HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on Intention to fine Marriott more than £99M under GDPR for data breach
The requirement of GDPR is not "don't get hacked", it's "take reasonable steps not to get hacked". If you take reasonable security measures and still get breached, you aren't liable.
stupidcar··on The human impact of having too few nurses
Better pay and recruitment might help move the needle on the number of nurses in the short to medium term, but long term, the demographic time-bomb in western countries means they will never have enough nurses to care for their entire aged population in the manner they do now. So either a lot of people are going to get sick and die without anybody to care for them, or, one way or another, nursing and healthcare is going to have to change to become more efficient. That will mean it becomes a lot more impersonal, with much greater use of mechanisation, automation and robotics.

I don't see this as being entirely a bad thing. While nurses and other caregivers can be an important source of human contact for the sick and elderly, caring and being cared for by another person can be an emotionally and physically fraught and draining process. If we can build automated systems that allow baseline physical and hygienic needs to be met, even for the frailest and sickest people, I think that had to be good for the mental health of both those needing care, as it will reduce their sense of being a burden, and on the caregivers themselves, as they will be able to focus on the most important quality-of-life issues instead of being stuck on a treadmill of providing basic care.

stupidcar··on Ask HN: Why do new(ish) programming languages eschew OOP features?
Many systems people want to build with computers cannot be easily conceptualised as graphs of largely self-contained objects, interacting through swapping messages. These problems instead revolve around complex data processing, and are more easily conceptualised as data flowing through a network of functions, and into and out of containers.

It is possible to build these systems using OO, by reifying the network of functions and the data into objects. But all you are really doing is reinventing functional programming with a layer of OO cruft on top of it, and it is always going to be easier to build the equivalent system in a language that lets the functions and the data structures be unencumbered.

For programming tasks that actually are best conceptualised as objects, OO works quite well. These usually involve the provisioning of some largely static virtual environment, such as a UI, game world, or inversion of control container. Here, objects are long-lived, genuinely independent, and interact in well-defined ways via actions and events, usually swapping only small pieces of state.

My guess is that the advent of GUIs and sophisticated games in the 80s and 90s pushed programmers to be more interested in this latter type of problem, and this was reflected in the languages that evolved. Then the advent of the internet and machine learning in the 2000s and 2010s revived interest in data processing and data flow, and so language design began to shift back.

I suspect in 100 years, if humans are still doing any programming, all popular languages will be mixed-paradigm, and the question of OO vs functional will simply be a blend decided by needs of the problem at hand, rather than the kind of dogmatic arguments of this era, which will be viewed through a historical lens as rather quaint and silly.

stupidcar··on Smartphones and Dematerialization
Why I agree smartphones should be recyclable, I'm not sure it's important in the larger scheme of things. A phone is a very small item, relatively speaking and even at its height, the upgrade cycle was only once every 12 months.

Now consider the sheer volume of trash — paper, plastic, foil, fumes, food, etc. — many individuals and organisations throw out every day. It essentially defies comprehension, but it's a lot. So much that's we've created an incredible reverse supply-chain to get it all out of sight and out of mind as quickly as possible, with the result that we rarely stop to think just how much crap we're all generating.

Set against this, people throwing out a tiny electronic item, even an item containing some nasty toxic stuff inside it, is a very small problem. Smartphones are novel and make for a high-profile target, but the real problem is the more mundane avalanche of detritus that accompanies modern civilisation.

stupidcar··on History Will Not Be Kind to Jony Ive
Was the integrated circuit a mistake because it isn't repairable? The historical arc of technological development is unmistakably towards smaller, more complex, more integrated systems that are impossible to access and repair without highly specialised equipment. Does anybody really believe that technology 100 years from now will be anything other than nano-tech meta-materials, the functioning of which is totally opaque to anybody without a tunnelling microscope and an in-depth understanding of quantum physics? History will judge Ive no more harshly than one person caught in an irresistible wave.
stupidcar··on The “backfire effect” is mostly a myth, a broad look at the research suggests
That was my conclusion, yes. Presuming Amy and Ben are ideologically wedded to their respective backfire beliefs: If the effect doesn't exist, Amy changes her mind, so won't try to Ben out of his disbelief. If the effect exists, the negative article will reinforce Amy's belief in it, but her positive argument will in turn only reinforce Ben's negative belief.
stupidcar··on The “backfire effect” is mostly a myth, a broad look at the research suggests
This is like one of those Knights and Knaves logic puzzles we used to do at school:

Amy believes the backfire effect is real, whereas Ben believes it is fake. Amy reads an article saying the backfire effect has been disproven, then passes her new opinion on to Ben. What will be Ben's revised opinion of the backfire effect be if 1) the backfire effect actually exists, 2) the backfire effect doesn't exist.

stupidcar··on Vue RFC: Expose logic-related component options via function-based APIs instead
You may not like it as a technology, but one search on recruitment sites will show you that it's far from dead.
stupidcar··on ECMO pumps blood out of the body, oxygenates it and returns it to the body
While I can understand the disquiet about loading patients onto this device when it's a bridge to nowhere, in terms of treatment and recovery, wouldn't it better to look at this in a more positive way: As providing the necessary (and astonishing, technologically speaking) first step in being able to treat previously untreatable conditions.

I'll bet that over time the technology will improve and require less intensive management, and for every patient who ends up in an unpleasant twilight between life and death, there's going to be one whose short-term survival inspires doctors to find a way to get them off ECMO. Long-term survival and recovery rates will improve as the years and decades go by, and eventually technology like this will be a regular and uncontroversial part of medicine. Doctors will look back on these early days like we look back on early surgery: as the hardest part of a learning curve that eventually pays off handsomely.

stupidcar··on Dishcraft Robotics Takes over Dishwashing from Humans
If they're so good and so cheap, then why do so many places still employ human dishwashers?
stupidcar··on One liner NPM package “is-windows” has 2.5M dependants, why on earth?
I think it's funny how so many people have an allergic reaction to using a package manager to add fragments of small but non-obvious code to their codebase, but have no issue with frequently using Google to track down one-liners on Stack Overflow, which they then copy-and-paste into their codebase.

Why is you acting like a slow, biological package manager for small bits of code better than using a real package manager for the same purpose?

stupidcar··on Classes vs. Data Structures
Whenever I hear "Socratic dialog", I reach for my revolver. Is there any other form of teaching so irritating and patronising? You might have a brilliant store of insight to impart, but if you insist on trying to do so via a twee, affected and unbelievable conversation with a Mary Sue wise professor, I'm going to write you off as insufferable before the fawning moron you have as proxy for your audience utters their first "Oh, wow! So you mean that straw-man you just put in my mouth isn't true?"
stupidcar··on The Pentagon is battling the clock to fix serious, unreported F-35 problems
Lots of countries burn money on labor and goods they don't need, they just call it "socialism" instead of "defence". The US might be better off of they acknowledged that the fruits of this particular labor weren't going anywhere real.
stupidcar··on Only 2% of actors make a living. How do you become one of them?
The comedy TV show Party Down, about a group of struggling actors working a side-gig as caterers, provides a good insight into the mindset required to have a chance at "making it" in Hollywood.

Its message seemed to be that, yes, you have virtually no chance of success, but accepting that fact means you have no chance of success. To have a chance, you have to willingly accept a degree of self-delusion, and have a support system of fellow wannabes who'll back up this self-delusion, as you back up theirs.

stupidcar··on Epistemic Learned Helplessness (2013)
Except the problem the author identifies is that in many fields, such as history, there's no way for the lay person to judge the predictive power of competing theories, short of expending outsized effort to become an expert themselves.

Since they cannot judge theories scientifically, and they cannot judge them based on how well they're presented, they can only fall back on social consensus and instinctive sense of weirdness. "Trust the academy", would seem to be the more accurate shorthand.

stupidcar··on CSS Grid Level 2 – subgrid is coming to Firefox
Arguments like this are basically a huge "fuck you" to anybody with internationalisation and accessibility needs.

Yes, if all you care about are able-bodied Western users consuming content on standard devices, then you can get away with just baking your style / layout into the markup like your someone hacking away back in the 90s. The moment you need to move beyond that, you'll start to introduce methods for abstracting style and layout that, eventually, will lead you to reinventing something pretty similar to CSS.

stupidcar··on Apple Pro Display XDR
There's actually a little bit at the end of the store page that mentions how developers can put it into portrait mode to see more code.

The thought of some dev buying this thing just to stare at xcode all day is kinda hilarious.

stupidcar··on "DigitalOcean Killed Our Company"
It won't be easier, and it won't be cheaper. When you're a small team trying to build a business, there are a lot of business functions where you won't personally have the expertise or the time to do it yourself efficiently, and your requirements won't be large enough to justify hiring somebody full-time.

In the case of these business functions, the standard and correct approach is to outsource them to a 3rd-party service provider. You do this with accountancy, legal representation, facilities, office management, recruitment, etc. If you try to bring all these things in-house from the get-go you'll never get around to building a product, and it's financially and logistically sensible to do it with IT as well. This calculation may change over time as your business grows, but if you can't comprehend that the correct strategy for a fledgling business may not be the same as an established one, then you're simply not suited to run a business in the first place.

Of course, in every case, you're taking a calculated risk by relying on a service provider: They may go bust, they may be incompetent or malicious, they might ramp up their prices. Your job as the manager of a company is to accept and manage these risks as best you can. Risks cannot be eliminated, only managed, and attempting to do is a fool's errand. If things do go wrong, you'll always have people lining up to tell you how you could have avoided this problem, usually it's by making a decision that can be justified with the benefit of hindsight. You should ignore these people. The only question is: did you make the correct decision at the time, based on the facts to hand?

stupidcar··on Angular v8.0
This feels like an argument made by somebody who has never built a serious project in either, and has instead formed an opinion based on quick glance at the respective syntaxes.

To me, Angular is what HTML and the DOM would look like if they had been designed from the beginning for application development:

- Custom elements backed by controller classes. - Data-binding and event-binding syntax baked into HTML - Component style encapsulation, on by default.

React seems far more like a project created by people who dislike front-end development: As I recall the genesis of the project was to replace traditional DOM mutation with a more PHP-esque approach of updating state and re-rendering everything, just as you would do on the back-end.

stupidcar··on W3C and the WHATWG sign agreement to collaborate on single version of HTML, DOM
> I think HTML deserves better than being tinkered with all the time for no good reasons other than job security and/or achieving Webkit dominance, or other nebulous reasons at this point.

That's good, because these aren't the reasons the HTML standard is changed, and to claim they are is absurd.

HTML may have had its origins in SGML, but it has long, long since grown past beyond those origins to become the web platform. Like any other non-dead software platform, it is undergoes a process of refinement and enhancement, not for reasons of "job security" or "Webkit dominance", but to provide additional functionality to allow more and better software to be build with of it, and to remain competitive with other software platforms.

You, and a large constituency of Hacker News commenters along with you, may utterly loathe the web platform. You may wish the web had evolved along entirely different lines, remaining a simple system for server hypertext documents. But the fact is, it didn't, and to act as if that the global development ecosystem that relies on the web platform doesn't exist is ridiculous.

stupidcar··on W3C and the WHATWG sign agreement to collaborate on single version of HTML, DOM
"Standard" = consensus definition of desired behaviour. "Living" = open to change.

I don't see what is so oxymoronic about this? Just because a consensus has been reached doesn't mean that consensus must be immutable.

Just because the process of standardisation in some technical domains has tended to use versioned documents doesn't mean that such an approach is fundamental to standardisation.

stupidcar··on SpaceX Raptor: Methane fueled full-flow staged combustion cycle engine
Does NASA have any choice? It seems like the political environment in which they operate makes it essentially impossible to pursue any kind of sane long-term strategy.
stupidcar··on Logical fallacies in software engineering
The "nirvana fallacy" is definitely one I commonly see on Hacker News. The ease with which people jump from "thing x is imperfect" to "thing x is worthless" is mind-boggling. This is usually coupled with familiarity bias, where the flaws of any existing technology are discounted vs. those of a new technology.
stupidcar··on Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system
Most people probably won't buy the terminal outright, though, I expect? You'll just buy a Starlink subscription with a fixed initial term and they'll lease you the terminal as part of that.
stupidcar··on Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system
So, part of Musk's long-term play here has got to be, eventually, to include a Starlink terminal into every Tesla, right? Probably without even charging any subscription. You and your passengers get free broadband internet in the car, and Tesla get a high-bandwidth channel to every vehicle on the road, allowing them to stream live, high-fidelity telemetry data back to their HQ and push out software updates as and when they need to.
stupidcar··on Starlink – SpaceX’s broadband internet system
I don't think they've announced much regarding the pricing or specifics of the terminals, but Musk has said in an interview they will require an antenna array with line of sight, and will be about the size of a pizza box.
stupidcar··on U.S. Judge Orders “Immediate Removal” of Website Critical of Voice Lie Detector
Firstly, who has more reason to research lie detectors and realise they don't work, a criminal or an innocent person? Clearly, it's the former, so you're using a "trick" that is weighted against innocent people.

Secondly, most criminal justice systems reward early confession with reduced sentences and plea bargaining. In such systems, presenting a suspect with fabricated evidence—which is what a "positive" lie detection report is—seems just as likely to induce a false confession as a real one.

If we allowed cops to plant evidence and falsify statements, we could probably get a lot more confessions. If we eliminated the "innocent" verdict at trial, or reintroduced trial by ordeal, we could do the same. But we don't do this because these are fundamentally unjust, and so is allowing law enforcement to claim they know people are guilty due to magic.

stupidcar··on U.S. Judge Orders “Immediate Removal” of Website Critical of Voice Lie Detector
Not clear there's any intent to censor here by the courts, so much as mediate a dispute between two equally disreputable vendors of bogus lie detection systems.

More concerning is the fact that so many large law enforcement institutions continue to use these systems even after the fact of their ineffectiveness has been established beyond a reasonable doubt. If such institutions cannot weigh and respond to evidence correctly as it relates to their own investigatory methods, why should we have any faith in their ability to handle evidence correctly in the course of those investigations themselves?

stupidcar··on The struggles of an open source maintainer
It's ironic that Git was intentionally designed to decentralise the process of software development, so that there was no single "blessed" repository, but instead of a network of peers, each of which could evolve at a different rate and in a different way, with the community deciding which would "win" in terms of popularity.

And yet, via Github, the community has reinvented the centralised model of software development. For any project, there is a single instance that is the "blessed" version, by virtue of having the most stars or collaborators, or owning the associated package name. 99% of forks are nothing more than a place where you create a feature branch that you intend to PR to the blessed project.

I hope that, one day, somebody invents a git-based project ecosystem that solves the problem of decentralised project management. I don't know exactly what this would look like, but I think it would need to embed the idea of community and contributor consensus and democracy at a fundamental level, separating the concept of the project and project ownership from any individual fork.

stupidcar··on Crimes in Concrete
> The argument seems to boil down to, "of course it's ugly, just look at it"

Yes, but only because the heart of the modernist movement has been an attempt to deny, belittle and mock the idea that the instinctive aesthetic reaction of the majority to their creations is important or valid. If you think their constructions are ugly, that's not their problem, it's your problem. Firstly, you're too stupid, conservative and narrow-minded to perceive its genius, and secondly, in fact, you actually do like it, or eventually you will, if you just shut up and wait long enough.

It's as if avant-garde jazz advocates were put in charge every radio station and music streaming service on Earth, and given free rein to remorselessly enforce their taste on the whole population, with any dissenter being shouted down and told that, when they eventually forget what all other music sounded like, they'll come to love atonal jazz noise.

In such a situation, the fightback would have to begin with people being told it's OK to trust their own instinct and hate the music that's been forced upon them. Likewise, the fightback against overweening modernism has to begin by bursting the elitist bubble of faux-intellectual obfuscation that modernists have created around architecture. It has to begin by telling people that they have as much right to judge the aesthetics of huge changes to the places they live and work as anybody else, and that if they think the changes are ugly, then that's valid, without any "but..." unfolding into a lecture about how daring and original the latest edifice being foisted upon them actually is.

← PreviousPage 7 of 26Next →