HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stevew20

-19 karma · joined January 24, 2017

submissionscomments
stevew20··on Thoughts On Machine Learning Accuracy
I personally believe that facial recognition software will eventually be employed by law enforcement no matter what we do; I also believe that this is a bad thing and lies on the path to a controlling and pervasive police state.

However, this article states clearly that there are recommendations to LE on how to use Rekognition in a meaningful and correct manner for LE's use case. I am highly confident that Amazon will provide technical documentation and manuals for a contract of that size; of course Amazon will not be able to conduct oversight on LE operations. LE may missuse it, the way they've missused Stingrays, stoplight cameras, clipper chips, and other devices.

You state that having 99% accuracy for identifying an individual will do large scale harm, and I agree; what about the 1 person out of every 100 that is falsly identified? The other side to this coin is the number of people law enforcement would miss recognizing without this software... This argument comes down to human ability vs. machine learning ability, and human discretion in interpreting results. I think with proper use it'll be a benefit to identying culprits quickly.

Regardless, it is still pretty evil giving LE any tool that can autonomously monitor people who have not committed any crimes. But who's going to stop them?

stevew20··on Ten years left to redesign lithium-ion batteries?
Lol
stevew20··on Ten years left to redesign lithium-ion batteries?
But the trees man... My god, think of the trees
stevew20··on Amazon’s Face Recognition Falsely Matched 28 Members of Congress with Mugshots
Police have a poor history in the US of exercising trigger discipline. A fair amount of this is due to overly aggressive training that is designed to keep the officers as safe as possible, sacrificing safety of anyone perceived as a threat (real or not), but another large portion is caused by the culture of dominance and entitlement that is endemic to our law enforcement.

If police engage a target with a weapon already drawn, there is a long list of things that person can do that will get them shot, and a very short (and often unclear) list of actions that will keep them safe.

Source: 10 years PMO in the Marine Corps, 1 month SFPD (then quit because their training was so shitty)

stevew20··on Unidentified Plane-Bae Woman’s Statement Confirms the Worst
This is why I support physical violence! If more people were to also follow this mantra, it would immunize all of us from assholes who seek to ruin our lives on the way to fame.
stevew20··on Why Most of Us Fail to Grasp Coming Exponential Gains in AI
Jesus, this is the kinda shallow meaning business jargon BS that make ML SO HARD to explain to the average person.
stevew20··on The dream of driverless cars is dying
How many years did it take for cars to go from beta to wide spread use?

It would be nice if it would happen faster, we could cut the number of car accidents in half, car related fatalities by a quarter, and zero speeding tickets...

stevew20··on Homeland Security’s New Database to Include Faces, DNA, and Relationships
Less accountable governments? You mean governments that are significantly less armed than their populace? Only way I know to keep a government accountable...
stevew20··on Homeland Security’s New Database to Include Faces, DNA, and Relationships
This post is 100% spot on. Ask the folks at Palantir under what conditions a person stops being identified as a 'target' in their database... Hint: everything you do, on a daily basis, can be construed as incriminating.

Source: Worked in an intelligence battalion for 5 years.

stevew20··on NSA encryption plan for ‘internet of things’ rejected by ISO
Though, the NSA did lose the keys to their van full of fun toys to the Shadow Brokers just a couple years ago. In my mind that adds 'incompetent' right there next to 'evil/criminal' on the list of reasons they are untrustworthy.
stevew20··on NSA encryption plan for ‘internet of things’ rejected by ISO
The NSA continues to work against the US national interest by illegally spying on its entire populace, so... Maybe let's not start throwing rocks over glass houses, ya know?
stevew20··on NSA encryption plan for ‘internet of things’ rejected by ISO
Optimized pessimist. You are part of the majority!
stevew20··on US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting sports gambling
Ooooo, I hope the next federal law changes our countries name from "The United States of America" to "Russia"! P.S. please let's all stop supporting our government making more laws. They are shit at it, and we should have MORE freedom, not less. Then we can enjoy life and do stuff, ya know?
stevew20··on Two high school seniors die when Tesla crashes into wall, bursts into flames
If the crash was bad enough to eject someone, then the Tesla catching fire is sad, but probably not why these kids died. Driving their powerful car into a concrete wall is what killed them; the make of the car has little to do with it. This article is written in a overly biased way depicting the Tesla as being at fault for steering off the road and into a concrete barrier and killing these kids; note that every time it references an event leading up to and including the crash, it puts blame on the Tesla...

"when the Tesla they were in crashed into a concrete wall and burst into flames "

"Police said the gray 2014 Tesla Motors Model S may have been speeding southbound"

Damn shoddy journalism here! I'd be ashamed to write such a nasty little article.

I don't want a car that I drive to catch fire in a severe crash, but honestly the possibility of dying in a normal car crash is several orders of magnitude higher than getting into a crash that is not severe enough to kill me instantly, but is capable of breaching the battery housing of the car. I'm more worried about getting bitten by a shark, which has a higher chance of occurring than a Tesla fire...

stevew20··on Facebook now denying access unless EU users opt-in to tracking
As a US citizen, and a former service member, and I can confirm that most independent businesses and corporations are more trustworthy than the US government.
stevew20··on Teenager facing prison for downloading unsecured files from government website
Each officer and official involved in this should face prison, as would any common burgler who holds a family at gunpoint in their own home.
stevew20··on Tesla issues strongest statement yet blaming driver for deadly crash
I vote that ABC News has it's journalism license revoked! All in favor?
stevew20··on The FBI could have broken into San Bernadino shooter's phone without Apple
It seems a very likely strategy for Comey (based on past instances of him lying under oath) to have tasked the unit with breaking into the phone, then simultaneously pushing on Apple to unlock it.

In this scenario, all Comey had to do was NOT ACCEPT the final report from the unit working on the phone, and that project would remain at <100% indefinitely. In a military beaurocracy setting, until a work order or transfer order is signed off by the one who issued it, it is not legally binding as being completed. Also, easy for Comey to tell the unit not to contact him with any details so he wouldn't have to purjure himself.

In any case, he really should be in jail, as he is a total sociopath and all of those FBI guys are guilty of watching kiddy porn.

stevew20··on The FBI could have broken into San Bernadino shooter's phone without Apple
Maybe they fired all the good investigators and hired data analysts, and are having serious buyers remorse!
stevew20··on CNN.com quietly turned on TLS/HTTPS over the weekend
Strange, given the numerous anti-cryptography articles they've published...
stevew20··on How fast is AMP really?
Don't use AMP... Aweful for everyone involved, except Google.
stevew20··on Internal Facebook posts of employees discussing leaked memo
I like that some of these employee's think they work for a company that is not evil.
stevew20··on Ask HN: What does HN think about adding “A” to STEM?
If art contributes as much as the rest to the well-being and advancement of mankind, then sure, stick it in there!
stevew20··on Velodyne Lidar Inc. baffled by Uber crash
I was really hoping I wouldn't need to be the first person to point this out! Thanks Jeff
stevew20··on What the F*** Was Facebook Thinking? – James Allworth – Medium
Uh, just throwing this out there, people gave up all that information voluntarily. I'd blame them, or more likely their parents, for not using better PII heigene. This article is sensationalist bullshit though... Really, shame on you, comparing FB's use of data that people gave to it with the hack on Target, or with 'losing nukes'... Whoever gave this guy a job writing tech articles made a pretty aweful mistake.
stevew20··on Man guilty of hate crime for filming pug's 'Nazi salutes'
Ouch.
stevew20··on Ask HN: Vulnerabilities in ML frameworks
See relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/1958/

I believe that most ML applications are fool-able by attacks of the same type as would fool a human doing the same task as the ML. The really big difference is the scale of attack required to fool ML vs a human.

For example, let's consider ML processing of camera+lidar data, similar to Google's self driving system, versus a cardboard cut-out of a puppy in the road. A human could be fooled by a really elaborate cardboard cut-out, or one viewed at a high speed. ML is likely to be fooled by a cut-out as well, but the elaborateness required of the cut-out would likely be lower (people would notice it doesn't look normal, while the ML has a much smaller dataset than the average person, and hasn't focussed on cute furry puppies as much). The ML would also likely be much better at dealing with high speeds than a human would be, because we don't have built in lidars and our brains work order of magnitudes slower; but taken to an extreme (ML can't complete processing in time to identify fake), the ML would not be able to tell the difference.

There are certainly other ways to go about it, but I think this is the most straight forward and general 'attack', in that false positives are unavoidable in ML (and in humans).

stevew20··on Ask for Advice, Not Permission (2015)
Pitbull, surprisingly enough, seems to be quite the business person. If you'd like evidence of this, and you, like me, think his music is aweful and his voice grating, take a look at how well he's done. He is more of an entertainer by trade, and he has performed in front of some very illustrious bodies, and invested his time in lucrative ventures. He's overcome a lack of musical talent with really good business moves... In some ways it reminds of Taylor Swift, who, going against her public image, seems to be incredibly shrewd and activistic in business matters, and has repeatedly given big tech companies the bird.
stevew20··on Airbnb is putting AMP at the core of its digital strategy
To those who think this could be a good idea: do some research on AMP, then reevaluate your opinion.

To my mind, AMP is a content reassociation tool, not a content distribution speedup tool. It succeeds in both, was designed as the former, and marketed as the latter. If Airbnb goes through with this folly, how exactly will they retain their business?

Google will be essentially filtering every booking that goes to Airbnb, controlling both the customer and the listings. I see most comments on HN are in agreement with this view, and those that aren't don't seem to meet the quality level normal to HN. Makes you wonder who exactly made this decision...

stevew20··on How UK Spies Hacked a European Ally and Got Away with It
This type of behavior is actually extremely commonplace. These are the ones that were sloppy enough to get caught...
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →