Now that crt royale... Color me impressed! Gonna try it as soon as I get access to a PC.
899 karma · joined January 5, 2013
Now that crt royale... Color me impressed! Gonna try it as soon as I get access to a PC.
What interests me is for an open implementation of Street View: drones plus crowdsourcing and we'd be free of requiring Google services for street visualization. We already have open street maps, we could have open street view too.
Notice the ones defending crazy "free" speech are the same who defend crazy capitalism? Yeah, that's the issue: by defending what I call "responsible speech", which is free but not ultimate, we are defending social welfare and human rights AGAINST the former, because the former has no interest in defending the latter. We see it even here in Hacker News, when a corporation does something unethical or morally wrong, there will be someone to say "but hey, the corps are right they exist just give shareholder profit and that's what they're doing". It's a serious debate about sustainable development, which has the very survival of our species at stake.
I used to write for WINAPI/GDI and I used to loathe it; I mostly disliked the way messages were handled by default: huge switch statements. After switching to Linux and checking out the many "toolkits" I find myself craving for some GDI-esque toolkit. GDI was bad, outdated when I started writing it (circa 2009) but things "just worked", looks were consistent and controls would do the same across applications. The GNU/Linux counterpart is a mess: drag & drop sometimes works across toolkits, sometimes it does not; some toolkits are unwillingly to standarize with each other; the looks are all different, the functionalities too. Need an IME? Well here's one for KDE and another one for GTK. And if you use a different toolkit, chances are there's no IME for you. Right clicking on text-boxes and getting the same default options is great, so is being able to extend the same text-boxes systemwide. This is simple on Windows, but GNU/Linux requires one implementation per widget type per toolkit. It's all fragmented and no one cares. I miss GDI, I crave for a simple standard X11-wide widget system. Users do care about widgets working the same on different applications and they don't care about which toolkit is being used, specially non-tech savvy people. I believe those issues are more linked to the meme of "year of the desktop Linux" never arriving than anything else, really: UX should be consistent.
Well now I'll end my rant.
I also really like how he's describing what I know as an OS, but before that term was used. He also mentions magnetic disks and terms like "words" (we use bytes now), "supervisor" (would be OS) and "alarm clock", which gives me a feeling of the turning point between huge expensive computers and personal computers. The work of this man and his team is truly the birth of computers as we knows them.
RIP
I'd like to point out my like of X11 over Wayland is not based on "retrocomputing". I'll try to clarify what I meant.
I know of X11's shortcomings, I have my own pet peeves with it, yet my issues with X are very different from the usual complaints you see in the wild. Although I agree X11 is pretty bad, when compared to Wayland it's like comparing a modern smartphone to a Symbian. I have issues with:
- the async way X11 operates; many, many times I've had clicks that lag a few milliseconds and end up pointing to the wrong window
- the whole event propagation model is awful, making it either an insecure system or a pretty cumbersome system to hook into events
- the over-using of the UNIX philosophy everywhere makes X11 feel like a bunch of brittle parts stuck together with cheap glue; none of the systems know much about each other
- the fact the client needs to be trusted on most of the properties it sets is simply stupid; some clients, to this day, still do not set, for example, _NET_WM_PID and for some reason Xorg developers decided it was a good idea to allow such important Atoms to be OPTIONAL. There are MANY simple tasks that are next to impossible under X11, like figuring out which window has the focus. This is RIDICULOUS
- some of its' internals must be so heavily intertwined together that I still get occasional crashes for reasons completely unrelated to window management or the GUI system
- toolkits; here is probably the number one reason there won't be a year of desktop on Linux: no one coming from any other OS understands why widgets look different, be it an user or a programmer who just wants to make a simple GUI app.
With all that said, the issue with Wayland is that it does not fix any of that. Worse, for some of those issues, it makes it even more difficult to work with.
I come from WINAPI/GDI, and before starting with X11 coding, I loathed it. I now see Windows GDI + WINAPI as the best designed GUI system I've coded for. Even with ALL OF ITS' SHORTCOMINGS, I can do everything I could imagine with windows objects: move windows, focus, unfocus, get keyboard input, change colors, change fonts, change text captions, completely hook into how client AND non-client area is drawn, override event procedures... The list goes on, WINAPI+GDI is a complete, consistent system; and because of politics, X11 devs time and time again refuse to make a solid system like it.
And Wayland comes from all those caveats and does not fix them: it maintains the same stupid politics and makes things EVEN HARDER to work with. It's akin to developing for an Android-like OS on a desktop computer. And the REASONS used to explain why Wayland exists are simply propaganda: they say X11 is old and unmaintainable, the code is awful, yadda, yadda. Those people must have never looked into the X11 codebase, because it's one of the most well-written and well commented pieces of code I've seen in my whole life. Here, take a look:
https://github.com/mirror/xserver/blob/master/dix/events.c
So, in conclusion, we do not need Wayland, we need X12, to fix the caveats, quit the over-engineered UNIX-everywhere design decisions, have a standard toolkit and event model, have a standard way for IPC and inter-window communication, sane defaults etc. Wayland is not the answer; Wayland is akin to shooting your only cow because it was infested with ticks! You don't kill the cow, you give her medicine so it gets better, because if you kill her, you'll also lose your daily milk supply! That is not smart.
This seems disingenuous, I could just as well point to a piece of code and say "if spaces are allowed in source code, people will mix them with tabs". People should get over themselves and accept some people prefer a single character to specify tabbed-space and other people want the exact number of spaces. I find space characters cumbersome to work with, so I use tabs myself.
While we only hear about Russia's and China's cyber ops on western news outlets, whenever I look into Reddit it feels quite the opposite. It feels like the perfect place to foment war, jingoism and xenophobia. Just look at /r/worldnews.
What if the person was simply serving those files for himself over the internet (I've done it countless times) and Google caught it because the author was careless with handling DNS entries? Now DO has an IP and an accusation, more power is given to the DMCA-strike-first-ask-later status quo, all for what? It's not child pornography we're talking about, it's books for Christ's sake. There's no harm, it does not affect your life, why go through the effort of bringing trouble to someone else because of your own lack of care with sensitive issues such as DNS entries?
In a civilization that has shown time and time again politicians are most often in bed with corporations and not with their electorate, why are we not using smart contracts for that? Why is it we are not using machine learning to find out when judges apply different sentences for the same crime depending on whether the accused is black or white, something pretty common in my country?
Since I first understood how deep learning works, I've been puzzled by the lack of verification we could be doing in order to mathematically detect corruption, injustice, prejudice, racism, hatred. All the tools are there, yet our laws and elections conveniently ignore those technologies and we're stuck in a system where we have to trust trust. What is so inherently good with the current system that we ditch mathematics, our most basic objective language and keep on using a system based on lies, promises that never come to happen and lobbying? There's something clearly rotten with the current concept of "democracy" being used in this planet yet the only tools which can fix it are ignored.
I believe we who see that "metaphor" rather see it as the truth: US soldiers go to countries they know nothing about and kill everyone. I do not fancy being murdered. Killing people is wrong, plain and simple.
You can't, for example, simply fire Spy++ and check what a given widget is doing, as you can with GDI. The lack of a basic widget building block in X11 makes each one implement the very basics their own different way. And when they need to talk to each other, it's at the very least an unpleasant ordeal.
Yes, I agree, Qt just works. My initial point was and still is about interoperability. They don't all speak well with each other and there are many good, useful applications in toolkits other than Qt or GTK.
Don't get me wrong, it would be awesome if we could compromise on any given toolkit, but do you honestly see any of them waving the white flag?
Meanwhile, on Windows for example, there's a standard way to write GUI apps, standardized, well-known and consistent APIs to deal with GDI's toolkit etc. It's awful to write GTK apps just as it's painful to write in pure WINAPI GDI, but GDI has the advantage of being the default, so that "native look" is consistent across most applications since the 3.1 days.
Then comes the community: we have 20+ years of GUI programming happening on Windows, most people simply stick to GDI + self-made custom controls. The outcome is a huge knowledge base that helps get anything and everything done on Windows. Here in the UNIX world over the same time period the GUI developers are spread among different toolkits, so we have many "ok" people in a dozen toolkits and few experts on each one.
There's no consistency between the dozen "toolkits", each one with its own way of doing things and a lack of interoperability. If you ever had to work with X11's concepts of drag'n'drop, windows, input etc. you probably know what I'm talking about. Dozens of toolkits, few of them talk to each other. It's a mess. Electron just works.
People who would have built a proper desktop application simply don't because the tooling, the environments, the standards (and lack thereof) are awful.
The whole concept of "toolkits" is what makes the situation a complete mess.