HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on JD Salinger's unseen writings to be published, family confirms
The interview makes it pretty clear that it isn't being published against his wishes. He wanted it out there, just not while he was alive.

Now perhaps Salinger's son (and his widow) could be lying in the hope of profiting off his work, but if so he's chosen a strange way to go about it, blocking publication of his juvenilia and neglecting his own acting and producing career to spend what will apparently be the best part of twenty years collecting and editing it all.

Personally though, I think Matt Salinger's genuine. In fact, he comes across as extraordinarily respectful of his father's legacy. Would that we all had people willing to expend so much effort and care to honour us after we have passed.

stupidcar··on Oumuamua continues to perplex astronomers a year after it vanished
I really recommend this Ars Technica podcast that features a long and in-depth interview with Avi Loeb:

https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/11/nailing-down-the-nat...

He makes a pretty convincing case that there are several highly unusual properties of Oumaumau that makes it reasonable to hypothesize that it is of unnatural origin. Whether or not you're convinced, you'll at least come away much better informed about his arguments that from the soundbite back-and-forth that passes for debate in articles like the BI one.

stupidcar··on I Am Not a Real Programmer
It seems like a significant subset of the developer community, or at least that proportion of that posts online, is hung up on questions of identity as related to their career. E.g. whether they're a programmer or not, whether they're a "real" programmer, whether they're a skilled programmer, why type of programmer they are, and all manner of critique of others answers to these questions and the set of assumptions and prejudices that underlie them.

While I can understand the instincts that drive this phenomenon, does anyone else not think it's all a bit self-absorbed and unnecessary? Like, why is it so important? Is your self-actualisation really so dependent on how you label the activities by which you make money? Bear in mind, to the vast majority of the population, the difference between somebody who "is" a programmer and somebody programs as part of an IT role is a barely existent irrelevance.

stupidcar··on My Losing Battle with Enterprise Sales
And then after 6 months of effort, the coach moves to a different role or leaves, and suddenly the whole deal deflates like a balloon.
stupidcar··on The China Conundrum – are we headed for a supply chain meltdown?
I think what we're seeing is the culmination of a breakdown in the decades old neoliberal political consensus that Chinese nationalism could be gradually dispelled through a policy of opening up Western economies to integration with China's. In practice, at the highest level, the Chinese government has kept the market subservient to nationalist goals, and remains stubbornly autocratic, repressive and hegemonistic.

The populist leanings of the Trump administration perhaps may make them more receptive to this argument, because they understand these kind of nationalist and hegemonistic instincts better than neoliberal technocrats, but I think this has been a dawning realisation throughout Western policymakers over the past decade. Even the Obama administration, which was strongly neoliberal, worked hard to isolate China economically through the TPP. Trump's disdain for trade deals killed that, but his confrontation of China is really just a noisier continuation of a pre-existing US foreign policy.

Big business might have put a restraint on Western policymakers' wishes to oppose China if they'd had more success in penetrating the Chinese market. But here the Chinese government has been too defensive, and Western business leaders have realised that they simply won't be allowed to be dominate in China in any meaningful way. Meanwhile, they have watched their infrastructure get attacked and their IP stolen, and have decided enough is enough.

stupidcar··on My Losing Battle with Enterprise Sales
Sales does suck, but as the article says, enterprise sales aren't the way they are because the salespeople are necessarily immoral or trying to fuck anyone out of their money, they're the way they are because big companies need to be sold to in a particular way. When the buyer is not the user, and there are multiple departments and decision makers involved, you can't just rely on the quality of your product to win out. You can have a fantastic product that you know will help the customer immensely, and you still have to follow the enterprise sales process if you want to sell it.
stupidcar··on The “Bug-O” Notation
It's also an emotive word that can make discussion more heated. If you're reviewing somebody's code and you call it "ugly", they're liable to get upset, and it's too imprecise for them to act on. It's far more helpful and less combative to explain, in concrete terms, what you think its problems are, and how a different approach could solve them.
stupidcar··on TypeScript Tricks: Type Guards
It does: http://blog.wolksoftware.com/decorators-metadata-reflection-...
stupidcar··on A Harvard Astronomer on the Interstellar Object ‘Oumuamua
Why should we favour the first one?

Imagine our best understanding of cosmology suggested that some interstellar object, which we'll call "foobars" for the sake of this argument, existed in high amounts. However, we weren't totally certain that foobars existed, or exactly what they would look like if they did.

In this case, when we discovered a new, weird and unexplainable phenomenon, would there really much pushback when somebody proposed that foobars might be the cause?

Well, according to the Fermi Paradox[1], there's seems to be a very good chance, statistically speaking, that alien life is common in our galaxy. So, when a phenomenon is observed with highly unusual characteristics, why should an alien origin be considered unlikely or fringe explanation?

I think people dismissing or diminishing the possibility of an alien explanation should also be required to provide a reasonable, evidence-based explanation for the Fermi Paradox.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox

stupidcar··on Show HN: Shiny.js simulates reflections on the web for mobile devices
This is pretty cool. I could see Apple or someone taking this idea and running with it. Like Face ID, they could use the front-facing camera with a NN to determine the location of nearby light sources, then provide an API to render 3D and reflective surfaces in a environmentally consistent way. Perhaps not just reflective highlights, but actual reflected and refracted images from the camera.
stupidcar··on Brexit Deal Fails in Parliament
Oh, really? Here's the speech Michael Gove gave at the outset of the Vote Leave campaign: http://www.voteleavetakecontrol.org/michael_gove_the_facts_o...

The key quote:

"There is a free trade zone stretching from Iceland to Turkey that all European nations have access to, regardless of whether they are in or out of the euro or EU. After we vote to leave we will stay in this zone. The suggestion that Bosnia, Serbia, Albania and the Ukraine would stay part of this free trade area - and Britain would be on the outside with just Belarus - is as credible as Jean-Claude Juncker joining UKIP."

So here you have one of the two most senior politicians in the Vote Leave campaign, in a flagship speech, saying that after we vote to leave we will continue to enjoy free trade with Europe. Not WTO rules, not even a negotiated deal. He says we'll just "stay in this zone" as if it was a default.

stupidcar··on React create composable components
I find it ironic that Angular's dependency injection system attracted so much disdain, particularly from React advocates, then React ends up implementing a less-powerful and more verbose equivalent in its new context API.
stupidcar··on SpaceX to lay off 10% of Workforce
Maybe, maybe not. Consider it in terms of your own workplace: if you worked on a team of 10, and one person got laid off, would that seem so huge? I think the question is whether this round of layoffs is in response to an acute cash flow issue or just part of long-term financial prudency. They fact that they waited until after Christmas and are providing 8 weeks of pay and benefits makes me hopeful that it's the latter.

Also, given that Falcon 9 is now essentially "done", I expect there probably is a fair bit of internal capacity that's accumulated during its development which can be cut. For example, SpaceX is famous for building a lot of components in house, but perhaps they'll move more to using subcontractors for Falcon 9 parts. That might free up money to spend on R&D. The challenge will be to become leaner and save money in the core launch business without compromising standards. It'll only take a couple of accidents to trash their reputation.

stupidcar··on How China could dominate science
Western commentators have be predicting that one social phenomenon or another would lead to a democratic awakening in China for decades: The collapse of the USSR, economic liberalisation, the growth of the middle class, generational shift, the internet, growing prosperity, falling prosperity, etc.

We must be pretty far down the list if we're now proposing that career scientists will lead a political revolution.

stupidcar··on How I Finally Hit 2000 on Lichess and Improved My Rating
Is it? I us chess.com, and parts of the Lichess interface seems quite primitive in comparison: The board doesn't resize to fit the screen, there's no live evaluation, and it just seems a bit less polished overall.
stupidcar··on Announcing unlimited free private repos
One of the best uses of GitHub is being able to search for some obscure framework method name or enum constant, and find examples of working code that uses it. This has saved my life many times when trying to figure out how to configure Java frameworks to interact with each other.

When searching for this kind of code, you have to wade through an awful lot of repos containing half-baked personal projects, experiments, unmodified clones of upstream frameworks, and barely-modified boilerplate examples. It would be nice if there was less of this detritus clogging up the search results.

However, sometimes the code you actually want is embedded in some otherwise useless, half-baked personal project, or barely-modified boilerplate example. So if all these projects disappear behind a veil of privacy, maybe it won't be a net win.

stupidcar··on Things You Can’t Say About Assange or WikiLeaks
I think you mean "a group of scientists have theorised that a recording obtained by the Associated Press, which the AP claimed to be 'generally consistent' with the sound heard by some US diplomats who reported being attacked, could be a recording of crickets", which is a very different thing than suggesting the attack has been "revealed" as crickets.

For someone so concerned with not being "played" by the media, you seem strangely happy to play exactly the same kinds of games with the facts.

stupidcar··on Netflix's Bow to Saudi Censors Comes at a Cost to Free Speech
We expect individuals to behave morally. Companies are richer, more powerful, more organised and more capable than individuals, so why should we hold them to a lower standard of behaviour?

Human society of any sort is only possible because our species evolved beyond purely selfish behaviour to co-operate for the greater good. Modern civilisation is reliant on the majority of individuals following moral codes, instilled by cultural, religious and familial institutions and enforced by community action. We do not allow "profit-seeking" as a pass for acting immorally.

If companies want to enjoy the rights given to individuals within our societies, such as freedom to operate, equal treatment and protection under the law, etc. Then they also need to be bound by the same moral codes that allows successful co-operation between individual people. Allowing companies to have full legal rights while exempting them from moral responsibility is just as unfair and dangerous as it is to give a certain class of human the freedom to ignore moral norms without consequence.

stupidcar··on Apple Had Five Ways to Fuel Earnings. Only One Still Works
I think what complicates it is that the shares themselves are a tradable commodity. The price of a commodity isn't just a function of the underlying value of the asset, but also expected change in price, the overall health of the economy, the attitude of other investors, etc. Many short to medium term investors may not care directly about profits at all, because they hope to make their money from growth in the price of the share as a commodity.
stupidcar··on Show HN: Learn and practice modern JavaScript
Very nice! This seems like a better way to learn or refresh on the language that just wading through tutorials/textbooks.

One thing that is missing is a way to report problems in the exercises. Already in the Conditions section I found an exercise that says:

"Implement a function canVote that returns true whenever the age is bigger than 18"

But the test is for a function that returns true when age is greater than or equal to 18.

stupidcar··on Gluten Free Antarctica
I was just making a dumb joke: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Supposedly_Fun_Thing_I'll_...
stupidcar··on Gluten Free Antarctica
Or, A Subarctically Fun Thing I'll Never Do Again.
stupidcar··on Browsers
Yes, my first browser was Mosaic, and I've been working as a professional web developer since before Firefox existed.

Firefox benefitted from years of stagnation and neglect of IE by Microsoft. And even then, when it was clearly the superior product, it took years to gain a significant portion of the browser market, and it still never managed to get much over 20%. Only Google, with the most popular website on the planet, and billions of dollars to spend, managed to actually dislodge IE.

As things stand, Chrome is not stagnating or neglected. Firefox is a good browser, but it is by no means a clearly superior product. There is a vastly larger number of deployed PCs, using Chrome as their default browser, than there was in the early 2000s. Mobile has replaced the desktop as the dominant consumer computing platform, where installing and using a replacement browser is far less likely. There are far more apps and content optimised for Chrome than there ever was even for IE, and the quantity is expanding all the time.

For all these reasons, and more, I am convinced that advocacy and evangelism alonge will not succeed to change the situation, and such efforts, while noble-minded, are mostly a waste of time.

stupidcar··on Browsers
I didn't say the concerns are wrong, just that repeating them again and again, mostly within an echo chamber of tech people, will do nothing to change the facts.

I don't think people should sit there and go meh. They should just be realistic about what actions will and will not make an actual difference.

stupidcar··on Browsers
I find it kind of hilarious that people seem to think the solution to the Chrome monoculture is them personally switching to Firefox and then writing a blog post / comment / tweet about it. It's like saying we need to get serious about climate change, so you're going to start cycling to work, and encourage your friends to do the same. If that salves your conscience, then great, but your individual actions are statistically irrelevant.

There are systemic trends and market forces at play here involving billions of people. And nowhere amongst the significant forces and trends will you find "there are insufficient nerds evangelising Firefox". Hacker News can upvote as many as these kinds of articles as it likes, but Chrome's market share will continue to grow until there is something far more substantial to stop it than philosophical objections by tech insiders.

stupidcar··on World's first fully electric bus fleet quietens Chinese megacity
The ones pictured in the article are BYD. I couldn't find any figures for the makeup of the fleet overall, but I imagine it's mostly BYD, as they seem to be by far the dominant player in the electric bus market, both in China and worldwide.
stupidcar··on China Warns Canada of ‘Heavy Price’ Over Huawei Arrest
Never heard of Jeff Skilling? Bernie Madoff? Martha Stewart?

Plenty of western CEOs have been arrested, convicted and jailed. I guess the difference is that they don't benefit from their government threatening severe consequences unless the rule of law is suspended.

stupidcar··on Inside China's audacious global propaganda campaign
I agree that competition of some kind could be welcome, but welcoming the state sponsored propaganda of autocratic, corrupt and repressive states just because their own hegemonic desires conflict with those of the US strikes me as being the most politically facile stance imaginable.
stupidcar··on Goodbye, EdgeHTML
Nowadays most enterprise and bespoke intranet apps are targeting Chrome as a platform, not "the web". It's a re-run of the IE6 situation in the late 90s / early 2000s, except this time Microsoft is the victim, not the beneficiary.

Whereas it used to be that big IT departments would nix the installation of any 3rd party browser, nowadays almost all accept the use of Chrome. And if you're selling an app into a big company, you always tell them to use Chrome, and never advertise IE/Edge support except as a last resort.

If Microsoft want to sell their cloud services into these companies, they need to support Chrome-based apps. Edge won't do. As such, they have little choice but to fork it and build their own browser, tied into their services. I'm sure they recognise the potential problems and downsides, but consider it the least worst option at this point.

stupidcar··on TypeScript in 5 minutes
What you're "missing", I think, is that Typescript's types only exist at compile-time, so they aren't available through runtime operations like instanceof. It's like a more extensive case of Java generics erasure.
← PreviousPage 9 of 26Next →