSLs, code generation, building a custom language layer and then write your app in that custom language and so on, and I buy into almost all of it)

I am sure the code above is poetry for those deep into it, but for a person who is a bit rusty (or god forbid, new to the code base), this is basically indecipherable. Look at how many tokens are there in a line like

(each c (dedup (map downcase (trues [uvar _ topcolor] (keys profs*))))

How many people can answer the question of which ones are macros, functions, simple identifiers and so on? In that particular example I am stumped at [uvar _ topcolor] and can't get past it.

Yes, I have read Paul's thesis on Lisp code density (quick summary: each line is dense, but there is a lot less overall code so it evens out or better), but my counter would be that there is a density beyond which most mortal brains can't penetrate.

Without intending to cause offense, I am going to say that this is tending to write-only code. Sure, the equivalent Ruby or Python (leave alone blubs like Java or C#) would be pages long, but I suspect that lower density leads to better understandability.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4