HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sshumaker

1,535 karma · joined October 16, 2009

email ===== work: scott at persona-ai dot ai personal: sshumaker at gmail

Product-focused tech executive with 20+ years experience building consumer and enterprise products. Currently co-founder of a stealth startup building something outrageously ambitious.

Previously VP at Microsoft and at Credit Karma. Ex-Googler and former gamedev.

submissionscomments
sshumaker··on Hans Rosling doesn’t consider himself an optimist or pessimist but ‘possibilist’
Because a substantial portion of these fathers are incarcerated due to issues with our criminal justice system?

If the right were indeed looking more broadly I would expect them to be advocates for justice system reform instead of "law and order."

sshumaker··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (December 2016)
Credit Karma | San Francisco and Los Angeles| Full Time, Onsite | https://creditkarma.com

Credit Karma's mission is to make financial progress possible for everyone. We have over 60 million US members and are a true mission-oriented business, a rare case where our incentives are aligned with our users - we succeed by helping our members attain financial progress.

We've been growing rapidly over the past few years (hypergrowth) and are hiring across a wide range of positions. On the backend side, we are moving to Scala-based microservices using finagle and Thrift, and as well as GraphQL on node.js. Our native iOS and Android apps are #1 in finance (with a 5 star rating on the App Store) and we're rebuilding our website in React + Redux. Our data teams use Kafka, Spark and BigQuery among other technologies.

If you're motivated by growth and impact Credit Karma is probably the best place to work in tech today. We have solved product / market fit and distribution, but compared to our peer unicorns there is still so much work to do. If you look at the gap between our product today and what we are well-positioned to become - the main touchpoint for consumer finance - there is tons of opportunity for people joining now to take on responsibility and ownership and have a meaningful impact.

Feel free to reach out to me personally (scott.shumaker at creditkarma dot com) or visit: https://www.creditkarma.com/careers

sshumaker··on The forces that drove this election’s media failure are likely to get worse
pcunite - we've discussed in another thread, but the election was actually quite close. HRC had more of the popular vote, and a 1% shift from Trump to Clinton would have resulted in her victory.

Here's an excellent analysis from five-thirty-eight: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-a-difference-2-perc...

sshumaker··on Trump’s Data Team Saw a Different America
The fact is, the election was actually very close. If there was 1% more turnout Hillary would have won (flipping Wisconsin, Florida, Michigan and Pennsylvania). She won the popular vote after all. So while it's easy to make broad sweeping generalizations, the story is more complicated than that.
sshumaker··on Ask HN: Ever been hired through a “who's hiring” post?
We (Credit Karma) hired two engineers from September's posting. One so far from October's (5 candidates are still in pipeline, more new grads).

We've hired front-end, data engineers, and eng lead roles. A bunch of full stack engineers are in the pipeline.

I personally respond to every candidate that reaches out (scott.shumaker at credit karma dot com), so that helps ensure they don't get lost in our HR pipeline.

sshumaker··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (November 2016)
Credit Karma | San Francisco | Full Time, Onsite

Credit Karma's mission is to make financial progress possible for everyone. We have over 60 million US members and are a true mission-oriented business, a rare case where our incentives are aligned with our users - we succeed by helping our members attain financial progress.

We've been growing rapidly over the past few years (hypergrowth) and are hiring across a wide range of positions. On the backend side, we are moving to Scala-based microservices using finagle and Thrift, and as well as GraphQL on node.js. Our native iOS and Android apps are #1 in finance (with a 5 star rating on the App Store) and we're rebuilding our website in React + Redux. Our data teams use Kafka, Spark and BigQuery among other technologies.

If you're motivated by growth and impact Credit Karma is probably the best place to work in tech today. We have solved product / market fit and distribution, but compared to our peer unicorns there is still so much work to do. If you look at the gap between our product today and what we are well-positioned to become - the main touchpoint for consumer finance - there is tons of opportunity for people joining now to take on responsibility and ownership and have a meaningful impact.

Feel free to reach out to me personally (scott.shumaker at creditkarma dot com) or visit: https://www.creditkarma.com/careers

sshumaker··on Herman Miller Launches New Aeron Chair
The cynic in me thinks they are releasing a new chair so they can recapture revenue in this market. Aeron is somewhat a victim of its own succcess - they are incredibly well-made so there is a thriving secondary market that Herman Miller doesn't capture. This could be like a drug company subtly making changes to a drug once generics show up on the market. I suppose that's better than building in planned obsolescence.
sshumaker··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (October 2016)
Yes. :)
sshumaker··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (October 2016)
Credit Karma | San Francisco | Full Time, Onsite

Credit Karma's mission is to make financial progress possible for everyone. We have over 60 million US members and are a true mission-oriented business, a rare case where our incentives are aligned with our users - we succeed by helping our members attain financial progress.

We've been growing rapidly over the past few years (hypergrowth) and are hiring across a wide range of positions. On the backend side, we are moving to Scala-based microservices using finagle and Thrift, and as well as GraphQL on node.js. Our native iOS and Android apps are #1 in finance (with a 5 star rating on the App Store) and we're rebuilding our website in React + Redux. Our data teams use Kafka, Spark and BigQuery among other technologies.

If you're motivated by growth and impact Credit Karma is probably the best place to work in tech today. We have solved product / market fit and distribution, but compared to our peer unicorns there is still so much work to do. If you look at the gap between our product today and what we are well-positioned to become - the main touchpoint for consumer finance - there is tons of opportunity for people joining now to take on responsibility and ownership and have a meaningful impact.

Feel free to reach out to me personally (scott.shumaker at creditkarma dot com) or visit: https://www.creditkarma.com/careers

sshumaker··on Laws of Performant Software
I think your point around abstractions could be more nuanced. The wrong abstractions can be deleterious to performance, thoughtfully chosen ones can actually be beneficial. Every programming language is several layers of abstraction above the hardware it runs on, which gives the compiler opportunities for optimization, or even the superscalar CPU opportunities for parallelization / reordering. And so on.
sshumaker··on People are still bad at gauging their own interview performance
I think this is probably because there is still a stigma associated with being a VB programmer. If you knew F# instead you might have been hired anyway.
sshumaker··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (September 2016)
Credit Karma | San Francisco | Full Time, Onsite

Credit Karma's mission is to make financial progress possible for everyone. We have over 60 million US members and are a true mission-oriented business, a rare case where our incentives are aligned with our users - we succeed by helping our members attain financial progress.

We've been growing rapidly over the past few years (hypergrowth) and are hiring across a wide range of positions. On the backend side, we are moving to Scala-based microservices using finagle and Thrift, and as well as GraphQL on node.js. Our native iOS and Android apps are #1 in finance (with a 5 star rating on the App Store) and we're rebuilding our website in React + Redux. Our data science team uses Kafka, Spark and BigQuery among other technologies.

If you're motivated by growth and impact Credit Karma is probably the best place to work in tech today. We have solved product / market fit and distribution, but compared to our peer unicorns there is still so much work to do. If you look at the gap between our product today and what we are well-positioned to become - the main touchpoint for consumer finance - there is tons of opportunity for people joining now to take on responsibility and ownership and have a meaningful impact.

Feel free to reach out to me personally (scott.shumaker at creditkarma dot com) or visit: https://www.creditkarma.com/careers

sshumaker··on EU regulations on algorithmic decision-making and a “right to explanation”
Credit Karma is legit and free. Also gives you your credit score and credit monitoring (all free).

(Disclaimer: I work there).

sshumaker··on Scaling Mercurial at Facebook
Wrong. Google has the exact same problem, only they chose to rewrite Perforce.

The scale of these codebases is way outside what most people have experienced and it might behoove people to realize that a lot of conventional wisdom might not apply. E.g. last time I checked, Google's codebase was >2Billion lines of code.

Google has 30,000 engineers working on a "monolithic" codebase and remain relatively productive despite (or perhaps because of it). There are whole sets of different problems at this scale.

sshumaker··on Ask HN: What are the cons of Google Polymer?
They don't re-evaluate on nested path changes, e.g. if (item.bar.isActive) won't trigger if isActive changes. You can work around this in practice but often it requires significant architectural changes and for your regular JS code to be Polymer-aware.

This wasn't true in Polymer 0.6 but required Object.observe which is SLOW.

React's render everything and diff approach avoids this issue.

sshumaker··on Ask HN: What are the cons of Google Polymer?
Pluses:

It was vastly preferable to server-side template rendering (how YouTube is traditionally built). :)

Generally well-built components with support for material design patterns.

Polymer team was responsive to issues and quick to address feedback.

Plus a bunch of non-technical reasons like developer mindshare within YouTube etc.

sshumaker··on Ask HN: What are the cons of Google Polymer?
Disclaimer: I led development of gaming.youtube.com. We chose Polymer at the time for non-technical reasons.

Some downsides: Performance is not great. Lack of coherent data architecture (e.g. Redux). Difficult to manage state change (as opposed to React) due to a more limited programming model - e.g. template ifs and repeats don't know to reevaluate in many cases. This makes it harder to integrate with third party js libraries. Inferior tooling vs React.

Philosophically Polymer is more about the DOM and React is more JS-focused. Some of this is personal preference.

sshumaker··on Postmates launches Amazon Prime-style subscription service
Between my wife and myself, I've ordered from Postmates over a hundred times. But we barely use the service anymore because it has gotten so unreliable.

Even aside from the frequent "No Postmates are available", a large number of orders have issues, from excessive delays to missing items to even orders that don't show up. And while they eventually get taken care of by customer support, after waiting for two hours for dinner only to find out it's not coming, getting a refund is small consolation.

(I almost feel like sometime last year they switched to a model where the delivery person places the order instead of a call center. If that's true, it would help explain the drop in timeliness).

So while the app UX is decent the overall user experience leaves a lot to be desired.

I realize it's a different model, but we have way better luck with caviar.

sshumaker··on Why do we work so hard?
You have to be very careful to tease out correlation from causation here. In the Middle Ages the Islamic world was significantly ahead of the West in these regards. For a bunch of historical reasons (ineffectiveness of Ottoman Empire for several hundred years, World War I) most of the Islamic world is indeed behind first-world countries.

But that's also like blaming Christianity for the problems in Central America or Central Africa. Religion is only a small factor.

sshumaker··on Wealth Inequality Is Even Worse in Reputation Economies
Charlie - what are your thoughts on the singularity these days? Is it captured in one of your more recent books?
sshumaker··on Electronic Arts Standard Template Library for C++ Open Sourced
I had the pleasure of being Paul's intern way back in 2000. At the time, Paul was at Maxis and if IIRC the library actually had its roots in the C++ frameworks Paul built for SimCity 3000. Those games actually were quite a bit ahead, engineering-wise, in terms of the C++ of the day.
sshumaker··on When to join a startup
I think the article's overall structure is actually pretty poor. One lens to think about a startup job is risk vs. upside - both risk and potential upside decrease as the startup progresses. Ultimately, a large publicly traded company has the least risk and least upside. It's a very broad brush to simply say 'unicorns are a bad time to join' - people who joined a few years before the Google or Facebook IPO still did very well with minimal risk.

Another approach is to consider what non-monetary goals you have - e.g. growth. For a junior engineer, going to a top-tier public company or unicorn is often a pretty good idea since you can learn a lot about best practices and can be mentored by more senior talent. Going to a startup mid-career is often useful since you get a broader perspective outside of engineering (on business, marketing, etc). etc.

sshumaker··on The Doomsday Scam
Did you even read the article? It talks about the legend of "red mercury", a magical substance that is more powerful than a neutron bomb, and various groups (including daesh) misguided attempts to procure this non-existent substance.

It's a really fascinating look at how people continue to believe in myth.

sshumaker··on Google Is 2B Lines of Code, All in One Place
Xoogler here. There were tons of benefits to Google's approach, but they were only viable with crazy amounts of tooling (code search, our own version control system, the aforementioned CitC, distributed builds that reused intermediate build objects, our own BUILD language, specialized code review tools, etc).

I'd say the major downside was that this approach basically required a 'work only in HEAD' model, since the tooling around branches was pretty subpar (more like the Perforce model, where branches are second-class citizens). You could deploy from a branch but they were basically just cut from HEAD immediately prior to a release.

This approach works pretty well for backend services that can be pushed frequently and often, but is a bit of a mismatch for mobile apps, where you want to have more carefully controlled, manually tested releases given the turnaround time if you screw something up (especially since UI is really inefficient to write useful automated tests around). It's also hard to collaborate on long-term features within a shipping codebase, which hurts exploration and prototyping.

sshumaker··on Google: 90% of our engineers use the software you wrote (Homebrew), but...
I think you may have left with the wrong impression. If you ask Googlers or Xooglers alike, most agree that the people here are actually the best thing about Google. Like anywhere else, there are some bad apples, but compared to most other places the people here are on average more talented, nicer human beings and more helpful. Certainly compared to your typical startup or other BigCo.

In my nearly 3 years here, that is my experience as well. I've also spoken to many engineers who have left who lamented the quality of their fellow engineering talent at their supposedly 'hot' startup, compared to their former team at Google. Or having to deal with way more unprofessional (or crazy) management, prima-donna teammates, etc.

sshumaker··on Secret Shuts Down
Are you serious? After taxes that's maybe 1.8mm each. That's great, but certainly not never-work-again, especially in SF where the median one bedroom goes for 3300/month.

When doing FU calculations, you have to figure out how much you can earn from investing it, then factor in cost of living increases over the next 40 years.

Put it another way, if they invest and get 4% annually that's like earning a salary of 72k. Good luck living on that in SF with rent increases. (Starting salary for a new CS graduate at bigco in the Bay Area is like 105k).

sshumaker··on On Secretly Terrible Engineers
Do you work at Google? I agree with the grandparent - I haven't met a single person lke that here. I'm sure false positives exist but they are rare - you need to do well on a bunch of interviews that involve both coding and algo questions. Either your friend learned how to code or won't last long.
sshumaker··on Gamma-ray bursts are a threat to life
I think we might be earth's last chance at an advanced civilization. We've depleted all of the readily available energy sources necessary for an emerging civilization (easily-accessible fossil fuels). It will take at least 500 million years for them to be replenished. And in one billion years, the increased luminosity from the sun will wipe out most advanced life due to runaway greenhouse effects. So there's a pretty narrow window in-between.
sshumaker··on The Parable of the Two Programmers (1985)
I have to disagree here. This is definitely possible, especially on more greenfield projects. Most of the engineers on my team produced that much sustained. And my average is closer to 400/day even though a big chunk of my time is spent doing things other than programming (e.g. tech leadership / management). LOC isn't a great metric though and can be easily gamed.
sshumaker··on Startups Spend with Abandon, Flush with Capital
I'm not sure if the landlords are as savvy as you think. If the startup runs out of money, landlords will be the last in line at bankruptcy proceedings. It's hard to claim losses for the next 6 years of lease income when they can turn around and rent the space to a new tenant.
← PreviousPage 5 of 11Next →