332 karma · joined February 4, 2013
it should not be legal for the FBI to get data on her directly from Apple. at least it should go through the law enforcement of her country of residence.
> Neither is hacking somebody’s computer, which is what Signal’s blog post is saying a “real exploit payload” could do. It said, “a real exploit payload would likely seek to undetectably alter previous reports, compromise the integrity of future reports (perhaps at random!), or exfiltrate data from the Cellebrite machine.” All of those things are a violation of the federal anti-hacking law known as the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, or CFAA, and probably also of many state-law versions of the CFAA
I'm not sure if that will hold in court. You can argue that the Signal app has built in hacking defenses. A more common case would be that Signal app detects that it is being hacked by Celebrite and self destructs (i.e. deletes all data) -- that's what an iphone does, if you make too many passcode attempts. In this case Signal jokes that it might counter hack even, but since it's a defense to being hacked in the first place, it shouldn't illegal.
I'm not hearing any major challenges here that couldn't be overcome in the EU, considering the EU is capable of building some of the machines which are state of the art. yeah, you need capital and workforce and a bunch of other things. those aren't really blockers though. I think maybe there is no point, since it would cost more than TSMC, so better just buy the chips. at least until now, when there is a chip shortage and you regret not having a foundry. by the same logic there is no point to manufacture a lot of things in EU (or US) because it's cheaper to get them from China.
it can't remain so unregulated as it is now. either corporations will take over and legitimize it but this means it will become centralized and owned by big tech. or, it will remain the wild west that it is now, for a while, and then gov will shut it down.
cryptocurrencies are the same as torrents. only popular while unregulated. but this only lasts until some big player decides to stop it