HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

stupidcar

8,592 karma · joined March 30, 2014

submissionscomments
stupidcar··on Why Mark Zuckerberg’s ’empty chair’ policy is backfiring
I remember listening to a UK Parliamentary Committee that had invited the head of a popular grassroots anti-TTIP campaign to give evidence. There wasn't even a pretence of trying to be even-handed or gain a better understanding of popular objections to TTIP. Instead, all the MPs present took turns to berate him in an imperious manner. He was simply a prop for them to lecture at.

I suspect many of the forums Zuckerberg is invited to participate in are similarly vehicles for politicians to gain exposure by being seen as attacking a popular bogeymen. I can't really blame him for not wanting to spend his life traipsing around world capitals helping these politicians get TV coverage by acting as a rhetorical piñata.

stupidcar··on Life Sentence for British Student Draws Criticism for U.A.E
The governments of these countries are in no sense “moderate”, and it is absurd to suggest that the only choice they face is between their incumbent autocratic regimes and fundamentalism Islamic ones. Extremists both secular and religious have prospered in the Middle East precisely because western backing for unrepresentative regimes has snuffed out moderate and democratic opposition.

This geopolitical calculus might have made sense when there was a real danger of such countries being swallowed up into the Soviet Union’s sphere of influence. But it would be much better now to disengage as much as possible with the governments of countries like Saudi Arabia and the UAE.

stupidcar··on Life Sentence for British Student Draws Criticism for U.A.E
Because they aren’t “just” as barbarous and cruel.

Violations of civil liberties occur in every country, but If you really believe that the rate and intensity of such is exactly the same in the UK as it is in Saudi Arabia or UAE, then you’re monumentally deluded.

stupidcar··on Life Sentence for British Student Draws Criticism for U.A.E
It’s absurd that a British citizen, or a citizen of any democratic county, is living and studying in a repressive, corrupt and violent regime like the United Arab Emirates. These countries and their kleptocratic Sheikhs throw wealth derived from oil and blood at western universities, and bribe their officials into setting up “campuses” in their states. Then they get upset when arriving students don’t conform to the apathetic conformity drilled into their own citizens.

The Cold War is over. Yet somehow western democracies are still clinging on to alliances with barbarous regimes like Saudi Arabia and UAE. And now we see the fruits of it: Yemeni citivilians murdered during an unending war, a British citizen imprisoned for life for offending his hosts, and an agent of the Saudi royalty installed as president of the USA. What an utterly pathetic state of affairs.

stupidcar··on You can't impress developers. So don't try
Yes, but the most upvoted comments are always the negative ones.
stupidcar··on ‘Oumuamua, Thin Films and Lightsails
Given how weird, and apparently unexplainable, various aspects of this object are, shouldn't we be moving heaven and earth to investigate the possibility of some kind of mission to it? From what I've read, there are ideas at least for how we might launch a spacecraft capable of catching up with it. Given the potential of what we could learn, wouldn't that be a better way to spend a few billion dollars than a return to the moon? (of course, ideally we'd do both, but...)
stupidcar··on Oculus co-founder is leaving Facebook after cancellation of ‘Rift 2’ headset
It really speaks to the disgustingly privileged and cloistered attitude of many tech geeks that they would consider a $400 consumer electronics device like the Oculus Quest cheap. And that they would rather see mainstream VR crash and burn, or dwindle to a tiny, dying niche, than make even the slightest concession to people who can't or won't spent $2k+ to indulge in the latest fad. What a joke.
stupidcar··on Some ancient narratives contain remarkably reliable records of real events
You definitely have to be a conspiracy theorist to buy any of the myriad contemporary Atlantis myths and the veracity of Plato's claims. The history podcast Our Fake History has an excellent three episode arc about Atlantis, including Plato's account.

https://ourfakehistory.com/index.php/season-2/

The upshot is that his account does not match up with any real world location, unless you are willing to engage in cherry-picking and an extremely generous interpretation of various things, and there is no credible explain of how he alone could have gained such detailed knowledge of a civilisation that existed thousands of years before his birth. One which no other historical writer mentioned.

In reality, Plato's description of "Atlantis" was considered as plainly allegorical by his contemporaries and subsequent scholars. A situation that continued for hundreds of years, and only began to change in the relatively recent past, with the rise of pseudo-history and conspiracy theorists.

stupidcar··on Are Black Holes Actually Dark Energy Stars?
If the EHT analysis of Sagittarius A* supported this theory, that would surely it would have already leaked? It seems like it would be simply too incredible not to start circulating amongst researchers and then get out into the wider world.
stupidcar··on The Bredesen protocol for treating Alzheimer’s
Bredesen has written a book describing it. But the core of it seems to be adopting habits that most HN readers would familiar with as being considered healthy, according to current medical fashion: E.g. eating a low-sugar, calorie-restricted diet, exercising regularly, maintaining gut health using probiotics, avoiding chronic inflammation, getting regular, sufficient and good quality sleep, staying mentally active. Stuff everyone should be doing, regardless of their current age or health.
stupidcar··on Air pollution linked to “huge” reduction in intelligence
I definitely agree about the last part. I live in London, don’t drive, and cycling would definitely be preferable to relying entirely on the Tube and taxis. But when I see the hell cyclists here have to contend with, and how aggressive they need to be, I know there’s no way I am a skilled or confident enough rider to do the same. But if the infrastructure and vehicle congestion ever improved to the point where cyclists were adequately protected, I would definitely start cycling.
stupidcar··on Jeff Hawkins Is Finally Ready to Explain His Brain Research
It’s weird how this headline and article makes it sound like Hawkins is being coy about his theories, or preferring to work in secret than explain them. But On Intelligence was published years ago, and contained a section on testable predictions. Likewise, Numenta has published papers, and made source code available.

So it doesn’t seem to me that the problem is that Hawkins has been uncommunicative, it’s that the wider academic and research community just hasn’t been interested. Perhaps that’s simply because his theories don’t have merit, but it’s also hard to shake the feeling that’s it more because his career, and therefore his theories, hasn’t fit the standard academic mould.

It seems to me that, if you want to be an influential theorist, you’re expected to study at a prestigious university, work with an older, respected researcher while getting your PhD, then become a professor, setup a research lab, mentor some PhD students of your own, then finally maybe spin off your research into some startups, or take a high-paying research position at a big company.

Hawkins hasn’t followed this path, so he has no network of peers and former students to evangelise his work and carry it forward. He’s done research and published it, like the scientific ideal says you should, but he’s missing the structure necessary to make it land in the research world.

It’s like a sort-of reverse cargo cult. He’s done the work of constructing a real airstrip and working planes, but he can’t persuade anybody to fly, because they’ve never seen or heard of air travel before.

stupidcar··on Oil droplets guided by pilot waves do not give rise to double-slit interference
It matters because the theory in this case wasn’t that both light and tennis balls behave like a particle. It was that light behaves like a tennis ball. As such, demonstrating that tennis balls succeed or fail to display certain light-like behavior is certainly an important result.

So, the most controversial aspect of pilot wave theory is the idea that a classical system can reproduce some phenomena considered only to arise in a quantum one. The 2006 result was important because it appeared to definitively prove a classical system could do just that, and for one of the most famously “weird” quantum results. How accurately it correlated with a hypothetical pilot wave based quantum reality wasn’t really relevant. And if the original result was important, then the failure to reproduce it is also important.

More generally, scientists can argue about theory, mathematics and the “deep” stuff until the cows come home. But what actually advances science is experiment. It may not always be the most glamorous or exciting work (CERN notwithstanding). It can be an expensive, years-log slog to add a single negative data point against an idea a theoretician dreamt up in an afternoon, and which they’ll dismiss as irrelevant, or avoid by tweaking a single equation. But it’s, quite literally, the part of science that gets results.

stupidcar··on There Goes Hurricane Florence; Here Come the Disaster Myths
There's little reason to believe so. Minds shaped by reinforcement learning will usually fall back on established behaviours, even in novel and unexpected situations. In stable societies, these behaviours include baseline trust, respect for property, non-violence, reciprocal altruism etc. Only if exposed to different and more hostile circumstances for a longer period should we expect different behaviors to develop.
stupidcar··on Academic Grievance Studies and the Corruption of Scholarship
So if you suspect a problem with epistemology, you can't conduct an experiment, because to do so is "bad faith"?

Do you display bad faith in the theory of gravity by conducting an experiment? Is the whole scientific process a bad faith attempt to determine objective truth by underhanded manipulation of the universe?

stupidcar··on Silicon Valley's Keystone Problem: A Monoculture of Thought
I'm curious why you don't count Detroit as a "tech hub"? Or NY? Or LA? Does you definition of technology not extend beyond software development?

There are myriad industries, like car manufacturing, energy, finance, filmmaking, aerospace, health, etc. that involve huge amounts of technology, and whose leading players are based nowhere near Silicon Valley. But instead of going out and working in these industries to build something revolutionary, tens of thousands of world class programmers cluster in Silicon Valley, all talking to each other about how amazing and disruptive they are, while wasting their prime years blowing through VC money in startups chasing the latest ecommerce/chatbot/messaging/AI/blockchain fad, or as a cog in some tech giant's machine to turn customer data into advertising dollars.

stupidcar··on A History of .NET Runtimes
Yeah, that's my understanding as well. But what I wonder is what would have happened if someone at the top had brought the C++ and .NET teams in and made some Jobsian declaration like "this isn't negotiable, the company is switching to .NET. All of your jobs depend on finding a way to make it work." Were those performance problems really insoluble, if all the engineering ability of the company were brought to bear on them? I get the impression that a lot of the C++ old hands were never pleased with .NET to begin with, and were all too happy to chuck it.
stupidcar··on A History of .NET Runtimes
Yeah, I think this was a far bigger contributor to the failure of .NET to achieve dominance. Silverlight was only ever a slightly weird sideline intended to compete with Flash, which became DOA the moment the iPhone launched and Jobs killed Flash overnight by saying the iPhone would never support it.

Microsoft's biggest internal teams turning against .NET during Longhorn created a schism that the company has never resolved. I often wonder what might have happened if they'd had the requisite leadership to force the change through organisation-wide, and MS had spent the last 15 years with a single, rational dev story.

stupidcar··on Did I just waste 3 years?
"Best advice" why? Accurate, perhaps. But do you really find going around telling people that they're not going to win the lottery makes them stop playing? Even after they read an article about someone who won $100m and has quit their job to sail around the world?

I think such advice misunderstands the psychology of why people gamble on very long odds. The primary drive is emotional, not rational. The rational brain only has to be convinced that a theoretical possibility exists. After that, it's a matter of emotional appeal, and culture is very good at presenting seductive narratives based on rare occurrences.

stupidcar··on Did I just waste 3 years?
That's clearly not entirely true though, because there are hits. They're just extremely rare, but extremely visible. You can read interviews with the Stardew Valley guy all over where he talks about spending 4 years working solo on his game, refusing to give up on realising his artistic vision. Then he releases and it's a mega-hit. That's a very seductive story.

This isn't a problem unique to indie games. Every creative field has an overabundance of hopefuls, all chasing a tiny chance of turning it into a success. The problem, as Daniel Clowes observed back in 1991[1] is that everyone thinks that they'll be one of the lucky ones.

[1] https://artinfiction.files.wordpress.com/2013/09/asc-3.jpg

stupidcar··on Ask HN: What podcasts do you listen to regularly?
I recent started listening to The Greatest Generation, a comedy podcast where two guys watch the whole of Star Trek: TNG in order (later they tackle DS9). They have a lot of fun riffing off it, especially the really bad early episodes, but there's also interesting discussion about the show's politics, whether it still holds up, etc. It's highly enjoyable, especially if you're of the age group who grew up with the show in the 80s and 90s.

https://www.maximumfun.org/shows/greatest-generation

stupidcar··on WWII Bombe operator Ruth Bourne: I'd never heard of Enigma until after the war
To me that movie's screenplay is the apotheosis of Hollywood writers' contempt for history, scientists and mathematicians, and their own audience. That the same screenplay actually won a fucking Oscar for "Best Adapted Screenplay" is a pretty sick joke.

It treats the actual facts of history as a worthless and inconvenient irrelevance. At every turn, reality is sacrificed, not even out of a necessary requirement to streamline the narrative, but because the truth fails to conform to the writer's prejudices, and the clichés of contemporary drama.

When presented with this dishonesty, writers usually issue some lame defence about reaching for a greater truth, but what they really mean is they lack the imagination or ability to distill the truth into a compelling story, or they simply don't care enough to try. So instead they feed their audiences warmed-over garbage, and win awards for it.

stupidcar··on Dear Moon
Many of the most famous works of classical art in the world were transactional and "eagerly public" in their time. The great artists of the renaissance created many works entirely funded and instigated by rich benefactors or the church, and which were intended for the consumption an awed public. But nowadays we don't look at the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel and think about the politics of the patronage relationship between Pope Julius II and Michelangelo. That's a historical issue, of no importance when considering its long-term artistic merit.

Great art transcends its origins, no matter what they are. Indeed, perhaps art is made greater by transcending its origins, just as it is by transcending the limitations of its form. The art created by this project probably won't be great, because most art isn't great. But it certainly could be. And, if so, your a priori dismissal of it will look about as informed as a contemporary renaissance critic dismissing a masterpiece as just another piece of church-funded propaganda.

stupidcar··on iOS 12 released
I use the swipable Google keyboard and it's generally OK. About 5% of the time an app will use the default Apple one, I think because they're using some kind of secure entry API.
stupidcar··on It’s Now Possible to Telepathically Communicate with a Drone Swarm
Never mind a swarm, what about controlling just a single drone? There are people in persistent vegetative states who can be communicated with via MRI scanners and appear to be essentially conscious but locked into their body. What if, with consent gained via MRI, you implanted this chip into them, and trained them to remotely control an always-on drone, which had visual and audio sensors streaming to a VR HUD and headphones on the vegetative person?

Could this let these people continue their lives in a new, drone body? How would society deal with that? Over time, it would be difficult to deny these drone avatars the same kinds of rights we award to physical citizens, e.g. to travel freely and not to be unduly harmed. Could the same be done with people suffering full-body paralysis? Or by people in wheelchairs to go to places otherwise inaccessible?

Once society became accustomed to drone avatars interacting with physical humans, might rich-enough, able-bodied people start to also use them in some circumstances. After all, there are advantages, not least the safety factory of not putting your physical body and mind at risk. Eventually, could this lead to a class of citizens who interact only via drone avatars?

stupidcar··on A new insomnia therapy
Insomniacs have more wakeful hours available to them, so, statistically speaking, they're likely to be overrepresented amongst active HN users at any given moment, resulting in a boost to sleep and insomnia related articles.
stupidcar··on What Companies Mean by Culture Fit
On a handful of occasions, I've said "yes" to hiring somebody, despite having a nagging doubt about them, because they seemed to have the requisite technical experience and interviewed OK, and I didn't feel I could justify saying "no" on the basis of an intuition.

In almost every case, they've ended up later either demonstrating some unprofessional behavior, like having an abusive temper, or been revealed to be incompetent in some aspect of the job. And yet, I still wouldn't feel comfortable turning somebody down purely based on a gut feeling. It's made me pretty uncomfortable about participating in hiring process at all.

stupidcar··on Conservative web development
Cool. Could someone just explain how to build https://app.moqups.com/ or https://designer.gravit.io/ using only HTML, CSS and server-side rendering?

Otherwise I'll just dismiss this as the same cloud-oriented geriatric yelling that Hacker News has been upvoting for the last 15 years, to absolutely no purpose or result.

stupidcar··on Space station leak caused by drill, not meteorite
Even in the most safety-conscious and blame-free work environment, I'm not sure you can entirely remove the desire for skilled professionals to cover up expensive errors. It's just a natural human instinct to want to avoid being embarrassed in front of your peers, no matter how understanding they'll be about it.
stupidcar··on F-35 Program Cutting Corners to “Complete” Development
Sorry, I don't follow miltech stuff very closely. Which of its alternatives have cost more than $1.5 trillion?
← PreviousPage 10 of 26Next →