HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on To make programming easier, first be conscious of what makes it hard (2014)
There are myriad GUI tools targeting the web platform. If none have achieved the success of VB, it’s not through a lack of capability.
stupidcar··on The Mighty Fallen: Argentina and the Great Depression
Almost all Latin American countries are presidential republics. This is a system of government that basically guarantees instability. The separation of the executive and the legislature is supposed to provide greater accountability, but eventually leads to populist presidents quarrelling with intransigent representatives. The result is political logjam and either the president finally disposes of the legislature, or the military gets rid of both.

In contrast, Australia and Canada both have Westminster parliamentary systems, where the executive is drawn from the legislature. Thus, the prime minister is guaranteed a base of support there and populist candidates cannot entirely circumvent it. The system has its flaws, but it does seem to be more stable in the long run.

stupidcar··on Driving engineers to an arbitrary date is a value destroying mistake (2020)
It seems strange to me that software engineers are so frequently singled out for schedule slippage, when the impression I get is that every novel engineering project suffers from the exact same problem. Projects to design and build new military and civilian hardware and infrastructure always involve budget and schedule overruns of months or years. Can anyone provide convincing empirical evidence that software projects are delayed more than hardware projects of equivalent budget and distinctiveness from previous solutions?

A negative comparison often seems to be made between software engineering and construction, but it seems to me that the latter is a unique subfield of engineering, where you have an unusually large number of projects with a roughly homogenous set of constraints and variables. This has allowed those constraints and variables to be studied, understood and mastered to produce a discipline that more closely resembles mass-production. And in those subfields of software that also involve more homogenous constraints, such as the production of standard commercial websites, you do see a more controlled and templated approach, using tools like Wordpress.

stupidcar··on Fire breaks out at Tesla Big Battery
The site is built and managed by Neoen[1]. Tesla are only the battery hardware provider. Neoen operates power and storage plants in 13 countries[2].

[1] https://www.power-technology.com/news/neoen-to-build-300mw-b... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoen

stupidcar··on Coding with Character
Obviously, it's not less work. Given the need to develop complex additional ligatures, it's likely more.

> I doubt that a programmer who wouldn't spend $100 for a font would spend $5

This is where we disagree then. I think there is a big psychological difference for most consumers, including devs, between spending $5 and $100. Even if you can afford both, the former falls into the range of impulse purchases, like getting a sandwich or a cup of coffee, where you spend without really thinking.

On the other hand, I think a $100 price is far more likely to trigger a more analytical and skeptical response. Do I really need it? Is it worth it? Should I research alternatives? Maybe, I should think about it and decide tomorrow... Etc. And the consequence will be a huge drop in sales.

Also, I also do think there are significant differences in the market for programming fonts vs. general desktop fonts. The market for a single font is likely a relatively small pool of designers / content creators who are spending their employers money, need it to complete a specific project, and who value achieving a unique look. The former is a larger market, who are spending their own money on a nice-to-have, and who don't particularly care about uniqueness.

stupidcar··on Coding with Character
The pricing model of programming fonts makes no sense. Most seem to be sold at standard desktop font licensing rates, i.e. the $30 to $100 range. 99.999% of developers are not going to spend this much on a nice-to-have.

On the other hand, if these fonts were priced at around $5, they drop into the range of an easy, impulse purchase. Even if the creators made substantially less money on each license, I'm sure they'd make more overall from much higher sales.

stupidcar··on My mindfulness practice led me to meltdown
If we're to believe the author, they meditated for 10 years and attended numerous classes, seminars and retreats. Clearly they were engaging it as more than a "stress-relief tool".

The article I will take as a single data point, about one person's experiences. But comments like yours, and others in this thread, worry me far more. Collectively, they exhibit the dismissiveness, defensiveness, condescension and victim-blaming that is absolutely typical of members of religions/cults both spiritual and secular. Anyone who can describe the experiences related in this article as "desired and welcome" has lost any sense of perspective.

stupidcar··on Dell Xps 13 Developer Edition availability?
At least in the UK, I've found Dell and Canonical's official line on availability often simply does not match the reality of the Dell online store.
stupidcar··on Tesla’s new patent involves using table salt to mine lithium
This article they quote from seems like a better source for details : https://electrek.co/2021/07/09/tesla-patent-reveals-elon-mus...
stupidcar··on Alphafold
Yep, but there's a couple of problems. Firstly, AFAIK Deepmind haven't made all the code and settings they used to train the model available (although the paper does describe the architecture). Secondly, training a machine-learning model of this complexity is generally much more expensive, in terms of time and compute requirements, than using the resulting model.

If you're a a medical startup, having an off-the-shelf prediction model you can just start using for all your protein folding needs is a very different proposition from having to train one yourself from scratch.

That said, hopefully other researchers and institutions will take Google's research and produce an equivalently powerful model but with a more commercially-friendly open-source license. From some comments in this thread, it sounds like that's already happening, in fact.

stupidcar··on Alphafold
The model parameters are only available for non-commercial use. That's a shame, as I presume there might be a lot of medical startups that would benefit from having this kind protein-folding tech available.
stupidcar··on What DeepMind’s AlphaFold 2 really achieved (2020)
According to the AlphaFold Wikipedia article:

> As of 18 June 2021, according to DeepMind's CEO Demis Hassabis a full methods paper to describe AlphaFold 2 had been written up and was undergoing peer review prior to publication, which would be accompanied by open source code and "broad free access to AlphaFold for the scientific community"

stupidcar··on SF's crime debate turns nasty
As a non-resident of San Francisco, I have no dog in this fight, but it shows up on my Twitter feed regardless. I was amused by a recent exchange where one user was complaining about the amount of human faeces on the sidewalk, and someone retorted that they'd lived in SF for 15 years and there'd always been human faeces on the sidewalk.

I don't know whether crime in SF has gotten worse or not, but as a resident of a city where people don't defecate on the sidewalk, it boggled my mind a little to see someone apparently advocating for the city on the basis that sidewalk defecation wasn't a new problem.

stupidcar··on Four approaches to implicit state in compound components, ranked
These are all terrible, and they all stem from TypeScript's inability to properly restrict the type of JSX children. Something that's been an issue for years with no sign of resolution, because the proposed fix (from a member of the TS team) has terrible performance: https://github.com/microsoft/TypeScript/issues/21699

But since React is a such a minor part of the JS/TS landscape, who can really blame the TS team for not prioritising this, right!?

stupidcar··on Deep JavaScript
Do you have any empirical evidence it is more convoluted than equivalent popular languages?
stupidcar··on Learn CSS
History can be important, but I don't see what knowing that developers used to (ab)use <table> for layout explains about modern CSS. By all means, include historical context if it helps explain why something works the way it does, but otherwise drop it.

And while backwards compatibility remains a concern for browser vendors, it's much less of a concern for web developers nowadays given the vast majority of users are using auto-updating browsers. Indeed, the purpose of this guide appears to be an explicitly "evergreen" guide to CSS, targeting only the feature set of modern browsers. If you're using grid, custom properties, conic gradients, etc. you're not writing backwards compatible code.

stupidcar··on LiveLeak shuts down after 15 years online
Agreed. After seeing that video, any time I'm in a crowded indoor space, I always make sure I take a look around for the nearest fire exit, as well as a couple of alternatives in case it is blocked.
stupidcar··on John Glenn popularized the word “glitch” (2019)
"Glitch" is an interesting word. I've rarely heard it used to describe problems within the software industry, and almost never by actual software developers. Yet journalists seem to love it, and you often see headlines like "Software glitch costs bank $500m a day" or "Report says software glitch caused fatal accident", even when stronger-sounding words like "defect" or "failure" would seem more appropriate.

And politicians seem to really love it as well, perhaps because it is a funny-sounding, non-threatening word, implying a minor hiccup rather than a serious defect. So, whenever some new, high-profile software system crashes and burns upon launch, you get lots of folksy talk about glitches: there's just a few glitches, they're fixing the glitches, you've got to expect a few glitches, etc. Whenever I heard such talk, I like to imagine the difference between the attempts to downplay the problems, and the likely reality of stressed-out engineers scrambling to fix a system that was released in a half-finished state due to an unrealistic deadline.

stupidcar··on EU preparing legal case against AstraZeneca over vaccine shortfalls
Why didn't you read the article I linked? It says:

"The contract makes clear the Commission and EU countries can't sue the drugmaker for a host of issues, most notably if there are 'delays in delivery of the Vaccine under this Agreement.'"

stupidcar··on EU preparing legal case against AstraZeneca over vaccine shortfalls
A couple of months ago Politico also reported that the EU had waived its right to sue in the AZ contract[1], so what gives? Would it kill Politico to give some additional context when a story seems to blatantly contradict its own reporting?

[1] https://www.politico.eu/article/coronavirus-vaccine-europe-c...

stupidcar··on Book Review: “A Thousand Brains” by Jeff Hawkins
AI safety seems like one of those topics that trips up even smart people such as Hawkins, because it intuitively seems like it has very obvious solutions. And for each objection raised there's usually a "so you just..." continuation, and an objection to that, until you're talking about things like instrumental convergence and you're in the territory of trying to reason in quite a complex way about the behaviour of systems that don't exist yet, and so the temptation is to dismiss it all as theoretical hand-wringing.

Personally, while I'm not on board with the board with the direst predictions of the super-intelligence pessimist crowd, I have become more and more convinced that goal misalignment is going to be a significant problem, and that while it might not doom the species, it's something that all AI researchers like Hawkins need to start paying close attention to now.

stupidcar··on Why Hypercard had to die (2011)
Those accessible programming environments tended to exhibit exponentially worsening performance and maintainability characteristics as the complexity of the system being built with them grew.

This would be have been fine, so long as these systems remained relatively simple, and were rebuilt in more heavyweight but scalable languages once they reached a certain level of complexity. But that isn't what happened. Instead, they just kept growing into twisted, unmaintainable monsters that organisations were completely reliant upon, but which were an absolute nightmare to maintain and extend.

As a result, the industry shifted to encouraging the use of "real" programming languages for everything, even the simplest systems, because the greater up-front costs were saved many times over by having a sane story for long-term maintenance and improvement.

stupidcar··on EU vaccine rollout severely lags behind
The original claim regarding the EU dragging its feet over signing the contract was made by the AstraZeneca CEO, not the UK government. And the UK's contract is not entirely the same as the EU's. For example, the EU waived its right to sue AstraZeneca for delivery failures, something the UK did not. This article by Politico does a good job of going beyond the rather reductive coverage (both pro-UK and pro-EU) in most of the press coverage of this affair, and digging more deeply into the facts:

https://www.politico.eu/article/the-key-differences-between-...

The conclusion, at least as I interpret it, is that both the UK and the EU can reasonably claim to have priority, based on their respective contracts, but that the UK did a better job than the EU in making theirs enforceable. Hence, AstraZeneca has prioritised them, while the EU has been forced to resort to political rather than legal measures to attempt redress (publishing the contract, export controls, etc.). And the UK's closer ties to the AstraZeneca vaccine project likely did mean they started work on the UK supply chain somewhat earlier than in the EU, even although the final contracts were signed essentially simultaneously (one day apart).

I honestly don't really see this as an affair with clear good guys and bad guys, but it seems like most people are determined to do so, and inevitably along the lines of their pre-existing sympathies.

stupidcar··on Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade EGA/VGA Comparison
100% agree. It's telling that most contemporary pixel artists work by choice with a limited palette. The actual number of colors, even in complex pieces, is often shockingly small.
stupidcar··on Germany pauses AstraZeneca vaccinations as a 'precaution'
An explanation of the above reports, including why they can't be used to make any inference about the safety of the vaccines: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/coronavirus-covid...
stupidcar··on Bring Your Own Client
Your objections seem to be predicated on the assumption that the attempt to separate storage providers from application providers wouldn't be properly enforced. Yes, obviously if Alphabet can just set up Google Cloud Storage and Google Cloud Apps and continue with business as usual, then this won't work.

But what I'm suggesting would be a functioning regulatory regime: An independent authority who classifies cloud providers as utilities, writes regulations specifying standards of interoperability, hears complaints from people and businesses and acts to enforce them. Antitrust regulation that stops collusion between service and application providers, and prevents companies or individuals owning a controlling stake in both.

And the major difference I see in contrast to railways is digital infrastructure is not limited in they same way physical infrastructure is. So long as there's only one set of tracks, you can never have a functioning market running trains on them, and it's impossible to build a second set. But while the capital costs of setting up a new data centre are large, they are still within the realm of possibility for many large companies.

stupidcar··on Bring Your Own Client
Can I ask why?

As I see it, cloud providers are currently entrenched as Lords of Everything because they can both provide the infrastructure and the products that run on top of it. Making them act more like utility providers would reduce their power, I think.

stupidcar··on Bring Your Own Client
The competitive advantages of owning both the application and the data are so high that don't see widespread BYOC ever happening without government intervention.

I'd like to see an enforced separation in law between commercial application providers and storage providers. So, if someone writes an app like Google Docs, they can't just store the data opaquely on their own cloud servers. They legally have to integrate with a separate storage provider. And that storage provider has an obligation to make my data accessible and manageable by me.

This wouldn't be a panacea, but it at least makes it theoretically possible to write a replacement client for Google Docs that could be a drop-in replacement.

stupidcar··on Starship goes up. Starship goes down. But is the program moving forward?
You say it's a dumb question to ask, yet you still deemed necessary to include in your own statement facts such as that these are "very early test launches" and that "so much went right".

If it's so dumb for anyone to even ask if three explosions is a problem, why did you do this? Why didn't you just write "Asking if three explosions is a problem is a dumb question to even ask."? Why was it necessary to introduce supporting evidence?

Could it be that you think it's a dumb question because you know these facts? And the article author's job, as a journalist, is to assume, accurately, that most people don't know these facts. Most people are not SpaceX super-fans who have been closely following the test programme. Many will just hear "SpaceX blew up a third rocket" and wonder if things are going wrong, and the author's job, as a professional journalist is to inform those people.

stupidcar··on How an Anti-TypeScript “JavaScript developer” like me became a TypeScript fan
Here's a project idea I'd really like to see: A version of Chromium, targeted at web developers, that is is modified to accept TypeScript syntax as a variant of JavaScript.

This hypothetical browser wouldn't perform type-checking, just be able to parse TS syntax and convert it to plain JS, in the same way tools like Babel do.

This would let you use TypeScript without the need for any transformation pipeline in dev. You could then separately run TypeScript in a console to get async checking. Then only when you build for production do you run everything through a compiler/bundler to get a plain JS bundle that will work in everyone's browsers.

← PreviousPage 2 of 26Next →