HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stnikolauswagne

257 karma · joined June 24, 2021

submissionscomments
stnikolauswagne··on On A.I. regulation and messaging
Yeah, thats why I meant I was in a spherical cow-situation, this was a situation where we took over a company in the exact same field and I had 5 years of experience on which tweaks would need to be made to be able to rationalise away positions.

This sort of system only works with internal software and an unusual amount of data. If we were in the business of selling that software we could not have charged a higher price for the new version over the old, the tweak could only be unlocked because we were able to control staff hiring and staff onboarding fully to make use of the new changes.

stnikolauswagne··on On AI regulation and messaging
Can only speak for my own project, but can give an example:

After an aquisition earlier this year I got the task of doing an SAP-Integration for the new company, last time I did this 5 years ago it was a 6 month task, but with the experience and skills ive gained since I estimated it would be a 3 month project (with or without AI, most work is just logistics, AI cant help much there).

In those 3 months I was able to not only integrate SAP but also deliver a completely modernised user-facing software for that integration. While I could have written that software myself in a vacuum it would have never been worth it financially, since it would have delayed the launch of the integration by 6+ months. Building the software post-launch of the integration would have easily taken 2.5 years at minimum.

But this is also basically a "spherical cow in a vacuum" scenario, where I was essentially acting as a solo dev, in full operational control of the project, with deep domain knowledge of the topic and an allready fully set up codebase that I knew perfectly while working down ideas I've had in my backlog for 5+ years.

stnikolauswagne··on The AI trade now runs on borrowed money, and the lenders are repricing it
I'd argue that data in this case is more like the actual models they use, their codebase and their engineering talent. Not deep enough in the sauce to say one way or another how big the realistic delta between companies is though.
stnikolauswagne··on The AI trade now runs on borrowed money, and the lenders are repricing it
For how long though? If Amazon never built AWS the core business conceivably would still be around today, if Anthropic stopped providing new models two years ago no one would care about them now.
stnikolauswagne··on The AI trade now runs on borrowed money, and the lenders are repricing it
I agree with the general sentiment, but I feel like it is also a bit reductive. Assets in this space are near impossible to evaluate and can fluctuate in value greatly based on other actors. In a hypothetical scenario where, say, google releases a new frontier model that somehow leapfrogs the competition by 5 months all of a sudden the value of the Asset of Fable 5 and GPT 5.6 might completely crater.
stnikolauswagne··on US citizen charged after GrapheneOS phone wipes during airport search
> However, there is zero legal duty for the police to protect someone who is currently under attack from a criminal.

That has to be incorrect, by the time someone is under actual attack from a criminal that criminal will have allready comitted crimes that the police can and have to punish for, i.e. Threat of Force with a Lethal weapon or sth like that.

stnikolauswagne··on Why skilled workers come to Germany and then leave again
I speak german as a mothertongue and fluent english, and I had massive troubles communicating in my own home.
stnikolauswagne··on Why skilled workers come to Germany and then leave again
There is some sort of weird phenomenon that I cant quite put to words, but the core is:

While there is a big chunk of the native german population speaking great english there is a subset of (often) service workers who... dont. Had multiple furniture movers come through my house the last few weeks, the only way to communicate with them was broken german, since they had no english skills and my (croatian? serbian?) skills were zero.

At one point I ended up in the weirdest situation of my live were i translated the german instructions from the phone rep into english to the shift lead of the moving company so he could then give them in the native language to the movers.

stnikolauswagne··on If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)
>I wouldn't call desktop computers or even just laptops "unsuccessful products". Would you?

With the caveat of "Casually browsing the web" I would, actually. They have been near completely subsumed by Ipads or Phones.

stnikolauswagne··on AI agent bankrupted their operator while trying to scan DN42
Im kind of struggling with this logic, because a conscious choice was made to engage with AWS, AWS having opaque billing and the ability to provide a huge amount of compute (even at high cost) at the click of a button should be known to anyone who did his research on providers.

In my mind I could see a true tradeoff to removing the ability to do this. If I'm in a critical situtaion where, say, my service is on the cusp of failing because my revenue 100xed in a short while I know I could just go to AWS, put in some data and buy enough compute to survive as a business.

stnikolauswagne··on AI Engineers aren't safe from being replaced by AI
Much less emasculating than accepting that all that weird tech mumbo jumbo that those overpaid senior engineers babble about actually has a deeper meaning and is not just there to artificially slow down the all important company growth!
stnikolauswagne··on AI Engineers aren't safe from being replaced by AI
Im curious if that point comes before it automates away the entire mid-upper management caste.

In a hypothetical world where LLMs have enough context window and "understanding" to have no need for an experienced user to give inputs I would assume its also going to have enough information to make most business decisions and provide well formatted info to the C-Suite.

stnikolauswagne··on AI Engineers aren't safe from being replaced by AI
Not to mention the fact that even the most well documented codebase will have documentation blindspots about real-world concerns or limitations that LLMs cant know about. Cursor yesterday tried to remove a document format from the codebase because it was convinced that it was non-existant, turns out that not only does it exist and is vitally important for our shipping process, but also the API it comes from does not document its existence at all.
stnikolauswagne··on AI Engineers aren't safe from being replaced by AI
The argument is "Software Engineer" sounds like "Programmer" to me and "Programming" is just typing lines of code, AI can do all that typing quicker than a human so there we go.

Currently leading an Integration that for the most part needs no new code written and the CEO is breathing down my neck telling me to cut my 4 week estimate down to 1 because "can't i just use AI like the other firms do?".

There's a morbid part of me that wants to give him what he wants and let claude make critical process decisions on internal processes that are very domain specific and have no online documentation, but alas I would rather not have the project go down in flames so I smile and nod.

stnikolauswagne··on We replaced Zendesk
As someone who is currently in the process of integrating Zendesk: It seems to have a moat, however directed in the wrong direction. This integration might be my first project failure in the last decade which included two SAP integrations.

There is just so much clunk and developer hostile stuff going on that I would rather just not deal with it anymore.

stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
To properly test an LLM based emergency system against the current as-is system there needs to be a way of verifying whether the LLM detected emergency is classed as an emergency as-is. If this information was available publicaly it could enable bad actors things like stress-testing the EMP-tolerance of the current systems or what level of malware infiltration is detected.
stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
>For recognising that you're in a shit situation, yeah, it'll probably do that fine, but won't be able to give the correct control inputs at the right time.

Even that im not sure of, I know relatively little about aviation safety but I can imagine that there are all kinds of 0.0000000001% percent corner cases that no plane has ever encountered that still need some sort of reaction, who knows how easy an llm can distinguish those from the 0.000000001% corner cases that no plane has ever encountered that are completely fine and can be ignored.

stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
Are all those security systems actually open right now? Because that sounds like an absolute security nightmare if so.
stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
That sounds like a solution looking for a problem though, i see plenty of arguments against throwing critical safety information that are in charge of peoples lives into an LLM "just in case the result is better than the result that the current battle-hardened systems already provide"
stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
Pretty sure ejection here is meant as shorthand for "Transfer the passenger to an entity on the ground to proceed from there" whether that entity is emergency medical services or law enforcement is secondary.
stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
Is there any indication that current warning systems are insufficient in any way that would be improved by LLM involvement?
stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
>never mind that most crashes are caused by humans, very rarely by technical issues going amok

Because humans are the fallback for all the scenarios that the tech cannot reliably cover. And my intuition says that the tech around planes is so heavily audited that only things that work with 99.999...% accuracy work will be left to tech.

stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
Give the whole scheme some sort of mile multiplier and you will get high-freq fliers salivating over taking a llm flight with a 12 hour layover in Iceland to get to Portland from New York for those sweet miles.
stnikolauswagne··on Can Claude Fly a Plane?
>I think it is more interesting to have 99% of flying done with automated systems but have an LLM focus on recognizing unanticipated situations and recovering or mitigating them.

Seeing how Claude (or any current LLM) perform in even the most low-stake coding scenario I dont think I would ever set foot on a plane where the 1% of most risky scenarios are decided by one.

stnikolauswagne··on What not to write on your security clearance form (1988)
Thats why I presume its asking about previous engagements, if they catch someone they suspect of espionage, dig into their background and find proof of previous activity they have a clear fraud charge without having to prove their suspicions about current activities.
stnikolauswagne··on Tesla Cybertruck deliveries on hold as trims are flying off 'bulletproof' truck
>but up immensely compared to France and the UK (which do not)

Have decent sick pay, france seems to pay 20%, UK like 10ish%, makes complete sense that such countries would have less sick days.

>I mean just google. For example:

This is the kind of mediocre dataset I dislike, going to their datasource ( https://gateway.euro.who.int/en/indicators/hfa_411-2700-abse... ) half of germanys neighbours have not reported data for 2022, the graph they use for "EU" seems to just use the data from 2020 and stretch it over to 2022 because thats where the WHO dataset ends.

For example if you check out slovenia in the dataset they have a huge spike in 2022 (similar to germany) but went down a lot in 2023, Germany has no 2023 data so we can't say whether germany went down based on the WHO dataset.

Two papers linked in the article show germany going down to at least 2021 levels in 2023, yet this does not seem represented in the graph.

stnikolauswagne··on Tesla Cybertruck deliveries on hold as trims are flying off 'bulletproof' truck
>Most of German workers work for German companies following German laws and German culture, not American companies. So why twice the sick days versus EU neighbours?

Which EU neighbours are we talking about? A cursory check shows them to be up by like 20ish% compared to czechia and poland, (which have decent sick pay) but up immensely compared to France and the UK (which do not). If #of sick days scales with % of sick pay it would make perfect sense for germany to be on top, do you have a decent dataset on #sick days by any chance? I was unable to find consistent data on this.

stnikolauswagne··on Integrating AI
Easily, I have a somewhat working understanding of the SAP version we run in my head, LLMs love hallucinating columns or endpoints that do not exist. I‘m sure the full SAP documentation easily clears 2 mil tokens. And thats not even touching our own codebase.
stnikolauswagne··on Russia: Citizens must turn off home surveillance because Ukrainians are coming
If this is not a strategic defeat then I struggle to think of what a defeat would actually look like. Ukrainian Troops entering the Kremlim?

They managed to: -get Sweden and Finland to finally join Nato

-completely demolish their entire military export potential

-lose half their warchest because they kept it in foreign banks

-lose all kinds of prestige the „mighty“ russian military had

-severely diminish the arms stocks they had left over from the soviet union

-lose the flagship of one of their fleets to a nation without a navy

-publically had one of their mercenary companies march on their capital in revolt

In exchange the land might gain from this is going to be completely devastated from the war.

Compare all of this to the 2014 fiasco where they ended up with crimea in exchange for some minor-ish sanctions,

stnikolauswagne··on Elon Musk's X gets another valuation cut from Fidelity
For starters twitter is settled with about 12 billion in expensive debt as part of the purchase which cost about a billion of year in interest alone [0].

[0] https://gizmodo.com/twitter-elon-musk-debt-interest-social-m...

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →