HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stinkytaco

3,062 karma · joined June 18, 2009

submissionscomments
stinkytaco··on Show HN: Obsidian for Mobile – Plain-text knowledge base on the go
> Is Obsidian worth trying if one's already using org-roam and is reasonably familiar with Emacs?

What features do you need that org-roam doesn't have? Hard to say if it's worth moving on without knowing that. If org-roam is working for you, then why bother moving? If it's not, why not and does obsidian possess those features?

stinkytaco··on Mozilla rolls out DoH to Canadian users of Firefox
That's not the case in the US. Our ISP will absolutely be within their rights to cancel our service if someone on our network is violating their TOS. And we don't really have the money or the standing to fight it.
stinkytaco··on Mozilla rolls out DoH to Canadian users of Firefox
> And if I run a guest wifi in one of the many countries where I have legal obligations to take steps to block illegal traffic because I am ultimately responsible for the emissions of my network, what would you suggest I do?

This is an oft overlooked part of these discussions. I manage a public network at a library (which is still the only access point for many people, unfortunately). DNS blacklisting certainly isn't the only tool in the toolkit, but it is one that DoH takes out. I'm genuinely conflicted on DoH because on one hand, I am a privacy advocate, but on the other I run a public network and that comes with certain obligations, both legal (we need to block filesharing) and to customers (we do traffic shaping because the budget it limited and bandwidth isn't cheap).

stinkytaco··on We replaced rental brokers with software and filled 200 vacant apartments
Please see: ticket sales: Ticketmaster, Stubhub, etc.

In theory, these make sense and reduce anti-consumer inefficiency like scalping that individual venues are not equipped to deal with. In practice, they extract fees. It's not that they are bad, per se, just that if the opportunity exists, someone with a spreadsheet will spot it, likely with the best intentions but no eye to the overall impact.

EDIT: To be clear, I think these services are a net good. Stubhub allows me to get sports tickets at a reduced price if someone can't go to the game. Ticketmaster stops people from spamming the system to gobble up tickets, it's just that these industries are now going to want a fee for that and we end up back where we started. I'm sure at one time brokers were helpful as well (a landlord free way to compare properties).

stinkytaco··on A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy (2003)
My dad teaches a world religion class and does a unit on religious restrictions (kosher, halal, etc.). He says one of the hardest things to get across to people, even non-religious people, is that rule systems like these are not about practical considerations, they are about defining who is "in" and who is "out". In a time where religion is no longer analogous with ethnicity, this is just not something people really understand anymore.
stinkytaco··on The rise of remote work may reshape college towns
Most vendors license based on students served, not public that pays taxes. If a university is licensing content based on the number of students or faculty at the university, it's likely that they are not allowed to offer it to tax payers. I understand your point is that you are paying, but that will not mean you can walk into a university and demand access. They would need to renegotiate with the vendor.
stinkytaco··on The rise of remote work may reshape college towns
I see a further class divide between people who work from home and those that need to work at a place, either blue collar or service jobs or white collar jobs that require some public interaction (banks, teaching, etc.). This isn't a reason not to shift to remote work, it's just a problem we need to be aware will occur. Workplaces will divide along "office" and "home" lines (they already are, in my observation, with a fair amount of resentment tied in on both sides), and service jobs will shift to where people are living.
stinkytaco··on Show HN: NocoDB – Open-Source Airtable Alternative
Great news. I don't know if anyone remembers this, but there used to be a program called Ecco Pro that Airtable really reminded me of. I haven't run Ecco in probably 20 years to more so I could be entirely off the mark, but the "freeform spreadsheet" seems really similar.
stinkytaco··on Rocky Linux releases its first release candidate
Is RHEL compatibility a must? At this point it feels like the only community solution that has a long term track record is Debian.
stinkytaco··on Snapchat Can Be Sued for Role in Fatal Car Crash, Court Rules
It's not the filter or the speedometer, it's the social incentive. If Twitter created a #highspeedometer hash tag, that would also be encouraging dangerous behavior.
stinkytaco··on Snapchat Can Be Sued for Role in Fatal Car Crash, Court Rules
I think if a social media organization encouraged a #highspeedometer hashtag they could also be liable. It's not the filter or the speedometer, it's that Snapchat set up a defacto social incentive for speeding.
stinkytaco··on Snapchat Can Be Sued for Role in Fatal Car Crash, Court Rules
A speedometer does the opposite of encouraging unsafe behavior by alerting you to the unsafeness of that behavior. The filter in question encouraged unsafe behavior by incentivizing such behavior for social engagement, however absurd you think that incentivization is personally. This is a bit like saying a frat house hazing isn't wrong because no one actually makes the kids drink, the social incentive remains dangerous.
stinkytaco··on Snapchat Can Be Sued for Role in Fatal Car Crash, Court Rules
This reminds me a bit of the McDonald's coffee case, something that seems absurd in a headline, but once you take time to understand it (like a jury or court would), makes a great deal of sense. The court of public opinion is generally a bad place to try things.
stinkytaco··on The Slackware Way (2012)
Not OP, but I'll pitch in because I'm an old Slackware user (late 90s to late 2000s).

Slack was as close as you got to the system you would get if you compiled everything from scratch. Basically, you just had Pat do the package selection and compiling for you. Even the package manager was really just a script to compile the source package. That made for a really clean, simple setup and made it easier to get support for software directly from project forums or mailing lists. If you had an idea of the dependency graph, it was dead easy to troubleshoot because there was no package maintainer making choices that you (or the developer) didn't know about, which cannot be said for Debian.

I really liked it, but Linux got more complicated and I got more busy and eventually I just wanted a system with sane defaults and a choice of DE. Slackware is very opinionated about its package selection and developers have shifted to the reality of systemd so now it's sometimes more of a hassle to get a package working out of the box. As apt improved, I also had fewer issues with Debian, though its sometimes out-of-date repos are frustrating because apt makes compiling from source more complicated than it was on Slack.

If you want the Slack philosophy of close to upstream but the convenience of a modern distro, I think Fedora is the good choice, but I have a soft spot for Slack.

stinkytaco··on At Satoshi’s Tea Garden
> You can probably equate the speculative parts of art collection to it, where the collector (or "investor") may never actually care about the work intrinsically and may never be closer than 1000 miles away from it because they view it solely as a financial asset.

Even this, I assume, is based on the assumption that someone, someday will want to do what you describe (hang it on a wall and have exclusive access) and pay you for the privilege to do so. Right now, that isn't really possible with an NFT.

stinkytaco··on Nano 5.7
I'm curious what the intended audience for micro is? It seems like if you want extensibility you use vi or emacs. If you want a very quick and dirty program where you use the same 4 or 5 commands every time you open it, you use nano since it's already installed. I don't know a lot of people in the middle, personally, so I'm curious what people who are using micro like about it in particular.
stinkytaco··on Calibre – E-Book Management
I prefer calibre-web[1] and it is under active development.

[1]:https://github.com/janeczku/calibre-web

stinkytaco··on Calibre – E-Book Management
I'm genuinely curious to hear any specific changes you might make. I'm a librarian and I can say that Libby was a huge improvement in usability over the Overdrive app and we spend much less time on basic user support now. There are weird quirks for me as well, but I'm always hard pressed to say exactly what I would change.
stinkytaco··on Calibre – E-Book Management
I think there are other contributors, but he rubs lots of people the wrong way, so probably not as many as there could be.
stinkytaco··on Fedora Linux 34 is officially here
What issues are you having with Ubuntu? Hard to say if Fedora is worth a switch without knowing that detail.

If you are satisfied with Ubuntu and it's meeting your needs, then I would argue there is not enough in Fedora to warrant switching. This isn't to say there's lots of things to like, just that my tolerance for disruption is pretty low.

stinkytaco··on IBM employee forced to stop kernel work under personal email address
> As a human being you are entitled to personal time.

I wonder about this in 2021. Social media and ubiquitous recording has changed what seems like an obvious truth into something more complex. A company employee badmouthing customers? A police officer who posts something racist? Attending a political demonstration? An employee who's working on a competing product in their spare time?

I don't have answers to these, but somewhere, the line became blurry.

stinkytaco··on Why has no one made a better Goodreads
I assume the effort, time and money required to get to "enough value to enough number of users" will require you to answer the "ways to monetise" question for a VC or even yourself before you start.
stinkytaco··on Luca App: CCC calls for a moratorium
At least in the US, some of it is the vagaries of government acquisitions. The requisition process is one that works fairly well for services and products that are established and largely interchangeable, but is more difficult for something that's either emerging or complex. So it's fairly straightforward to say "I require a piece of construction equipment that does something" and then go view a few off-the-shelf options and pick the best price. But for software and services, especially things that don't exist, the existing requisition process doesn't work well. You're required to plan very far ahead in a market that moves quickly. By the time you get to bids, the requirements have likely changed, but it might be too late to go back and change requisition without going through an approval process again. It also requires you boil down a process into a series of atomized pieces that can be scored so you've got a clear paper-trail of the acquisitions process.

It's a system that benefits vendors that can manage the red tape that's there to prevent corruption.

stinkytaco··on Denmark to permanently cease using AstraZeneca vaccine
I'd really like to see some data on this, because that's a giant assumption to make. There's many reasons an able person would choose to work in public health beyond that they are apparently too bad at medicine to do anything else.
stinkytaco··on HW accelerated Xwayland rendering for Nvidia merged
On the other hand, a bunch of X11 issues were just listed, and X has existed three times as long. Some issues are architectural and thus probably not solvable, some are just persistent annoyances that must be difficult to fix and likely will not get fixed because X11 has so little active development anymore. X has enough issues that a good portion of the community said, "we've got to fix this". And frankly, I've used software from multi-billion dollar corporations that gives me more trouble in a day than Wayland does in a month.
stinkytaco··on Giant Ship Is Moved To and Fro to Break Suction: Suez Update
If there was a article on HN about a company sunk by its excessive inventory and storage costs, we'd all be kibitzing about how they should use JIT inventory. Some companies make mistakes, some people aren't as expert as they think, but in aggregate I can't really do anything but assume that other people know more than I do about most things.
stinkytaco··on Serenity notes: E2E encrypted notes
Few things here:

1. Note taking apps are easy to build.

2. Note taking apps are something many of us want and take pretty seriously (you say you find a deal breaker in a workflow as basic as note taking, which seems to indicate this is something you take quite seriously).

3. We have a desire to tweak our setup for whatever reason. Whether it's "if I can solve this one problem everything else will fall into place" syndrome, motivation, solving an actual problem or simply to avoid real work, productivity porn creates clicks.

So yeah, I'm pretty tired of it, but I don't think fatigue has yet set it because it scratches and itch in many people.

stinkytaco··on Avoid Consumer Routers
Isn't Merlin just the Asus firmware with some additional features? From a security perspective it does not seem like an upgrade since it still includes many proprietary Asus blobs.
stinkytaco··on Fitbit is doomed: Here's why everything Google buys turns to garbage (2019)
Especially when they have tons of counter examples: Android, Youtube, Gmail, Docs, Drive (and all the educational contracts those include), Cloud... I'd be willing to bet that if I wanted to use the Internet and not interact with Google I probably couldn't do it for long. At the very least I'm willing to bet that some organization I need to interact with is using Gmail for Business.
stinkytaco··on Has Y Combinator lost its way when the latest company is a Mac only widget?
I think the point was that Dropbox was not at the time viewed as "seamlessly moving data around". We see it in retrospect as revolutionary, but that was certainly not the view at the time since many of us had already seen online storage platforms come and go (xdrive, anyone?).

I will not comment on whether this calendar app is revolutionary, it might not be, but it's also possible it is something that will make an impact. There's lots of untapped potential in the calendar and event space, in my opinion.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →