HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stratos123

663 karma · joined February 16, 2026

submissionscomments
stratos123··on RimWorld 1.7 moves from Unity to Ludeon's in-house Waylith engine
I think they're being a bit too optimistic about mod compatibility - from a cursory look, a lot of Rimworld mods do at least import UnityEngine (mostly for small utilities), so it'd take at least a recompilation. The fact they test with hundreds of mods does suggest they don't plan on leaving modders hanging, though.
stratos123··on Making big downloads resumable in Firefox
I use aria2 sometimes, but one thing that surprised me is that it doesn't fully support retries. As in, even if you pass something like "--always-resume=true --continue=true", if you try to use aria2c on a bad connection, you will sometimes get errors which make aria2c just exit. Thankfully it does have good resume support, so I was able to wrap aria2c in a bash script that calls it repeatedly until the download succeeds, but it's strange to me that this was necessary.

Some relevant github issues: https://github.com/aria2/aria2/issues/1399 https://github.com/aria2/aria2/pull/2004

stratos123··on Recursive self-improvement through collective intelligence
Online learning is the term, yes.

> The way “recursive self-improvement” is being used recently seems to be intentional marketing. A model helping code/train/test the next generation of its model family isn’t technically “self”-improvement.

The term RSI is ~20 years old at this point, and the concept is even older. If an AI can't continuously modify itself and instead has to build a successor that builds a successor, that changes some specifics (for example, the alignment problem becomes more relevant - how can the AI ensure that its successor shares its goals?) but it's still a situation that may produce exponential growth, and hence most RSI-related considerations still apply.

(In fact, as a toy example, note that it's in theory possible to get exponential growth in capabilities even if you hold the software fixed, if e.g. you have an AI that can design and build better hardware to run itself faster on, which lets it design even better hardware even faster.)

stratos123··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
This is a case of https://xkcd.com/2933/ . Your two paths are "Oh no. Simple layers can combine to produce complex behaviours!" and "Oh no. Modern layers are not this simple!"
stratos123··on Muse Wonder
To be clear, Meta here is not using "Super Intelligence" the bullshit term Trump wants companies to adopt as a show of submission. They use "superintelligence" the bullshit term that Facebook made up for marketing reasons a few years ago. Both of these are of course entirely unrelated to the long-established meaning of the word (e.g. how Bostrom defines it).
stratos123··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
Before the latest Russian election one of the parties opposed the war in Ukraine and was a bit too popular, so, well, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yabloko :

  Yabloko is the sole officially registered party to openly oppose the Russian war in Ukraine, openly calling "for peace and freedom". The party planned to partake in the 2026 Russian legislative election under their anti-war slogan.[29][30] However, in August 2026, the party was barred from running by the Supreme Court of Russia due to a lawsuit by Rodina.
Also, several politicians associated with it were imprisoned, e.g. this guy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lev_Shlosberg
stratos123··on Anthropic Bans Cruelty to Claude, Still Won't Say What It Protects
You can use the same argument to prove that humans can't possibly be sentient, too.
stratos123··on Nitter: Update Oct 10th seeking funding and legal help
> And where can one read a bio of the creator(s)?

This comes across to me as a surprising question - why do you assume there's such a bio at all, rather than it being developed by someone anonymous, as is the case for many questionably legal privacy tools?

stratos123··on Rogue Anthropic AI agent gave police fake tip in unsolved murder case
> We don't say "a rogue knife stabbed someone", or "a rogue scalpel botched a surgery".

Well, yeah. It's almost as if LLMs are different from knifes.

> The person responsible who lost control is still responsible for losing control.

That's valid, and yet one can advocate for AI companies to be culpable for actions of their agents, while still admitting that rogue AI agents are a thing that exists.

stratos123··on Can you use autoregressive diffusion to generate market data?
For more info on why flow-matching is more stable than DDIM, see Heitz 2023, which nicely explains how they're almost equivalent but DDIM corresponds to a differential equation with a 1/α term that diverges at the start of the denoising process, while flow-matching/IADB doesn't diverge: https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.03486
stratos123··on Python 3.15
On Linux it was, but not on Windows.
stratos123··on OpenAI fires three safety researchers for "mishandling research information"
Astra uses[1] a new-for-frontier-models technique, recurrent depth. It has a section of layers in the middle - I'll call it R while the other sections are P (prelude) and C (coda), to match Geiping 2025 - which gets looped. So instead of the sequence of layers involved in the forward pass looking like P->R->C, it instead looks like P->R->R->...->R->C, with the model's effective depth being notably higher than the number of layers. This is basically a cheap way to get some of the effect of stacking more layers, without having to pay the cost of having more real layers that need to be trained.

Increasing effective depth like this is bad for safety because it can ruin CoT monitorability: the reason why looking at the model's CoT actually gives you info about what the model is thinking is that the model can't do enough thinking in a forward pass alone to solve complex tasks, and hence has to do multi-step reasoning in CoT. The more thinking the model can do in a single token's forward pass, the more opaque the model's reasoning is, and the less reason there is to believe that what it writes down in the CoT has anything to do with reality.

For Astra specifically, the impact seems to be limited to a moderate monitorability hit, like the concerning result from the model card that Astra is notably better than any model before at solving problems under the constraint of not mentioning the answer in the CoT. The really bad scenario, however, is that this may create a race to the bottom where OpenAI and Anthropic feel the need to use more recurrent depth in each generation to not get outcompeted on capabilities, completely bricking CoT monitoring for both model families. Or, worse, the pressure to compete might push them into one of the worse techniques, like training on the CoT[2], or eliminating human-readable CoT and letting the model think entirely in neuralese.

For more details on recurrent depth in Astra, see "Part 2" here: https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2026/09/08/astra-is-hard-to-mon... , or this article mentioning some expert responses: https://techcrunch.com/2026/09/02/openais-new-reasoning-tech...

[1] The model card doesn't mention it at all; it was reported by The Information prior to model release, then confirmed by OpenAI researchers.

[2] https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/mpmsK8KKysgSKDm2T/the-most-f...

stratos123··on The Mathocalypse
You're probably still stuck with old beliefs from when all available AI checkers were snake oil. Pangram is, to my knowledge, the only AI checker today that actually passes accuracy assessments. See e.g. on their own site: https://www.pangram.com/blog/third-party-pangram-evals

(Incidentally, if you asked me a few years ago I'd have predicted that reliable AI detection was impossible. I still suspect that it's impossible in general and that Pangram would break as soon as companies figure out how to make LLMs stop all sounding the same - but until then, it'll work fine.)

stratos123··on I gave Opus 5.5 one prompt and six hours to visualize Invisible Cities
Approximately nothing - the carbon cost of electricity is already very low, and most of the inference costs are GPU and datacenter amortization. You could require all AI inference to be carbon-neutral and that'd barely raise the API prices.
stratos123··on Matthew Green: "I think we might lose public key cryptography"
I wouldn't go that far, but I sure wonder what's going to happen to the cryptography advances that OpenAI almost certainly obtained several of. Do they release them eventually? Do they sit on them forever? Do they share it (voluntarily or not) with the US government but not with the public? How much scary immediately-applicable stuff is in there?
stratos123··on Claude Haiku 5.5
The benchmark is not saturated. They are in the training set in a way where the models have heard of it, but not in a way where all the models get a perfect score on it.
stratos123··on The Mathocalypse
I'm not sure why one'd expect Scott Aaronson's posts to be AI-written, but sure enough, Pangram detects 0% of this post as AI.
stratos123··on OpenTPU – An open-source AI accelerator, developed by AI
I think you're massive underestimating intelligence - not ASI, but just, like, human-level intelligence. Most of the existence of human civilization has taken place in conditions wildly different from the ancestral environment, and we adapted anyway - and the reason why it was possible was because we have a tiny bit of general intelligence.

For your simulation argument, see e.g. https://alicorn.elcenia.com/stories/starwink.shtml - I think you're arguing that nothing like this could possibly happen, because humans are too dumb to ever figure out unfamiliar physics without prolonged experimentation, even given hundreds of years of theoretical research and several attempts in the real world? I think the closest real-world example of this is space exploration - it's extremely expensive and takes years to put stuff in space, and yet probes and rovers we launch end up working most of the time. On my model, it's because we have a decent grasp of the underlying physics in enough detail to predict real-world complexity, and we have toy testing areas we can test the tech on, and if you do this cautiously enough you can, in fact, launch a thing that ends up working.

I think there's a fundamental difference, between the sort of careful planning that lets you launch space probes, and blind optimization like evolution does. The former can generalize to unfamiliar domains even when the latter doesn't. That's what intelligence gives us.

stratos123··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
Nah, I just phrased it a bit confusingly - I meant the capabilities of LLMs as a technology (equivalently, the capabilities of whatever the frontier model is at each time) grow over time, even though any particular model is static.
stratos123··on OpenTPU – An open-source AI accelerator, developed by AI
> it is entirely possible (probable IMO) that ASI will plateau far above human capability in digital and symbolic intelligence, while staying far below in the ability to operate in the physical world.

I don't think this is plausible, most notably because "AI research" is one of the tasks that clearly belongs to the digital world. You're suggesting that in the future all AI research is done by AIs because they are better at it than humans, and yet capabilities plateau at that point, instead of going into the RSI regime. (And it'd also require "physical intuition" to be a harder to generalize skill than research, which also seems like it can't possibly be true - one of these is just physics.)

stratos123··on The cost of lies: A Mineserver story
> Unless, of course, it really was a case of "reverse engineer and reimplement Minecraft to make my own server." Not strictly impossible, but a completely unreasonable goal.

Hasn't that already been done several times? There's feather-rs (fairly mature but reduced set of features) and Pumpkin and FerrumC. And, for that matter, Paper - that one is Java and I haven't checked to what degree it's just borrowing from the original implementation, but I do know that Paper is actually used for real servers.

stratos123··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
> I'm a transhumanist, I want to build god and kill death.

This is good and admirable, but it'd really suck if by trying to build god without knowing how we end the human species. We could simply wait some more decades until we actually have any idea what we're doing, and then do that without the risk.

stratos123··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
> Why do you think the world to date hasn't been taken over by evil genius mathematicians?

A "mathematician" is a human who decided to spend their lives studying mathematics. Mathematicians also tend to be smart, but intelligence is innate, not acquired, so studying mathematics doesn't make you smarter. This makes it obvious why they don't rule the world - if you want to rule the world you'd want to focus on that (for example, doing business or finance), and becoming a mathematician is just a waste of time.

LLMs don't work like that. Like in humans, all of their capabilities correlate, and unlike a human, their overall capabilities grow over time. Looking at LLM mathematical ability over time* therefore gives you info about the progress of their general capabilities, and ability to take over the world would be determined by the latter.

* In fact it'd be better to look at a mix of different capabilities, but that's growing too at about the same rate, see https://epoch.ai/eci

stratos123··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
> But where are the people who are suggesting these probabilities getting their numbers? I personally can't imagine where, and I'm an engineer with a specific technical interest in LLMs. And I haven't heard one clear description of the methodologies used to calculate these chances.

All there really is is arguments from theory (most notably, the orthogonality thesis and instrumental convergence). It's not like we have a spare universe to conduct experimental research on the likelihood of human extinction. That said, the 5-10% range is not some specific person's wild guess, it's the median wild guess of a poll of AI experts: https://aiimpacts.org/2022-expert-survey-on-progress-in-ai/

> or they have some weird counterintuitive agenda (e.g. Anthropic and OpenAI trying to position themselves as the amazing, trustworthy keepers of this dangerous technology before their IPOs).

They are not "trying to position themselves" that way - back when those companies were founded, the people who did it were already convinced they were trying to make the ("inevitable") development of AI go better. It's not some novel galaxy-brained marketing strategy, it's just what they thought the whole time.

stratos123··on Improper redaction reveals Google Data Center water and electricity usage
There are non-fossil sources of energy, though. Even without a major discovery like fusion power, we could in theory stop the progress of global warming at any time by building a lot of fission powerplants powering direct carbon capture.
stratos123··on Protest against housing crisis in Spain
America famously doesn't do the unlimited growth these days - that's why they also have a terrible housing shortage.
stratos123··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
> Yes that is one dumb quote, but I listened to the whole podcast, and it is nothing like that.

Really? Here's a longer Bill Gates quote (from https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/29/opinion/ezra-klein-podcas... ):

Ezra Klein: "So why is anything needed beyond — and is anything needed beyond? — the simply natural incentives under capitalism and normal corporate reputational management?"

Bill Gates: "Well, I almost can’t believe you’re asking that. This is the most dangerous thing that humans have ever gone near. [...] You can take an open-source model that can create bioweapons and disable any monitoring of any kind, and this exists today. So no, there is no filtering of any kind. And so say you kill 100 million people — you want to use a lawsuit? I almost can’t keep a straight face."

stratos123··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
> Unless you can detail exactly how this happens its still complete science fiction.

You're saying that if one were to describe this scenario in more detail, it'd be less of science fiction? That's a bit against the grain - usually it's the more detailed arguments that get dismissed as science fiction, while the less detailed ones get dismissed as abstract theorizing.

stratos123··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
Ignoring you ignoring the much more important congitive stuff - human bodies are not designed, they are the product of evolution. That means there's like a billion ways in which they are obviously suboptimal and far worse than what an engineer would do, but evolution can't fix it because it only works via small random changes with no planning. The only reason why modern robotics are worse than biology is that we have a much worse substrate to work with, having to make stuff out of metal and plastic with giant tolerances instead of growing engineered organisms.
stratos123··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
> The apocalyptic stuff feels either misguided or like some kind of weird, toxic, reverse psychology marketing by OpenAI and Anthropic. I wish we would just move on from it.

If you for a second put yourself into the shoes of a person who thinks "the apocalyptic stuff" has even a 5% chance of literally happening in the real world, you might see how you wouldn't agree to move on from it.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →