HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

starspangled

828 karma · joined March 3, 2024

submissionscomments
starspangled··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
> I respond in good faith until the other party shows themselves not to be,

That was my first comment.

> and his glib rhetoric of "what do you mean, cost-gated?" while in the next sentence demonstrating he knows exactly what I'm speaking of - a public healthcare option

Public healthcare is cost-gated though. The recipient doesn't see the cost, but they see wait lists and procedures and medications and devices that are not covered. It is cost-gated. Prattling on about taxing the rich doesn't change that, it's just deflecting and changing the subject. If governments had unlimited money then healthcare would not be cost gated. Great. Astounding deduction. Now back to reality...

I think your attempt to spread disinformation about measles -- or worse, simply being willfully uninformed about simple facts yet trying to make statements of authority about them -- shows exactly what kind of person I'm dealing with.

starspangled··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
> Apparently the US spends twice on healthcare for the same outcomes compared to comparable nations with universal healthcare.

Sure, but I was talking about costs in other developed countries, not USA. Healthcare in Australia is about 1/4 of government expenditure with welfare being another 1/4, for example.

> Therefore the concern about costs does not add up.

Non-sequitur. Costs obviously do and I explained in very simple terms why (e.g., you could double welfare payments for about the same cost). Please explain your reasoning if you want to support the claim that cost is not a concern.

starspangled··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
This is a fairly unhinged reply to my quite specific question and comment. Pretty rude saying things like this

> Drastic, brazen or glib misunderstanding of history and politics

while pretending you weren't just spouting on about measels htat you had no idea about.

Healthcare is extremely expensive and taxing more won't magically make costs irrelevant or the cost of healthcare having to be weighed against other important and worthwhile government expenditure like welfare. That's just the reality of it no matter how much you're going to prattle on.

starspangled··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
Can communities choose to permit murder or ban people of certain races? Is America not free because they cannot choose to vote for a government that would prohibit women from voting or jail people for expressing political opinions?

You're using an extreme definition of freedom that I suspect is not quite the trump card you think it is. No, "communities" can't just do whatever they want because they "choose" to, and nobody ouside the lunatic fringe thinks that's a prerequisite for freedom.

starspangled··on Utah becomes first US state to ban fluoride in its water
What do you mean by "without cost-gating"?

Public healthcare systems in other countries have procedures they don't cover, and significant wait periods (i.e., shortages) to see doctors and specialists and have procedures done. Because of the cost.

I'm not saying they aren't better than America's, but the idea you can just let people have it and not worry about costs isn't true. Health is like around quarter of entire government expenditure, it's fantastically expensive. Around the same amount of welfare expenditure, so you could double the number of people receiving welfare or double the amount that welfare recipients get for the same price, for example, which would be lifechanging for millions of the poorest and most disadvantaged people.

> except the one where measles is making a comeback?

Measles is growing globally. In the "European region" there were double the number of measles cases in 2024 as there were in 2023. https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/european-region-report...

starspangled··on The Unbearable Loudness of Chewing
I'm friends with somebody who seems to suffer from this. I'm not talking mouth open lip smacking eating or slurping, just noise of using cutlery and chewing something not crunchy and swallowing seems to set them off at times. They've had outbursts at me before. I didn't really take offense, maybe felt embarrassed or defensive but I tried to be quieter. Which actually seemed to make things worse because I was awkwardly trying to be careful, but maybe it was just because I was focusing on it more.

In any case that still wasn't good enough for them, so I proffered some helpful suggestions for alternative solutions to the problem, which was that they take themselves somewhere else, or they could learn to deal with it themselves. Unfortunately this was taken extremely personally and caused great offense, judging by the reaction.

I have even pointed out to them when they are eating loudly and they do the revenge chew thing you're talking about, lol. I don't think the rational part of their brain has reconciled the fact that it's not actually possible for them to eat silently with their unreasonable demands of others.

At some point if your behavior is outside the norm, things are going to go more smoothly for you if you cater to the rest of society and deal rather than the other way around. You can always ask people to eat quieter and maybe they should but you'll certainly annoy and/or embarrass many people by asking, that's the reality.

> The only thing I find to improve it is to not be tired or stressed when eating with others, or lively conversation as a distraction. Easy, right?

That does actually sound easy unless you work at a restaurant or on a submarine or something.

starspangled··on We Were Badly Misled About the Event That Changed Our Lives
This should be a very good introspective learning experience for people who blindly trusted governments and their "experts", social media and "news" corporations, "fact checkers", etc., and who believed that all being in it together meant that anybody who doubts or even questions the accepted narrative should be bullied and censored and silenced.

I doubt many will take advantage of the opportunity, but we can only hope.

starspangled··on Exploring Polymorphism in C: Lessons from Linux and FFmpeg's Code Design (2019)
> You can take it a step further:

No, that is essentially what Linux does in this article (and by the looks of it also ffmpeg).

struct file does not have a bunch of pointers to functions, it has a pointer to a struct file_operations, and that is set to a (usually / always?) const global struct defined by a filesystem.

As you can see, the function types of the pointers in that file_operations struct take a struct file pointer as the first argument. This is not a hard and fast rule in Linux, arguments even to such ops structures are normally added as required not just-in-case (in part because ABI stability is not a high priority). Also the name is not mangled like that because it would be silly. But otherwise that's what these are, a "real" vtable.

Surely this kind of thing came before C++ or the name vtable? The Unix V4 source code contains a pointers to functions (one in file name lookup code, even) (though not in a struct but passed as an argument). "Object oriented" languages and techniques must have first congealed out of existing practices with earlier languages, you would think.

starspangled··on Tesla created secret team to suppress driving range complaints (2023)
> I have a model 3 (from 2023), that is rated 270 miles. I can get at max 120 miles, more like 90 miles from it. My drive to work involves going steeply uphill, not very cold. The only reason I don’t care is I have free office charging. If I didn’t I would be pissed by the range I observe.

Were you mislead about or unaware of the range claims when you bought the car?

I don't own an EV or have any real interest in them, but I know the range is highly dependent on driving conditions and automobile condition (often to a much greater degree than ICE vehicles) and I'd assumed that was made pretty clear in advertising materials and sales pitch. I could easily see unscrupulous companies and salesmen or just unaware 2nd hand buyers being caught out by the range claims though.

starspangled··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
Easy to assume you could only respond with that because you are incapable of providing a coherent response to the quoted point or any of the others.
starspangled··on Brother accused of locking down third-party printer ink cartridges
My print workload is very bursty but also low volume at the best of times. When my printer died I decided not to replace it because document printing services cost on the order of 10 cents per page (non-bulk) for basic printing.

I'd have to print hundreds of pages to even match the cost of a very cheap printer. I may never reach that threshold ever.

Best of all I don't have to worry about storing a crappy printer somewhere or have it dry out or clog up or spend time and effort on it and blocking it from accessing the internet and probably end up throwing it out and having to get a new one when I pull it out once every 4 years.

starspangled··on Brother accused of locking down third-party printer ink cartridges
There are places in the tropics where a lot of the houses aren't kept closed up with AC running constantly. A lot of South-East Asia, for example.
starspangled··on We're Charging Our Cars Wrong
Contaminants in fuel can cause damage to cars. I don't know if retailers tend to carry insurance for this but typically they are responsible, although proving it may not be easy. I imagine the risk would be quite rare and fairly well handled with insurance.

What's patented? Seems like a ridiculous patent if it entirely covered all practical manner of swapping batteries to recharge an EV.

starspangled··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
What are you talking about? You think I'm a westerner bragging about blocking something that isn't even blocked and I'm an intruder?

All I said was that China is terrified of naval blockade, which it is. You're the one being hilarious here.

starspangled··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
> How would you bock China's access to the sea along it's 14000 km coastline?

With missiles and submarines presumably.

> That woulde be a heck of a blockade, with or without Taiwan.

Of course, due to China's military build up around the sea. Due to their being afraid of said blockade. The one they want Taiwan and other disputed islands to help counter.

starspangled··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
> TSMC is the only card Taiwan has,

No it isn't.

> But, I think I see where you’re going: the US preemptively destroying Taiwan’s fab capacity…

I'm not going anywhere. China would bomb TSMCs factories itself and spend hundreds of times more on an invasion and subsequent sanctions and costs than it spends on funding its own semiconductor development, if it meant it could control Taiwan. Taiwan's cards are that it is a linchpin for air and naval control of the South and East China seas, and that it is protected from invasion by a hundred miles of water and challenging geography. That's why China wants it. That's the card.

Blow up all TSMC's factories on Taiwan tomorrow and relocate its scientists and engineers and you think China would suddenly drop its ambitions to "reunify" and take control of the island? Since its alleged only card was gone?

starspangled··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
No I don't, and anyway US-aligned semiconductor design and fabrication is still superior to Chinese if TSMC did not exist.
starspangled··on TSMC expected to announce $100B investment in U.S.
TSMC factories on Taiwan are small fry in the scheme of things and won't really move the needle much, in terms of strategy. Samsung and Intel are pretty comparable in manufacturing capability, within a couple of years really. And most chips you find in cars and ships and missiles and satellites and jets aren't leading-edge either.

China is terrified of their access to the sea being blockaded. They'd gladly give up TSMC technology without a second thought and continue to bribe, beg, steal their way around sancations and barriers to semiconductor technology as they have been doing just fine up to now if they could occupy Taiwan for its strategic position to deny American access and defend the sea around their coast.

starspangled··on How the U.K. broke its own economy
China now emits almost 2x the carbon per capita than the UK, and alone emits more than all western countries combined including the US. The UK can't solve climate change at the margin or anywhere else with domestic energy policy.

China is now consuming record amounts of coal (the globe has not actually even reached peak-coal yet despite claims we'd already passed it going back decades and despite western coal consumption taking a nosedive starting about 20 years ago). Which is strange considering that it has also been an enormous producer and exporter of allegedly much cheaper solar and wind generators for many years.

Something doesn't add up here, and further disadvantaging much cleaner domestic industry and driving production offshore to countries with far higher emissions intensity of production (not to mention many other environmental and humanitraian issues) is not the way to solve climate change. It could be making it even worse.

starspangled··on Efabless – Shutdown Notice
TSMC, Samsung, or Intel might be able to build a 3nm fab for about that price (maybe it's more like $30 billion though).

You or I? No.

starspangled··on Jeff Bezos exerts more control of Washington Post opinion
Looks like the old "they're a private company, they can do what they want" chestnut is coming back around. Whoever could possibly have foreseen this?
starspangled··on Dogs may have domesticated themselves because they liked snacks, model suggests
No that's just basic control and domination of resources that exised eons before humans did. Lots of animals have and guard their "territory" and don't farm. Plenty of human tribes did the same before they had developed agriculture.
starspangled··on Larry Ellison's half-billion-dollar quest to change farming
> Germany leads in engineering and automotive tech (Siemens, BMW, Bosch). Sweden produces global tech giants like Spotify and Klarna. Denmark is a leader in renewable energy (Vestas, Ørsted). Japan? It revolutionized robotics, semiconductors, and high-speed rail while fostering companies like Toyota, Sony, and Nintendo.

And you can't think of anything the US innovates in?

Your evidence / anecdotes aren't really sufficient to prove the claim .

starspangled··on Grok 3 claims its system prompt includes censorship about Musk/Trump
Denouncing and accusing people as fascists who must not be tolerated for the transgression of discussing social and political issues in a manner deemed verboten seems like something a fascist might do.
starspangled··on Grok 3 claims its system prompt includes censorship about Musk/Trump
Seems too simplistic and centric to one particular country / system / ideology.

Laws and courts can be and are made oppressive and used against the people by a tyrannical government.

Taking power away from [government] is not necessarily fascism. It really depends what and why. If it is a rogue court that is protecting corrupt politicians and human rights abusers? What really matters is the power the government as a whole has over the people.

There has recently been a lot of noise from American left wing about the Supreme Court being corrupt, illegitimate, politicized, etc., etc., and calls to reduce its powers, for example.

You could call that "fascistic" I suppose, but I'm not really here to get bogged down in semantics, my point is that the types of real or imagined enemies of political movements very much run the spectrum.

starspangled··on Grok 3 claims its system prompt includes censorship about Musk/Trump
You're very intolerant of people discussing this subject.
starspangled··on Grok 3 claims its system prompt includes censorship about Musk/Trump
There's n except about it. It was previously on the verge of becoming the governments's de facto censorship and propaganda platform. But apparently it was a private company and could do what it wanted.

People really should have thought a bit harder about that one.

starspangled··on Grok 3 claims its system prompt includes censorship about Musk/Trump
I didn't create a false equivalence.
starspangled··on Grok 3 claims its system prompt includes censorship about Musk/Trump
I didn't say it wasn't.
starspangled··on Grok 3 claims its system prompt includes censorship about Musk/Trump
No I haven't.
← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →