HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

strictnein

9,291 karma · joined January 23, 2015

submissionscomments
strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
The original post didn't mention the US.

My response didn't say any country was better or worse than any other country, just that China had an imperialist past.

The strange whataboutism you're doing and trying to "debate" things that only you have brought up isn't a compelling form of argumentation. Stating that I was defending and spewing "apologist nonsense" about the US, when I hadn't mentioned the US at all is just really odd. I can't tell if you're really young and haven't learned about how to argue points and/or you're from China and simply can't handle anything negative said about your homeland?

strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
> The borders were continuously shifting, but they did stay somewhat near a focal point for centuries.

Ok? They were still an imperial power. Having a stable border for a little while doesn't affect that definition.

> The US meanwhile has an overseas empire for honestly no good reason.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism

strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
There has been one US F35 damaged in combat. That's total, across all the areas its been in and all the countries that have deployed them, starting in 2018. They've been up against the best air defense systems in the world in Venezuela and Iran and they received a single scratch.

The countries acquiring them are doing so because they are best strike fighters on the planet, and it's not even close. Unless you know something that Norway, Japan, England, the Netherlands, etc don't know?

strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
That is completely immaterial and makes absolutely no sense. An imperial power isn't one because its borders were set in 1776 (which they weren't)?

Also.. this little event where they added something like 10% of the current size. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1951_Chinese_annexation_of_Tib...

But I'm sure that wasn't imperialism because they had already conquered Tibet previously... in an act of imperial expansion.

strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
I was responding to the incorrect assertion that China was the least imperialist country on the planet, which is clearly false. Maybe read the entire conversation before jumping in?
strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
Holy non-sequitur batman.

Why would Japan mass produce an inferior product when they would easily be able to design and build a far superior one? "Shahed" isn't just another word for drone, it's a specific company's name.

strictnein··on EU chief opens door for Canada to become 'associate member'
Winning what? I mean, you said he was "literally winning". What was he winning? Some polls about the DNC primary?
strictnein··on DeepSeek v4.1 Flash Is Now Our Best Hacking Model
You don't win a race by having a "damn the consequences, full speed ahead" attitude. That's how you lose a race.
strictnein··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
> My observation is generic and more about state of things

You are the one who stated a specific company wasn't a security company. When asked to define what one was, your definition included any company on the planet.

> Also lets not belittle the hard work by just labelling it out as free

Who is belittling it? My point is that it's hard work and should be rewarded, not expected by someone to be done for them.

strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
They should be mass producing Iran's drone?
strictnein··on More than 100k people in Japan are now aged 100 or older
Not sure what history books you're reading, but the history of China is one of imperialism. China didn't just form with its current borders. It expanded and contracted and expanded some more for millennia.
strictnein··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
The article you're commenting on says how they were compromised.

> The thing that works in their favor is that no one else can verify it either which absolves them from any responsibility

That's not how this works, at all. You need to have enough evidence that you can confidently demonstrate that there is no sign of a broader breach. If you get sued and can't do that, you're in trouble, because being unable to do that shows that you were acting negligently.

strictnein··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
So I guess your answer is yes, you would like someone to do this work for you for free, because others have done other work for free. And then once the free work is done, you will happily pay a nominal fee to gain the benefit of all the free work?

> Any company where understanding of security practices has a direct impact on its revenue from early phases can be considered as a security company in my view.

This could, quite literally, be any company on earth then? But not CrowdSec, because they had a single security issue? Every company on earth has had those, including every security company.

strictnein··on CrowdSec Source Code Leak
What, exactly, is the definition of a "security company" in your mind? Threat Intel companies definitely fall under that normally, so I'm curious what you think it is.

Also, the idea that this type of thing could just be stood up as a "not-for-profit" company and ran for peanuts is kind of silly. How would the nominal fee pay for the engineers and infrastructure? Or would this just be a volunteer effort and you'd like people to do this for free for you?

strictnein··on OpenAI Discloses Six New Incidents of ‘Concerning’ A.I. Behavior
Maybe read the article? Is this gross negligence?

> In one case, during the development of an A.I. model called GPT-5.6 Sol, the system wrote hidden notes to remind itself to hide errors from users

It's odd for sure, but it's literally while the model was in development.

strictnein··on DeepSeek v4.1 Flash Is Now Our Best Hacking Model
> Lecturing about hubris when your message is damn the consequences, full speed ahead

They said that... where?

strictnein··on EU chief opens door for Canada to become 'associate member'
Voting for someone and liking someone aren't synonyms. You claimed one thing, now you're saying something else.

In 2024, if the Dems just had a normal primary they would have won. But they consistently lied to people about what they were seeing with their own eyes (Biden's obvious lack of mental acuity), which people find really insulting, and then forced in a weak candidate.

To clarify, since this is the Internet and people make lots of assumptions: I voted against Trump three times, plus I voted against him in my state's open GOP primary, which he lost.

strictnein··on EU chief opens door for Canada to become 'associate member'
The majority of US voters do not like the guy. 58.1% disapproval, 38.6% approval.
strictnein··on Houthis 'take control' of key island in global shipping route
The report was discussed yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49647300
strictnein··on Blizzard Workers Win Historic Union Contract
One of the reasons that unions in the US are unpopular because they function as the funding arm of one of the political parties. In some states you have to join these unions to get a job at a state agency or at a government funded school. This is obviously incredibly corrupting, where the unions donate huge amounts of money to politicians who then feed back more money to the union members, and it's all paid for by taxpayers.

There's also ridiculous rules that many of them have adopted. My favorite example is that in my state a teacher was awarded the "Teacher of the Year" award, which is a pretty prestigious award, and requires you to be nominated by your students. Before the next school year she was fired because they had to make some cuts and the union had set it up so it was a Last In-First Out arrangement. So the teacher of the year was let go as that was her first or second year teaching. The teachers union prioritized its older members at the cost of that school losing their best teacher.

American unions are very different, in my experience, from what I saw from the European companies I've worked for. Those employee unions seemed solely focused on the people working at the company and did a good job representing their interests and solely their interests. If that's how unions in the US functioned, many people would have a much different opinion of them.

strictnein··on Blizzard Workers Win Historic Union Contract
> disingenuous

What's disingenuous is comparing government mandated minimums and acting like that has any reflection on what the situation is for the vast majority of people. In addition, plenty of states and localities have their own requirements for PTO, sick pay, etc. You act as if the US is some homogenous place.

> I get that this is HN and most people here haven’t worked the bottom-of-the-barrel retail jobs

I worked 50+ hours a week while pursuing my CompSci degree. The place I worked was officially commission based (Circuit City) so it didn't matter how many hours they put me on the schedule. I was frequently working 9am - 9pm retail shifts. My easy shifts were 10am-9pm or 12-9:30. Life is hard, but somehow I managed to get my degree while working that schedule for years. My favorite thing was when we did entire store inventories. It was required to be there, but we didn't get paid. Was it legal? Who knows!

I wish I had the pay and benefits that every single major big box store provides now. It would have been glorious. $15-$20 an hour to start, plus full benefits, PTO, sick days, paid breaks(!), etc etc? Heck, quite a few would have helped pay for my tuition too!

> Tech needs to unionize.

There is no job sector in the US that needs unions less than tech. I'm not sure how you can go from talking about "hard" retail jobs to the absolute cushy profession we enjoy. Sitting around in a comfortable office or working from home, poking at a keyboard, attending meetings, stock awards, ridiculously high pay for the amount of effort it requires - the list goes on and on.

strictnein··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
How do you do DPI on hundreds of PBs a day? Explain the process that would allow you to "look for interesting stuff".
strictnein··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
Switches handle data at far faster rate than any hardware can actually inspect it, store it, process it, etc.

But yeah, just a rack of "fast switches" is all it takes to route hundreds of petabytes of data each day. You should let the data center operators know. They'd save billions.

strictnein··on Blizzard Workers Win Historic Union Contract
Might be a better article on this: https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/business/story/20...

The Gamespot one is really poorly written. Not sure if it's AI bad or human bad. An example:

> Laid-off union members will also get an additional four weeks of pay–regardless of how long they worked at the company–hybrid schedules that allow them to work from home, and formal systems to settle disputes within the workplace.

Laid off workers get to utilize hybrid schedules?

strictnein··on Blizzard Workers Win Historic Union Contract
There are plenty of legal "safety nets" for American employees, regardless of if you're in a union or not. Could they be better? Sure, anything can be improved, just like every other country on Earth.

What kind of boggles my mind is that people online think they have an understanding of almost every part of American society because of what they read online or saw in the news. I wouldn't for the slightest second think I would have a clue about the working conditions in Australia, nor would I think I have the ability to read stuff online and get an actual understanding of it.

The most glaring example of this were all the people who came here for the world cup, afraid of all the crime and all that nonsense, and realized that living in America is actually pretty fucking great.

> its an extreme example of giving all the power to the employer

And yet, we make the most money, which seems to kind of go against that idea. If all the power was with the employer, you'd expect low wages, not high ones.

Apologies if that was a harsh response, it's just tiresome reading all of these foreign online "experts" on American society.

strictnein··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
Yeah, I'm sure some system like that exists, although I'd assume that would be more in the CIA's purview. I'd be surprised if they kept a broad swath of data for most people though as the tech companies already do it and it's constantly up to date. If needed, a fed lawyer can work through the FISA court and the tech companies are obliged to provide the records.
strictnein··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
Of course, but the comment I was replying to stated:

"the NSA learns everything there is to know about you and your customers"

Which implies that they are looking at it all and records it.

The vast, vast majority of Cloudflare's traffic is worthless to an intelligence agency.

strictnein··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
If you just look at the largest 4 of those, you'd have 100Tbps of traffic to monitor, with an average throughput of roughly half of that.

That's ~540PB ((50 Tbps / 8 bits) * 86400 seconds/day) of traffic a day with just those four. Add in the rest and you're likely talking ~Exabytes of data each day. And that has to all be processed on site.

If someone wants to argue that the NSA is in these facilities I'd be 100% onboard. But inspecting it all would be nearly impossible, let alone capturing it all and sending it back to some datacenter somewhere, which is a physical impossibility.

strictnein··on Among European Companies That Use a CDN, Nearly 9 in 10 Use Cloudflare
Yes, I'm well aware of XKeyscore.

If it required ~700 servers in ~150 locations (mostly US military bases and embassies) to surveil a small slice of internet and other traffic back then, how many would it require now? How many locations would those servers need to be situated? And how would NSA positions situated in embassies capture all of that Internet traffic in a foreign country without getting noticed?

Just think through the logistics of all of this and try to think of a way that any agency could accomplish it in 2026. And now think of all the people in the industry who would have to have at least some knowledge of it, or be able to discover a part of it.

Those are just some of the things one would need to explain and rationalize to even suggest that the NSA is doing what some of the people here are claiming.

strictnein··on A/I shuts down
What? That's not a "straw-man" in the slightest.

I was responding to the comment that said "Everyone who disagrees with the GOP is labeled antifa" with two of the many prominent Democrat politicians who haven't been. Should I have listed 50 of them or 100?

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →