HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on Semiconductors Demand 30% Above Supply, 20% Year-on-Year Growth
The DoD's Industrial Capabilities report to Congress[1] that got posted on HN last week recommended exactly this:

> "Outside of the United States, foreign governments and their citizens pay the lion’s share, one way or another, of the cost of building the fab. The companies do not. They take on the other massive set of costs: running the fab. The hard truth is that if the United States does not start doing the same, our nation will continue to see its historically low share of chip production continue to decline to irrelevance."

[1] https://www.businessdefense.gov/Portals/51/USA002573-20%20IC...

stupidcar··on I Am Bezos
I am consistently surprised at how anti-inequality activists return, again and again, to the same tactic of restating the numerical and relative degree of wealth inequality. Like how, every new year, the media publishes the same stories about how Bill Gates / Jeff Bezos / Elon Musk (or whoever the latest richest person is) has earned more than the average person's yearly salary in x number of minutes. This happens despite the repeated, abject failure of this tactic over the past decades to help their cause and create a mass consensus in favour of stronger redistributional measures.

It seems to be a common anti-pattern of political activism across the spectrum: Things that are so intrinsically outrageous to activists that they assume their reaction is universal, and that simple exposure to the facts will be enough to convert others.

stupidcar··on “Silicon Valley’s Safe Space” has misinformed readers
I've read it. Almost the first thing I saw was:

"Slate Star Codex was a window into the Silicon Valley psyche."

This is just so obviously, insanely wrong that it's impossible to take anything else in the article seriously.

stupidcar··on The new reading stack
The entire statement is in fact a falsehood, as Amazon does not embody that idea, regardless of its veracity. Amazon has never paid a dividend, and is guided as much or more by the pursuit of growth (and also "customer value" although unevenly) that simply maximising shareholder value.
stupidcar··on Ask HN: What is the oldest image online in which the link is not broken?
The answer is most likely an image hosted on an academic's personal site on a university server somewhere. Although how you would ever figure which is the actual oldest, I have no i idea.
stupidcar··on Navy speaks up about its “UFO patent” experiments
Another possibility could be office politics. Perhaps the researcher played golf or whatever with somebody quite senior and convinced them to back his pet project. The senior person's juniors know it's nonsense, but they fund the most bare-bones programme anyway in order to placate them.
stupidcar··on Counterfeiting Stock – Explaining illegal naked shorting and stock manipulation
What your describing still sounds incredibly dodgy.

The price of anything is a result of its some intrinsic value and the volume of supply. So a precious stone is valuable because of its beauty, but also because it's rare. If someone mines a billion such stones, it won't affect their individual beauty, but it will certainly reduce the price someone is willing to pay for one.

Now, you seem to be saying that short selling is a signal about intrinsic value, but the process you describe, whether you want to call it counterfeit shares or fractional reserve shareholding or whatever also messes with the valuation by inflating the supply. If there are more shares of a given company available, those individual shares will be worth less.

The result would seem to be that naked short selling at volume will create a self-fulfilling prophecy. You can drive the price down simply by inflating the supply, regardless of whether the company is well managed or not. Maybe you start with badly-managed companies, but there's always going to be a perverse incentive to target any company so long as you can manipulate the supply enough to force a price drop. If you care about the market as a measure of company health, that doesn't sound like a good idea.

stupidcar··on AstraZeneca/EU contract
I don't think the EU is really expecting to receive a legal remedy. If they were, they wouldn't be publishing the contract or making such a public fuss. What you're seeing with this publication, with the aggressive statements by senior EU politicians, and with the imposition of border controls, is the application of political pressure, not legal pressure.

I think the EU's behaviour is mostly driven by internal political reasons. Their vaccination programme has been highly inept so far, partly due to the failure of the commission. But no government admits failure when there's a possibility of assigning blame elsewhere. The more EU citizens can be convinced that it's all AZ's fault for missing deliveries, and the dastardly post-Brexit UK holding doses hostage, the less scrutiny will be be applied to their own role in creating the situation.

stupidcar··on Why Working from Home Will Stick [pdf]
If my employer tries to remain 100% remote I will leave and go somewhere with an office. I find working from home too lonely, and I detest spending hours of every day on video calls. Of course, I'm just a single data point, and perhaps not representative, but I'm also generally less social than other people, so I find it hard to believe there won't be a lot of people feeling the same.

I'm sure that there will be a much greater prevalence and acceptable of working from home after the pandemic, but I'm equally sure that there will be a gradual but significant shift back to large numbers of people working in offices. The only way this won't happen is if there genuinely is a major uplift in productivity from remote work, and I'm incredibly sceptical about that. Self-reported improvements in productivity are worthless, IMO.

stupidcar··on React created roadblocks in our enterprise app
I watched it. It was dumb. A textbook example of some major fallacies:

The first is mistaking your level of desire for something to happen with the actual probability of it happening. It's clear he doesn't just think web programming is going to collapse, he wants it to happen. And it's distorted his estimation of its likelihood. I'm sure in 2030 he'll be making videos confidently predicting the collapse of web programming by 2040.

The second is where an expert in one domain considers its complexity to be inherent and unavoidable, while assuming other domains, of which they are ignorant, are inherently simple. Then when they try to engage with those domains, they run into significant complexity and experience the uncomfortable and unfamiliar sensation of being an amateur again. Since the unfamiliar domain is, by their estimation, simple, they conclude that the complexity they've encountered is unnecessary — a result of people working in that domain being too stupid or inventing busywork.

The third is the mistaken belief that our means will improve, but that our desires will remain the same. So, right now we have certain requirements, and in order to meet them requires us to do a lot of complicated, cutting edge stuff. But soon all that complexity will get figured out, the cowpaths will get paved etc., and we'll happily just pushing a single button to do everything we need. The reality is, of course, that our requirements will just get more complicated as well. Human civilisation has been on this treadmill since time immemorial.

stupidcar··on Can you treat loneliness by creating an imaginary friend?
Weird edge cases: You create a tulpa, but then you’re so busy socialising with other tulpamancers you neglect it until it gets lonely and decides to create a tulpa.
stupidcar··on Software Is Drowning the World
Things break down and things eventually need to be replaced. This has been a fact of life since time immemorial. I do tire of programmers acting as if the necessity of maintenance is some novel and unexpected problem, unique to software development, presented with hyperbolic titles like "software is drowning the world". Is physical infrastructure "drowning the world" because it needs to be maintained?
stupidcar··on London will be overwhelmed by Covid in a fortnight says leaked NHS briefing
This article is confusing. It starts off by saying this is an analysis of "best" and "worst" case scenarios for continued growth in cases, but later it says:

> HSJ understands that the briefing was part of an attempt to get senior clinical leaders to focus on what they would have to do, if current growth trends were not surpressed by the tighter lockdown.

So, er, what if the growth trends are suppressed by the tighter lockdown, as seems likely? Will things then be better than the "best" case scenario?

It sounds like there's a bit of misreporting going on here. The leaked document forecasts demand based on pre-lockdown trends, to highlight the significant risks. But the article is reporting it as if running of beds is totally guaranteed in all circumstances, which doesn't appear to be the case, if the lockdown works.

stupidcar··on London will be overwhelmed by Covid in a fortnight says leaked NHS briefing
In tier 4 areas, which included London[1], no mixing was allowed over the Christmas period, including Christmas day.

Source: Being in London during Christmas.

[1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-55380644

stupidcar··on Run, Die, Repeat: How Roguelike Games Helped Us Get Through 2020
It's interesting to me how Hades incorporates a lot of the aesthetic and techniques from free-to-play games, but within a paid game. The result is incredibly addictive. It's a constant stream of vivid animation and sound, coupled with the gradual accumulation of different currencies and collectables that makes you always feel like you're making some forward progress.

At times it can feel almost a bit _too_ slick and addictive. Like it's manipulating the reward centres of your brain bit too perfectly. Fortunately, what saves it from feeling hollow is the quality of the writing and the story. I'm just glad I've started playing it over the Christmas holiday, because all the times I've stayed up until 3am wouldn't be good if I had to get up for work the next day.

stupidcar··on AI Update, Late 2020 – Dumpster Fire
Reading this is like talking to that one friend who has something negative to say about every movie, TV show and musician you like. Even when their criticisms are valid, the relentlessness of their cynicism is obnoxious.
stupidcar··on HTML5 still doesn't replicate what mattered about Flash
I've come across a lot of similar sentiment from ex-Flash devs, who romanticise its heyday as a period of fertile creativity (true) and say that HTML5/JS/CSS/SVG is an inadequate replacement (false).

In truth, the fundamental capabilities of the modern web platform matches and typically exceeds anything that was offered by Flash. What these people are really lamenting is the ease of authorship that Flash provided to non-technical users.

Macromedia/Adobe provided a suite of powerful tools for authoring Flash animations and applications. There is no free equivalent available targeting HTML/JS. This is not a problem of capability in the platform technologies. It is because there is no economic incentive to make and give away such tools. What equivalents do exist in this sector cost money.

When it comes to Flash, the old adage, "if you're not paying for the product, you are the product" holds true. The Flash authorship tools were free because 3rd party authors creating Flash content were assisting in the promulgation of a proprietary platform that was gradually replacing open web standards. Had they succeeded, Macromedia/Adobe would inevitably have looked to squeeze and monetise their domination of the web.

Programmers are often accused of not understanding what Flash offered to artists. Maybe that's true, but I've not encountered many artists who conversely understand the above.

stupidcar··on HTML5 still doesn't replicate what mattered about Flash
They have. It’s called Webpack. There are also various similar tools.

EDIT: I got downvoted for telling the truth? The website is here if you don't believe me: https://webpack.js.org/ It literally does what the post I replied to asked for.

stupidcar··on In study, acetaminophen makes risky moves seem less dangerous
I occasionally take some paracetamol if I've suffered some upsetting emotional event, like a bad argument at work. It's most likely just a placebo effect, but I do feel like it numbs my emotions a bit and helps me stop fixating on the memory.

I'm well aware it's not the healthiest behaviour, but I consider it better than the other ways I know I would likely respond, by either sinking into a mild depression, or using alcohol and/or other intoxicants.

stupidcar··on In study, acetaminophen makes risky moves seem less dangerous
Isn't this is what meditation is for?
stupidcar··on No Cookie for You
Did you seriously just link an IETF document as the basis for an argument about the law? Never mind the difference between "should" and "must", do you understand the difference between an RFC and the law?

And there is no room for ambiguity in the actual law:

https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=uriserv%...

> Consent should be given by a clear affirmative act establishing a freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject's agreement to the processing of personal data relating to him or her, such as by a written statement, including by electronic means, or an oral statement. This could include ticking a box when visiting an internet website, choosing technical settings for information society services or another statement or conduct which clearly indicates in this context the data subject's acceptance of the proposed processing of his or her personal data. Silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity should not therefore constitute consent. Consent should cover all processing activities carried out for the same purpose or purposes. When the processing has multiple purposes, consent should be given for all of them. If the data subject's consent is to be given following a request by electronic means, the request must be clear, concise and not unnecessarily disruptive to the use of the service for which it is provided.

stupidcar··on John le Carré has died
I'm now imagining a Pythonesque comedy sketch where he accepts the offer, but it turns out it really is just some obscure agency, and your professor goes wandering around the fjords talking in code to perplexed Norwegian fishermen.
stupidcar··on AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in biology
> this isn't the typical HN pedantry

This is the absolute definition of it.

stupidcar··on Tips for Performant TypeScript
We've encountered huge performance problems using TypeScript with the styled-components library. Something about how that library is typed results in multi-second delays before the VSCode intellisense updates on any file in our project. It's absolutely agonising.
stupidcar··on Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla and the Unfortunate Implications
> Now, do I think that the developers set out to create a sanitized defense of colonialism (much less an apologia for Nazi race ideology)? Of course not. But they ended up doing it anyway.

I agree with the article's main points, but I think the author gives the game's creators too much credit here. You could tell from the first trailer that this game was going to engage in historical revisionism of the "the Vikings were really noble heroes" type. This isn't oversight or subtext, it's a conscious and deliberate choice.

The people who made this game weren't stupid or ignorant. If they chose to erase the reality of Viking slavery and violence against defenceless civilians, it wasn't an accident. They may (or may not) have intended to defend colonialism in general, but this game is an entirely intentional attempt to defend _Viking_ colonialism specifically. And they will have been perfectly aware that this played into neo-Nazi tropes.

stupidcar··on The Next Decade Could Be Even Worse
> Turchin noted that a person can be part of an ideological elite rather than an economic one. (He doesn’t view himself as a member of either. A professor reaches at most a few hundred students, he told me. “You reach hundreds of thousands.”)

His theories are interesting, but the fact that he claims not to be part of the elite himself indicates he's got some serious intellectual blindspots. Modern academia is one the most perfect examples of "elite overproduction" there is. Hundreds of thousands of doctoral students investing huge amounts of time and money to chase a relatively tiny pool of prestigious teaching and research positions.

stupidcar··on Angular 11
They are finally making reactive forms strongly typed, at least[1].

On the Observables point, the Ngrx folks have created the @ngrx/component[2] and @ngrx/component-state projects[3] to try to build true reactivity into the component model. It's a shame this effort is happening outside of the main project, but it's something.

[1] https://angular.io/guide/roadmap#better-developer-ergonomics... [2] https://ngrx.io/guide/component [3] https://ngrx.io/guide/component-store

stupidcar··on Angular 11
It's anecdotal, but that SVG path editor that recently made it to the top of HN was a brand new Angular project: https://github.com/Yqnn/svg-path-editor

And on npm it's gaining popularity: https://www.npmjs.com/package/@angular/core

React is still the clear winner in terms of market share, but Vue.js and Angular are very popular and not going anywhere. Fortunately, there's room in the world for more than one front-end framework.

Having used Angular professionally for several years, and React for the past two, I think both have clear strengths and weaknesses, but informed debate is sadly lacking, and instead we have a lot of partisanship and uninformed opinions.

stupidcar··on CSS Layout – Grid vs. Flexbox
It's extremely disappointing that, other than Firefox, browsers have refused to implement subgrid[1]. As I understand it, this feature was deferred from the basic grid spec with the understanding that it was still necessary and would be implemented, not so it could consequently be ignored. If Mozilla was capable of implementing subgrid, Apple and Google certainly have the capacity to do so.

[1] https://caniuse.com/?search=subgrid

stupidcar··on IBM is splitting itself into two public companies
> They now have 1 desktop, updated every few years, one laptop, updated every few years.

Not true. They have three desktop form factors — Mac Mini, iMac and Mac Pro — and three laptop form factors — MacBook Air, 13" MacBook Pro and 16" MacBook pro. And each can be variously customised by CPU, memory, storage, etc. Most of these are updated with 1-2 year cadence.

Of course, it's much easier to make any case if you disregard the most basic facts within the first paragraph.

← PreviousPage 3 of 26Next →