HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

strangeattractr

458 karma · joined October 5, 2020

submissionscomments
strangeattractr··on My Resignation from the Intercept
I actually don't have very much respect for Glenn Greenwald. Whilst I largely agree with his views on free speech, he has repeatedly shown himself to be a petty and narcissistic man who seems to be unable to have a healthy disagreement with anyone. Once he decides someone is an enemy he seems to lose his head - his attacks on Sam Harris, who I'm by no means an acolyte of, saw him repeatedly seek to discredit Harris not through argument but by claiming Harris was "radicalising" people to adopt extreme right-wing views.

I've seen a few people in this thread refer to his reputation to affirm his account. This is a very dangerous way to evaluate the veracity of conflicting claims. Particularly when part of his reputation is built atop Snowden's choosing of him rather than anything he uncovered himself.

Having read the piece and the emails I don't think this justifies the hysteria, I've had far more aggressive email exchanges at work that didn't blow up this badly. I can see why the editors felt revisions were needed, the title was clickbaity and it read more like an angry blog post with facts interlaced with strangely personal attacks e.g.

by Thomas Rid, one of those centrists establishmentarian professors whom media outlets routinely use to provide the facade of expert approval for deranged conspiracy theories

That is certainly not what I would consider dispassionate and impartial analysis. He has a problem with this person having in the past called him a 'cold war grifter'. He seems to consider any suggestions that Russia may be using internet disinformation to sow discord in the US ridiculous and conspiratorial. Which I find as naive as all the democrats who dismiss all negative stories as Russian disinformation. If the NSA had the opportunity to undermine Russia for geopolitical advantage it would, I have no doubt the GRU/FSB would seek to capitalise on this opportunity.

However, I do think he has some valid general points re: Biden's refusal to engage, as well as the criticisms of the blatantly partisan news media - that includes his sources. I just don't think that particular piece is a good exploration of it.

Disclaimer: I'm not an American and I have no particular affinity for Biden or Trump.

strangeattractr··on I Violated a Code of Conduct
Can't help but feel these codes of conduct are unnecessary. I get the problem they're supposed to solve, setting ground rules for a community expected to broach various cultural boundaries, but I don't actually think they functionally achieve this. Few people bother reading them so they're more a mechanism for discipline than anything constructive.
strangeattractr··on Free Linear Algebra textbook
I think it's the leap from - 'I'm not a fan of the approach' to 'this is a poor textbook'. Just because they don't like the approach doesn't mean it won't be effective for other learners. Some people absolutely need examples before they can attach anything theoretical to a concept.
strangeattractr··on Apple, Google and a Deal That Controls the Internet
Only on here could people say that the engineering challenges Google faces in delivering search are 'solved problems' that could be easily mimicked.

I get that people don't like the surveillance tech business model, I don't really like it myself. But we can't just pretend that the personal data that they gather to serve you ads more effectively isn't also the reason their search results, at least in my experience, are better than their competitors'.

strangeattractr··on Excel warriors who save governments and companies from spreadsheet errors
I agree the excel is great for cleansing or processing small/medium sized data sets. It's great for comparing two or more data sets too. The thing that makes it great for these things is visual editing, and the ease of setting up formulas. This also makes it dangerous in business critical processes because it allows too great a surface for mistakes.

There's also the issue that they're often set up as an ad hoc analysis only to become a process carried out on a schedule. This gets particularly bad when macros are involved - especially when they're password protected.

strangeattractr··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
50/50 of a voter turnout around 50%. If half the country doesn't bother voting I doubt this is alienating them.
strangeattractr··on Rust After the Honeymoon
Nobody cares about your problems, nobody cares if you learn a new language or not. The thread is about reflections on using rust - if you don't want to learn/use it fine, but being irritated that others are is just strange.
strangeattractr··on The shadow investment wars of Alibaba and Tencent
I'm concerned that you don't seem to believe America is in a recession at present.
strangeattractr··on .NET Orleans
> constant spaghetti of JS/Go.

I've written a lot of Go and there are plenty of faults but I'm curious why you consider it 'constant spaghetti' apparently in the same class as JS.

strangeattractr··on Missing Covid-19 test data was caused by the ill-thought-out use of Excel
Can attest to this. Some of the things I've seen excel spreadsheets contorted to do horrify me.

I once got spreadsheet dumped on me to debug because it wasn't working. A colleague used the spreadsheet to 'generate' interest rates that were then input into a mainframe. Dug into the VBA spaghetti mess, turns out this 15 year old script that took 15 minutes to run originally hit a bunch of Oracle/External APIs and performed calculations was now just copying the rates in from a csv file on a shared drive.

The error was caused by an excel formula ticking over a new year causing it to look for a directory it did not need to access that didn't exist. I thought it was pretty funny until I heard that the entire asset finance business had been unable to write any loans for days because of this.

strangeattractr··on Missing Covid-19 test data was caused by the ill-thought-out use of Excel
The most salient point of the paper was the inflection point of 90% for sharply lower growth. It was and still is used by proponents of fiscal austerity to argue against fiscal stimulus.
strangeattractr··on Why I left my tenured academic job
> Industry/capitalism/profit-seeking by definition makes it incredibly difficult to do things where there isn't a large expected monetary return. But profitability is a poor proxy for whether a thing is useful to do or not.

I don't think that's unique to capitalism. The Soviets were building spacecraft and nuclear weapons while people went without food.

Curing an extremely rare disease is valuable, we all value human life. But say there are tens of thousands of uncured diseases and more coming every year. Then let's say there is a finite number of people capable of working on them, how do you decide which cure we're going to target. The tradeoffs are a consequence of limited resources, not the system.

Market based health care does make me uncomfortable though, mainly because the incentives aren't in curing but in perpetual treatment to generate an income stream.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5