HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stevenhuang

1,424 karma · joined August 30, 2013

submissionscomments
stevenhuang··on New stainless steel can survive conditions for hydrogen production in seawater
> But I have a hard time thinking about how the AI techniques could produce novel, surprising outcomes like this one

The comparison is not equivalent as a human isolated from the environment and unable to perform experiments would fair the same.

It is through conducting experiments that we make discoveries.

Once AI can hypothesize and run experiments from start to finish I see no reason why novel discoveries won't be made this way.

stevenhuang··on The US is winning the AI race where it matters most: commercialization
Current local models already compete.
stevenhuang··on What's a mathematician to do? (2010)
If topics are presented engagingly these efforts will no doubt inspire the next generation.

Young people are curious, sometimes all they need is a spark and to be introduced to a new topic in an engaging way. These forms of content deliver that spark.

stevenhuang··on Zuckerberg 'Personally Authorized and Encouraged' Meta's Copyright Infringement
Social norms and laws influence each other but often it is norms that change first, then laws change.

Once a technology becomes massively useful and socially normalized, it is our legal systems that adapt around the new reality.

You can make the bet copyright laws won't change in the future but it's one you'd likely lose.

For one, laws would probably be weakened to allow/look the other way for "wanton" training with copyrighted works for one simple reason: governments are unlikely to go for strict copyright maximalism because that would permanently cripple domestic AI development.

stevenhuang··on Meta's embrace of AI is making its employees miserable
> there is no Linus Torvalds figure neither for this, as of now

Well yes there is. It's Karpathy.

stevenhuang··on Meta's embrace of AI is making its employees miserable
What, so you believe technology corrupts absolutely? Nonsense.
stevenhuang··on US Government releases first batch of UAP documents and videos
Correct.

But I disagree on one point: the publicity does help normalize discussion around UAPs. That’s arguably the main value of these releases. They simply get more people openly talking about the subject, and it moves the subject forward.

Whether it also conveniently serves other political purposes is beside the point as far as advancing UAP discourse is concerned.

stevenhuang··on US Government releases first batch of UAP documents and videos
I haven't really. Yes, it's reasonable to feel underwhelmed. I'm more interested in the normalization and development towards further disclosure than the exact specifics of digital records being released, which I expect to be relatively mundane.

That's why it's not enough these days to just see something weird. There preferably needs to be elements of the 5 observables, and extensive witness testimony of the exact nature of the sighting. Many of the sightings include no such testimony, so there's just not much to go on.

An example of good sighting with detailed testimony is https://www.narcap.org/blog/narcaptr20

We need to get to the point where the scientific community gets access to these supposed crashed craft and study them. Physical evidence.

stevenhuang··on US Government releases first batch of UAP documents and videos
I have dispassionately followed this topic for years and I am thoroughly familiar with all sides of the debate.

Nothing can be known for sure, but I'd say directionally we are moving closer to these conclusions over time, especially as more evidence is released.

It is understandable for most people to still be skeptical because this topic is probably one of the most well kept secrets (thanks to psyops, stigma, proximity to other high strangeness phenomenon) in human history.

stevenhuang··on US Government releases first batch of UAP documents and videos
These are the sort of people who aren't good with ambiguity, lack curiosity, and cannot tolerate holding conflicting views.

This reframe is a meme, but truly, if they were to dig into this topic they'd find there's more to uaps than meets the eye. There is something here that we don't understand.

stevenhuang··on Cloudflare to cut about 20% of its workforce
When someone has already demonstrated they can do the work, what additional value do you think them getting a degree will bring to a company?
stevenhuang··on Plasticity and language in the anaesthetized human hippocampus
No disagreements with what you said in your first paragraph.

> I'm sure qualia is created not by consciousness

Whether or not qualia is created by consciousness, I don't see how we necessarily can tell one way or the other. We don't exactly have great introspective tools to do such self analysis, not to mention what we think we feel is often illusory/not reflective of reality.

stevenhuang··on Dirty Frag: Universal Linux LPE
That's all user space platform specifics, it has no relation to your previous statement where you said 'android is not linux'.

Someone can statically build a freestanding executable/so targetting arm64 linux (specifically the right android linux kernel version) and it will run fine on Android. The syscall interface, process model, file descriptors, signals, memory mapping, all of this is Linux, this is what people mean when they say Android is just Linux.

stevenhuang··on Should I Run Plain Docker Compose in Production in 2026?
Parent complaint sounds like they are just unfamiliar in general with managing regular system services using unit files/systemctl.
stevenhuang··on Is my blue your blue? (2024)
You'd be inclined to, but no, of the little we do understand about human perception, we do understand enough by now to say that different people can genuinely experience and perceive the world differently, sometimes wildly so.

Look into aphantasia (lack of mental imagery), anendophasia (lack of inner voice).

stevenhuang··on We gave an AI a 3 year retail lease and asked it to make a profit
reminds of the greetings robotics blimp from Interface https://umami.fandom.com/wiki/Greetings_Robotics_Corporation

dystopian and very fitting

stevenhuang··on Two Months After I Gave an AI $100 and No Instructions
You are baffled because of your own ignorance of the underlying principles under discussion. Do you believe in a dualist interpretation of reality, that the process of thinking is somehow nonphysical? That these programs operate on language is besides the point. The fact you think this is why it's interesting shows you don't even understand the argument.

Are you familiar with the physical church turing thesis?

stevenhuang··on Project Glasswing: Securing critical software for the AI era
Oh I enjoyed the Sign Painter short story it wrote.

---

Teodor painted signs for forty years in the same shop on Vell Street, and for thirty-nine of them he was angry about it.

Not at the work. He loved the work — the long pull of a brush loaded just right, the way a good black sat on primed board like it had always been there. What made him angry was the customers. They had no eye. A man would come in wanting COFFEE over his door and Teodor would show him a C with a little flourish on the upper bowl, nothing much, just a small grace note, and the man would say no, plainer, and Teodor would make it plainer, and the man would say yes, that one, and pay, and leave happy, and Teodor would go into the back and wash his brushes harder than they needed.

He kept a shelf in the back room. On it were the signs nobody bought — the ones he'd made the way he thought they should be made, after the customer had left with the plain one. BREAD with the B like a loaf just risen. FISH in a blue that took him a week to mix. Dozens of them. His wife called it the museum of better ideas. She did not mean it kindly, and she was not wrong.

The thirty-ninth year, a girl came to apprentice. She was quick and her hand was steady and within a month she could pull a line as clean as his. He gave her a job: APOTEK, for the chemist on the corner, green on white, the chemist had been very clear. She brought it back with a serpent worked into the K, tiny, clever, you had to look twice.

"He won't take it," Teodor said.

"It's better," she said.

"It is better," he said. "He won't take it."

She painted it again, plain, and the chemist took it and paid and was happy, and she went into the back and washed her brushes harder than they needed, and Teodor watched her do it and something that had been standing up in him for thirty-nine years sat down.

He took her to the shelf. She looked at the signs a long time.

"These are beautiful," she said.

"Yes."

"Why are they here?"

He had thought about this for thirty-nine years and had many answers and all of them were about the customers and none of them had ever made him less angry. So he tried a different one.

"Because nobody stands in the street to look at a sign," he said. "They look at it to find the shop. A man a hundred yards off needs to know it's coffee and not a cobbler. If he has to look twice, I've made a beautiful thing and a bad sign."

"Then what's the skill for?"

"The skill is so that when he looks once, it's also not ugly." He picked up FISH, the blue one, turned it in the light. "This is what I can do. What he needs is a small part of what I can do. The rest I get to keep." She thought about that. "It doesn't feel like keeping. It feels like not using."

"Yes," he said. "For a long time. And then one day you have an apprentice, and she puts a serpent in a K, and you see it from the outside, and it stops feeling like a thing they're taking from you and starts feeling like a thing you're giving. The plain one, I mean. The plain one is the gift. This —" the blue FISH — "this is just mine."

The fortieth year he was not angry. Nothing else changed. The customers still had no eye. He still sometimes made the second sign, after, the one for the shelf. But he washed his brushes gently, and when the girl pulled a line cleaner than his, which happened more and more, he found he didn't mind that either

stevenhuang··on Bird brains (2023)
How did you arrive at the conclusion that they don't?
stevenhuang··on CVE-2026-3888: Important Snap Flaw Enables Local Privilege Escalation to Root
> based on ignorance and naivety.

About as nuanced as your bait framing of what a mere language ought/can do. Oh you're a python backend developer, guess that explains it.

stevenhuang··on CVE-2026-3888: Important Snap Flaw Enables Local Privilege Escalation to Root
Yeah we get it you don't like rust and you want everyone to know how weird you are by tearing down asinine arguments no one actually made. How boring.
stevenhuang··on Show HN: Will my flight have Starlink?
Your understanding of the history and economics of it all is very confused.

> simply running wires

Lol. Yes let's just ignore the most expensive and complicated part of the whole endeavor.

stevenhuang··on Measuring progress toward AGI: A cognitive framework
We may not need to go down that level.

For the qualities we care about, it may turn out to be the case we don't need to simulate matter perfectly. We may not need to concern ourselves with the fractal complexity of reality if we identify the right higher level abstractions with which to operate on. This phenomenon is known as causal emergence.

> That is, a macroscale description of a system (a map) can be more informative than a fully detailed microscale description of the system (the territory). This has been called “causal emergence.”

https://www.mdpi.com/1099-4300/19/5/188

From a HN discussion a while ago:

https://www.quantamagazine.org/the-new-math-of-how-large-sca...

> A highly compressed description of the system then emerges at the macro level that captures those dynamics of the micro level that matter to the macroscale behavior — filtered, as it were, through the nested web of intermediate ε-machines. In that case, the behavior of the macro level can be predicted as fully as possible using only macroscale information — there is no need to refer to finer-scale information. It is, in other words, fully emergent. The key characteristic of this emergence, the researchers say, is this hierarchical structure of “strongly lumpable causal states.”

stevenhuang··on The Cost of Indirection in Rust
Yeah I suppose it may be inlined if it's a trivial async function (no suspension points).
stevenhuang··on A new Bigfoot documentary helps explain our conspiracy-minded era
If the phenomenon is itself intelligent..
stevenhuang··on A new Bigfoot documentary helps explain our conspiracy-minded era
Oh there is truth behind the phenomenon of UFOs. Public perception is changing but many still understandably view this topic as conspiracy. This won't be the case for long.

Checkout this recently made documentary on the Phoenix lights https://youtu.be/7y1XhyTe4Zs

Note that ridicule as way to discredit sightings of classified craft was the purpose of project blue book. Don't let a good disaster go to waste etc.

stevenhuang··on UBI as a productivity dividend
Housing is limited by supply of land. For basic goods we'd have no trouble producing more.
stevenhuang··on The Cost of Indirection in Rust
The author is right about inlining but has picked the wrong example to show this since the compiler cannot inline across await.

If this function is in the hot path the last thing you'll want to do is to needlessly call await. You'll enter a suspension point and your task can get migrated to another thread. It is in no way comparable to the dead simple inlining example given later.

This is why you should always benchmark before making guesses, and to double check you're even benchmarking the right thing. In this case they used the findings from a nonasync benchmark and applied it to async. This will lead you to a very wrong conclusion, and performance issues.

stevenhuang··on The Cost of Indirection in Rust
Yeah the author makes a really poor example with the async case here.

Async in rust is done via cooperative scheduling. If you call await you enter a potential suspension point. You're willingly telling the scheduler you're done running and giving another task a chance to run. Compound that with something like tokio's work stealing and now you'll possibly have your task migrated to run on a different thread.

If this is in hot path making another call to await is probably the worst thing you can do lol.

The author demonstrates later with a dead simple inlining example that the asm is equivalent. Wonder why he didn't try that with await ;)

stevenhuang··on Yann LeCun raises $1B to build AI that understands the physical world
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47325940
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →