HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stinkytaco

3,062 karma · joined June 18, 2009

submissionscomments
stinkytaco··on Facing sky-high connection fees, rural Ontarians go off the grid
> They are the roots for growth, where in cities, the marginal value they contribute is a fraction of what they can contribute outside of one.

It sounds like you are ascribing some special virtue to rural living that I just don't see. When I think about work that adds social value, very little of it requires rural living (farming, mostly) and most of it can be done anywhere (computer programming, skilled trades, manufacturing, etc.). Why is a person's contribution bigger if they are rural? What special value is there in doing these things in a place no one lives? Why do we need to increase growth in some arbitrary rural location.

> There is a prevailing political worldview predicated on warehousing people in cities and making them dependent on public services

And ironically, you are arguing that we should be providing these people a public service, presumably because they are dependent on it. I fail to see where the cut off should be.

stinkytaco··on Facing sky-high connection fees, rural Ontarians go off the grid
> The govt needs rural people settling remote areas more than those people need govt.

I'm not sure I agree with this, but I'm curious to hear your logic. My understanding is that more urbanization is required for both environmental and infrastructural reasons.

stinkytaco··on The ‘Dune’ Screenplay Was Written in Movie Master on MS-DOS
For DOS specifically, there is a market. So much of one that I can buy PCs with FreeDOS preinstalled. DOS, specifically, is used in many embedded applications that do not require multitasking (digital display boards, point of sale systems, etc.). That's not exactly addressing the question, but one of the things that makes a successful business is finding a niche and exploiting it and though there may not be a mass market consumer market, there are definitely companies making money with "old tech".
stinkytaco··on The ‘Dune’ Screenplay Was Written in Movie Master on MS-DOS
I think the Dana has an SD card if that's more your thing. Those things are also pretty indestructible and relatively cheap on ebay.
stinkytaco··on The wealthiest 10% of Americans own a record 89% of all U.S. stocks
Perhaps this is a foolish question, but how do retirement accounts fit into this? I assume many of us have retirement accounts that own parts of mutual funds or ETFs, are those counted, or are the banks that managed those considered the "owner" and we're just getting a share?
stinkytaco··on The City of London Is Hiding the World’s Stolen Money
Whoa, whoa, let's not get carried away with such broad accusations.

After all, sometimes it's New York.

stinkytaco··on Firefox Suggest (address bar based ads, currently limited to US)
Genuinely curious if this could possibly work when there are so many free option pre-installed on devices (Edge and Safari) or only a click away (Chrome). What would you have to charge willing users a year to break even on this?
stinkytaco··on Firefox Suggest (address bar based ads, currently limited to US)
But Google is funding them with... advertising money. Collected from your searches and search suggestions. I'm really unsure why reliance on Google is better than other options?
stinkytaco··on Firefox Suggest (address bar based ads, currently limited to US)
> It is not Mozilla's job to profit off its users. Its job is to provide a browser.

Firefox is a non-profit, but it needs revenue to provide that browser to users. Right now most of that revenue comes from Google (and its search suggestions, also enabled by default, I think). I'm not sure how you expect it to do its job for free, and it seems to get nothing but pushback whenever it tries to become more independent. I do not agree with all of Firefox's decisions, but to say they have "utterly failed" feels overstated.

stinkytaco··on Firefox Suggest (address bar based ads, currently limited to US)
> What should we do about it?

Fork it.

But I'm not sure I agree this is malicious. Perhaps annoying and even poorly thought out, but malicious implies they are actively trying to undermine the project, rather than trying to find ways to break the project's dependence on Google but missing the mark.

stinkytaco··on Internal emails show Zuckerberg and Facebook execs discuss cloning competitors
I don't know that American's don't value it, it's not like everyone's emails are part of the public record after all. The HJC has (probably good) reason to believe that large companies are engaging in anti-competitive practices and it's their responsibility to investigate that and this is one of the major tools to do so.
stinkytaco··on Internal emails show Zuckerberg and Facebook execs discuss cloning competitors
These emails are part of the public record [1], subpoenaed on behalf of the House Judiciary Committee's Investigation of Competition in Digital Markets [2].

[1] https://judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/0006754900067553.p...

[2] https://judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/competition_in_dig...

stinkytaco··on Internal emails show Zuckerberg and Facebook execs discuss cloning competitors
I'm not really sure I see the issue here, though I'm no expert. Isn't this what competitors do? If Facebook failed because Pinterest and WhatsApp overtook them, the comments would be full of "well, they stood pat while WhatsApp innovated". I think it would be neglectful not to see what works and attempt to replicate that success.
stinkytaco··on Pumps run dry at gas stations in Britain
In addition to my sibling comment, I'd point out that the weight of fuel is negligible in this application, especially in a smaller car. A full 14 gallon tank weighs half of an adult male. You'd save more fuel in the long run by losing some weight, but it still wouldn't be that much.
stinkytaco··on Pumps run dry at gas stations in Britain
I think about myself as a pretty standard middle class person who's obviously empathetic to those who have less. But this proves how easy it is to be out of touch an not even realize it. I really had no idea. I just assumed when you filled, you filled all the way.
stinkytaco··on Epic launches anti-cheat support for Linux, Mac, and Steam Deck
> I find between the spyware, bluescreens when trying to move a boot drive to a new box, explorer.exe

I worry that EAC basically amounts to spyware, however.

Also, and this is off topic, but I think Windows Explorer is the best GUI file manager on any platform. Shoot me.

stinkytaco··on Epic launches anti-cheat support for Linux, Mac, and Steam Deck
If anything, this is the reason Linux could hit that point. Desktops are increasingly for specialized applications: gaming, development, content production, etc. If you just need general consumption, you probably have a tablet or phone. I could absolutely see Linux hitting 5% just because people who would never use Linux have stopped using a computer at all.
stinkytaco··on I like e-readers now
In one of the early episodes of 99% Invisible they look at the Oxo vegetable peeler. The conclusion is that by pursuing accessible design, they improved the experience for everyone, which is a theme they regularly return to. It's something I try to think about when "designing" an experience, partially because it narrows my focus quite a bit and is much less overwhelming that trying to think of the myriad ways something might be approached.
stinkytaco··on I like e-readers now
Yes, it's Libby going forward. It fairness, Kindle delivery is very easy if you are not a tech savvy person, which a lot of library users are not. They have a Kindle because they desire the accessibility tools (larger printer, lighter weight) or their kids bought it for them or whatever. Being able to do delivery just like they would buy a book is great. But Amazon requires prominent Kindle branding and locks the Libby app out of their app store, so it's also somewhat annoying if you are a librarian who doesn't want to promote a specific brand. But the Kindle is such a huge part of our user base, it's hard to go back now. Other methods work, there's just nothing as smooth as the Kindle.
stinkytaco··on I like e-readers now
Fair enough.

I can see this being useful for someone with Parkinson's or even someone who just has trouble regularly lifting their arm (they can lift a book and place it, but flipping the pages would just tire their arm out). I now wish there was a straightforward remote control you could buy with the Kindle.

stinkytaco··on I like e-readers now
Amazon has their hooks deep into Overdrive in exchange for supporting Kindle delivery for library books, so I doubt this will ever get better. Overdrive has moved its focus to its mobile app. I hope Kobo support will improve, but I am not optimistic.
stinkytaco··on I like e-readers now
> I've never understood how this isn't a standard feature with standalone Kindles.

Is this an accessibility issue? I work fairly extensively with ebook devices and users in my job and this has never come up, I doubt it even occurs to most people, which probably answers your question. However, I also work quite a bit with accessibility (for which the Kindle is excellent for many common challenges that come with age) and I know users that this would be quite useful for if it was a standard feature, so I'm curious what your use case is.

stinkytaco··on My mouse driver is asking for a firewall exemption (2019)
OK, I did as suggested. Now can I complain about the Twitter format?
stinkytaco··on Ask HN: What's the most life-changing blog post you've ever read?
Every time I see something like this I have two answers: none and all. On one hand, "life changing" is a big word and I have never read anything that I could possibly say had as big an impact on me as, say, having children. It's hard to imagine articles and books are life changing, only that they can contribute to life changing actions.

On the other, nearly everything I've read has changed me and how I saw the world, even ever so slightly. Different perspectives, bits of knowledge, connections made that I'm not even aware of. So I guess I just have to assume that everyone's definition of "life changing" is going to be quite wide depending on their own life experience and attitudes.

stinkytaco··on SerenityOS: Graphical Unix-like operating system with classic 90s UI
Is there a term for something that is absolutely not for you, but that you're still very happy exists? I can't see myself ever using this, but the idea that someone has put that kind of effort in is amazing.
stinkytaco··on My Custom Stream Deck Toolkit
If you're a game streamer, the keyboard might not be an option (since you're using it to play), and that's who it's aimed at, I think. I can definitely see the appeal, just leaning over to tap while in a meeting or watching a video or something. It would be useful in a conference room as well. It's a luxury item, but it definitely fills a niche.
stinkytaco··on A Generation Lost in the Bazaar (2012)
> it becomes attractive (and safer) to deal more in the pseudo-work than the actual work.

More charitably, they feel this work will make the product better. That may or may not be true, but if you've been involved in failures and part of the after action review was "this person should have been consulted because they are the expert in whatever failed", that becomes part of the process. Pretty soon, this refactoring and consultation becomes expected, and so on until we're at the point you are speaking of.

And I say this as someone who is part of the problem. I have unfinished projects right now that are stuck in meetings and consensus building. I want, at minimum, to be able to say, "you were given the opportunity to participate in the process, but you left it to me." but I've also made mistakes and poor decisions for lack of those steps more than once.

I have no doubt that there are people avoiding failure by not shipping, but I do not think it is as simple as that, there are a variety of cultural norms and experience colliding here.

stinkytaco··on A Generation Lost in the Bazaar (2012)
I've worked in environments like that (in and out of software), and this is almost always driven in reaction to something, which is why it's hard to unteach. In my current office there is a culture of consensus building and feedback. If someone feels they were not given sufficient opportunity to participate in a decision, they will complain, resist or otherwise cause an issue in the future. Sometimes they are correct, which is why it's not as easy as simply firing them. Sometimes the red tape is in response to problems in the past. Policies that were poorly enforced that resulted in negative consequences for customers (support failures or discriminatory behaviors). Sometimes it's there to protect low level staff from accusations of the above or to provide clear guidance when dealing with a high stakes/high stress situation. Sometimes it's to protect customers, such as regular security reviews.

So no, I do not think this is about "low effort", though that can be a side-effect. No one sits in an office wanting to find ways to make their coworkers lives difficult. More often than not the policy is a response to pressure to do something to prevent whatever failure prompted the policy. The people who like the process heavy approach, in my experience, anyway, are often remembering a time when failure to follow a procedure resulted in negative consequences for someone.

stinkytaco··on Haiku Beta 3
From the era? Probably not. I like GoBe Productive and actually used PoorMan for some internal stuff, but neither would be sufficient for most uses today.

However, TuneTracker and its associated suite of tools for radio station automation ran on BeOS and then on Haiku. It's been a few years since the website was updated, so I do not know if it's still active, but it was worth running in a very specific setting.

stinkytaco··on Becoming a Chess Grandmaster
Scalabrine is very accessible and does regular interviews and has talked extensively about "The Scallenge" (where he challenged several high level non-professional players in one-on-one). One extremely insightful point he once made on Duncan Robinson's podcast is that part of the reason he's "closer to LeBron" is that he's played LeBron. He wouldn't be a good player if he hadn't played professionally against top-level talent. It might not be worth it to dedicate yourself like that, but that kind of dedication and commitment to competition is probably the only way you will achieve close to a high level and even then, you may end up only an also-ran.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →