HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stelonix

899 karma · joined January 5, 2013

hnchat:XPpx7cBoCETwe4sYelJ0
submissionscomments
stelonix··on Color Emulation
Ok, I gotta say: none of the shaders or scanlines I've tried before ever came close to what I'm seeing in those videos; to the point I'd think "uh looks nice but that's not how I remember from the 90s".

Now that crt royale... Color me impressed! Gonna try it as soon as I get access to a PC.

stelonix··on Show HN: Browse Reddit in 3D
It looks neat, but I can't use it because it keeps looking up as if I were moving my mouse (I'm not). Running it on Firefox 69 on Linux.
stelonix··on When I Took My Zipcar Into the Wilderness
The comment you're replying to is not the person who was banned by ZipCar, but someone else showing why the logic behind the corporativist comment is wrong.
stelonix··on Reasons Not to Use Google (2015)
Uh, fascists and communist are polar opposites, but authoritarianism has nothing to do with communism by definition. If Stalin implemented an authoritarian regime while using the term "communism", that does not make communism a regime based on authoritarianism. It's nice to remember North Korea consider themselves a "People's Republic" but I'm sure you do not believe it is a democracy just because of a name or official designation; likewise, late stage western capitalism consider themselves "Representative Democracies", but a solid argument could be made comparing those nations with nazifascist states of the 1930s. Things are not so simple and simplifying such complex topics is what leads to populist governments rising. I believe we should not dumb things down. Instead, we should believe people are capable of critical thinking and we must help them see the whole picture for themselves instead of spreading McCarthist stories about the communist boogeyman.
stelonix··on Brazilian Butchers Who Took over the World
Although the series might expose how corruption works in Brazil, keep in mind there's plenty of controversy and (valid, imo) accusations of partisanship in the way the show portrays certain politicians and situations, which even if based in real life, have switched characters and quotes, effectively targeting an specific political party.
stelonix··on Real world location virtually recreated to scale in minutes [video]
Hadn't heard of DTAM yet, but found a video and am very impressed! What GPU did you use? Do you think it'd be feasible on mobile GPUs?
stelonix··on Real world location virtually recreated to scale in minutes [video]
This has been possible for a good while, the most common algorithm is Parallel Tracking and Mapping (PTAM). No stereo cameras are needed, but there are also implementations that make use of depth sensors.

What interests me is for an open implementation of Street View: drones plus crowdsourcing and we'd be free of requiring Google services for street visualization. We already have open street maps, we could have open street view too.

stelonix··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
I agree with you: the real issue we're talking about is putting a restraint on capitalism, because it is the notion that "development" means profit that's causing these issues. Those same advertisements make poor people in my country join the narcos, because while the government doesn't care about inequalities and unemployment, since it does not have social welfare as goal, those people are easily lured to work in drug trafficking, which pays.

Notice the ones defending crazy "free" speech are the same who defend crazy capitalism? Yeah, that's the issue: by defending what I call "responsible speech", which is free but not ultimate, we are defending social welfare and human rights AGAINST the former, because the former has no interest in defending the latter. We see it even here in Hacker News, when a corporation does something unethical or morally wrong, there will be someone to say "but hey, the corps are right they exist just give shareholder profit and that's what they're doing". It's a serious debate about sustainable development, which has the very survival of our species at stake.

stelonix··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
I respectfully and vehemently disagree. Hate speech has been proven to be able to convince people by virtue of appealing to their emotions rather than their intellect. It does not make sense to have a society based around human rights, with a point of view where stealing, murdering or otherwise deceiving people is wrong, while at the same time allowing speech which can subvert that same democracy. It's simply not smart. Just like your body has antibodies to prevent outside threats from outright destroying you from the inside (or outside), democracy too requires its defenses in order for it to work. The advent of fake news and social media manipulation should be enough to realize this: the US has a president that questions that validity of its own institutions right now, so does Brazil. Two democracies which have proven deceiving or hateful speech can mean trouble even for citizens who do not have anything to do with such rhetoric. Simply no, full-on free speech does not work and never will. The (anecdotal) fact Europe has some restraints on free speech while sporting arguably more freedoms, as in, freedom to live your life with a lot less chance of some random person killing you because they hide behind some crazy above-anything notion of freedom, should be enough to illustrate what I mean. Speech needs restraint or we need to stop pretending we care about human rights, simple as that.
stelonix··on Flutter looks good, but is painful
I agree with this 90%, but I'm not sure about the state of GUI apps after Windows 7. Up to Win7 though, most applications simply used native controls, sometimes wrapped by WPF or WFC.

I used to write for WINAPI/GDI and I used to loathe it; I mostly disliked the way messages were handled by default: huge switch statements. After switching to Linux and checking out the many "toolkits" I find myself craving for some GDI-esque toolkit. GDI was bad, outdated when I started writing it (circa 2009) but things "just worked", looks were consistent and controls would do the same across applications. The GNU/Linux counterpart is a mess: drag & drop sometimes works across toolkits, sometimes it does not; some toolkits are unwillingly to standarize with each other; the looks are all different, the functionalities too. Need an IME? Well here's one for KDE and another one for GTK. And if you use a different toolkit, chances are there's no IME for you. Right clicking on text-boxes and getting the same default options is great, so is being able to extend the same text-boxes systemwide. This is simple on Windows, but GNU/Linux requires one implementation per widget type per toolkit. It's all fragmented and no one cares. I miss GDI, I crave for a simple standard X11-wide widget system. Users do care about widgets working the same on different applications and they don't care about which toolkit is being used, specially non-tech savvy people. I believe those issues are more linked to the meme of "year of the desktop Linux" never arriving than anything else, really: UX should be consistent.

Well now I'll end my rant.

stelonix··on Fernando Corbató, a Father of Your Computer (and Your Password), Has Died
Well, I meant he used words instead of bytes, even if in some architectures, a word was a byte. That's because the term "word" was more widely used back then from what I can tell. Nowadays it's much more meaningful to give the actual size in bytes rather than words simply because 8-bit bytes are common throughout most modern computer systems.
stelonix··on Fernando Corbató, a Father of Your Computer (and Your Password), Has Died
That is one of the most worth to watch videos ever. I also had no idea it was a "precursor" to UNIX, so it kind of amazed me as if I was understanding time-sharing for the first time in my life.

I also really like how he's describing what I know as an OS, but before that term was used. He also mentions magnetic disks and terms like "words" (we use bytes now), "supervisor" (would be OS) and "alarm clock", which gives me a feeling of the turning point between huge expensive computers and personal computers. The work of this man and his team is truly the birth of computers as we knows them.

RIP

stelonix··on What it’s like to pursue a dream for 30 years and fail
Goes to show how much marketing is enormously important for a product. I only realized he compared to vehicles after reading your comment, because I had closed the video before it showed up.
stelonix··on Adding Glue to a Desktop Environment
Brother, I'm sorry, but your post was very hard to understand, because you touched on many different subjects and linked several different comments from different times.

I'd like to point out my like of X11 over Wayland is not based on "retrocomputing". I'll try to clarify what I meant.

I know of X11's shortcomings, I have my own pet peeves with it, yet my issues with X are very different from the usual complaints you see in the wild. Although I agree X11 is pretty bad, when compared to Wayland it's like comparing a modern smartphone to a Symbian. I have issues with:

- the async way X11 operates; many, many times I've had clicks that lag a few milliseconds and end up pointing to the wrong window

- the whole event propagation model is awful, making it either an insecure system or a pretty cumbersome system to hook into events

- the over-using of the UNIX philosophy everywhere makes X11 feel like a bunch of brittle parts stuck together with cheap glue; none of the systems know much about each other

- the fact the client needs to be trusted on most of the properties it sets is simply stupid; some clients, to this day, still do not set, for example, _NET_WM_PID and for some reason Xorg developers decided it was a good idea to allow such important Atoms to be OPTIONAL. There are MANY simple tasks that are next to impossible under X11, like figuring out which window has the focus. This is RIDICULOUS

- some of its' internals must be so heavily intertwined together that I still get occasional crashes for reasons completely unrelated to window management or the GUI system

- toolkits; here is probably the number one reason there won't be a year of desktop on Linux: no one coming from any other OS understands why widgets look different, be it an user or a programmer who just wants to make a simple GUI app.

With all that said, the issue with Wayland is that it does not fix any of that. Worse, for some of those issues, it makes it even more difficult to work with.

I come from WINAPI/GDI, and before starting with X11 coding, I loathed it. I now see Windows GDI + WINAPI as the best designed GUI system I've coded for. Even with ALL OF ITS' SHORTCOMINGS, I can do everything I could imagine with windows objects: move windows, focus, unfocus, get keyboard input, change colors, change fonts, change text captions, completely hook into how client AND non-client area is drawn, override event procedures... The list goes on, WINAPI+GDI is a complete, consistent system; and because of politics, X11 devs time and time again refuse to make a solid system like it.

And Wayland comes from all those caveats and does not fix them: it maintains the same stupid politics and makes things EVEN HARDER to work with. It's akin to developing for an Android-like OS on a desktop computer. And the REASONS used to explain why Wayland exists are simply propaganda: they say X11 is old and unmaintainable, the code is awful, yadda, yadda. Those people must have never looked into the X11 codebase, because it's one of the most well-written and well commented pieces of code I've seen in my whole life. Here, take a look:

https://github.com/mirror/xserver/blob/master/dix/events.c

So, in conclusion, we do not need Wayland, we need X12, to fix the caveats, quit the over-engineered UNIX-everywhere design decisions, have a standard toolkit and event model, have a standard way for IPC and inter-window communication, sane defaults etc. Wayland is not the answer; Wayland is akin to shooting your only cow because it was infested with ticks! You don't kill the cow, you give her medicine so it gets better, because if you kill her, you'll also lose your daily milk supply! That is not smart.

stelonix··on Adding Glue to a Desktop Environment
I am not. There are some of us who disagree "Wayland is the future". Some of us believe Xorg is great, tried and tested through many battles over the last 20 years. I have no intention or interest in switching to Wayland in the near future, too.
stelonix··on Show HN: Visalist – Find visa requirements for countries around the world
I disagree with the GP comment, something like this is exactly what I needed about a month ago, due to possibly needing political asylum. Speaking of which, I'll take the time to suggest you, if you can, to add information whether a given country is a signatory of the 1967 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees. Thank you for the great work!
stelonix··on Ask HN: Have you ever regretted working on a product?
When you say "you thought" do you mean you were somehow tricked by higher ups?
stelonix··on In Brazil, it is considered rude to be on time to a party
I am Brazilian and can confirm: in pretty much every state I've been to (some 10 in total), no event starts on time, there's always a delay, even if minuscule.
stelonix··on Gravity – An embeddable programming language
> also serves as a nice illustration of the fact that if tabs are allowed in source code, people will mix them with spaces

This seems disingenuous, I could just as well point to a piece of code and say "if spaces are allowed in source code, people will mix them with tabs". People should get over themselves and accept some people prefer a single character to specify tabbed-space and other people want the exact number of spaces. I find space characters cumbersome to work with, so I use tabs myself.

stelonix··on Reddit just passed Facebook as #3 most popular website in US
So, your comment is a pretty good example why I find Reddit such a toxic place. It's filled with absolute truths, and if you disagree you're a bot, a shill. You make a rational, logical, thoughtful comment but if you disagree with the "hivemind" someone else will just dismiss you with some dumb one-liner, eg. "How much does the FSB pay you?". Nowadays for example it's Russo/Sinophobia. I'm not talking about Trump supporters either, I'm talking about accounts which seem to be from every direction of the political spectrum repeat jargons and falsehoods without previously being given some critical thought into.

While we only hear about Russia's and China's cyber ops on western news outlets, whenever I look into Reddit it feels quite the opposite. It feels like the perfect place to foment war, jingoism and xenophobia. Just look at /r/worldnews.

stelonix··on Steve Wozniak Recounts His Efforts to Engineer the Apple II Floppy Disk System
I couldn't disagree more. The raw transcribed text made me feel immersed in the storytelling.
stelonix··on A Recycled IP Address Caused Me to Pirate Books by Accident
This. The article was interesting but the copyright knighthood put me off.

What if the person was simply serving those files for himself over the internet (I've done it countless times) and Google caught it because the author was careless with handling DNS entries? Now DO has an IP and an accusation, more power is given to the DMCA-strike-first-ask-later status quo, all for what? It's not child pornography we're talking about, it's books for Christ's sake. There's no harm, it does not affect your life, why go through the effort of bringing trouble to someone else because of your own lack of care with sensitive issues such as DNS entries?

stelonix··on Our democracy is broken. Why can't technology fix it?
Although I agree online voting should be obvious over the globe in 2018, what intrigues me more is why we're still using a system where the elected have zero responsibility with their campaign. Nothing happens if a politicians promises X and delivers Y or even worse, delivers the opposite of X.

In a civilization that has shown time and time again politicians are most often in bed with corporations and not with their electorate, why are we not using smart contracts for that? Why is it we are not using machine learning to find out when judges apply different sentences for the same crime depending on whether the accused is black or white, something pretty common in my country?

Since I first understood how deep learning works, I've been puzzled by the lack of verification we could be doing in order to mathematically detect corruption, injustice, prejudice, racism, hatred. All the tools are there, yet our laws and elections conveniently ignore those technologies and we're stuck in a system where we have to trust trust. What is so inherently good with the current system that we ditch mathematics, our most basic objective language and keep on using a system based on lies, promises that never come to happen and lobbying? There's something clearly rotten with the current concept of "democracy" being used in this planet yet the only tools which can fix it are ignored.

stelonix··on At My Lai: The Photographer Who Captured the Massacre
You're suggesting there isn't an ideology moving the US government? Every country has an ideology, a doctrine or something like that, and independently of the sheer number and diversity of its population, what's ALWAYS discussed when someone mentions a country is its government and its policies, including foreign policies. You're bringing a no true Scotsman to the table, which is a fallacy. From its foreign policy on Vietnam, the US does not seem to "give a shit" as the OP said.
stelonix··on At My Lai: The Photographer Who Captured the Massacre
I believe this view also does not consider economic and government system hegemony as a good reason to end lives. Many of the people who lived those massacres, from Vietnam to Iraq seem to agree with this view. Since I come from a country that has also been victim to American interventionism I tend to agree, our lives are more important than capitalism, communism, war on terror or whatever it is the excuse of the times for invading sovereign nations and slaughtering its people.

I believe we who see that "metaphor" rather see it as the truth: US soldiers go to countries they know nothing about and kill everyone. I do not fancy being murdered. Killing people is wrong, plain and simple.

stelonix··on In a first, U.S. blames Russia for cyber attacks on energy grid
It did not start with the Ukrainian coup, but rather with the Georgia conflict back in 2008. Can't really blame the Russians, what do you think it'd happen if a pro-Moscow government were elected in Mexico? What would be the US' reaction?
stelonix··on Electron 2.0.0 beta
That's not what i'm talking about. Qt is cross-platform after all. I'm saying there's no consistency in the concepts, how things are built. A Listview in GTK is very different from a Listview in Qt or wx, for example. They fire different events at different points of their cycles, they have different properties, different ways to be customized etc.

You can't, for example, simply fire Spy++ and check what a given widget is doing, as you can with GDI. The lack of a basic widget building block in X11 makes each one implement the very basics their own different way. And when they need to talk to each other, it's at the very least an unpleasant ordeal.

stelonix··on Electron 2.0.0 beta
Yes, I have. Here's some to name a few: GTK, Qt, wx, Fox, fltk...

Yes, I agree, Qt just works. My initial point was and still is about interoperability. They don't all speak well with each other and there are many good, useful applications in toolkits other than Qt or GTK.

stelonix··on Electron 2.0.0 beta
It's not just about development, there are numerous applications built in different toolkits which many of us use everyday. Some of these apps are closed source, so suggesting a rewrite in Qt is out of question.

Don't get me wrong, it would be awesome if we could compromise on any given toolkit, but do you honestly see any of them waving the white flag?

Meanwhile, on Windows for example, there's a standard way to write GUI apps, standardized, well-known and consistent APIs to deal with GDI's toolkit etc. It's awful to write GTK apps just as it's painful to write in pure WINAPI GDI, but GDI has the advantage of being the default, so that "native look" is consistent across most applications since the 3.1 days.

Then comes the community: we have 20+ years of GUI programming happening on Windows, most people simply stick to GDI + self-made custom controls. The outcome is a huge knowledge base that helps get anything and everything done on Windows. Here in the UNIX world over the same time period the GUI developers are spread among different toolkits, so we have many "ok" people in a dozen toolkits and few experts on each one.

stelonix··on Electron 2.0.0 beta
When you look at the Linux desktop software stack, I can't condemn anyone for choosing js+html+css over what's available.

There's no consistency between the dozen "toolkits", each one with its own way of doing things and a lack of interoperability. If you ever had to work with X11's concepts of drag'n'drop, windows, input etc. you probably know what I'm talking about. Dozens of toolkits, few of them talk to each other. It's a mess. Electron just works.

People who would have built a proper desktop application simply don't because the tooling, the environments, the standards (and lack thereof) are awful.

The whole concept of "toolkits" is what makes the situation a complete mess.

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →