HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

streetfighter64

212 karma · joined February 4, 2026

submissionscomments
streetfighter64··on Smartphone makers don't bother to comply with EU repairability requirements
Seems like we very quickly went from "there are tradeoffs" to "modular phones are objectively the best in all aspects". So, where's your proof of that claim? In my experience (as stated above) it's not the case.

The modular phones I've owned probably used more resources than the non-modular ones, because I needed to repair them more often. But hey, at least the repair was marginally more easy.

And yes, modular phones might have gotten better the last few years. But then you need to show that, not just claim it.

streetfighter64··on Smartphone makers don't bother to comply with EU repairability requirements
I don't really see the value of regulation requiring a certain preference, given that there are tradeoffs. I owned a modular phone previously, and it was, as you say, not as thin and not waterproof, and not dustproof either. Given that it takes like 30 minutes to change the screen or battery on my current phone (which is not modular), I don't see why my preference should be disallowed by EU regulation?
streetfighter64··on Smartphone makers don't bother to comply with EU repairability requirements
Sure, but so far I've replaced my phone screen once and the battery never, I suppose both would be equally easy though. Why is heating a big issue but removing screws not? Shouldn't we mandate user-replaceable screens too? Soon you'll end up regulating all phones to be modular.
streetfighter64··on Smartphone makers don't bother to comply with EU repairability requirements
Powerbank: Works with all phones, Doesn't require you to shut down and take your phone apart, Can be charged with a regular phone charger.

Spare battery: ???

streetfighter64··on Claude Fable 5.1 and Claude Mythos 5.1
I don't know, in my experience the chat output has been fairly natural.

The quoted sentence seems to be from some "model internals". Of course that can be incomprehensible, what an AI assistant is really doing is just statistically generating text with some bells and whistles to make it do useful stuff. Poking around in the internals doesn't seem like a good use of time? Comparable to cat:ing a compressed file, of course you get garbage.

I'm talking about the value of making the output in STE style, which doesn't seem useful. The value of having internal stuff in a given writing style would have to be evaluated as to whether it improves model performance.

streetfighter64··on Claude Fable 5.1 and Claude Mythos 5.1
By default? I doubt it would be useful or desirable for 95% of users. I'm guessing most people find natural language easiest to read, STE seems to be like a project almost akin to Esperanto or Lojban.
streetfighter64··on It takes 5 cloud services to hear my doorbell
It's controversial because your definition of "over-engineered" is different from most other people's understanding of the term. Most people would take it to mean "using more complex systems than needed to achieve a given outcome", while you are defining it more like "using any system at all to achieve an outcome that I consider unnecessary".

The former definition is somewhat objective in that it can be tested and proven, while the latter definition is entirely subjective and sort of meaningless. I could just as well state that any doorbell is over-engineered since you can just knock.

> GP: The minimum of 5+x^2 is closer to 5.5 than 10

> You: If you were minimizing 3+x^2 you could get an even lower value

streetfighter64··on It takes 5 cloud services to hear my doorbell
Godwin's law was invoked quickly. It's not very hacker spirit to hear a story of somebody putting together a cool hardware solution to do something they wanted, and then complain that they wanted the wrong thing.

> check out my hand-embroidered curtains, it's got exactly the flower pattern I wanted

> yeah well you shouldn't want flowers on your curtains, just buy plain white ones from the store

streetfighter64··on Please stop flooding our projects with AI slop to furnish your CV
Well, as I mentioned there was already in 2020 the problem of (human-generated) slop commits causing unnecessary work for maintainers.

The commit in itself might add some minuscule value to the project, but when you take into account the time it takes to check the commit and approve it, you're probably back at negative value again.

Plus, there's the problem of people doing this in an adversarial way. How can you tell whether a random commit touching 100 files is the work of an enthusiastic beginner, or a malicious hacker that's hidden a subtle attack somewhere? Well, you need to spend your time carefully checking it.

So it's way more pragmatic just to set up some automated filter to put all of this stuff in the bin.

Oh and by the way:

> I wouldn’t think a commit fixing typos ever attributed merit to a developer.

The first sentences of the article in question:

> Successful contributions to open source projects are a kind of currency. GitHub in particular encourages this in a number of ways: [...] Potential hiring managers often take note of this. Recruiters often find and screen candidates this way.

streetfighter64··on Please stop flooding our projects with AI slop to furnish your CV
I think Goodhart's law applies really well here. When people make commits for the sake of having made a commit to some famous repo, the "merit" that a commit measures is already useless. Remember Hacktoberfest 2020, before LLMs were popular? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24643894
streetfighter64··on The Hugging Face incident and the road ahead
Well, it's about as honest as repackaging tap water as mineral water, given that the fans could just prompt personalized stories of the same quality, but it's a career for sure. :)
streetfighter64··on The Hugging Face incident and the road ahead
Well, we don't. Just look at all the wars going on right now. In light of that, does it seem like a good idea to introduce a bunch of even less aligned agents into the world?

"Grey goo" nanobots are another example of artificial agents that aren't aligned with humanity, that we should probably try to avoid creating.

streetfighter64··on The Hugging Face incident and the road ahead
Like most of these get-rich-quick schemes, there's probably no money in actually doing it, but lots of money selling "courses" supposedly teaching people how to make money day trading or betting. You don't even need to rent a supercar and a mansion for your photoshoot anymore, just generate some images "proving" your success.
streetfighter64··on The Hugging Face incident and the road ahead
> There is no amount of care that will be able to fully protect you.

That's true, but one thing that'll protect you is just not doing it. If you want to go cave diving, or do gain of function research on dangerous viruses, you'll just have to accept there's a significant risk of you dying, or causing a pandemic, respectively, no matter how careful you are.

streetfighter64··on Most Physicists Don't Agree on Most Things
I'm not sure what you mean with "load bearing"?

My example of newtonian mechanics was actually to exemplify a simple model that's obviously correct to everybody (given that you use it for what it's useful for). Like, everybody would agree that a magnifying glass (newtonian mechanics) works for looking at stuff at a normal human scale, but an electron microscope (quantum mechanics) is something there can be more disagreement about among experts.

> I guess my true objection is how this poll will be interpreted, which is more about popular perception of how science works than anything else.

I don't know if I'm interpreting you correctly, but I for one have enough faith in people to guess that most people wouldn't interpret the poll as implying physicists disagree about the wavefunction of the ground state of hydrogen or something.

streetfighter64··on Most Physicists Don't Agree on Most Things
> That matters because most people won't actually read the article but will see the title and take it at face value.

Welcome to, like any news article in the history of mankind. Also I disagree that it's a lie. Clearly it depends on your interpretation of "most", but any reasonable person would interpret it as "most of things that can have disagreement", i.e. "questions that have not been settled".

streetfighter64··on Most Physicists Don't Agree on Most Things
It's a tautology, who would need explaining of it? The fact that "if there is evidence for something, people will agree with that thing". That's like, pretty much the definition of evidence...
streetfighter64··on Most Physicists Don't Agree on Most Things
Surprised at the quick dismissals in the comments here. Of course the title is a bit sensationalist, that's the case for all pop-sci articles. I don't think anybody would reasonably believe physicists disagree about for example Newtonian mechanics. Aren't the following facts still pretty interesting?

> The Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics came in at 36%.

> Although it's often reported in the press that the black hole information paradox has been resolved in favour of information preservation, the survey found that 19% of physicists still side with Stephen Hawking's earlier view that information is lost.

To see how the survey is useful, consider the "null hypothesis" so to speak, that a majority of physicists agree that one answer is most likely. Such as the Collatz conjecture from mathematics, where if surveyed, probably around 80% of mathematicians would agree that it's true, even though it's not been settled yet. Clearly this is not the case for most of the ten questions in this survey.

streetfighter64··on A faster way to calculate the day of the week
More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_rule
streetfighter64··on I close SSH port 22 (and what I use instead)
AI writing, sigh...

> to be unreachable: no banner, no version string,

> It works, but it has a real weakness:

streetfighter64··on uBlock Origin Is Giving Up the Fight to Keep Ads Off Facebook
> They try to inject malware into your thinking, manipulating your worldview and your actions.

Isn't your comment an attack as well by that line of thinking? Am I attacking you by arguing that people nowadays are way to quick to consider something "damaging" "attacks".

streetfighter64··on Civilian plane crash in New Mexico tied to military GPS blocking
In Europe the problem is already pretty solved because you can get a MPL and fly right seat in a passenger jet in 245 flight hours, just by going through an airline cadet program or something like that.

If I'm not mistaken the US still has the 1500 hour requirement that was illogical even when it was first introduced. It was introduced as a response to a crash by poorly trained pilots, but both pilots in that crash had over 2000 hours each, so the lesson should clearly have been that a raw number of hours is a very poor indicator of competence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airline_transport_pilot_licenc...

streetfighter64··on Civilian plane crash in New Mexico tied to military GPS blocking
Perhaps I'm being a bit reductive, but threads on anything that you're more well versed in than the average person, are evidently almost always goofy. It's called the "Gell-Mann Amnesia" effect.
streetfighter64··on Civilian plane crash in New Mexico tied to military GPS blocking
No, pilots should ensure they're current at navigating without GPS because it can fail, just like pilots practice engine failure procedures and every other emergency / non-normal procedure. That doesn't mean it should be "randomly disabled" for the same reason that you don't test software in production or randomly turn off the engine of the plane. Obviously.
streetfighter64··on 'VPNs are lawful technical tools,' says EU Court in landmark copyright ruling
> it is a big problem for a lot of rich people who have the time and money to think about this sort of stuff

Because banks famously love spending time and money on IT security... Anyway, if TLS was broken, that would be a big problem for everybody.

Using a VPN to protect against a zero-day in TLS, is sort of like hoarding gold to prepare for a collapse of society, in that it's a very unlikely scenario, and if it actually were to happen you'd have a bunch of other problems that aren't solved by gold / a VPN.

streetfighter64··on 'VPNs are lawful technical tools,' says EU Court in landmark copyright ruling
If there's a zero-day in TLS there would be a huge amount of problems that a VPN wouldn't protect you against. Even if you're using a VPN (or just a trusted ISP from your home), as soon as your data leaves their hands it would be vulnerable.

Like, suppose I want to send a physical letter to my bank. I can either ensure it can't be opened (using TLS), or I can get a trusted mailman to bring it to the mail central (using a VPN or trused ISP), but only one of those measures are going to protect me against a malicious mailman carrying it from the mail central to the bank.

streetfighter64··on OpenJDK Interim Policy on Generative AI
> short sighted for an interim policy

Bit of an oxymoron, no?

> just require clear and detailed disclosure of the use of said tools

Do you mean disclosure of the use of tools used "privately to help comprehend, debug, and review" contributions? Or do you mean that they should not prohibit AI-generated contributions?

If the former I wonder how useful the data would be, and if the latter, they are probably not (yet) willing to allow such contributions because of the mentioned risks: "to reviewer burden, to safety and security, and to intellectual property."

streetfighter64··on AI companies are shredding rare books
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49073042

> an 18th century botanical text that there's only 2 copies of in existence.

> books that had little in common, except for the fact that they all had ISBNs. This seller also sells rare books that do not have ISBNs, and none of those were part of the bulk purchases

Wow, that's impressive they had ISBNs in the 18th century.

streetfighter64··on AI companies are shredding rare books
Again, what's more technically feasible? Setting up a DRM-cracking LLM and manually verifying that it's actually succeeded for each and every DRM scheme you encounter, or just throwing the books in a regular old office scanner and being sure it works without even checking...
streetfighter64··on AI companies are shredding rare books
Well, destroying them once they already exist is reasonable, but producing garbage (e.g. great quantities of unsold books) on a "massive scale" is completely unreasonable though.

But that's a larger problem that encompasses single use packaging and all the other plastic garbage we're producing all the time.

← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →