HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stinkytaco

3,062 karma · joined June 18, 2009

submissionscomments
stinkytaco··on PicoLisp
> dependencies are a necessary evil, but still an evil

I'm curious about this assertation. I've also heard that "do one thing and do it well" is a desirable goal and one should offload tasks to other pieces that specialize in that task (e.g. don't write your own crypto, use existing libraries), is there something that makes a programming language different?

stinkytaco··on The value of owning more books than you can read (2018)
> I wonder what it is about the folks who are able to "get into" eBooks.

If you view a book as a one time use, disposable good, it's not hard. That sounds far more disrespectful than I mean it, but if you're the type of reader that's reading many things for pleasure (possibly multiple books a week) and will likely only read them once, they become more like I might view a TV show: something I want to consume conveniently and not necessarily catalog permanently. In that case, eBooks are great.

stinkytaco··on The value of owning more books than you can read (2018)
In my line of work I get asked about the future of books with some regularity. I've got a canned, slightly jokey response by this point, but one thing I point out is that the UI of a book is really very good. Part of it is that we've got a lifetime of experience interacting with it from a very young age, but books can be browsed easily, annotated, and scanned quickly. They have an excellent screen and are easy on the eyes and are quite responsive (generally slow load times in regular use). The search is lacking, but there are generally adequate workarounds for that.
stinkytaco··on Learning algebra in my 60s
I really liked the Common Core early math curriculum. My daughter was taught to do calculations the way I had to come to them myself later on: break the problem apart into easier pieces. A simple example: If you are adding 73 and 29 break it to 70+20 and 3+9. Quick calculations takes the burden off on harder problems later on. Also, she learned to round and estimate and they did lots of practical math applications -- especially in probability -- so she's learned to think of math in a "common sense" way, for lack of a better word. It's easier for her to look at an answer and say "wait, that doesn't make any sense considering the givens".
stinkytaco··on Blosxom: The Zen of Blogging
I think Moveable Type is still a going concern. I think there's even a hosted platform.
stinkytaco··on Ask HN: Any great books about technical writing?
Somewhat interestingly, Ted Chiang, in my opinion one of the best writers working in science fiction today, worked as a technical writer for Microsoft. However, he has said that they are very different and he doesn't feel one really impacts the other [1]. I'm not entirely sure I buy that, but it is interesting to see someone who's worked in both mediums talk about the connection.

[0]:https://electricliterature.com/the-legendary-ted-chiang-on-s...

stinkytaco··on MIT, Autodesk develop AI that can figure out Lego instructions
This is entirely beside the point, but I think Lego instructions were my first real foray into technical documentation. It's surprising how well they worked. Their ability to boil down a complicated process into something a 10 year old could follow was impressive. As I got older I sort of dismissed them as antithetical to creativity, but after doing Lego robotics with some kids I began to realize the value I got from them.
stinkytaco··on Cinema’s greatest scene: ‘Casablanca’ and ‘La Marseillaise’ (2015)
> Would Brazil 1970 beat Spain 2008

No. Spain 2008-2012 may be the best overall international team of all time. Too organized even for the front five of Brazil.

> Man Utd 1999

Yes. Good team, but a lot of things broke their way that season and they were defensively somewhat weak. Though Schmeichel was one of the first goalies to be very good with the ball at his feet, so that may give an advantage in the modern game.

I think the exercise is fun partially because it makes us ask questions about the game, how it's changed and where it's going. To answer this question you need to think about the modern tactical game, the backpass rule, how players have changed and all the other factors that make me interested in a game.

In the same way evaluating movies makes me think about the context of a movie and how it was made rather than just a pure evaluation of its "quality".

stinkytaco··on Notation as a Tool of Thought (1979)
So long. Bookmarks, pocket articles, org-roam notes, things jotted in notebooks, I even have an org capture template that quickly populates a list of "recommended media" (books, movies, etc) from friends and relations. Maintaining my list of things to read or watch has become a hobby unto itself.

Every once and a while I go through some[1] of it and ask myself "Will I ever actually look at this"? Sometimes there's a clear answer, but more often it stays in the list because it still looks interesting and I only consume maybe 5-10% of what I saved. There's got to be some term for this. Digital hording? It makes me anxious to have it and anxious to just delete it. There are plenty of times I do remember something I saw and wish I could find it again, but I lean too hard into "maybe I'll think about this again and want it".

[1]: It's so long I generally lose the will to even evaluate the items after a while.

stinkytaco··on Kanopy – Stream films with your public library or university card
It would be. Making unlimited ebooks available would be even cheaper than that. But neither of those really fits the business model of the publisher. A public library is already a compromise in the eyes on many publishers.
stinkytaco··on Kanopy – Stream films with your public library or university card
For the same reason they pay $80 for a single use copy of an ebook: because users expect it and don't really care about the excuse. Users see that other libraries offer a service, they see the services they want to use and no number of spreadsheets will make them happy with answer "no".
stinkytaco··on Kanopy – Stream films with your public library or university card
Incidentally, Libby and Kanopy are owned by the same company and they are planning some further film discovery focused enhancements in the Libby app this year.
stinkytaco··on Kanopy – Stream films with your public library or university card
A few years ago, I attempted to work out what a circulation cost us calculating things like our collection budget, staff budget, etc. vs number of circs. It came out to about $2.50 or so. Keep in mind there are some serious limitations; for example, the buildings are a fixed cost and there would need to be a precipitous drop in circulation to lay off staff, but it gave a rough idea of what it costs to buy something, check it out, re-shelve it, etc.
stinkytaco··on Kanopy – Stream films with your public library or university card
The library signs up with Kanopy. Sets restrictions on who can use the service and how often, then makes it available to their patrons.
stinkytaco··on My 40-liter backpack travel guide
Not OP, but I have a lot of experience with Merino wool.

My opinion is that it's great, but expensive and not durable as outerwear. It snags easily and if you're wearing the thinner stuff, you will end up with runs and even tears after a while. If you can afford $60 t-shirts, that might be fine for you, but I haven't had a wool t-shirt that it didn't wear through the armpits on after a couple of years of regular wear. The thicker stuff holds up a bit better, but is obviously not as nice in hot climates. If you're wearing it as a base layer in a cooler climate, I love it.

stinkytaco··on My 40-liter backpack travel guide
For readers not at all familiar with American idioms, "astroturfed" is a response to "grassroots". A "grassroots" movement in American slang is one that is bottom up and not driven by advertising, corporations or political parties. Astroturfing gives the appearance of being grassroots when it is not.
stinkytaco··on My 40-liter backpack travel guide
> In my electronics bag I carry a short extension cord, some USB plugs and charging cables, etc. That'll make you the hero in every cafe you go to.

A small power strip might have been my best travel investment. Good way to meet people if nothing else.

stinkytaco··on Cool desktops don’t change
> Yeah it's kind of weird that people want things to work as well as they do in Xorg. While I completely understand that it works very well for you, the "for you" doesn't actually make it so for me.

But the converse is also true. Just because it doesn't work for you, it doesn't mean that it's in and of itself bad. Why would you be mad at Wayland if Xorg works for you? In that case it seems like there's really nothing at all to comment on.

However, the fact that there is so much discussion around this leads me to believe that X doesn't work for many people and that seems to be the fault of Xorg, not Wayland, so I don't understand why Wayland comes in for so much of the criticism. Wayland devs identified some problems and set out to fix them, this shouldn't really have any impact on Xorg at all, right? Just continue to use X.

EDIT: And to be clear on a point, it's not that I think Wayland should be immune from criticism. It's missing features and there are probably things that are broken. But the tone of the discussion (and of other comments in this thread) is that Wayland is bad for the community. That its very existence is somehow an affront. That's what I don't really get.

stinkytaco··on Cool desktops don’t change
Yet... it's still the only way I can use mixed DPI displays. I'm sure all of these concerns are justified in one way or the other, but no one's really given me a lot of other options. A quick environmental scan reveals two serious contenders: Xorg and Wayland. Open source precludes the idea of a grand conspiracy, so I'm not sure why no one's working on an alternative if it's as bad as you say.

It's a bit like complaining about factory conditions in China. I'd sure like to buy a computer from somewhere else, but I'm sort of left without a bunch of options so I shrug my shoulders and hold my nose and hope the market sorts it out. Ironically, this is one of the issues that puts me off upgrading to another HiDPI display, thus necessitating my need for Wayland...

stinkytaco··on Cool desktops don’t change
> Wayland isn't going to happen.

I'd be very disappointed by this because I'm in a mixed DPI environment and I need its support.

Seriously though, I find hostility toward Wayland so weird. I could kind of understand it with systemd, but X seems perpetually stuck in 2005.

stinkytaco··on Apple Could Kill CAPTCHAs with Private Access Tokens
I'm nervous about how these technologies impact public computing like public libraries or other shared networks. We still occasionally run into sites flagging our network as spam and requiring additional attestation (something your average public library user can't really understand or even sometimes cope with) and further barriers make it harder to work around at point of need and more challenging for administrators. I completely understand how this happens, but it's also another way we widen the digital gap with good intentions.
stinkytaco··on Lead poisoning probably did not cause the downfall of the Roman Empire
I agree this is a troll, but I'd like to point out a few things:

> - Not going far from home, but using ~23 liters of gas($50 @ 210/L) just to get there?

Absolutely could see this. I live in the US, but the nearest spot I'd like to go camping is probably a $50 round trip. And I'd like to camp in different places, so we're starting to look at $50 being entirely reasonable if I made a list of places I'd like to camp. Not every trip, but certainly within the realm of possibility.

> - Paying for firewood instead of just collecting it?

For what it's worth, this is not allowed in many parks.

> - Spending $25/person/day on food?

This doesn't sound insane in the context of a trip, even a camping trip. You'll probably buy some special meat to grill, marshmallows to roast, some trail mix and maybe stop for food on the way out or back. $25 isn't really that crazy when you're traveling.

stinkytaco··on The scourge of Rec dot gov (2021)
Though I like this idea, as I age, I sympathize with people who are unable to do this for a variety of reasons. I'm sure those people can be accommodated, but that opens the door to abuse, putting us right back in this position.
stinkytaco··on The scourge of Rec dot gov (2021)
It's the angry stream of people you need to turn away that becomes the issue. It's not confusing, it's just time consuming and frustrating for all involved. Doubly so if there's an event the overwhelms your normal facilities and staffing.

I recall a bedraggled stream of cars and park officials when I camped to see the solar eclipse in Nebraska. All very nice people, one even drove around to issue protective lenses to all the campers that didn't bring them, but I sure sympathized with those who didn't make reservations and those who had to disappoint them.

stinkytaco··on The unreasonable fight for municipal broadband
I don't. I work in municipal government and if anything the firewall is greater here than it is the private sector because we know all the rules. We handle citizen data in all sort of ways and the police don't get automatic access to it just because we share a boss. There are plenty of good reasons to question who handles your data and how in government, but assuming that they are in league with the police is not one of them.
stinkytaco··on College became the default – Let's rethink that
I'm a college educated, well off person and most of my social circle is as well and they are very much on this train. My question is always, "What do you want your child to do?" It's very easy to send other people's kids to trade trade schools.

I come from a family that immigrated and worked in trades (cooking, baking, manufacturing, etc.) and I'd like to think I have a great deal of respect for those professions. But the pay is often poor and the work is hard and risky. A radical rethink of how we treat skilled labor and the long term well-being of the people who do it is required before I actively encourage anyone who's not already expressing interest to go into a trade.

stinkytaco··on College became the default – Let's rethink that
We also need more support for people who work trades. Often those are jobs you cannot work until you are 65 or that involve non trivial amounts of physical risk. It's not just the current stigma, it's the long term social impacts. I'll have a comfortable retirement and can work until I'm 70, a welder likely doesn't have a 401k and can work until they are 50.
stinkytaco··on Pronounce GIF · the Correct Way, Without Question
Except the way it's pronounced in the song is not the way the English pronounce it, if that's what you mean. The emphasis is on the first syllable in the song and on the second in the British English. It's like someone who has heard someone imitating and English accent wrote the song.
stinkytaco··on Pronounce GIF · the Correct Way, Without Question
I've actually never heard it pronounced "Jiff" in conversation. Ever. I'm not going to categorically claim that people don't do it, because anecdote isn't evidence, but I've only ever heard the word "jiff" in the context of an Internet debate I'm increasingly believing is made up.

EDIT: Additionally, I've never heard anyone say po-tah-to or toe-mah-to outside of the song. Where does this urge come from?

stinkytaco··on White House warns of 'extraordinarily elevated' March inflation
UBI != stimulus. The vast majority of this money went into state and local governments which led to infrastructure projects, expanded social programs, etc. which have large ripple effects in the economy. I'm not really on one side or another regarding UBI, but it's faulty to compare large scale government spending with UBI. The demand is in different places. It's also faulty to lay this strictly at the feet of stimulus when the seismic shift in the global economy and workforce also play a role.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →