HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

strangeattractr

458 karma · joined October 5, 2020

submissionscomments
strangeattractr··on The Software Foundations: mathematical underpinnings of reliable software
Thank you for this comment, you shed some light on something I considered too opaque to dig into and made it clear why this would be useful.
strangeattractr··on Speeding up Go's built-in JSON encoder for large arrays of objects
I enjoyed reading it, as someone who writes a lot of go but hasn't done any profiling of code.
strangeattractr··on How generics are implemented in Go 1.18
Honestly, the lack of enums annoys me far more than the generics ever do. Mainly because we have interfaces.
strangeattractr··on Solid.js feels like what I always wanted React to be
The vue code for this is pretty terse anyway to be honest. A single variable in data, a call to setInterval in the created hook and a few lines of html with template formatting. It's extremely clear what's going on too.
strangeattractr··on Things you notice when you quit the news (2016)
As a counterpoint, I've found The Economist is quite good on my own domestic politics when it does cover it - albeit rarely.

To me this quote underlines the importance of reading news from varied sources rather than not reading it at all. I mean clearly 99.99% of news I ignore, but if I think it's important I'll read about it from multiple papers because the one I primarily read - the FT will have its own viewpoint.

strangeattractr··on Web3 doesn’t care about privacy
I usually find it's the opposite to be honest. Most people that I know that have a good understanding of how the technology works are far more sanguine about what it can and cannot do. Whereas those friends and acquaintances who understand the technology the least tend to be far more zealous in its potential.
strangeattractr··on Royal Society cautions against censorship of scientific misinformation online
This is a commonly suggested solution that fundamentally misunderstands the problem. Most of these people aren't believing falsehoods because they don't have access to better information. It's because they don't trust the institutions that they believe drive science. Additionally, as these annotations only represent an opinion and are subject to change when they aren't correct they likely cause even greater distrust.
strangeattractr··on The Shameful Decline of Scientific American
This is a pretty poor criticism of the normal distribution, for one it doesn't contain a single mention of variance or standard deviation which is as important as the mean. Modelling something with a normal distribution does not say that any member of the sample actually recorded the average value, it simply states that the values cluster around the mean. If the average American household has 2.5 children, it's fairly obvious that there is not a household in the country that has the mean value. I haven't bothered to look at the underlying distribution of children but the principle is the same.
strangeattractr··on Watching video twice at 2x can benefit learning better than once at normal speed
Subtitles can be a massive help if they're accurate when watching sped up. YouTube autogen ones are often distractingly wrong though
strangeattractr··on Watching video twice at 2x can benefit learning better than once at normal speed
Would never speed up something I was watching for enjoyment. I was slightly puzzled when I saw Netflix enable speeding up video, I suppose someone out there must have wanted it.
strangeattractr··on Watching video twice at 2x can benefit learning better than once at normal speed
Have you tried watching things at 2x speed? I watch anything educational at 2x stopping to replay (often several times) anything I don't understand, watching at normal speed. I end up powering through the bits I understand and focusing on parts I don't. I also find the fact that I really have to concentrate to decipher what's being said means I don't get distracted.

While some stuff that gets posted here veers into productivity cult status, I personally don't think this deserves to be lumped in with that. In spite of speeding it up, I probably spend the same amount of time watching the lecture as I would at normal speed. I do it because in my experience any concept that's novel or hard in a lecture won't be understood by me on the first viewing. So will require several attempts and usually reading something.

strangeattractr··on YouTube takes down independent court livestreams
People don't base this opinion on a single article but on the coverage of the situation holistically as it evolves. Most of the 'bombshell' revelations in this trial have been available on the internet since the week of the shooting. The number of videos and images that show that it wasn't until Grosskreutz pointed his gun at Rittenhouse and advanced on him aiming at his head that he was shot is overwhelming and yet it seemed to catch the prosecutors and journalists completely by surprise.

If you watch the videos of the event in sequence you realise that this is one of the most blatant and well documented cases of self-defence in history, yet people who have only consumed media coverage of the shooting have been surprised by the difficulty that the prosecution have had proving it was murder. Clearly there is something broken in the transmission of information there.

strangeattractr··on Richard ‘Lowtax’ Kyanka, founder of Something Awful, has died
4chan's influence is not good but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist. In fact it's so influential that a lot of the garbage on there bleeds into the real world e.g. Pizzagate, QAnon, the OK symbol means 'white power' hoax. Most of the terrible stuff that people blame facebook or twitter for spreading usually comes from there.
strangeattractr··on Rittenhouse lawyer claims iPad pinch-to-zoom uses AI to fake video footage
The prosecutor has a tough job. He's trying to prove murder in one of the most obvious and well documented cases of self-defence in history. There is so much video evidence that shows a reasonable person would fear for their lives in that situation that its insurmountable. When you throw in a star witness who is repeatedly shown to lie you realise the mistake was bothering with the trial at all.
strangeattractr··on Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance state operatives and liars
I can't believe what a cliche you are. You make grand claims of right wing extremist threats from people gripped by misinformation. Post a handful of tweets and Wapo articles as evidence then trumpet myths about people being beaten to death on Jan 6th. You are the thing you're railing against.

You spread lies and then resort to the most generic ad hom questioning my education and telling me to touch grass. Maybe get off Twitter and meet some people in the real world, you might find most of the country isn't trying to kill you as you claim.

strangeattractr··on Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance state operatives and liars
You have my sincerest sympathies, I can see the onslaught of corporate media coverage and social media engagement has exhausted you to the point where you aren't even able to muster a scintilla of scepticism anymore. Nobody was beaten to death on Jan 6th, Brian Sicknick died of "natural causes". NYT, Wapo etc have retracted this misinformation but as you can see the horse has bolted on that front [1][2].

You respond to a post about CNN, question the 'urgency' of the criticism and then claim that you've made 'no comment' about CNN coverage. Read your own post, you directly claim it is less important than your perceived threat of right wing extremism. The fact that you replied this way shows how mired you are in partisan politics. The opposite to CNN isn't Fox News.

A few tweets isn't going to change my mind about the extent of the threat. Trump was able to rustle up around 3000 crazy people to breach the Capitol in a nation of 300+ million. I would wager Al Gore would have been able to get people to do this if he was as deranged as Trump. It really tells us nothing. As for your tweets showing violence at the Olympia protest, am I supposed to believe this is representative? Because if I am then I'd have to conclude far left extremism is the greater threat considering a counter-protestor shot someone. To be clear, I am not denying the existence of extremists I am questioning whether they are as numerous as journalists are trying to convince you they are.

You can ridicule people for raising questions about the FBI's involvement in Jan 6th all you want but the only people to blame for this are the FBI themselves. They have shown themselves perfectly willing to celebrate foiling plots that they essentially created whether it was after 9/11 or as recently as the Whitmer 'assassination plot' which was 50% FBI agents and organised at an FBI funded event [3]. Everyone should treat what the CIA, NSA and FBI say with extreme scepticism, regardless of your politics.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/who-died-in-capitol-bu... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/brian-sic... [3] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/kenbensinger/michigan-k...

strangeattractr··on Edward Snowden on corporate media hiring surveillance state operatives and liars
This sounds like an absolutely hysterical reaction to someone pointing out the effects of watching CNN who have been pursuing a narrative intended to make people scared. As evidenced by polling in September that showed that Democrats significantly overestimated the danger of COVID.

It's hilarious that people like you will underplay the issue of misinformation when it's disseminated about COVID when there has been no single bigger political issue in the world for the past 2 years. Restrictions put in place are not costless and have real impact on people's lives.

As for your laundry list of crazed conspiracy theories, I have a hard time believing that Fox News has been publishing them. So they don't seem analogous to results of CNN coverage. They sound far more like the sort of thing that propagates from 4chan into social media. Regardless, they can't be that common as you have also said they intend to massacre their opponents. Seeing as we're 10 months into the Biden presidency you'd think we'd have started seeing these massacres by now. Maybe they're like the next Jan 6th the FBI is always warning against, always another month away.

https://www.brookings.edu/research/how-misinformation-is-dis...

strangeattractr··on Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California
Maybe try thinking about it for a moment instead of resorting to the boring heuristic of assuming Americans are dumb zealots treasuring rights because they are brainwashed.

People like you need to stop saying things like "I understand citizens need the right to voice their opinion without fear of government repression" because this is exactly the opposite of what you want. You want views that you consider objectionable to be subject to government repression. You don't have to qualify it, just admit it.

The reason people oppose restrictions on freedom of speech are fairly obvious to anyone who has thought about the question for more than 5 minutes. The moment you start deciding which speech is and isn't legal, you have now established a mechanism to censor. Ban 'hate speech', those who define the term now control the boundaries of allowable speech, and you can guarantee bad actors will seek those powers and abuse them.

strangeattractr··on Why “Trusting the Science” Is Complicated
‘Trust the science’ is something generally said by people trying to get others to abide by their demands. In my experience there’s usually nothing scientific behind what they’re requesting. I see it said constantly where I live when people question the efficacy of some of the harshest COVID restrictions in the world including 9pm-5am curfews. For some it’s as though the utterances of our politicians have become ‘The Science’ in which we must believe.
strangeattractr··on Atlassian fired me while I was taking care of my wife who is fighting cancer
I work in financial services we have set time off and managers are punished in their performance reviews when employees don't take their time off because it accrues as a liability and means that salary costs are 1/13th higher than they should be due to the liability.

I think that a mandated minimum PTO allowance + discretionary 'unlimited' PTO would be better at a large organisation. Eventually a company grows to such a size that the influx of assholes is inevitable, mandating the minimum and accruing the expense aligns incentives better in my opinion.

strangeattractr··on Australia’s new mass surveillance mandate
I live in Victoria. We have certainly given up all of our freedom. Our Premier has suspended parliament and now rules by decree. Citing fabled 'health advice', which is never made public nor provided when queried, to justify anything he does. That's why we have a 9PM curfew that has done nothing to stem the spread, punitive 'alchohol must be drunk through a mask' rules and playground closures. Those were not legitimate public health measures, but punishments for Victorians risking his re-election strategy of 'beating the virus' after spending the weekend outside in the sunshine.

Police harass citizens for the crime of taking a rest on a park bench while on their 1 hour of allowed outside time per day. I have friends who have been unable to leave the country to see dying parents. I have had friends unable to travel interstate to see their dying parents. My own grandmother died in our lockdown so the last 12 months of her life were spent locked in her own home.

This is not a successful strategy, and anybody reading Australia's low deaths and case numbers need to realise this. We have myopic politicians who are suffering from an obsession with a particular metric, neglecting everything else enabled by a population of unthinking zealots who genuinely believe a single death is a policy failure.

Locking down this severely is neither clever nor demonstrates a particularly high level of consideration. It is the most blunt and basic response to the virus and it's only possible in a country of docile livestock who are content to cede every right if the person they're ceding it to promises it will make them safer from a virus, or in the case of these new national 'security' measures pedophiles or terrorists.

strangeattractr··on MIT Mathlets
Nice work - this is really impressive.
strangeattractr··on Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video]
Honestly, Argentina has tried almost every style of economic management and failed.

As I said they were investment led growth miracles, but I think that people who dismiss the importance of exports to these countries are extremely misguided. Exploiting excess labour for labour intensive industries e.g. garment manufacture in export markets they gained much needed income to import raw materials needed for heavy industry. By suppressing wages and thus consumption, they made savings available to invest into capital intensive industry which then came to dominate their exports.

Once they had developed sufficiently the investment led growth becomes self-sustaining. If your exports are growing at 20% p.a. as Japan's were in the 60s and 70s, investment in infrastructure becomes justified particularly when the country is underinvested after a war. But the shift to consumption led growth is difficult to achieve, it's why you see debt to GDP climb after the period of initial growth as malinvestment becomes common. Consumption's share of GDP in South Korea is still extremely low, Japan's only began to climb after complete collapse in 1990, China's is the lowest of all at 55%.

strangeattractr··on Noam Chomsky – Startup Culture (2015) [video]
Investment led growth miracles that occurred in Japan, South Korea, Taiwan and China have almost nothing to do with innovation. These nations all suffered from excess labour and insufficient capital.

They relied on protecting domestic industry through tariffs and suppressing wages relative to productivity to sell into export markets, driving up the savings rate to facilitate further investment. They do this either through political repression of labour unions (China) or through strategic undervaluation of the currency.

South Korea and Taiwan were military dictatorships when they began this process. It's completely unremarkable that a nation that doesn't have democracy achieved middle income status, because the purpose of democracy isn't achieving economic development. Although the first nation to implement this style of economic management was a democracy, the US did so in the late 1700s after Hamilton recommended it.

The problem with this growth model is that it relies on someone somewhere to absorb the production. If not for the free market ideologues in the export markets advocating for lowering trade barriers, these growth miracles probably wouldn't have happened to the same degree. The US isn't advocating free trade out of misguided benevolence, equal access to markets is what it considers 'fair'.

strangeattractr··on Apple Regrets Confusion over 'iPhone Scanning'
So if we submit to having all our content scanned by them they'll even give us E2EE on iCloud? I guess they really do care about our privacy.
strangeattractr··on Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles under a fake name
They made a list of 'Anti-Muslim extremists' and included both a victim of extremism and a former islamic extremist on it. Because their views which are informed by first hand experience are different from those held by the SPLC. Their entry on Nawaz also seemed to imply he was not a true muslim because he went to a strip club as well.
strangeattractr··on Co-founder of Snopes was writing plagiarized articles under a fake name
Yes I just looked, they do have 'mostly true' and they didn't use it. Honestly, if that first one doesn't make you roll your eyes I don't know what to say.

Would a reasonable person consider a person who was a member of a terrorist group that bombed the senate and was subsequently convicted of being in possession of large amounts of explosives and firearms a domestic terrorist? I think it's an emphatic yes.

It's like arguing that a man caught by police attempting to have sex with a 16 year old girl from the internet shouldn't be considered a sexual predator because he didn't succeed and there is no single universally-agreed definition for the age of consent.

strangeattractr··on Instagram launches hate-speech 'limits' to hide abuse
Everything is a bandaid when you're policing what people say. Manual moderation is unlikely to solve the issue to people's liking either, it doesn't on here or anywhere else I see it done.

Moderation on social media isn't something that can be solved satisfactorily, everyone is always unhappy with it. Take the lab leak theory with COVID, originally Facebook came under fire for allowing misinformation to spread so was blocking content which contained this claim because it was considered harmful but they reversed course once traditional media such as Vanity Fair began reporting it. Regardless of where you stand on this, you're unhappy with what they did.

Even hate speech is pretty ambiguous. The issue is one of subjective interpretation. Some comments are unambiguously hateful, others are hateful to some and not to others due to their cultural context which is important when you consider that these are global platforms. I've found it much easier to not use them than worry about what's on them.

strangeattractr··on Why is China smashing its tech industry?
> He can be voted out at any time. Western democracies don't even have democratic recall outside of the neutered impeachment process.

Seems a very odd thing to complain about 'neutered impeachment processes' in Western democracies whilst claiming he can be 'voted out at any time'. The US President can be impeached at any time too and removed from office. You claim impeachment is neutered presumably because the power has never successfully removed anyone from office. How then do you manage to praise the Chinese system for its ability to remove leaders. They don't have democratic recall either despite the theatre of voting, their President has never been removed and is essentially selected by his predecessor, the worst performing president at election captured more than 90% of the vote and even with the addition of state sanctioned 'independents' the leader still captures 99% of the vote.

Secondly, I'm not sure exactly why you say 'Western democracies' when you really just mean the US. Just because you're unhappy with the most recent impeachment failures doesn't mean other 'Western democracies' lack the ability to remove the ruling party or the leader.

strangeattractr··on Square to acquire Afterpay for $29B
Is it possible you don't like living in Australia and that may be making you a bit myopic? You are talking about Australian's cavalier attitude towards debt and issues with housing affordability in the two most expensive cities in the country whilst imagining other anglophone countries being better.

Look at property prices in Vancouver and Toronto, New York and San Francisco or London. You're going to find them just as unaffordable relative to the median salary. The difference is that for you personally - a worker in tech, the US will likely pay you a better salary relative to the median than you receive in Australia.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →